Key takeaways
- A DBA links the lawyer's payment to the financial benefit the client obtains, and must meet statutory conditions to be enforceable[1].
- Caps, including VAT: 25% of general damages and past losses in personal injury, 35% in employment matters and 50% in other claims[2][3].
- DBAs cannot be used for criminal or family proceedings, the same exclusions as CFAs[1].
- Employment work is where DBAs are most common, and Employment Tribunal demand is rising fast[4].
What a DBA is
A damages-based agreement is the closest thing England and Wales has to an American contingency fee. Under section 58AA of the Courts and Legal Services Act 1990, it is an agreement between a person providing advocacy, litigation or claims management services and the client, under which the client pays if they obtain a specified financial benefit, and the amount is determined by reference to that benefit[1]. In plain terms, the lawyer takes a percentage of what the client recovers.
A DBA is enforceable only if it meets the conditions in section 58AA[1]. It must be in writing, must not relate to proceedings that cannot be the subject of an enforceable conditional fee agreement, must not provide for a payment above the prescribed amount, must comply with the prescribed terms, and must be made only after the provider has given any prescribed information[1]. A DBA that fails any of these conditions is unenforceable, which can leave the firm with nothing.
The caps
The Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013 set the maximum payment, and in each case the cap includes VAT. In a personal injury claim, the payment cannot exceed 25% of the combined general damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenity and damages for past financial loss[2]. In other claims, apart from employment matters, the cap is 50% of the sums ultimately recovered by the client[2]. In an employment matter, the payment cannot exceed 35% of the sums ultimately recovered[3]. The personal injury and general caps apply only to claims or proceedings at first instance[2].
| Type of claim | Maximum payment, including VAT | Calculated on |
|---|---|---|
| Personal injury | 25%[2] | General damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenity, plus past financial loss |
| Employment matter | 35%[3] | Sums ultimately recovered by the client |
| Other civil claims | 50%[2] | Sums ultimately recovered by the client |
Because the caps include VAT, the firm's net fee is lower than the headline percentage. A 35% DBA in an employment matter yields rather less than 35% to the firm once VAT is accounted for[3]. Build that into your pricing decisions, and make sure the client understands that the percentage is the total they pay for your fees.
How a DBA differs from a CFA
| Feature | Conditional fee agreement | Damages-based agreement |
|---|---|---|
| What the lawyer is paid | Base costs plus a success fee if the client wins | A percentage of the sums recovered |
| Link to outcome | Fee rises with work done, not damages | Fee rises with damages, not work done |
| Cap | Success fee capped; base costs not capped by damages | Total payment capped as a share of damages |
| If the client loses | Usually nothing for fees, as the agreement says | Usually nothing for fees, as the agreement says |
| Excluded proceedings | Criminal and family | Criminal and family |
| Common use | Personal injury and clinical negligence | Employment and some commercial claims |
The economic difference is fundamental. Under a CFA, the firm's fee depends on the work it does, and the success fee rewards the risk. Under a DBA, the fee depends on the result. A DBA suits claims where the likely recovery is reasonably predictable and large relative to the work. It suits the firm less well where the work could be heavy and the recovery modest.
Employment claims: where DBAs fit most often
Employment tribunals do not usually order the losing side to pay costs, so a DBA is often the most practical way for an employee to fund representation. Demand is rising. Single-claim Employment Tribunal receipts rose 28% year on year in April to June 2026, to 14,000, and the single-claim open caseload stood at 70,000 at the end of June 2026, up 51% in a year[4]. A growing caseload means longer waits, which affects the economics of any outcome-based fee.
Source: Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK), 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| New single-claim receipts in the quarter | 14,000 |
| Open single-claim caseload at end of June | 70,000 |
Before an employment DBA is made, the regulations require specific information to be given to the client in writing, including the circumstances in which the client may seek a review of the costs, the conciliation service provided by ACAS, and whether other methods of pursuing or funding the claim are available. Build those points into a standard pre-agreement letter so they are never missed.
Deciding whether a DBA fits
Estimate the likely recovery
Form a realistic view of the range of damages or compensation and the probability of success.
Estimate the work
Estimate the hours needed to reach a likely settlement and to reach a final hearing.
Compare the outcomes
Model the firm's fee under a DBA against hourly rates and a CFA for each scenario, net of VAT.
Consider the client
Ask which option leaves the client better off in each likely outcome, and whether other funding, such as legal expenses insurance or a trade union, is available.
Decide and explain
If a DBA fits, explain the percentage in money terms using the client's likely figures.
Document the decision
Record why the DBA was chosen and what alternatives were discussed.
Example: an unfair dismissal claim
Example (fictional, round figures). An employee with a strong unfair dismissal claim expects compensation in the range of £20,000 to £30,000. The firm offers a DBA at 30%, inclusive of VAT, below the 35% cap. If the claim settles for £25,000, the client pays £7,500 and keeps £17,500. If the claim is lost, the client pays nothing for the firm's fees under the agreement, although they may still pay certain expenses if the agreement says so.
The fee earner also models an hourly retainer: if the case settled after modest work, the client would pay less on hourly rates, but they would carry the risk of a large bill if the case went to a hearing. The client chooses the DBA for certainty. The file records the comparison, the client's choice and the written pre-agreement information, so the decision can be explained if questioned later.
Paperwork for an enforceable DBA
Because an agreement that misses a statutory condition is unenforceable, treat DBA paperwork as a controlled template rather than a document drafted afresh each time. Before the client signs, check that:
- the agreement is in writing and signed;
- the matter is not one that cannot be the subject of an enforceable CFA, such as family or criminal proceedings;
- the percentage, including VAT, is within the cap for the type of claim;
- the agreement specifies the claim or proceedings it relates to, the circumstances in which the payment is due and the reason for setting the percentage at that level;
- in employment matters, the prescribed information was given in writing before the agreement was made, and a copy is on the file;
- the client has had time to read it and ask questions, and you have recorded the explanation you gave.
A supervisor should check the first few agreements a fee earner prepares, and the template should be reviewed whenever the regulations or case law change.
When a DBA is the wrong choice
A DBA is not always in the client's interest. Where the claim is likely to settle quickly for a large sum with little work, an hourly or fixed fee may cost the client far less than a percentage. Where the client has legal expenses insurance or trade union support, those may fund the claim without any deduction from compensation. And where the main remedy is non-monetary, such as reinstatement or a reference, a percentage of damages may not reflect the value of the work. In each case, explain the alternatives and record why the client chose the arrangement they did.
Risks for the firm
- An unenforceable agreement, because a statutory condition or prescribed information was missed.
- Mispricing: heavy work on a claim that settles low, or a cap that bites harder than expected because it includes VAT.
- Conflicts between the firm's interest in a quick settlement and the client's interest in the best outcome.
- Disputes over what counts as sums recovered, such as non-monetary settlement terms.
- Long tribunal waits that delay payment for work already done.
The conflict point deserves attention. A percentage fee can tempt a firm to recommend settlement earlier than the client should accept. Advice on offers must be driven by the client's interests, and the file should show why a recommendation was made.
Explaining a DBA to clients
Clients usually understand a percentage better than a success fee, which is one reason DBAs appeal. The risk is that they assume the percentage is all they will ever pay. Explain clearly what the percentage is taken from, that it includes VAT, what happens to any costs the other side pays, which expenses the client may still have to meet and what happens if the agreement ends early. Use their own likely figures and repeat the calculation when an offer arrives.
For comparison with CFAs, see conditional fee agreements explained for clients. For other funding sources, see legal expenses insurance and ATE at onboarding and litigation funding and consumer protection, and for estimates generally, see costs estimates at the start that hold up.
Frequently asked questions
What is the maximum percentage under a DBA?
Including VAT, 25% of general damages and past losses in personal injury claims, 35% in employment matters and 50% of sums recovered in other claims.
Can a DBA be used in a family case?
No. DBAs cannot relate to proceedings that cannot be the subject of an enforceable CFA, which include family and most criminal proceedings.
Is a DBA the same as no win, no fee?
It is one type of no win, no fee arrangement. The other common type is a CFA. Always tell the client which one you are using and what they may still pay.
Does the client pay anything if they lose under a DBA?
Usually not for the firm's fees, but they may still pay some expenses or the other side's costs, depending on the agreement and the forum. Explain this before they sign.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1990). Courts and Legal Services Act 1990, section 58AA: damages-based agreements (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2013). The Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013, regulation 4: payment (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2013). The Damages-Based Agreements Regulations 2013, regulation 7: payment in an employment matter (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Tribunal Statistics Quarterly: April to June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑