Technology and AI

Case management systems for UK firms compared

The main types of case management software for UK solicitors compared on SRA accounts, workflows and cloud access, with a weighted scoring method.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What a case management system has to do
  2. The five categories
  3. Comparing on SRA accounts
  4. Comparing on workflows and client updates
  5. Comparing on cloud access and security
  6. Building a weighted scoring matrix
  7. Example: reading the scores
  8. Integrations worth testing in the demo
  9. Contract terms worth negotiating
  10. Questions for reference calls
  11. Next steps
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • Compare categories of system first: all-in-one cloud suites, established hosted suites, specialist workflow systems, accounts-led packages and do-it-yourself setups.
  • Accounts capability is the hardest requirement to bolt on later; check reconciliation and bill records against the SRA Accounts Rules.
  • Poor communication and delay are the most common complaint types at the Legal Ombudsman, so workflow and client updates deserve real weight.
  • Score shortlisted systems against weighted criteria using one real, anonymised matter as the demo script.

What a case management system has to do

A case management system is where a matter lives: client and matter records, documents, tasks, key dates, time and, in many products, the client and office ledgers. In small firms the terms case management and practice management are used interchangeably. What matters is whether the system holds the whole matter, so that a colleague can open the file and know exactly where things stand.

The market is busy. There were 8,899 SRA-regulated law firms in England and Wales at the end of September 2026, of which 1,306 were sole practices[1]. Vendors range from large suites built over decades to young cloud products and niche tools for one practice area. Rather than compare dozens of brand names, it is more useful to understand the five categories you will meet and what each is good at.

The five categories

Categories rather than vendors: most products fit mainly into one of these groups.
CategoryStrengthsWatch forUsually suits
All-in-one cloud suiteBrowser access, frequent updates, built-in accounts, client portal optionsWorkflow depth in specialist areas, data export termsSmall and growing general practices
Established hosted or on-premise suiteDeep accounts and workflow, long track record, extensive reportingOlder interfaces, upgrade projects, server or hosting costsMid-sized firms with in-house support
Specialist workflow systemStrong conveyancing, personal injury or debt recovery automationWeaker in other practice areas, separate accounts may be neededVolume practices in one area
Accounts-led package with matter add-onsReliable cashiering and reports for the accountantLimited document and task managementFirms whose main pain is accounts
Do-it-yourself setupLow upfront cost, familiar office toolsNo audit trail, key dates in spreadsheets, single points of failureVery small firms as a stopgap only

Many products straddle two categories, so treat the table as a way to frame questions rather than a verdict. A cloud suite may have an excellent conveyancing module; an established suite may offer a modern browser front end. Ask each vendor which category its own customers would put it in, and why.

Comparing on SRA accounts

Accounts are the requirement you cannot work around later. The SRA Accounts Rules require client money to be kept separate from the firm's money, bank statements to be obtained and reconciliations completed for all client accounts at least every five weeks, and a central record of all bills to be kept readily accessible[2]. Firms that must obtain an accountant's report have six months from the end of the accounting period to obtain it and deliver it to the SRA[2].

In a demo, ask the vendor to post a receipt to client account, transfer costs to office after a bill, and run a three-way reconciliation with one deliberate difference. Watch how the difference is flagged and cleared. If the system needs a separate accounts package, check how matters, bills and ledgers stay in step between the two.

Comparing on workflows and client updates

Workflow features decide whether the system reduces delay or just stores documents. Complaints data shows why this matters. Poor communication (24%) and delay or failure to progress (22%) were the most common complaint types brought to the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26, and they were also the two largest categories of upheld complaints[3].

Communication and delay in Legal Ombudsman complaints, 2025/26
Communication and delay in Legal Ombudsman complaints, 2025/26Comparison. Poor communication: Share of complaint types brought 24%, Share of upheld complaints 25%; Delay or failure to progress: Share of complaint types brought 22%, Share of upheld complaints 19%.Poor communicationPoor communication · Share of complaint types brought: 24%24%Poor communication · Share of upheld complaints: 25%25%Delay or failure to progressDelay or failure to progress · Share of complaint types brought: 22%22%Delay or failure to progress · Share of upheld complaints: 19%19%Communication and delay in Legal Ombudsman complaints, 2025/26Comparison. Poor communication: Share of complaint types brought 24%, Share of upheld complaints 25%; Delay or failure to progress: Share of complaint types brought 22%, Share of upheld complaints 19%.Poor communicationPoor communication · Share of complaint types brought: 24%24%Poor communication · Share of upheld complaints: 25%25%Delay or failure to progressDelay or failure to progress · Share of complaint types brought: 22%22%Delay or failure to progress · Share of upheld complaints: 19%19%
  • Share of complaint types brought
  • Share of upheld complaints

Source: Legal Ombudsman, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemShare of complaint types broughtShare of upheld complaints
Poor communication24%25%
Delay or failure to progress22%19%

Residential conveyancing alone accounted for 36% of complaints accepted by the Ombudsman in 2025/26[3]. If conveyancing is a large part of your work, test the system's milestone tracking, automatic client updates and search ordering closely. For other practice areas, check that key dates, limitation reminders and review tasks can be set per matter type and reported on by supervisors.

  • Can a supervisor see every overdue task in their team on one screen?
  • Can matter templates set tasks and key dates automatically when a matter is opened?
  • Are client updates logged against the matter, whatever the channel?
  • Can workflows be edited by your staff, or only by the vendor at extra cost?

Comparing on cloud access and security

Hosting is now mostly a question of who runs the servers. Professional, scientific and technical businesses are more likely to buy external software or ready-to-use services than to use free tools[4], and most new case management products are delivered as a service. The questions are where data is stored, how sign-in is protected, how backups are tested and how you get your data back when the contract ends. Our separate guide to cloud vs on-premise legal software covers the trade-offs in detail.

Building a weighted scoring matrix

  1. Pick eight criteria

    For example: accounts, workflow for your main practice area, document management, client updates, reporting, integrations, data export and support.

  2. Weight them out of 100

    Agree the weights with partners before any demo, so a polished presentation cannot shift priorities.

  3. Write one demo script

    Use a real, anonymised matter from instruction to closure. Every vendor runs the same script.

  4. Score independently

    Two or three people score each criterion from 1 to 5 during the demo, then compare and discuss gaps.

  5. Check with references

    Speak to two firms of similar size and practice mix, and adjust scores where their experience differs from the demo.

Example: fictional scores for three shortlisted systems; weighted total is each score multiplied by its weight.
Criterion (weight)System ASystem BSystem C
Accounts (25)453
Main workflow (20)345
Client updates (15)434
Documents (10)443
Reporting (10)353
Integrations (10)533
Data export (5)432
Support (5)443
Weighted total out of 500380410355

Example: reading the scores

Example (fictional): a seven-solicitor firm doing residential conveyancing and private client work shortlists three systems. System C has the best conveyancing workflow but weak accounts and poor data export. System B wins on accounts and reporting, while System A integrates most easily with the firm's phone system and document platform.

The partners choose System B, because accounts errors carry regulatory risk and its conveyancing workflow scored a respectable 4. They negotiate a fixed-price workflow build for their sale and purchase templates as part of the contract, rather than paying later. The low score for System C on data export would have made a future move expensive, which is easy to overlook in a demo.

Integrations worth testing in the demo

Integration claims are easy to make and hard to check from a brochure. A system that lists dozens of connectors may still leave your staff copying names, addresses and dates by hand between screens. Ask to see each integration you care about working live, on the vendor's own test account, with data flowing in both directions where that matters.

  • Email and documents: can a fee earner file an email to the matter in two clicks, with attachments, from the mail client they already use?
  • Telephony: does an incoming call show the caller's matter, and is the call logged against it automatically?
  • Identity and AML checks: are results and certificates saved to the client record without downloading and uploading files?
  • Accounts and banking: do bank feeds post to the right ledger, and can the cashier match receipts in bulk?
  • E-signature: does a signed document return to the matter with its audit certificate attached?

Write down what you see rather than what you are told, and ask whether each integration is built and maintained by the vendor or by a third party. Third-party connectors can be excellent, but they add another contract, another processor and another thing that can stop working after an update.

Contract terms worth negotiating

The demo decides which system you prefer; the contract decides how comfortable you will be in three years. Before signing, ask for the following in writing: a named data location and a processor agreement, a full export of matters, documents, ledgers and audit logs in a documented format at no extra charge on exit, a fixed price or capped day rate for workflow builds, and support hours that match your working day, including the hours your cashier actually works. Ask how much notice you will get of price changes and of features being withdrawn. Short initial terms with a renewal option are often available if you ask, especially for smaller firms.

Questions for reference calls

  • How long did your migration take, and what would you do differently?
  • What does support do when a reconciliation will not balance?
  • Which features did you stop using, and why?
  • How often do updates change screens your staff rely on?
  • Have you tried exporting a full set of matters, and what came out?

Ask the vendor for references you choose from a list, not ones they hand-pick, and ask at least one firm that has been a customer for more than three years. Long-standing customers can tell you how pricing and support changed after the first contract.

Next steps

Use the practice management buyer's checklist to turn these criteria into vendor questions, and read legal accounting software and the SRA Accounts Rules before you test accounts features. If you have not yet decided which system to replace first, start with legal technology for small law firms.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between case management and practice management software?

Case management focuses on the matter: documents, tasks, key dates and workflow. Practice management usually adds time recording, billing and accounts. Many products now do both, so compare features rather than labels.

Do I need case management software that includes accounts?

Not always, but the two must stay in step. If accounts are separate, check how matters, bills and ledgers are shared, and test a reconciliation during the demo.

How many systems should a small firm shortlist?

Two or three. More than that dilutes scoring and wastes partner time. Use categories to narrow the field before booking demos.

Is a specialist conveyancing system better than a general suite?

For high-volume conveyancing it often is, because milestone tracking and search ordering are deeper. For a mixed practice, a general suite with a strong conveyancing module may be simpler to run.

References

  1. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Breakdown of solicitor firms (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2019). SRA Accounts Rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Artificial intelligence in UK businesses: 2023 to 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo