Client onboarding and AML

Client and matter risk assessments for AML

A practical client and matter risk assessment for solicitors: the legal basis, risk factors, scoring, when to refresh, and what SRA inspectors look for.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the CMRA matters
  2. What the SRA finds
  3. The five risk areas
  4. Scoring without losing judgement
  5. How to complete a CMRA: step by step
  6. Common CMRA mistakes
  7. Training fee earners to do it well
  8. Out-of-scope work and mixed matters
  9. When to refresh the assessment
  10. Example: a completed CMRA extract
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Regulation 28 requires CDD measures to reflect the firm-wide risk assessment and the risk in each case, and you must be able to show the SRA they are appropriate[1].
  • In 2024/25, 16% of files the SRA reviewed had no or an incomplete client and matter risk assessment, and 39% of the assessments reviewed were ineffective[2].
  • 135 firms were referred for investigation for a lack of client and matter risk assessments on files[2].
  • Assess five areas: client, service, transaction, delivery channel and geography, and explain the rating in words.
  • A risk factor does not automatically mean high risk; the regulations require judgement, not just a score[3].

Why the CMRA matters

The client and matter risk assessment, usually shortened to CMRA, is where a firm decides how much due diligence a particular client and matter need. It connects the firm-wide risk assessment to the individual file. Without it, CDD is either the same for everyone, which wastes effort on low-risk work and under-checks high-risk work, or it is left to each fee earner's instinct, which is impossible to defend.

The legal basis is regulation 28 of the Money Laundering Regulations 2017. The CDD measures must reflect the firm's risk assessment under regulation 18 and its assessment of the level of risk arising in any particular case, and may differ from case to case[1]. Firms must take into account factors including the purpose of the transaction or relationship, the level of assets or size of transactions, and the regularity and duration of the relationship, and must be able to demonstrate to their supervisor that the extent of the measures is appropriate[1].

What the SRA finds

The SRA's 2024/25 AML annual report shows the CMRA is one of the weakest points in firms' controls. Some 950 files, 16% of those reviewed, did not contain a CMRA or the CMRA was incomplete[2]. Of the CMRAs reviewed, 39% were ineffective, and on a small number of files, 5%, the SRA disagreed with the risk rating[2]. 135 firms, half of those referred for investigation, were referred for a lack of CMRAs on files[2].

Client and matter risk assessment problems found by the SRA, 2024/25Percentages as reported by the SRA; bases differ (files reviewed or assessments reviewed)
Client and matter risk assessment problems found by the SRA, 2024/25Bar chart. CMRAs reviewed that were ineffective: 39%; Files with no or an incomplete CMRA: 16%; Files where the SRA disagreed with the rating: 5%.CMRAs reviewed that were ineffectiveCMRAs reviewed that were ineffective: 39%39%Files with no or an incomplete CMRAFiles with no or an incomplete CMRA: 16%16%Files where the SRA disagreed with the ratingFiles where the SRA disagreed with the rating: 5%5%Client and matter risk assessment problems found by the SRA, 2024/25Bar chart. CMRAs reviewed that were ineffective: 39%; Files with no or an incomplete CMRA: 16%; Files where the SRA disagreed with the rating: 5%.CMRAs reviewed that were ineffectiveCMRAs reviewed that were ineffective: 39%39%Files with no or an incomplete CMRAFiles with no or an incomplete CMRA: 16%16%Files where the SRA disagreed with theratingFiles where the SRA disagreed with the rating: 5%5%

Source: Solicitors Regulation Authority, 2025[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
CMRAs reviewed that were ineffective39%
Files with no or an incomplete CMRA16%
Files where the SRA disagreed with the rating5%

Ineffective usually means one of three things: a template completed with ticks but no explanation, an assessment that ignores obvious risk factors on the file, or an assessment done after the work started. Inspectors look for a reasoned rating, completed before CDD was decided, that matches what the file shows.

The five risk areas

Use the same five areas your firm-wide risk assessment covers, so the two documents speak the same language. For each, record what you know and how it affects risk.

Client and matter risk assessment: factors by area
AreaLower risk indicatorsHigher risk indicators
ClientKnown individual, UK resident, transparent employment or business, met in person or reliably verifiedPEP or close associate, complex or opaque ownership, nominee shareholders, cash-intensive business, reluctance to give information
ServiceRoutine work the firm does often, clear legal purposeWork outside the firm's usual practice, trust or company formation without clear purpose, holding funds without an underlying transaction
TransactionValue consistent with client's profile, mortgage from a mainstream lenderUnusually large or complex, cash purchase, rapid resale, payments from unknown third parties, no apparent economic purpose
Delivery channelFace-to-face or strong digital ID, direct instructionNon-face-to-face without safeguards, instructions through intermediaries, pressure to move fast
GeographyUK-based parties and fundsLinks to high-risk third countries, jurisdictions with high corruption or sanctions exposure

Regulation 33 lists factors that may indicate higher risk, including clients that are vehicles for holding personal assets, companies with nominee shareholders or bearer shares, cash-intensive businesses, unusually complex ownership, non-face-to-face relationships without safeguards, payments from unknown third parties, and countries without effective AML systems or with high levels of corruption[3].

Scoring without losing judgement

Many firms use a simple score for each area, such as low, medium or high, and an overall rating. Scores help consistency, but they cannot replace judgement. The regulations say the presence of one or more risk factors does not necessarily indicate a high risk in every case[3]. Equally, a single serious factor, such as a PEP or funds from a high-risk third country, can make a matter high risk even if everything else scores low.

  • Score each area, then decide the overall rating in words, explaining the main drivers.
  • Allow any single high factor to override an average score.
  • Link the rating to a defined CDD level: simplified, standard or enhanced.
  • Require supervisor or MLRO approval for high-risk ratings before work proceeds.
  • Never let the system calculate a rating that nobody reads.

How to complete a CMRA: step by step

  1. Gather the facts first

    Use the instruction details, ID results, ownership information and the funding plan. A CMRA completed before you know how the matter is funded is premature.

  2. Work through the five areas

    For each, note the relevant facts and whether they lower or raise risk. Write a sentence, not just a tick.

  3. Check the firm-wide assessment

    Does it identify this matter type or client type as higher risk? If so, say how this matter compares.

  4. Set the rating and CDD level

    Explain the reasons. If enhanced, list the extra measures, such as source of wealth evidence or senior approval.

  5. Get sign-off where required

    High-risk matters should be approved before work begins, and the approval recorded.

  6. Date and diary review

    Record when the CMRA was completed and set triggers for review.

Common CMRA mistakes

Most weak assessments share a few habits. Recognising them is the quickest way to improve a firm's files before the SRA does it for you.

  1. Completing the form at file closure, or after exchange, rather than at the start.
  2. Copying the previous matter's assessment for a returning client without checking what has changed.
  3. Rating every matter low because the client is known to the partner.
  4. Ticking 'no PEP' without having screened the client.
  5. Recording a funding plan in the CMRA that does not match what later arrives in client account.
  6. Leaving the overall rating unexplained, so a reviewer cannot see why standard CDD was enough.

Training fee earners to do it well

A good template is only half the answer. Fee earners need to understand why each question is there and what a good answer looks like. Short, practical training works best: take three anonymised files from your own practice, one low, one medium and one high risk, and walk through how each assessment should read. Then ask fee earners to complete a CMRA for a fictional scenario and compare the results. Differences in rating show where your guidance is unclear.

Build the assessment into the workflow rather than adding it at the end. If the matter cannot move to live status, or client money cannot be received, until the CMRA is complete and approved where needed, the habit forms quickly. Sample a handful of CMRAs each month and give individual feedback.

Out-of-scope work and mixed matters

Matters outside the regulations do not need a CMRA, but they do need a recorded scope decision. Be careful with mixed matters: a divorce settlement where the firm handles the sale of the family home, an estate where the firm goes on to act as trustee of a continuing trust, or a dispute that ends with the firm moving settlement funds can raise the question of whether part of the work is in scope. Check against the regulations and your firm's guidance. Review the scope decision when the matter changes, and complete a CMRA at that point if needed.

When to refresh the assessment

A CMRA is a snapshot. Refresh it when something material changes: a new party joins the transaction, the funding source changes, the price or structure changes significantly, the client's ownership changes, or something unexpected appears, such as a request to pay funds to a third party. For long-running relationships, review at regular intervals set by your policy. Firms must also monitor the relationship throughout, checking that transactions are consistent with what they know about the client[1].

Example: a completed CMRA extract

Example (fictional). Client: an individual buying a buy-to-let flat. Client area: UK resident, salaried professional, verified by digital ID with chip read; low. Service: residential purchase, routine for the firm; low. Transaction: price within normal range for the area, but 60% funded by a transfer from a relative overseas; medium. Delivery channel: instructed remotely through a mortgage broker the firm has not worked with before; medium. Geography: relative's funds from a country not on the high-risk list but with moderate corruption indicators; medium. Overall: medium, driven by the overseas third-party funding. CDD level: standard, plus source of funds evidence from the relative, including their identity, the origin of the funds and confirmation the transfer is a gift. Reviewer: approved by supervisor before exchange.

Residential purchases are the most common in-scope work for many firms. There were 1,144,580 UK residential property transactions in the 2025 to 2026 financial year[4], and each purchase a firm handles needs its own assessment. Related guides: source of funds vs source of wealth checks, firm-wide AML risk assessment: what to include and enhanced due diligence and politically exposed persons.

Frequently asked questions

What is a client and matter risk assessment?

A documented assessment, for each in-scope client and matter, of the money laundering and terrorist financing risk, used to decide the level of due diligence needed. It should reflect the firm-wide risk assessment.

Is a client and matter risk assessment a legal requirement?

Regulation 28 requires CDD measures to reflect the firm's risk assessment and the risk in each case, and firms must show the SRA their measures are appropriate. A documented CMRA is the practical way to do that, and the SRA expects to see one.

When should the risk assessment be done?

At the start of the matter, once enough facts are known, and before CDD is decided and work begins. It should be refreshed when material facts change.

Can software calculate the risk rating?

Software can help with consistency, but a person must review the result and explain it. A single serious factor can make a matter high risk even if the score is low.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2017). The Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017, regulation 28 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). Anti-money laundering annual report 2024/25 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2017). The Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations 2017, regulation 33 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK) (2026). UK monthly property transactions tables (Table 3: residential transactions by month), October 2026 release (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo