Key takeaways
- Start six months before renewal: the proposal form is only as good as the data and evidence behind it.
- SRA minimum cover is £3 million for relevant recognised and licensed bodies and £2 million for other firms, with defence costs on top[1].
- A firm without qualifying cover moves into an extended policy period and then a cessation period, and must notify the SRA and its insurer within five business days[1].
- Firms that cannot renew must stop practising by the end of the cessation period[1]; 62.1% of recent firm closures were firms that ceased practising[2].
- Only 56% of consumers found information on indemnity insurance and the right to complain easy to locate[3]; make yours easy to find after renewal.
Why renewal needs six months, not six weeks
Professional indemnity insurance is a condition of practice. Under the SRA Indemnity Insurance Rules, a firm must hold qualifying insurance with a participating insurer for every indemnity period, and must obtain new cover to start when the old policy expires[1]. Most firms renew without drama, but a renewal left until the last few weeks gives the broker little time to present the firm well, gives insurers little reason to compete, and leaves no room if the expiring insurer declines to quote.
The firms most at risk are those whose work mix, claims history or size make them less attractive to insurers. Those are also the firms that most need a long, well-prepared approach to the market.
The minimum terms in brief
| Requirement | What the SRA rules say |
|---|---|
| Minimum cover per claim | £3 million for relevant recognised bodies and relevant licensed bodies; £2 million for all other firms, excluding defence costs |
| Defence costs | No monetary limit, although a policy may limit them proportionately where a claim exceeds the sum insured |
| Insurer | Cover must come from a participating insurer |
| Insurer insolvency | Arrange cover with another participating insurer as soon as reasonably practicable and within four weeks |
| Extended policy or cessation period | Notify the SRA and the insurer within five business days of entering either period |
| Run-off | Where run-off cover applies on closure, the period of insurance is extended for an additional six years |
These points come from the SRA Indemnity Insurance Rules and the minimum terms and conditions[1]. Check the SRA Glossary for which minimum applies to your firm's structure, and read the full rules before relying on any summary.
The timeline, month by month
The timeline below counts back from the renewal date. In the worked example the firm renews on 1 October; move each step to fit your own date.
Six months before (April)
Review the year: claims and circumstances notified, complaints, file review findings and any changes in work mix. Agree who will lead the renewal, usually the COFA or managing partner with the practice manager.
Five months before (May)
Meet the broker. Discuss last year's terms, the market, and what insurers are likely to focus on. Agree the data and evidence you will provide and the deadline for each item.
Four months before (June)
Gather the data: fee income by work type over the last few years, fee earner numbers and supervision arrangements, claims history, client account controls, and cyber security measures. Write a short risk management summary.
Three months before (July)
Complete the proposal form carefully and consistently with the data. Have a second partner check it. Inaccurate or incomplete answers can cause problems when a claim is made.
Two months before (August)
The broker presents the firm to insurers. Be available for insurers' questions and calls; slow answers in August cost leverage in September.
Six weeks before (mid-August)
Review quotes with the broker, comparing excess, terms and exclusions as well as premium. Decide whether to fund the premium in instalments.
Four weeks before (September)
Accept terms in writing, check the policy documents against the minimum terms, and arrange payment or premium funding.
Renewal date (1 October)
Confirm cover is in force, file the certificate, and update the insurer details wherever the firm publishes them.
One month after (November)
Hold a short review: what insurers asked, what slowed things down, and what to improve before next year.
What to prepare
- Fee income split by work type, with an explanation of any significant change, such as growth in conveyancing or a new practice area.
- Claims and circumstances notified in recent years, with what was learned and changed after each.
- Supervision: who supervises whom, how often files are reviewed, and how new staff are trained.
- Client account controls, including reconciliation sign-off and how payment instructions are verified.
- Cyber security measures, such as multi-factor authentication, staff training and how the firm protects completion funds.
- Complaints data and how the firm handles complaints.
A short covering summary, two pages at most, that tells the firm's story in plain terms is often more useful to an insurer than a thick bundle. Explain changes before the insurer has to ask about them.
Comparing quotes: more than the premium
When quotes arrive, the cheapest is not always the best. Compare them on the points that will matter if a claim is made, and ask the broker to set them out side by side.
- The excess per claim, and whether it applies to defence costs as well as damages.
- Any aggregate excess, and how it would work in a year with several small claims.
- Exclusions or conditions beyond the minimum terms, such as conditions about payment verification or specific work types.
- The insurer's approach to claims handling and its record in the market, which the broker should be able to describe.
- Whether the insurer offers risk management support, such as training or file review tools.
- The length of the policy and any long-term agreement offered.
Record the reasons for the final choice in a short note for the partners' file. It will be useful next year, and it shows the decision was considered rather than rushed.
If cover cannot be found
The rules provide a safety net, but it is short. If the firm has not obtained qualifying insurance by the end of its policy period, it enters an extended policy period, and then a cessation period[1]. The firm must notify the SRA and its insurer within five business days of entering either period, and during the cessation period it may only carry out work needed to fulfil existing instructions. If it still has no qualifying insurance by the end of the cessation period, it must stop practising[1].
Do not wait for the extended policy period to start before acting. If the expiring insurer signals it may not renew, tell the broker at once and widen the approach to the market.
Closures are a regular part of the market. In the 12 months to the end of June 2026, 514 law firms closed for all reasons, including mergers[4], and of those closures 62.1% ceased practising while 18.5% merged or amalgamated[2]. Not every closure relates to insurance, but early preparation keeps renewal from becoming one of the reasons.
- Ceased practising 62.1%
- Merged or amalgamated 18.5%
- Other reasons 19.4%
Source: Solicitors Regulation Authority, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Ceased practising | 62.1% |
| Merged or amalgamated | 18.5% |
| Other reasons | 19.4% |
Premium, cash and the partners' diary
For many small firms the PII premium is one of the largest single payments of the year. Put it in the cash forecast from the spring, with an estimate that the broker can refine, and decide early whether to pay in one sum or through premium funding over several months. Premium funding spreads the cost but adds interest, so compare the total cost. Block out partners' time for August and September too: insurers' questions, a possible meeting and the final decision all need a partner who is not on holiday.
Example: a renewal that started in April
Example (fictional). A five-partner firm renewing on 1 October had grown its residential conveyancing from a fifth to over a third of fees in two years. Last year it started in August and received two quotes, both with higher excesses. This year the managing partner starts in April, writes a two-page summary explaining the growth, the new supervision structure and the payment verification process, and sends the data to the broker in June. Insurers' questions are answered within a day. The firm receives four quotes, accepts terms in early September and renews on time, with an excess unchanged from last year.
After renewal
Clients look for this information more than firms expect, and often struggle to find it. In the Legal Services Consumer Panel's 2026 research, only 56% of consumers found information on professional indemnity insurance and the right to complain to an ombudsman easy to locate[3]. After renewal, check that the insurer details you publish are up to date and easy to find. Then put the next renewal's six-month start date in the diary, and add it to the annual compliance calendar for COLPs and COFAs. Renewal often lands in the same months as the legal year's workload, so plan the partners' time accordingly.
Frequently asked questions
When should a law firm start preparing for PII renewal?
About six months before the renewal date. That leaves time to gather data, complete the proposal form carefully and give insurers a reason to compete.
What is the minimum PII cover for solicitors?
Under the SRA rules, £3 million per claim for relevant recognised bodies and relevant licensed bodies and £2 million for other firms, excluding defence costs. Check the SRA Glossary for which applies to you.
What happens if we cannot renew on time?
The firm enters an extended policy period and then a cessation period, must notify the SRA and its insurer within five business days, and must stop practising if it has no qualifying cover by the end of the cessation period.
Does run-off cover apply if a firm closes?
Where run-off cover applies, the minimum terms extend the period of insurance for an additional six years. Check the rules for when it applies to your firm.
References
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2019). SRA Indemnity Insurance Rules (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Breakdown of firm closures by reason (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Firms opened and closed (opens in a new tab) ↑