Practice area operations

Criminal legal aid vs private fees: explaining options

Explaining criminal legal aid and private fees to clients and families: free police station advice, means testing, Crown Court contributions and scripts.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the funding conversation is hard
  2. At the police station: free for everyone
  3. In the magistrates' court: two tests
  4. In the Crown Court: legal aid with contributions
  5. Options by stage
  6. Where private fees fit
  7. A script for the funding conversation
  8. Misunderstandings to correct gently
  9. Example: a family ready to pay
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Advice at the police station is free for anyone questioned there, whatever their income[1].
  • Court legal aid depends on an interests of justice test and a means test, with automatic eligibility for under-18s and people on certain benefits[2].
  • In the Crown Court, legal aid may be granted with income contributions, set at 90% of disposable income for up to six months[2].
  • Explain options neutrally and in writing; families often pay without understanding what legal aid would have covered.

Why the funding conversation is hard

Criminal clients and their families usually raise money at the worst possible moment: just after an arrest, before a first hearing or when a case is sent to the Crown Court. They have heard that legal aid is 'free', or that it is 'only for people on benefits', or that a private solicitor will try harder. None of those beliefs is reliable, and a firm that explains the real position calmly earns trust that lasts the whole case.

The rules are technical, so this guide gives front-line staff and junior fee earners a structure for the conversation rather than a substitute for the Legal Aid Agency's own guidance. The LAA's criminal means testing guidance was last updated in February 2025[2]; check it before relying on any threshold below.

At the police station: free for everyone

The simplest message is also the most important. GOV.UK says people have the right to free legal advice if they are questioned at a police station, and that the duty solicitor is available 24 hours a day[1]. There is no means test for this advice. A family member who offers to pay privately for a solicitor to attend an interview should be told, accurately, that police station advice is free, and that the person can ask for a solicitor of their choice, including the firm, if the firm does this work.

This is a large part of criminal legal aid. Police station advice made up 69% of Crime Lower legal aid workload in April to June 2026, but only 58% of Crime Lower expenditure[3]. In England and Wales 1,044 providers held criminal legal aid contracts in June 2026[3].

Police station advice as a share of Crime Lower legal aidEngland and Wales, April to June 2026
Police station advice as a share of Crime Lower legal aidComparison. Share of Crime Lower workload: 69%; Share of Crime Lower expenditure: 58%.69%Share of Crime Lower workloadShare of Crime Lower workload: 69%58%Share of Crime Lower expenditureShare of Crime Lower expenditure: 58%Police station advice as a share of Crime Lower legal aidComparison. Share of Crime Lower workload: 69%; Share of Crime Lower expenditure: 58%.69%Share of Crime Lower workloadShare of Crime Lower workload: 69%58%Share of Crime Lower expenditureShare of Crime Lower expenditure: 58%

Source: Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK), 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Share of Crime Lower workload69%
Share of Crime Lower expenditure58%

In the magistrates' court: two tests

For representation in court, an applicant must pass both an interests of justice test and a means test[2]. The interests of justice test looks at factors such as the seriousness of the case and the risk to the person's liberty or livelihood. The means test has several layers.

  • Passporting: applicants automatically pass the means test if they are under 18 or receive Universal Credit, Income Support, income-based Jobseeker's Allowance, Guarantee Credit or income-based Employment and Support Allowance[2].
  • Initial means test: applicants with lower adjusted income pass without a full assessment; the full means test is used where adjusted annual income is more than £12,475 and less than £22,325[2].
  • Full means test: where disposable income is £3,398 or less, magistrates' court representation is funded; above that it is not[2].
  • Applicants with higher incomes are likely to fail the magistrates' court means test and may need to pay privately, though they can still have free advice at the police station.

Never tell a caller that they 'will not get legal aid' because of their job or house. Run the firm's screening questions and let the fee earner or the LAA decide.

The Crown Court works differently. Eligibility is wider there, but some defendants are asked to contribute. The LAA's guidance says that where disposable income is above £3,398, a Crown Court trial defendant may be eligible with an income contribution, and that income contributions are set at 90% of disposable income for a maximum of six months[2]. Applicants assessed with disposable income of £37,500 or more can apply for an eligibility review[2].

Crown Court work accounts for a relatively small share of criminal legal aid by volume but around two thirds of criminal legal aid expenditure[3]. The bulletin reports that representation orders granted in the magistrates' court rose 10% compared with the same period in 2024, while those in the Crown Court fell 7%[3]. For families, the key point is that a Crown Court case is not automatically private: legal aid with a contribution may be cheaper and more predictable than they expect.

Options by stage

Criminal funding options by stage, summarised from the Legal Aid Agency's means testing guidance
StageLegal aid positionWhat to explain about private fees
Police station interviewFree advice for anyone questionedUsually no reason to pay privately for police station advice
Magistrates' courtInterests of justice test and means test; passported for under-18s and certain benefitsIf the means test is failed, the firm's private fixed fees apply; explain what each covers
Appeal to the Crown CourtPossible funding, depending on means and outcome of the appealExplain any contribution risk if the appeal fails
Crown Court trialOften available, sometimes with income contributionsCompare contributions with private fees carefully before advising
Committal for sentenceFunded where magistrates' court eligibility is metExplain continuity of representation

Where private fees fit

Most legal services in England and Wales are paid for privately. In the 2026 consumer tracker, 74% of users paid for the service themselves or with help from family or friends, and legal aid funded only 5%[4]. In criminal work the balance is different, but private clients remain important: people whose income is above the magistrates' court thresholds, people charged with motoring and other summary offences, and some who want representation that legal aid does not cover.

  • Quote private fees as fixed fees by stage wherever possible, with clear triggers for any change.
  • Explain whether the fee covers a guilty plea, a trial, or both, and what happens if the case moves court.
  • Put the explanation of legal aid and the private fee side by side in the client care letter.
  • Record that the client was told about legal aid eligibility, even if they chose to pay privately.

A script for the funding conversation

  1. Start with the free part

    'Advice at the police station is free for everyone, so there is nothing to pay for that.'

  2. Explain the two tests

    'For court, legal aid depends on how serious the case is and on income. Some people qualify automatically, such as under-18s and people on certain benefits.'

  3. Ask the screening questions

    Age, benefits, household income and whether a partner's income counts, using the firm's approved form.

  4. Explain what happens if they do not qualify

    'If legal aid is not available, our fixed fees for this stage are on our website, and we will confirm them in writing.'

  5. For Crown Court cases, mention contributions

    'Legal aid in the Crown Court is often available, sometimes with a monthly contribution. We will work out which option is better for you.'

  6. Confirm in writing

    Send the explanation and the fee basis the same day, so the family can read it calmly.

Misunderstandings to correct gently

Families and defendants bring strong assumptions to the funding conversation. Correcting them politely, early and in writing prevents disputes later and helps the client make a real choice.

  • 'Legal aid lawyers are not as good.' The same solicitors often do both legal aid and private work, and the client can usually choose a firm that holds a contract.
  • 'Parents' income counts.' The means test looks at the defendant and any partner; the LAA's worked examples include a partner's income, not that of other relatives[2].
  • 'If I have a job, I cannot get legal aid.' Working people on modest incomes can pass the magistrates' court test, and Crown Court eligibility is wider.
  • 'Paying privately means the case will be quicker.' Court timetables are the same whoever pays.
  • 'Legal aid is free in the Crown Court.' It may come with income contributions, and the client needs to understand them before choosing.

Record on the file which of these points was discussed and what the client decided. If a client later asks why they paid privately, a clear note that legal aid was explained protects both the client relationship and the firm.

Example: a family ready to pay

Example (fictional). A father calls because his 19-year-old daughter has been charged with an assault and has a magistrates' court date. He says the family will pay whatever it costs. The receptionist explains that the daughter's own means are assessed, not her father's, asks the screening questions and learns that she is a student with a part-time job. She books a fee earner, who helps the daughter apply for legal aid. It is granted.

Example (fictional). The father is surprised and grateful. Had the firm simply quoted a private fee, the family would have paid for representation that legal aid covered, and might later have felt misled. The firm earns the case, a referral to a family friend, and a client who trusts its advice.

Frequently asked questions

Is police station advice free?

Yes. Anyone questioned at a police station has the right to free legal advice, and the duty solicitor is available 24 hours a day.

Who qualifies automatically for magistrates' court legal aid on means?

Under-18s and people receiving certain benefits, such as Universal Credit or income-based Jobseeker's Allowance, pass the means test automatically. They must still pass the interests of justice test.

Do people pay towards Crown Court legal aid?

Some do. Where disposable income is above the threshold, legal aid may be granted with income contributions of 90% of disposable income for up to six months.

Should a family pay privately if they can afford it?

Not without first checking legal aid. The means test looks at the defendant and any partner, not parents or other relatives, so legal aid may cover work the family was ready to pay for.

References

  1. GOV.UK (2026). Being arrested: your rights: legal advice at the police station (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Aid Agency (GOV.UK) (2025). Criminal legal aid: means testing (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Legal aid statistics England and Wales bulletin: April to June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo