Staffing and training

Fairer hiring and social mobility

Practical steps for fairer, wider hiring at solicitors firms: what SRA diversity data shows, where bias creeps in and a structured hiring process to adopt.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why fairer hiring is a business issue
  2. What the data shows
  3. Where bias creeps into hiring
  4. A fairer hiring process, step by step
  5. Structured interview questions that work
  6. Publish pay ranges
  7. Wider routes into law
  8. Outreach a small firm can manage
  9. Positive action: what is allowed
  10. Measure what happens
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • 24% of lawyers in SRA-regulated firms attended a fee-paying school, against 6% of students in England, excluding unknown responses[1].
  • 66% of lawyers come from a professional family background, against 46% nationally, on the same basis[1].
  • Most bias enters before interview: in job adverts, unnecessary entry requirements, referrals and unpaid work experience.
  • Structured interviews, work-sample tests and published pay ranges widen the pool at little cost.
  • Positive action is lawful within limits; positive discrimination is not. Know the difference before you start.

Why fairer hiring is a business issue

Small and mid-sized firms compete for staff with large firms, in-house legal teams and other sectors. In-house solicitor numbers rose 4% in the year to July 2024, to 37,035[2], and many paralegals and secretaries can earn similar money outside law. A firm that recruits only from the same schools, universities and personal networks is fishing in a small pond, even in a profession of 181,481 practising solicitors at the end of September 2026[3].

There are other reasons too. Clients come from every background, and teams that reflect them often find it easier to build trust and explain things clearly. And the profession's regulator collects diversity data from firms, so the picture is visible.

What the data shows

The SRA's 2025 law firm diversity data, collected in summer 2025, shows a profession that remains socially narrow. 20% of lawyers attended an independent or fee-paying school; excluding those who preferred not to say and those schooled outside the UK, the figure is 24%, compared with 6% of all students in England in 2024/25[1]. On the same basis, 66% of lawyers come from a professional family background, compared with 46% nationally[1].

Background of lawyers compared with national figuresSRA 2025 firm data, excluding unknown responses; comparisons are students in England, the general population and the UK workforce
Background of lawyers compared with national figuresColumn chart. Attended fee-paying school: Lawyers 24%, National comparison 6%; Professional family background: Lawyers 66%, National comparison 46%; Black, Asian and minority ethnic: Lawyers 21%, National comparison 18%.0%20%40%60%80%Attended fee-paying school · Lawyers: 24%24%Attended fee-paying school · National comparison: 6%6%Attended fee-paying schoolProfessional family background · Lawyers: 66%66%Professional family background · National comparison: 46%46%Professional familybackgroundBlack, Asian and minority ethnic · Lawyers: 21%21%Black, Asian and minority ethnic · National comparison: 18%18%Black, Asian and minorityethnicBackground of lawyers compared with national figuresColumn chart. Attended fee-paying school: Lawyers 24%, National comparison 6%; Professional family background: Lawyers 66%, National comparison 46%; Black, Asian and minority ethnic: Lawyers 21%, National comparison 18%.Attended fee-paying schoolAttended fee-paying school · Lawyers: 24%24%Attended fee-paying school · National comparison: 6%6%Professional family backgroundProfessional family background · Lawyers: 66%66%Professional family background · National comparison: 46%46%Black, Asian and minority ethnicBlack, Asian and minority ethnic · Lawyers: 21%21%Black, Asian and minority ethnic · National comparison: 18%18%
  • Lawyers
  • National comparison

Source: Solicitors Regulation Authority, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemLawyersNational comparison
Attended fee-paying school24%6%
Professional family background66%46%
Black, Asian and minority ethnic21%18%

Ethnic diversity looks different. Black, Asian and minority ethnic groups made up 21% of the known population of lawyers, compared with 18% of the UK workforce in 2025[1]. But representation is uneven by seniority. Female representation at partner-equivalent level rose only from 34% in 2023 to 35% in 2024[2]. The challenge is not only who joins, but who progresses.

Where bias creeps into hiring

Example: hiring practices compared with fairer alternatives
Common practiceWhy it narrows the poolFairer alternative
Minimum A-level grades or degree class for every roleScreens out people who succeeded later or with less supportAssess the skills the role needs; use contextual information on grades
Hiring through personal referralsReproduces the networks of current staffAdvertise every role, even when a referral is likely
Unpaid work experienceOnly those who can afford to work for free applyPaid placements, even if short
Unstructured interviews and a feel for fitFavours people like the interviewerStructured questions scored against criteria
Adverts with no salaryDiscourages people who cannot afford to guessPublish a salary range
Long, jargon-heavy job descriptionsDeters capable applicants from outside lawShort, plain descriptions focused on the real tasks

None of these changes lowers standards. They remove barriers that have nothing to do with whether someone can do the job.

A fairer hiring process, step by step

  1. Define the job, then the person

    List the tasks and the skills, knowledge and behaviours needed to do them. Drop any requirement you cannot link to a task.

  2. Write a plain, short advert

    Describe the work, the team, the flexibility available and the salary range. Avoid phrases that signal a narrow background.

  3. Advertise widely

    Beyond the usual legal job boards: local colleges, universities outside your usual list, community groups, apprenticeship services and returner programmes.

  4. Screen consistently

    Use a simple scoring sheet against the criteria. Consider removing names, schools and universities from the first sift.

  5. Use a work sample

    A short practical task related to the job, such as drafting a client letter from a file note, tells you more than a CV.

  6. Run structured interviews

    Ask every candidate the same core questions, score answers against the criteria and have at least two interviewers.

  7. Offer adjustments

    Ask every candidate whether they need any adjustments, and make it easy to say yes.

  8. Give feedback

    Short, honest feedback to unsuccessful candidates builds your reputation as an employer.

Structured interview questions that work

Structured interviews are fairer because every candidate gets the same chance to show the same things. They also make decisions easier to explain. Build four to six core questions from the criteria, then score each answer on a simple scale before discussing candidates. Some examples for a paralegal or legal assistant role:

  1. Tell us about a time you had several urgent tasks at once. How did you decide what to do first?
  2. Describe a time you had to explain something complicated to someone who was worried or upset.
  3. Here is a short client email. What would you reply, and what would you check with a solicitor first?
  4. Tell us about a mistake you made at work or in study. What happened and what did you change?
  5. What would you do if a client asked you for advice you were not sure you were allowed to give?

Avoid questions that reward a particular background rather than ability, such as which law firms the candidate has worked experience with or what their parents do. Ask about experience from any setting, including retail, hospitality, caring and customer service roles, which often build exactly the skills legal support roles need.

Publish pay ranges

Publishing a salary range is one of the cheapest steps towards fairer hiring. It helps people who lack the networks to know what a role usually pays, reduces negotiation gaps and saves time on candidates whose expectations do not match. For context, the 2026 provisional median for full-time legal associate professionals, which includes paralegals and legal executives, was £37,148 a year[4]. Our guide to salary bands and pay transparency explains how to set ranges.

Wider routes into law

The Solicitors Qualifying Examination has made it easier to qualify without the traditional university and training contract route. Small firms can take advantage of that.

  • Solicitor apprenticeships, where an apprentice works and studies at the same time, with training funded through the apprenticeship system.
  • Paralegal-to-solicitor routes, where qualifying work experience gained as a paralegal counts towards qualification.
  • Chartered legal executive routes for people who want to specialise and qualify while working.
  • Support staff development, so that secretaries and assistants who want to move into fee-earning roles can do so.

See our guide to solicitor and paralegal apprenticeships for the practical detail.

Outreach a small firm can manage

Large firms run formal social mobility programmes. A small firm can still make a difference locally with modest effort.

  • Offer a few paid work experience places each year through a local school or college, rather than to the children of clients and contacts.
  • Give a talk at a sixth form or further education college about careers in law, including support roles and apprenticeships.
  • Partner with a local university that is not on your usual list for one placement or project a year.
  • Let staff volunteer at advice agencies or legal clinics, which builds skills and connections with communities you may not otherwise reach.
  • Keep in touch with good candidates you could not hire this time, and tell them about the next vacancy.

Track whether outreach leads to applications. Even small numbers tell you which activities are worth repeating.

Positive action: what is allowed

The Equality Act 2010 allows positive action, such as encouraging applications from under-represented groups, offering targeted outreach or mentoring, and, where two candidates are as qualified as each other, preferring the one from an under-represented group. It does not allow positive discrimination, meaning appointing someone because of a protected characteristic regardless of merit. Socio-economic background is not a protected characteristic, but outreach and contextual recruitment aimed at it are generally lawful when applied fairly. Take advice before introducing any tie-break rule.

Measure what happens

Collect voluntary diversity information from applicants, kept separate from the selection process, and look at how each group progresses through each stage. If one group drops out disproportionately at the sift, the screening criteria may be the problem. If they drop out at interview, look at the questions and the panel. Diversity information is often special category data under UK GDPR, so explain why you collect it, keep it secure and report only in aggregate.

Example: a fictional 30-person firm replaced its minimum degree requirement for paralegals with a short written exercise and published a salary range in every advert. Applications for its next two paralegal roles came from a wider range of colleges and universities, and one successful candidate had moved into law after several years in a local council's customer service team.

Hiring is only the start. Retention and progression decide whether a more diverse intake reaches senior roles. See managing remote and hybrid teams, staff handbooks and continuing competence and training budgets.

Frequently asked questions

How can a small law firm hire more fairly without extra cost?

Publish salary ranges, drop requirements you cannot link to the job, advertise every role, use structured interviews and a short work sample. Most of these cost nothing.

Is it lawful to target under-represented groups?

Positive action, such as targeted outreach and mentoring, is allowed under the Equality Act 2010. Appointing someone because of a protected characteristic regardless of merit is not.

Should we remove names from CVs?

Removing names, schools and universities at the first sift can reduce bias. It works best combined with clear scoring criteria.

What is contextual recruitment?

Considering a candidate's achievements in the light of their circumstances, such as the school they attended or whether they were eligible for free school meals.

References

  1. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). How diverse is the legal profession? (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. The Law Society (2024). Annual statistics report 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Population of solicitors in England and Wales (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo