Practice area operations

Fixed recoverable costs and intake decisions

How extended fixed recoverable costs affect which claims a firm takes on, with an intake decision matrix and the questions that predict the track.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why fixed costs are an intake question
  2. The regime in brief
  3. Claims outside the regime
  4. An intake decision matrix
  5. Questions that predict the track
  6. What reception should and should not say
  7. Recording the intake for the fee earner
  8. The funding conversation with clients
  9. Example: two injury enquiries under the new rules
  10. Measuring whether intake decisions are working
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Since 1 October 2023, fixed recoverable costs cover the fast track and a new intermediate track for simpler claims up to £100,000[1].
  • For personal injury, the regime applies where the cause of action accrued on or after 1 October 2023[1].
  • Intake should identify the likely track and complexity band early, because recoverable costs are largely fixed by them.
  • Some claims are excluded, including clinical negligence unless breach and causation are admitted[1].

Why fixed costs are an intake question

In many civil claims, the costs a winning party can recover from the loser are now largely set in advance by the claim's track and complexity band. That turns a case acceptance decision into an economic one: if the work needed is likely to exceed what can be recovered, the firm either absorbs the difference, recovers it from the client's damages under its retainer, or declines the case. Each of those decisions depends on facts that can be gathered at the first contact.

That does not mean reception should make acceptance decisions. It means the intake form and the first call should collect the information that predicts the track, so that a fee earner can make a sound decision quickly, rather than discovering after weeks of work that the economics never made sense.

The regime in brief

The Ministry of Justice's note on the new rules explains that from 1 October 2023 fixed recoverable costs were extended across the fast track, and to a new intermediate track for simpler cases valued up to £100,000[1]. The fast track remains the normal track for claims up to £25,000 where the trial is likely to last no more than a day, with limited expert evidence[1]. The intermediate track captures cases that can be tried in three days or less, with no more than two expert witnesses giving oral evidence on each side[1].

  • Each track has four complexity bands, each with a grid of fixed costs for the stages of a claim[1].
  • Judges keep discretion to allocate more complex cases under £100,000 to the multi-track, outside fixed costs[1].
  • For personal injury, the rules apply where the cause of action accrues on or after 1 October 2023; for disease claims, where the letter of claim had not been sent before that date[1].
  • For other claims, the rules apply where proceedings are issued on or after 1 October 2023[1].
  • Below the fast track, road traffic injury claims under £5,000 sit in the small claims track and generally use the Official Injury Claim service[2].
Upper value of claims covered by fixed recoverable costs, by trackDamages value; extended regime from 1 October 2023
Upper value of claims covered by fixed recoverable costs, by trackComparison. Fast track: £25,000; Intermediate track: £100,000.£25,000Fast trackFast track: £25,000£100,000Intermediate trackIntermediate track: £100,000Upper value of claims covered by fixed recoverable costs, by trackComparison. Fast track: £25,000; Intermediate track: £100,000.£25,000Fast trackFast track: £25,000£100,000Intermediate trackIntermediate track: £100,000

Source: Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK), 2023[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Fast track£25,000
Intermediate track£100,000

Claims outside the regime

The rules list types of claim that go to the multi-track rather than the intermediate track, and so fall outside the extended fixed costs. They include mesothelioma and other asbestos lung disease claims, claims that include clinical negligence unless both breach of duty and causation have been admitted, and claims for damages relating to harm, abuse or neglect of or by children or vulnerable adults[1]. The government also delayed the application of fixed costs to housing claims for two years[1].

Keep an up-to-date exclusion list next to the intake form. A claim that looks low value but falls in an excluded category needs a different conversation about costs and risk.

An intake decision matrix

Matching claim profiles to the likely track and costs regime; allocation is always for the court and the fee earner
Claim profile at first contactLikely track and costs positionIntake implication
Road traffic injury, soft tissue only, likely value under £5,000Small claims; costs generally not recoverableApply the firm's portal claims policy; explain charging clearly
Workplace or public liability injury, likely value under £25,000, liability disputedFast track, fixed costs by bandCheck whether the expected work fits the band; consider evidence needs early
Injury with likely value £25,000 to £100,000 and two medical expertsIntermediate track, fixed costs by bandSenior review of complexity band and likely trial length before acceptance
Clinical negligence where breach and causation are disputedMulti-track, outside extended fixed costsSpecialist merit screening; different funding and risk assessment
Asbestos lung disease or mesotheliomaMulti-track, outside extended fixed costsSame-day specialist referral
Professional negligence or contract dispute under £100,000Possibly intermediate track if simpleAssess documents and witness needs before quoting

Questions that predict the track

  1. When did it happen?

    For injury, the date of the cause of action decides whether the extended regime applies at all, as well as limitation.

  2. What kind of claim?

    Injury, disease, clinical negligence, abuse, housing, contract or professional negligence. Some types are excluded by the rules.

  3. How serious is the loss?

    Injuries and recovery time, time off work and other financial losses give a rough value range, which suggests the track.

  4. Is liability admitted?

    An admission usually reduces the work and the complexity band; a full dispute increases both.

  5. What evidence will be needed?

    Number of experts and witnesses likely, which affects both the band and whether a three-day trial limit fits.

  6. Is the client vulnerable?

    Vulnerability can affect how the claim is run and may carry costs implications the fee earner will consider.

What reception should and should not say

Callers increasingly ask whether their claim is 'worth it' after reading about fixed costs or small claims online. Reception can describe the process accurately without making a judgement that belongs to a lawyer. The difference matters, because a casual 'that sounds too small for us' can turn away a claim that the firm would have taken, and a casual 'you will get your costs back' can set an expectation the regime does not support.

  • Say: 'The court sets how much in costs can be recovered for many claims, so the solicitor will look at the details before confirming how the firm can help.'
  • Say: 'We will explain in writing how we charge and whether anything would come out of your compensation.'
  • Avoid: 'Your costs will be paid by the other side.' It is often only partly true.
  • Avoid: 'It is not worth claiming.' That is a merits and value judgement for a fee earner.

Recording the intake for the fee earner

A good intake record lets a fee earner make the acceptance decision in a few minutes. Build the fields into your enquiry form or case management system so they are completed every time, rather than relying on free-text notes that vary from person to person.

  • Date of incident or diagnosis, and date of birth for children.
  • Claim type, with a tick-box for categories excluded from the extended regime.
  • Rough value indicators: injuries, recovery time, time off work, other losses.
  • Liability position and the identity of the other side or their insurer.
  • Likely evidence: medical, engineering, accounting or other experts.
  • Vulnerability or capacity concerns, and who is giving instructions.

Add two fields for the fee earner to complete: predicted track and predicted band. Comparing those predictions with the eventual allocation is the simplest way to improve intake over time.

The funding conversation with clients

Clients rarely know that the costs a court allows are separate from what they may pay their own lawyer. Explaining this at the start is a conduct requirement and a complaints safeguard. Consumers are used to fixed pricing: in 2026, 57% of legal services users had their bill calculated as a fixed fee and only 9% were charged an hourly rate[3]. Injury clients often expect the same certainty, and the fixed costs regime can help firms give it.

  • Explain what can be recovered from the other side and what, if anything, may be deducted from damages.
  • Give a worked figure in the client care letter, using a realistic example award.
  • Explain what happens to costs if the claim moves to a different track or band.
  • Revisit the explanation whenever the case changes in a way that affects costs.

Example: two injury enquiries under the new rules

Example (fictional). A warehouse worker calls about a back injury from a fall at work in 2025. He was off for six weeks and has recovered. The employer disputes that the floor was unsafe. The intake record shows a likely fast track claim with a liability dispute. The fee earner reviews the band, decides the evidence needed is proportionate and accepts the case, explaining the charging position in writing.

Example (fictional). A retired engineer calls about breathing problems that his GP links to asbestos exposure decades ago. The intake record flags an asbestos lung disease claim. Because those claims sit outside the extended fixed costs and need urgent specialist attention, the enquiry goes to the industrial disease team the same day, with the date of diagnosis and the names of past employers already recorded.

Measuring whether intake decisions are working

Fixed costs reward firms that know their numbers. Track, for each band, how many enquiries were accepted, how long the matters took and what was recovered. Patterns appear quickly: some bands may be consistently loss-making for the firm's way of working, while others are efficient. Injury clients also choose quickly; 37% of accident and injury consumers compared providers on speed in 2026[4], so slow acceptance decisions lose good cases to faster firms.

  • Record the predicted track and band at intake, and the actual allocation later.
  • Review mismatches monthly; they show which intake questions need improving.
  • Track complaints and client feedback on costs, since personal injury accounted for 14% of Legal Ombudsman accepted complaints in 2025/26[5].
  • Revisit the acceptance policy when the fixed costs grids are uprated.

Frequently asked questions

What are fixed recoverable costs?

Set amounts of legal costs that a winning party can recover from the losing party, fixed by the claim's track and complexity band rather than assessed case by case.

Which claims are in the intermediate track?

Simpler claims valued up to £100,000 that can be tried in three days or less, with no more than two expert witnesses giving oral evidence on each side.

Do fixed recoverable costs apply to clinical negligence?

Claims including clinical negligence are allocated to the multi-track and excluded from the extended regime unless both breach of duty and causation have been admitted.

When did the extended regime start?

On 1 October 2023. For personal injury it applies where the cause of action accrued on or after that date.

References

  1. Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2023). Extending Fixed Recoverable Costs: a note on the new rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Official Injury Claim (MIB for the Ministry of Justice) (2026). Official Injury Claim: April to June 2026 data publication (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo