Key takeaways
- An early case assessment answers one question for the client: is this dispute worth pursuing, and how?
- Time is part of the cost: the median fast, intermediate and multi-track claim took 55.9 weeks to reach trial[1].
- Score merits, evidence, recoverability, value against cost, and funding separately; a strong claim against an insolvent opponent is a weak case.
- Give the best possible information on cost at the start and update it as the matter moves[2].
- Most disputes settle, so plan the early steps around getting to a sensible negotiation quickly.
What early case assessment is for
A business owner who calls about a commercial dispute usually wants a verdict: 'Do we have a case?' The more useful question is whether pursuing the dispute is worth it, on what route and at what cost. Early case assessment is the structured way to answer that in the first few weeks, before the client has spent heavily or committed to a strategy driven by anger.
Disputes cost small businesses more than legal fees. Research for the Legal Services Board found that 28% of small businesses with a legal issue lost income because of it and 10% lost a customer or contract[3]. A third (32%) had at least one legal issue in a year[4], but only a quarter (25%) of those with an issue used professional help[5], so many disputes reach a solicitor late, with positions already hardened. The firm that helps a client decide quickly, even if the decision is not to litigate, often keeps that client for years.
The six questions in a commercial ECA
- Merits: on the documents available, how strong is the claim or defence on liability, causation and loss?
- Evidence: what documents, witnesses and expert evidence exist, and who controls them?
- Recoverability: if the client wins, can the other side pay?
- Value against cost: what is realistically recoverable, compared with the cost of getting there and the risk of paying the other side's costs?
- Time: how long will each route take, and what does delay cost the business?
- Funding and alternatives: how will the client pay, and is there a quicker or cheaper route such as negotiation, mediation or expert determination?
Each question gets its own answer. A common error is to let a strong view on merits carry the others. A clear breach of contract by a company that is about to enter administration is not a good case to fund, however strong the liability argument.
An ECA scorecard
| Factor | Strong | Uncertain | Weak |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability | Clear contract term and clear breach | Arguable either way, or turns on oral terms | Contract favours the other side |
| Loss | Documented and calculable | Depends on expert evidence | Speculative or hard to prove |
| Evidence | Emails and documents held by the client | Key evidence held by the other side | Mostly recollection |
| Recoverability | Solvent opponent with assets | Unknown financial position | Signs of insolvency |
| Value against cost | Value well above likely cost to trial | Value and cost close | Cost likely to exceed value |
| Time pressure | Client can wait | Delay is painful but manageable | Delay threatens the business |
Share the completed scorecard with the client. It turns a vague 'it depends' into a concrete picture, and it gives the client something to discuss with co-directors or their bank. Update it after disclosure, after expert evidence and before any settlement meeting.
Time is part of the cost
Clients routinely underestimate how long litigation takes. In April to June 2026, the median time for fast, intermediate and multi-track claims to reach trial was 55.9 weeks, and small claims took a median of 41.0 weeks[1]. Those are medians for cases that reached trial; many settle earlier, but the timetable shapes the pressure on both sides.
Source: Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK), 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Small claims | 41 weeks |
| Fast, intermediate and multi-track | 55.9 weeks |
Few cases get that far. There were 12,000 trials in April to June 2026, down 10% on a year earlier[1], against hundreds of thousands of claims issued. Most disputes end in a negotiated settlement, so an early assessment should be designed to get the client to a well-informed negotiation, not just to a trial date.
55.9 weeks
median time from issue to trial for fast, intermediate and multi-track claims, April to June 2026[1]
Talking about costs and costs risk
Solicitors must give clients the best possible information about pricing at the time of engagement and as the matter progresses[2]. In a dispute, that means more than an hourly rate. The client needs to understand three numbers: what their own costs might be at each stage, how much of those they might recover if they win, and what they might have to pay the other side if they lose.
Present costs by phase: pre-action, issue and statements of case, disclosure, witness and expert evidence, trial preparation and trial. Give a range for each and explain what moves a case from the bottom of the range to the top, such as the volume of documents or a contested expert issue. In many multi-track claims the court will also manage costs through budgets, so explain early that the budget becomes a constraint on what can be recovered.
Poor information on cost and progress is a frequent source of complaints. Poor communication (24%) and delay or failure to progress (22%) were the most common complaint types brought to the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26[6]. A written costs update at each phase is cheap insurance against both.
Funding options to discuss at the start
- Own funds: the simplest route; agree a budget and review points.
- Legal expenses insurance: check the client's business insurance policies for cover before advising on anything else.
- Conditional fee agreements: the firm takes some risk in return for a success fee, where the firm offers them and the case suits it.
- After-the-event insurance: protects against adverse costs; premiums and terms vary with the merits.
- Third-party funding: for larger claims, a funder may pay costs in return for a share of the proceeds; expect detailed scrutiny of merits and recoverability.
- Staged instructions: fund only the next phase, with a decision point at the end of each.
Record which options were discussed and why each was or was not suitable. Clients sometimes forget an earlier conversation about insurance when an adverse costs order arrives.
The first 14 days
Day 1 to 2: intake and conflict check
Identify the parties, run the conflict check, capture the key dates and ask for the contract and core correspondence.
Day 3 to 5: limitation and urgency
Diary any limitation date (contract claims are generally barred after six years) and check for urgent issues such as asset dissipation or contractual notice deadlines.
Day 5 to 8: document review
Read the contract, the correspondence and any expert reports. Build a short chronology.
Day 8 to 10: opponent check
Search Companies House for accounts and charges, and consider the opponent's ability to pay.
Day 10 to 12: scorecard and costs
Complete the scorecard and a phased costs estimate with ranges.
Day 12 to 14: advice meeting
Present the options, including negotiation and mediation, and agree the next phase and its budget in writing.
Worked example: a supplier dispute
Example: a food manufacturer claims £120,000 from a packaging supplier after a batch of faulty trays caused a product recall. The supplier denies fault and says the manufacturer stored the trays badly. The manufacturer's managing director wants to issue proceedings immediately.
Example, continued: the assessment scores liability as uncertain (the contract's quality terms are clear, but storage is disputed), loss as strong (recall costs are documented), evidence as uncertain (the supplier holds its production records), recoverability as strong (a solvent group company) and value against cost as acceptable but tight once an expert is needed. The solicitor recommends a detailed letter of claim, a joint expert inspection of retained trays and an early mediation once the expert reports. The client agrees a budget for that phase only. The dispute settles at mediation for a sum the client accepts, long before any trial could have been listed, and the client's total spend is a fraction of a full litigation budget.
Making the first contact count
Commercial dispute enquiries often come straight after a breakdown: a final email from the other side, a rejected invoice or a cancelled contract. The caller is under pressure and may have a deadline they have not noticed. Reception should capture the parties, the amount, the key dates and any deadlines mentioned in correspondence, and route the call to a dispute resolution solicitor the same day.
If calls come in after hours, an AI Employee such as Ava can capture those details and book the first review slot, with every judgement on merits and strategy left to the solicitor. For related business enquiries, see debt recovery and pre-action steps, shareholder agreements and business versus consumer enquiries.
Frequently asked questions
What is early case assessment?
A structured review in the first weeks of a dispute that scores merits, evidence, recoverability, value against cost, time and funding, and recommends a route.
How long does a commercial claim take to reach trial?
In April to June 2026 the median for fast, intermediate and multi-track claims was 55.9 weeks[1], though most disputes settle before trial.
Should a client always try mediation?
Usually it should be considered seriously. It is often quicker and cheaper, and courts expect parties to consider alternatives to litigation.
What should a firm tell a client about costs at the start?
The best possible information about likely costs, how they may change as the matter progresses, and the risk of paying the other side's costs[2].
References
Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Civil Justice Statistics Quarterly: April to June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2021). Small business legal needs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2021). Small business legal needs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2021). Small business legal needs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑