Key takeaways
- Phishing is the most common attack on UK businesses, and email is where payment diversion against conveyancing clients usually starts.
- Enforce multi-factor sign-in for every account and block older sign-in methods that bypass it.
- Block automatic forwarding to outside addresses and alert on new inbox rules, the classic signs of a compromised mailbox.
- Have a written response plan for a compromised account, including the 72-hour breach notification decision.
Why email is the front door
For most law firms, Microsoft 365 holds the things criminals want: client correspondence, completion statements, bank details and the ability to send convincing emails from a trusted address. The government's Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025 found that 43% of UK businesses identified a breach or attack in the previous 12 months, and phishing was experienced by 85% of those[1]. Only 40% of businesses had adopted two-factor authentication[1].
Property work raises the stakes. There were 1,144,580 UK residential property transactions in the 2025 to 2026 financial year[2], each with deposits and completion monies moving between clients, firms and lenders. Clients are trusting: 94% of consumers were confident their legal provider would keep their money safe[3]. A single compromised mailbox can be used to send a client false bank details at exactly the wrong moment.
The settings that matter most
| Setting | Why it matters for a law firm | Priority |
|---|---|---|
| Multi-factor sign-in for every user | Stops most attacks that rely on a stolen password | Do now |
| Block legacy authentication | Older protocols can bypass multi-factor sign-in | Do now |
| Separate admin accounts, plus an emergency access account | Limits damage if a daily account is compromised | Do now |
| Block automatic external forwarding | A forwarding rule is a common way to copy a victim's mail silently | Do now |
| Alerts on suspicious inbox rules and sign-ins | Early warning of a compromised mailbox | Do now |
| Impersonation protection for partners and cashiers | Spots lookalike senders targeting payments | Next 30 days |
| SPF, DKIM and DMARC on your domain | Makes it harder to spoof your firm's address | Next 30 days |
| External sharing limited to named people, with link expiry | Stops client documents being reachable by anyone with a link | Next 30 days |
| Managed, encrypted devices | Protects data on lost laptops and phones | Next 90 days |
| Audit logging and a separate backup | Lets you investigate incidents and recover data | Next 90 days |
Identity and sign-in
Turn on multi-factor sign-in for every account, including partners, part-time staff and shared mailboxes that people sign in to. Small tenants can use Microsoft's security defaults, which switch on a sensible baseline at no extra cost. Conditional Access policies give finer control, for example requiring a managed device or blocking sign-ins from unexpected countries, but they need a higher-tier identity licence, included in some business plans such as Business Premium.
Block legacy authentication, the older sign-in methods used by some mail apps and printers, because they can bypass multi-factor checks. Give anyone with administrator rights a separate admin account they use only for administration, and keep one emergency access account with a long, securely stored password for the day something goes wrong with sign-in itself.
Email protection
When criminals take over a mailbox, they often create an inbox rule that forwards copies of messages to an outside address, or moves replies from a particular client into a hidden folder. Block automatic forwarding to external addresses across the tenant, and set alerts for new forwarding or suspicious inbox rules so that someone looks at them the same day.
Switch on impersonation protection for the people most likely to be imitated: partners, the COFA and anyone who confirms payments. Add a visible tag to emails from outside the firm, so a message that looks internal but is not stands out. Publish SPF, DKIM and DMARC records for your domain and move DMARC towards a rejecting policy once you are sure all legitimate senders are covered. That makes it much harder for someone to send email that appears to come from your firm.
Sharing, devices and data
SharePoint and OneDrive make it easy to share documents with clients and other firms, and easy to overshare. Set the default sharing link to specific people rather than anyone with the link, add expiry dates to external links, and review external sharing reports each month. Consider sensitivity labels for documents such as completion statements and medical records, so that they cannot be forwarded or opened outside the firm without permission.
Manage the devices that reach firm data. Require encryption, current operating system updates and a screen lock, and make sure you can remotely wipe firm data from a lost phone or laptop. Where staff use personal phones for email, app protection policies can keep firm data inside managed apps without taking control of the whole device.
Logging, retention and backup
Make sure audit logging is on and that someone knows how to search it. After an incident, the first questions are who signed in, from where, and what they read or sent; without logs, you cannot answer them. Set retention policies that match your file retention schedule, so that email is neither kept forever by default nor deleted before your policy allows.
Retention is not the same as backup. Many firms add a separate backup service for Microsoft 365, so that mail and files can be restored after accidental deletion, a malicious insider or a ransomware infection that syncs encrypted files to the cloud. Test a restore at least once a year.
Starters, leavers and shared mailboxes
Many compromises begin with accounts nobody is watching. A leaver's mailbox kept open so a colleague can monitor replies, a shared reception mailbox with a password everyone knows, or a trainee account created months ago and never used are all easy targets. Write a short starters and leavers checklist and make one person responsible for running it on the day someone joins or leaves.
- Disable a leaver's sign-in on their last day and convert the mailbox to a shared mailbox if colleagues need access.
- Remove leavers from distribution lists, Teams channels and external sharing links.
- Give shared mailboxes no direct sign-in; grant named users access to them instead.
- Review guest accounts from other firms and clients every quarter and remove those no longer needed.
Training people, not just tenants
Settings reduce the number of attacks that succeed, but people still decide whether to click, approve or pay. Keep training short, practical and specific to legal work: what a fake completion email looks like, why a sudden request for an unusual payment from a partner should always be checked by phone, and how to report a suspicious message without embarrassment. Staff who report a mistake quickly should be thanked, because the first hour after a compromise is when the most damage can still be prevented.
Responding to a compromised mailbox
Contain
Reset the password, revoke active sessions and re-register multi-factor methods for the affected account.
Look for persistence
Check inbox rules, forwarding settings, connected apps and mailbox delegates, and remove anything unexpected.
Establish what happened
Review sign-in and audit logs to see when access began, from where and which messages were read or sent.
Protect clients and funds
Identify matters with payments due, call those clients on known numbers to warn them, and pause payments that relied on details received by email.
Assess notification
Decide whether this is a notifiable personal data breach. If it is, report it to the regulator without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours of becoming aware[4], and consider your SRA reporting duties and your insurer's requirements.
Learn
Record how the account was compromised and close the gap, whether that is a missing setting, a training need or a process change.
Example: a Friday afternoon email
Example (fictional): at 3pm on a Friday, a buyer receives an email from her conveyancer's genuine address saying the firm's bank details have changed. She hesitates because the client care letter told her the firm never changes bank details by email, and she calls the office on the number in that letter. The firm confirms the message is false, finds a new forwarding rule created two days earlier, and follows its response plan. Because external forwarding alerts were switched on that week, the IT provider had already flagged the rule; the call simply confirmed it.
A review routine
- Monthly: review admin roles, external sharing, forwarding alerts and risky sign-ins.
- Quarterly: check that leavers' accounts are disabled and devices removed, and test a restore.
- Yearly: run a phishing awareness session for all staff and review the response plan.
- After any incident: update settings and training based on what you learned.
Security settings sit underneath every other system. If you are introducing new tools, read migrating to a new case management system and legal CRM: does a small firm need one?, and before switching on AI features in your office suite, see generative AI in law firms and what the SRA expects from firms using AI.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most important Microsoft 365 security setting for a law firm?
Multi-factor sign-in for every account, with older sign-in methods blocked so it cannot be bypassed. It stops most attacks that rely on a stolen password.
Should we block email forwarding to external addresses?
Yes, in most firms. Automatic external forwarding is a common sign of a compromised mailbox. Allow exceptions only where there is a documented business need.
Is Microsoft 365 retention the same as a backup?
No. Retention keeps data for set periods; a backup lets you restore it after deletion or ransomware. Many firms add a separate backup service and test restores.
What should we do if a fee earner's mailbox is compromised?
Contain the account, remove any rules or connected apps, review logs, warn clients with payments due by phone, assess whether the breach must be notified within 72 hours, and fix the gap that allowed it.
References
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (GOV.UK) (2025). Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Revenue & Customs (GOV.UK) (2026). UK monthly property transactions tables, October 2026 release (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 33: Notification of a personal data breach to the supervisory authority (opens in a new tab) ↑