Consultations and booking

First meeting checklist for employers facing a dispute

What to cover when an employer instructs on a grievance, dismissal or tribunal claim: deadlines, documents, facts, risks and next steps.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the first meeting sets the outcome
  2. Triage before the meeting
  3. Deadlines that matter
  4. Document checklist
  5. A first meeting agenda
  6. Managing contact with the employee while advice is pending
  7. Privilege, protected conversations and settlement
  8. What employers want from the meeting
  9. Example: a grievance before a planned dismissal
  10. After the meeting
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Single-claim Employment Tribunal receipts rose 28% year on year in April to June 2026, and the open caseload reached 70,000[1].
  • Check deadlines first: an employer has 28 days to respond to a claim, and the tribunal may decide against a late respondent without a hearing[2].
  • For problems arising on or after 1 October 2026, employees have 6 months minus 1 day for most claims, so a dispute can surface long after the event[3].
  • Ask for the documents that prove process, not just the ones that tell the story.
  • Agree an early view on settlement, protected conversations and communications with the employee before you leave.

Why the first meeting sets the outcome

Employers usually call a solicitor at one of three moments: a grievance or allegation has landed, a dismissal is being considered, or an ACAS early conciliation notice or tribunal claim has arrived. At each point the first meeting decides whether the firm controls the timetable or reacts to it. The volume of claims means tribunals are less forgiving of delay than ever. Single-claim receipts rose 28% year on year to 14,000 in April to June 2026, and the single-claim open caseload stood at 70,000 at the end of June, up 51% in a year[1].

Smaller employers are the most exposed. The Legal Services Board's small business research found that 32% of small businesses had at least one legal issue in a 12-month period, and only a quarter of those with an issue used professional help[4]. Of small businesses with a legal issue, 28% lost income because of it and 10% lost a customer or contract[4]. Many of your employer clients will be dealing with their first dispute.

Small businesses with a legal issue: what happenedEngland and Wales, LSB small business legal needs research
Small businesses with a legal issue: what happenedBar chart. Lost income because of the issue: 28%; Used professional help: 25%; Lost a customer or contract: 10%.Lost income because of the issueLost income because of the issue: 28%28%Used professional helpUsed professional help: 25%25%Lost a customer or contractLost a customer or contract: 10%10%Small businesses with a legal issue: what happenedBar chart. Lost income because of the issue: 28%; Used professional help: 25%; Lost a customer or contract: 10%.Lost income because of the issueLost income because of the issue: 28%28%Used professional helpUsed professional help: 25%25%Lost a customer or contractLost a customer or contract: 10%10%

Source: Legal Services Board, 2021[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Lost income because of the issue28%
Used professional help25%
Lost a customer or contract10%

Triage before the meeting

When the employer first calls, collect enough to run a conflict check and spot deadlines. Ask for the employee's name, the employer's legal entity, the stage the dispute has reached and any document with a date on it.

  • Has the employee contacted ACAS? If so, when, and has an early conciliation certificate been issued?
  • Has a claim form been received from the tribunal? On what date was it sent?
  • Is there an internal grievance, disciplinary or appeal hearing already scheduled?
  • Is the employee still employed, on sick leave, suspended or dismissed?
  • Has anyone said anything to the employee about leaving or settlement?
  • Does the employer have insurance that may cover legal costs, and must the insurer be notified?

If a claim has been received, put the response deadline in the file and in two diaries on the day of the call. Missing it can mean the tribunal decides the claim without hearing from the employer[2].

Deadlines that matter

Time limits changed on 1 October 2026. For problems before that date, most claims had a limit of 3 months minus 1 day; for problems on or after it, the limit is 6 months minus 1 day for most claims[3]. Notifying ACAS for early conciliation pauses the time limit until conciliation ends, provided the employee notifies within the limit[3]. In practice, that means employers should assume a dismissed employee may still bring a claim many months later, and should preserve documents accordingly.

Once a claim is served, the employer must respond within 28 days, and more time can only be requested from the tribunal[2]. Other dates to capture at the first meeting include internal appeal deadlines, any notice period ending, and the date of any protected conversation or settlement offer.

Document checklist

Documents to request when an employer instructs
DocumentWhy you need itWho usually holds it
Contract and statement of particularsTerms, notice, restrictive covenantsHR or the owner
Relevant policies and handbookGrievance, disciplinary, sickness, equalityHR
Grievance or complaint lettersWhat the employee alleges, in their wordsLine manager or HR
Investigation notes and interview recordsShows whether the process was fairInvestigating manager
Meeting invitations and outcome lettersProves notice and right to be accompaniedHR
Emails and messages about the employeeDisclosure risk and contextManagers, often on personal phones
Absence and performance recordsSupports or undermines the stated reasonPayroll or line manager
ACAS certificate and claim formDeadlines and claims madeOwner or HR

Tell the client early that all relevant documents may be disclosed in proceedings, including messages on WhatsApp and personal phones. Ask them to stop deleting anything and to keep internal comments about the employee to a minimum.

A first meeting agenda

  1. Confirm the client and the decision-makers

    Identify the legal entity, who gives instructions, and who must not be involved because they are a witness or the subject of the complaint.

  2. Build a timeline

    Walk through events in date order, with documents. Mark each date that could start a time limit.

  3. Identify the claims

    Unfair dismissal, discrimination, whistleblowing, wages, breach of contract. Note any that do not need a qualifying period of employment.

  4. Test the process

    Was there an investigation? Was the employee told the allegations and given a chance to respond? Were they offered a companion and an appeal?

  5. Assess exposure

    Rough range of compensation and costs, reputational risk and management time.

  6. Agree a strategy

    Defend, investigate further, offer settlement, or a combination. Decide who speaks to the employee and how.

  7. Confirm costs and next steps

    Give a costs estimate for the next stage and agree dates for documents and witness meetings.

Managing contact with the employee while advice is pending

The period between the first call and your written advice is when well-meaning managers do the most damage. A manager who tells the employee 'we are getting the lawyers in' or who changes their duties without explanation can create a new complaint before the old one is resolved. Agree simple rules in the meeting.

  • Name one person who communicates with the employee, and keep that person out of the facts in dispute where possible.
  • Keep communications short, factual and in writing where the subject is the dispute.
  • Do not change the employee's pay, duties, access or reporting lines without advice.
  • If the employee is off sick, follow the normal sickness policy and keep contact supportive.
  • Route any approach from the employee's representative to the solicitor.

Privilege, protected conversations and settlement

Explain the difference between documents that are privileged and those that are not. Advice from you is generally protected; internal emails between managers discussing the employee usually are not, and may have to be disclosed. Encourage the client to send questions to you rather than circulating opinions internally.

If settlement is a realistic option, discuss how and when to raise it. Without prejudice discussions and protected conversations offer some protection from disclosure, but each has limits, and improper behaviour in the conversation can remove the protection. Agree who will make any approach, what will be offered and how the offer will be recorded, so that a well-intentioned chat does not become evidence in the claim.

What employers want from the meeting

Business clients want a straight answer about risk and a plan they can follow. They are often frustrated by advice that lists every possibility without a recommendation. They also want convenience: in the Legal Services Consumer Panel's 2026 tracker, an online service mattered more for employment disputes than for legal services in general, with 39% comparing it against 24% overall[5]. Offer video meetings, a shared document request list and a single point of contact.

  • Give a clear view of the likely outcome, with your confidence level.
  • Separate legal risk from commercial choice; settlement can be sensible even where the employer would probably win.
  • Explain how to handle the employee day to day while the dispute runs.
  • Warn against retaliatory steps, which can create new claims.

Example: a grievance before a planned dismissal

Example (fictional). A 30-person logistics company calls on a Monday. It plans to dismiss a warehouse supervisor for poor performance on Friday, but on Sunday the supervisor raised a grievance alleging his manager made comments about his age. At the first meeting the solicitor builds a timeline, finds the performance concerns were raised informally only, and notes the grievance names the manager who would chair the dismissal meeting. The advice: pause the dismissal, appoint an independent manager to hear the grievance, preserve the manager's messages, and revisit performance through a documented process. The employer leaves with a written action list and a fixed fee for the grievance stage.

After the meeting

Send a short advice note the same week: the timeline, the claims you see, your view on risk, and the actions with owners and dates. Record the deadlines in the case management system and confirm them in writing to the client. If an internal hearing is coming up, offer to review the invitation letter and script before it goes out. Our related guides on first family law meetings and reception areas and meeting rooms cover other parts of the consultation process.

Frequently asked questions

How long does an employer have to respond to a tribunal claim?

GOV.UK says the employer must respond within 28 days. More time can be requested from the tribunal, but if the response is late or missing the tribunal may decide against the employer without a hearing.

How long does an employee have to bring a claim?

According to ACAS, for problems on or after 1 October 2026 the limit is 6 months minus 1 day for most claims; for earlier problems it was 3 months minus 1 day. Early conciliation pauses the clock.

What documents should an employer bring to the first meeting?

The contract, relevant policies, the grievance or complaint, investigation notes, meeting letters, absence and performance records, relevant messages, and any ACAS certificate or claim form.

Should an employer offer settlement early?

Sometimes. Settlement can make commercial sense even where the employer would probably win. The first meeting should give a view on exposure so the client can decide.

References

  1. Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Tribunal Statistics Quarterly: April to June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). Being taken to an employment tribunal by an employee (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Acas (2026). Time limits for making an employment tribunal claim (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Board (2021). Small business legal needs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo