Key takeaways
- Repeat use and personal recommendation remain the most common reasons people choose a legal provider.
- Small local firms are still the most used, but their share is falling as national brands and online services grow.
- Search and reviews matter most at the comparison stage; people check what they have been told.
- Being regulated and specialist are the strongest trust signals, so show both clearly.
- Record the source of every new instruction; most firms do not, and guess wrong.
The short answer
Most solicitors win most new clients the same way they always have: people come back, and people recommend them. In the Legal Services Consumer Panel's 2026 tracker, prior use by the client or their family (21%) and recommendations from family or friends (18%) were the most common ways consumers chose a legal provider[1]. Everything else, from search to directories to advertising, works alongside that, often as the way people check a recommendation before calling.
That does not make marketing pointless. It means the most effective marketing for most firms is the kind that makes recommendations easier to act on and repeat work easier to give: a findable firm, a clear website, good reviews and a phone that is answered.
Who people use
Small local firms remain the most common choice, but their share is falling. In 2026, 59% of consumers who used a lawyer said they used a small local firm, down eight points from 67% in 2025; 13% used a national brand with a local office and 9% a large corporate firm[2].
Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Small local firm | 59% |
| National brand with a local office | 13% |
| Large corporate firm | 9% |
The fall is a warning for high street firms. National brands invest in search, comparison sites and fast enquiry handling. A local firm that relies only on reputation may find fewer first-time clients each year, even while its loyal clients stay.
Channel by channel
| Channel | What drives it | What a firm can do | How to measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Repeat clients | A good experience and staying in touch | Closing letters, permitted past-client contact, will reviews | Share of new matters from past clients |
| Personal recommendation | Clients who would happily recommend you | Excellent service; making the firm easy to find by name | New clients naming a person who recommended them |
| Professional referrers | Agents, accountants, IFAs who trust you | Regular contact, fast service to referred clients, clear disclosure of any arrangements | Instructions by referrer |
| Search | Visibility for local and service searches | Clear service pages, local profile, practical content | Enquiries from organic search |
| Reviews | Volume, recency and replies | Ask every client, reply to all, keep it honest | Reviews per month; enquiries mentioning reviews |
| Panels and comparison sites | Price and speed | Choose carefully; check the margin after fees | Instructions and profit per panel |
| Directories | Professional standing, local listings | Accurate listings, SRA register details | Enquiries by directory |
Professional referrers in practice
For conveyancing, private client and commercial work, professional referrers can be as important as personal recommendation. Estate agents, mortgage brokers, accountants, financial advisers and other solicitors all meet clients at the moment a legal need appears. They refer to firms that make them look good: quick to respond, clear on price and easy for their own clients to deal with.
- Keep a short list of your main referrers and track instructions from each one.
- Make it easy to refer: a named contact, a direct line and a promise of a same-day response.
- Tell referrers, with the client's consent, when a referred matter is underway and when it completes.
- Disclose any referral arrangement to the client where the rules require it, and never let one affect your advice.
Panels and comparison sites
Panels and comparison sites can deliver volume, particularly for conveyancing and wills. They also bring lower margins, service standards set by someone else and clients who chose on price. Before joining, work out the profit per matter after any fees, the response times you must meet and the share of your capacity it will take. Track instructions and profit from each panel separately, and review every year whether it still earns its place.
How search and reviews fit in
Search often works as a checking step. In the Legal Services Board's Legal Needs Survey, when choosing a main adviser, 25% of people searched around, 15% obtained service details, 14% searched for reviews and 13% searched for prices[3]. Someone recommended to "Smith and Co" will usually search the name, look at the reviews and visit the website before calling. If what they find is thin or out of date, the recommendation weakens.
- Make sure a search for your firm's name shows an accurate profile, recent reviews and a working phone number.
- Give each main service its own page with the price information, process and timescales clients want.
- Reply to reviews, including critical ones, without breaching confidentiality.
- Keep reviews honest. Under UK consumer law, businesses must not write or commission fake reviews, and those publishing reviews must take steps to prevent fake and concealed incentivised ones[4].
Trust signals that actually matter
When people choose a lawyer, they look for reasons to trust them. In the Consumer Panel's 2026 tracker, 91% of consumers said a provider being regulated was important when choosing, the most important factor that year[1]. Show regulation plainly: the SRA badge, your SRA number, the names of your solicitors and their specialisms. Accreditations, such as quality marks for conveyancing or panels for family or private client work, are also worth showing where you have them.
Specialism matters too. Clients want to know that the person handling their matter does this kind of work regularly. Team pages that say what each person does, with a photograph and a direct way to get in touch, often do more for conversion than any brochure.
Expertise shown through content works the same way. A clear, practical guide on your website to a question clients ask, such as what happens if a buyer pulls out or how long an estate takes to administer, demonstrates that the firm understands the issue before anyone has called.
Directories and the SRA register
Directories rarely create demand on their own, but they are part of the checking step. Make sure your firm's details are accurate on the SRA register and in the Law Society's Find a Solicitor, and that local listings show the same name, address and phone number as your website. Inconsistent details confuse both people and search engines, and an old phone number on a directory is a lost enquiry.
What firms cannot do
Some ways of winning work are closed to solicitors. SRA rules bar unsolicited approaches to members of the public, other than current or former clients, to advertise legal services[5]. Cold calling, door-knocking and approaching people at a hospital or court are ruled out. Publicity must be accurate and not misleading, and any referral arrangements must be disclosed to clients where the rules require it. These limits make inbound channels, reputation and referrers even more important.
Where new work is lost
Many firms win the recommendation and lose the client at the first contact. People decide quickly, so an unanswered call or a reply that comes two days later sends them to the next firm on their list. Before spending on any new channel, check:
- How many calls go unanswered, and at what times of day?
- How quickly does a web enquiry get a reply from a person?
- How many enquiries become consultations, and how many consultations become instructions?
- Does every quote get a follow-up within a few days?
Fixing these usually produces more new instructions than a new marketing channel, because the demand is already there.
A simple order of work for the next quarter follows from this:
- Start recording the source of every new enquiry and instruction.
- Measure missed calls and web reply times for four weeks, and fix the worst gap.
- Check what a search for your firm's name shows, and correct anything out of date.
- Contact your three most important referrers and ask what would make referring easier.
- Ask every client whose matter closes this quarter for feedback and, if they are happy, a review.
Example: finding out what really works
Example: a four-partner firm believes most of its new clients come from Google. It adds a required "how did you hear about us?" field to its intake form, with a short list of options and a free-text box, and asks the question on every first call. After six months, the data shows that past clients and family recommendations account for the largest share, estate agent referrals come next, and search is mostly used to find the firm's phone number after a recommendation.
The firm shifts effort accordingly: it improves its closing letters and past-client contact, schedules regular meetings with its three main referring agents, and tidies its Google Business Profile and service pages so people checking a recommendation find what they need. Paid search is reduced to one service where it was producing instructions directly.
For turning this into a year's plan, see marketing plan for a small law firm. For the spend side, see how much should a law firm spend on marketing.
Frequently asked questions
How do most people choose a solicitor?
Mostly through prior use and personal recommendation, which were the most common factors in the 2026 Consumer Panel tracker[1]. Search and reviews are often used to check a recommendation.
Do online reviews matter for solicitors?
Yes, especially at the checking stage. Some people search specifically for reviews when choosing an adviser[3]. Ask every client, reply to reviews and keep the process honest.
Are small local firms losing clients to national brands?
Their share fell from 67% to 59% between 2025 and 2026, while national brands and large firms took a larger share[2].
How can we find out where our clients come from?
Ask every new client and record the answer in a required field at intake. Review the data every quarter before deciding where to spend.
References
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑