Data protection and cyber security

Emailing clients and prospects: PECR and soft opt-in

When a firm can email clients and prospects about its services: PECR consent, the soft opt-in, SRA limits on approaches and an opt-out checklist.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the rules matter to a law firm's growth
  2. What PECR says
  3. How the soft opt-in maps onto legal work
  4. The SRA layer
  5. Service message or marketing?
  6. Building a list that will survive scrutiny
  7. Referrers, introducers and fee earners' own contacts
  8. Enforcement after the 2025 reforms
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • Marketing emails and texts to individuals need prior consent unless the soft opt-in applies[1].
  • The soft opt-in needs three things: details collected in a sale or negotiation, marketing of similar services only, and a simple way to refuse at collection and in every message[1].
  • SRA rules separately bar unsolicited approaches to members of the public other than current or former clients[2].
  • Past clients and their families are the biggest source of new work: prior use (21%) and recommendations (18%) were the most common ways people chose a provider[3].
  • A PECR breach can now occur even if the message never arrives, and fines align with the Data Protection Act 2018[4][5].

Why the rules matter to a law firm's growth

Most firms do not win clients through cold campaigns. They win them from people who have used the firm before, or whose family has, and from recommendations. In the 2026 tracker survey, prior use by the client or their family (21%) and recommendations from family or friends (18%) were the most common ways consumers chose a legal provider[3]. Staying in touch with former clients is therefore one of the most valuable things a firm's marketing can do, and email is the natural channel: it is also the channel clients most often prefer for progress updates, at 45%[6].

The two most common ways consumers chose a legal providerLegal Services Consumer Panel tracker survey 2026.
The two most common ways consumers chose a legal providerComparison. Used before by the client or family: 21%; Recommended by family or friends: 18%.21%Used before by the client or familyUsed before by the client or family: 21%18%Recommended by family or friendsRecommended by family or friends: 18%The two most common ways consumers chose a legal providerComparison. Used before by the client or family: 21%; Recommended by family or friends: 18%.21%Used before by the client or familyUsed before by the client or family: 21%18%Recommended by family or friendsRecommended by family or friends: 18%

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Used before by the client or family21%
Recommended by family or friends18%

The difficulty is that the same email address is used for matter updates, which are not marketing, and for newsletters, event invitations and review requests, which usually are. Getting the line right lets you market confidently to the people most likely to instruct you again.

What PECR says

Regulation 22 of PECR says you must not send, or instigate the sending of, unsolicited direct marketing by electronic mail, which includes email and text messages, to an individual subscriber unless they have told you they consent to it[1]. The exception is the soft opt-in in regulation 22(3), which allows marketing where all three conditions are met[1]:

  1. You obtained the person's contact details in the course of a sale, or negotiations for the sale, of a product or service to them.
  2. The marketing is about your own similar products and services only.
  3. They were given a simple, free way of refusing the marketing when their details were collected and, if they did not refuse, in every later message.

Individual subscribers include sole traders and some partnerships as well as private individuals. Emails to staff at companies, LLPs and public bodies fall outside regulation 22, but you must still identify yourself, include a valid opt-out address, and treat the named recipient's details lawfully under UK GDPR.

For a law firm, a sale is an instruction. Negotiations for a sale are wider: an enquiry that led to a discussion of the matter, a quote or a fee estimate is likely to qualify even if the person did not go on to instruct you. Someone who only downloaded a guide or attended a free seminar has not entered negotiations, so you need their consent.

Similar services should be read in the way the client would reasonably expect. A former conveyancing client would not be surprised to hear about wills or lasting powers of attorney from the same private client team. A former criminal defence client would be surprised to receive your commercial property newsletter. When in doubt, ask for consent at the point of collection with a clear, unticked option.

The SRA layer

Solicitors have a second set of rules that marketing teams sometimes forget. The SRA Code of Conduct bars unsolicited approaches to members of the public, other than current or former clients, to advertise legal services[2], and any publicity, including about charges, must be accurate and not misleading[7]. So even a perfectly PECR-compliant bought-in list of consumers is off limits, and a mailing to people who simply appear in your case files as opponents, witnesses or other parties would breach both regimes.

Example decision table. Record your own reasoning for each audience.
RecipientPECR positionSRA positionCan you send marketing?
Former client, opt-out offered at engagementSoft opt-in for similar servicesFormer client, permittedYes, with an opt-out in every email
Enquirer given a fee estimate, did not instructSoft opt-in likely, if opt-out was offeredNot yet a client; treat as requested contact onlyOnly if they asked to hear from you or consented
Seminar attendeeConsent neededUnsolicited unless they askedOnly with consent
Client's family member who called on their behalfNo sale to them; consent neededMember of the publicNo, unless they consent
In-house lawyer at a companyCorporate subscriber; identify yourself and offer opt-outBusiness contact, permittedYes, with care
Purchased consumer listConsent rarely validUnsolicited approachNo

Service message or marketing?

  • Matter updates, document requests and appointment confirmations are service messages, not marketing.
  • A request for a review after completion is usually marketing, because it promotes the firm. Send it only to clients who have not opted out.
  • A newsletter about changes in the law is marketing if it promotes your services, which almost every firm newsletter does.
  • A reminder that a client's will is due for review is marketing unless it is part of an agreed ongoing service, such as a will storage arrangement with a review term.
  • Event invitations and seasonal greetings that mention your services are marketing.

Do not mix the two. Adding a promotional banner to a completion email turns a service message into a marketing message, and the whole email then has to meet PECR.

Building a list that will survive scrutiny

  1. Add the choice to engagement

    Put a short marketing paragraph and an unticked box or clear opt-out in the client care letter and the online engagement form.

  2. Capture it in the system

    Record the source, date and wording of each consent or opt-out in the case management or CRM record, not a spreadsheet.

  3. Segment by service

    Tag contacts by the team that acted, so that private client marketing goes to private client clients and the similar-services test is respected.

  4. Exclude sensitive matters

    Do not create marketing segments that reveal matter types such as divorce, crime or immigration.

  5. Honour opt-outs fast

    Process unsubscribes automatically and suppress the address across every list.

  6. Audit annually

    Remove contacts with no engagement for several years and refresh consents where the original wording no longer matches what you send.

Wording that works at collection: We would like to send you occasional updates about legal services similar to those we are providing. You can say no now or unsubscribe at any time using the link in each email. Do not send me these updates.

Referrers, introducers and fee earners' own contacts

Much of a firm's marketing happens outside the official mailing list. Partners email their contacts, business development staff follow up after networking events, and fee earners send personal updates to former clients from their own inboxes. All of it is the firm's marketing for PECR and SRA purposes, and all of it needs to follow the same rules.

  • Professional referrers such as accountants, estate agents and independent financial advisers working at companies are usually corporate subscribers. You can email them about your services with a clear sender identity and a way to opt out, but sole-trader referrers are individual subscribers and need consent or a soft opt-in.
  • Business cards collected at an event are not consent to marketing. A short follow-up that asks whether the person would like to receive updates is fine; adding them straight to the newsletter is not.
  • Fee earners who move firms cannot take a list of clients with them and start marketing to it. The contact details were collected by the old firm, and the soft opt-in belongs to it.
  • Introducer arrangements, where another business passes you contact details, need careful checking: the consent must name your firm, and the SRA's rules on referrals and fee sharing also apply.

The simplest control is to route all marketing through one system that holds consent and opt-out records, and to tell partners and fee earners that bulk or repeat promotional emails from personal mailboxes are not allowed. One-to-one correspondence with an existing client about their own affairs remains ordinary client care.

Enforcement after the 2025 reforms

The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 made clear that a PECR direct marketing breach can occur even if the call or message never reached the intended recipient[4], so a campaign that bounces is not a defence. It also aligned PECR enforcement powers and fines with the Data Protection Act 2018[5]. Marketing complaints are among the easiest for the public to make, so a single badly built list can generate many.

Example: a fictional private client team wants to email 2,000 former clients about lasting powers of attorney. It filters to clients whose engagement letter offered an opt-out and who did not use it, removes anyone whose matter was handled by the crime or family teams, adds an unsubscribe link and a plain sender name, and keeps a copy of the final list and the email with the date sent. Enquirers who never instructed the firm are left out unless they ticked the updates box.

For texts, the same rules apply with extra confidentiality risks on lock screens; see text messages to clients. For the website side, see cookie consent on solicitors websites, and for the reforms in full, the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025.

Frequently asked questions

Can we email former clients without asking first?

Under the soft opt-in, yes, about similar services, provided they were offered a simple way to refuse when you collected their details and every email includes an opt-out. The SRA permits approaches to current and former clients.

Is a client newsletter marketing?

Usually. If it promotes the firm or its services, even indirectly through legal updates, treat it as marketing and send it only to people with consent or a valid soft opt-in.

Does PECR apply to emails to business contacts?

Regulation 22 does not cover corporate subscribers such as companies and LLPs, but you must identify yourself and give a valid opt-out address, and UK GDPR applies to named individuals.

Can we text clients about new services?

Texts are electronic mail under PECR, so the same consent and soft opt-in rules apply. Keep texts short and never include confidential matter details.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 22 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (unsolicited approaches) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (DSIT) (2025). Data (Use and Access) Act factsheet: PEC Regulations (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. GOV.UK (DSIT) (2025). Data (Use and Access) Act factsheet: ICO (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (publicity) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo