Practice area operations

Contentious probate enquiries: early risk triage

How to triage contentious probate enquiries in the first call: time limits, caveats, conflict checks, risk signals and when to escalate to a specialist.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What a contentious probate call sounds like
  2. Two dates that matter more than any other
  3. Caveats: useful, but not a casual step
  4. Risk signals and what to do with them
  5. The early triage call, step by step
  6. Who the firm can act for
  7. Calls from executors facing a challenge
  8. Example: a call that nearly missed the clock
  9. Why careful triage protects the firm too
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • An Inheritance Act claim must normally be made within six months of the grant, so the grant date is the first fact to capture[1].
  • A caveat stops a grant for six months at first and can be extended, but it can lead to legal action and costs[2].
  • Run the conflict check before the caller explains the dispute; the firm may already act for the estate.
  • Wills and probate complaints show the highest rate of poor service findings, so careful early handling pays off[3].

What a contentious probate call sounds like

Few callers say 'I want to bring a contentious probate claim'. They say their father changed his will after he became ill, that their stepmother has 'taken everything', that they were promised the farm, that the executor will not tell them anything, or that they were left out entirely. Some callers are potential claimants. Others are executors or beneficiaries who are facing a challenge and want to defend the will. The same receptionist may take both kinds of call in a morning, sometimes about the same estate.

Because these disputes are emotional and often urgent, the first call should be short, careful and focused on three things: who the caller is, what the key dates are, and whether the firm can act. Detailed discussion of the merits belongs with a specialist fee earner, ideally within a day or two.

Two dates that matter more than any other

The first date is the grant of representation. Under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, an application for financial provision from an estate cannot be made more than six months after representation is first taken out, except with the court's permission[1]. The Act also allows an application to be made before the grant[1]. If a caller mentions that probate has been granted, or might be granted soon, the enquiry becomes time-critical.

The second date is the date of death, because it tells the fee earner how far the estate has probably progressed and whether assets may already have been distributed. In April to June 2026 there were 61,941 probate applications and grants took about 5 weeks on average to issue, so the window between death and grant can be short[4]. A caller who waits two months to ring a solicitor may find the grant already issued.

6 months

from the grant, the normal time limit for an Inheritance Act claim without the court's permission[1]

Caveats: useful, but not a casual step

Callers often ask how to 'stop probate'. GOV.UK explains that a person can enter a caveat if there is a dispute, for example about who can apply, whether a will exists or whether a will is valid[2]. The caveat lasts for 6 months at first and can be extended for another 6 months, and it stops all grants on the estate during that time[2]. GOV.UK also warns that entering a caveat can lead to legal action and legal costs, and suggests trying to reach agreement with the applicant first[2].

Reception should never advise a caller to enter a caveat, or tell them not to. They can explain that a caveat exists, that it has consequences, and that a specialist will advise on whether it is the right step. Where a caller says they intend to enter one themselves today, flag the enquiry for a same-day call-back.

Risk signals and what to do with them

Early risk signals in contentious probate enquiries and the first action for each
What the caller mentionsWhat it may indicateAction
Probate has been granted, or the executor says it is imminentThe six-month Inheritance Act clock is running or about to startSame-day call-back from a specialist
The will was changed shortly before death, during illnessPossible capacity or undue influence issuesBook specialist meeting; ask for dates and names of witnesses if known
A relative helped prepare the will or was present when it was signedPossible want of knowledge and approvalRecord the caller's account in their own words
The caller was promised property in return for work or carePossible proprietary estoppel claimNote what was promised, by whom and when
The caller was financially dependent on the deceasedPossible Inheritance Act claimCapture relationship, living arrangements and the grant date
Assets are being sold or movedRisk that the estate is distributed before a claimEscalate the same day
The executor is refusing to share informationPossible administration disputeBook specialist meeting; ask what has been requested

Do not write 'no merit' or 'strong claim' on an enquiry record. Reception's job is to record facts and urgency; merit is for the specialist.

The early triage call, step by step

  1. Take names for the conflict check first

    Ask for the name of the person who died, the executors and the main beneficiaries before the caller explains the dispute. The firm may have drafted the will or may act for the estate.

  2. Identify the caller's role

    Potential claimant, executor, beneficiary defending the will, or a relative seeking information. Each needs a different fee earner approach.

  3. Capture the key dates

    Date of death, date of the will in dispute, whether a grant has been issued and when, and any date by which assets will be sold.

  4. Ask what the caller wants

    To challenge the will, to receive provision from the estate, to get information, or to defend a challenge.

  5. Ask about documents

    Copies of wills, the grant, letters from the executor or the other side, and any medical information about capacity.

  6. Explain costs and next steps

    Say that disputes can be costly, that the specialist will explain funding options and risk at the first meeting, and book it.

  7. Confirm in writing

    Send a summary that repeats the key dates the caller gave, so any error is corrected early.

Who the firm can act for

Conflicts are more common in this work than in almost any other private client area. The firm may have drafted the disputed will, may be acting as executor, or may act for another family member. Each of those can prevent the firm from acting for the caller, and in some cases the firm will itself be a witness to how the will was made. That is why names come before facts on the first call.

  • If the firm drafted the will, the will file may be evidence; the specialist will decide what can be disclosed and to whom.
  • If the firm acts for the executors, it cannot advise a beneficiary who is challenging them.
  • If two family members call separately, do not act for either until a fee earner has checked the conflict position.
  • If the firm cannot act, say so promptly and suggest the caller seeks advice elsewhere quickly because of time limits.

Calls from executors facing a challenge

Not every contentious call comes from someone unhappy with the will. Executors and beneficiaries often call because they have received a solicitor's letter, learned that a caveat has been entered, or heard that a relative intends to challenge. These callers are anxious about personal liability and about the delay to the estate, and they usually want to know whether they can carry on administering it.

  • Ask for the letter or notice they have received, and the date on it, since replies may have deadlines.
  • Ask whether any assets have already been distributed or are about to be sold.
  • Ask whether the firm, or another firm, is already acting in the administration.
  • Tell them not to reply to the other side in detail before speaking to the specialist.
  • Book the specialist promptly; a measured early response often prevents a dispute from escalating.

An executor who is well advised at the start can often keep the estate moving on the parts that are not in dispute. One who replies alone, angrily, to a claimant's letter can make settlement much harder. A calm first call that books the right person quickly is worth a great deal to both.

Example: a call that nearly missed the clock

Example (fictional). A woman calls on a Thursday afternoon about her late partner's estate. She lived with him for several years, he left everything to his brother, and she 'did not want to make a fuss'. The receptionist takes the names, runs the conflict check and asks the grant question. The caller says the grant was issued 'some months ago' and finds the letter: it is five and a half months old.

Example (fictional). The receptionist flags the enquiry as time-critical and gets a contentious probate solicitor on the phone within the hour. The solicitor takes instructions and acts before the six-month point. Had the call been booked into a routine appointment the following week, the claim would have needed the court's permission to proceed.

Why careful triage protects the firm too

Wills and probate accounted for 1,147 complaints accepted by the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26, 14% of the total, and had the highest rate of evidence of poor service of any area at 79%[3]. Contentious matters are a significant source of that risk, because expectations about cost and outcome are set early and are hard to reset later.

Legal Ombudsman complaints with evidence of poor service, 2025/26Share of complaints assessed where the Legal Ombudsman found evidence of poor service
Legal Ombudsman complaints with evidence of poor service, 2025/26Bar chart. Wills and probate: 79%; Residential conveyancing: 78%; All complaints assessed: 72%.Wills and probateWills and probate: 79%79%Residential conveyancingResidential conveyancing: 78%78%All complaints assessedAll complaints assessed: 72%72%Legal Ombudsman complaints with evidence of poor service, 2025/26Bar chart. Wills and probate: 79%; Residential conveyancing: 78%; All complaints assessed: 72%.Wills and probateWills and probate: 79%79%Residential conveyancingResidential conveyancing: 78%78%All complaints assessedAll complaints assessed: 72%72%

Source: Legal Ombudsman, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Wills and probate79%
Residential conveyancing78%
All complaints assessed72%
  • Record exactly what the caller was told about time limits and costs on the first call.
  • Use a written enquiry summary to fix the key dates in writing from day one.
  • Diarise the six-month date on any potential Inheritance Act matter, even before the client instructs.
  • Close enquiries the firm cannot take with a short non-engagement letter that mentions time limits.

Frequently asked questions

What is the time limit for an Inheritance Act claim?

Normally six months from the date the grant of representation is first taken out. After that, the court's permission is needed. A claim can also be made before the grant.

How long does a probate caveat last?

Six months at first, and it can be extended for another six months. It stops any grant being issued on the estate while it is in force.

Can reception tell a caller whether they have a claim?

No. Reception should record facts, dates and urgency, run the conflict check and book a specialist. Merit is assessed by the fee earner.

Why ask for names before the story?

The firm may have drafted the will or may act for the executors or another beneficiary. Hearing the dispute first can create a conflict problem before the check is done.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1975). Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, section 4 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). Stopping a probate application: challenge someone else's probate application (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Family Court Statistics Quarterly: April to June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo