Key takeaways
- Every SRA-authorised firm must hold qualifying insurance with at least £2m cover per claim, or £3m for recognised and licensed bodies, with no aggregate cap.
- Insurers price on work mix, claims and circumstances, supervision, client money handling and cyber controls, so evidence in each area matters.
- Residential conveyancing drew 36% of complaints accepted by the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26, which is one reason insurers probe property work closely.
- A clear, documented risk story presented early in the renewal cycle does more for premiums than any single control.
What every policy has to cover
Professional indemnity insurance is not optional. An SRA-authorised body must take out and maintain qualifying insurance with a participating insurer, and if it cannot renew it must cease practice promptly[1]. The minimum terms fix the floor: cover of at least £3m for any one claim where the firm is a relevant recognised body or licensed body, and at least £2m in other cases. The insurance must not limit liability with an aggregate limit beyond those terms[1].
Because the cover itself is standardised, insurers compete on price and appetite. They decide both by reading your proposal form and supporting documents as a picture of how likely you are to generate claims. A firm with the same fee income as its neighbour can pay very differently depending on what that picture shows.
How insurers read a proposal
Underwriters vary, but the questions they ask cluster around the same themes. The table pairs each theme with the evidence that tends to help and the weak answer that tends to hurt.
| Insurer question | Evidence that helps | Answer that hurts |
|---|---|---|
| What work do you do? | Accurate fee split by work type, with reasons for any change | Vague categories or an unexplained jump into a new area |
| What claims and circumstances have you had? | Full list, what went wrong, what you changed | Omissions or 'none' when a circumstance was notified |
| How do you supervise? | Named supervisors, ratios, file review records | A sole supervisor for many unqualified fee earners |
| How do you handle client money? | Clean reconciliations, payment verification, few breaches | Large residual balances and repeated breaches |
| How do you manage cyber risk? | Call-back checks on bank details, multi-factor login, training records | Bank details accepted by email without checks |
| How do you control undertakings and deadlines? | Central undertakings register and key dates diary | Undertakings tracked in individual inboxes |
| How do you handle complaints? | Written procedure, log, root-cause review | No log or no evidence of learning |
The common thread is evidence. An underwriter cannot visit every firm, so documents that show controls working, not just existing, carry the weight. A file review log with dates and findings is worth more than a policy that says files are reviewed.
Work mix and where risk concentrates
Complaints are not the same as negligence claims, but they show where service problems cluster, and insurers watch the same areas. In 2025/26, residential conveyancing accounted for 36% of complaints accepted by the Legal Ombudsman, with wills and probate and personal injury at 14% each[2]. Conveyancing complaints also rose 41% on the year before[2].
- Residential conveyancing 36%
- Wills and probate 14%
- Personal injury 14%
- All other areas 36%
Source: Legal Ombudsman, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Residential conveyancing | 36% |
| Wills and probate | 14% |
| Personal injury | 14% |
| All other areas | 36% |
Evidence of poor service was found in 72% of complaints the Ombudsman assessed, and 46% of its investigative outcomes found unreasonable complaint handling by the provider[2]. For an insurer, a firm that handles complaints badly is a firm more likely to see a dissatisfied client turn into a claim. If property work is a large share of your fee income, expect detailed questions on supervision, searches, source of funds checks and how you manage completion money.
Cyber and payment fraud
Payment diversion fraud is one of the most expensive ways a small firm can generate a claim, and insurers ask about it in detail. The wider picture explains why. In the government's 2025 survey, 43% of UK businesses reported a cyber security breach or attack in the previous 12 months, and phishing was the most common type, experienced by 85% of those affected[3].
- Verify any change of bank details by calling a number you already hold, never one in the email.
- Tell clients at the start of every matter that you will never change bank details by email.
- Use multi-factor login for email, case management and banking.
- Train every member of staff on phishing at least once a year and keep attendance records.
- Keep a written incident plan, including how you would assess a personal data breach within the 72 hours the UK GDPR allows for notifying the ICO[4].
- Restrict who can add or change payees on the bank mandate.
When you list these controls on the proposal, add the date each was introduced and how you check it is followed. A control described in one line with no evidence reads as aspiration.
Preparing your renewal
Start three to four months out
Diary the start of renewal work well before the policy end date, so you are not negotiating under time pressure.
Assemble the facts
Collect fee income by work type, fee earner numbers and qualifications, supervision ratios, and the full claims and circumstances history.
Write the risk story
Draft a short covering note: what the firm does, what changed this year, what went wrong and what you fixed. Keep it factual.
Attach the evidence
Include file review summaries, the complaints log, the undertakings register, cyber controls and any accreditation reports.
Use a specialist broker
A broker who places solicitors' PII can tell you which insurers have appetite for your work mix and how your proposal reads.
Answer questions promptly
Underwriter queries left unanswered for weeks suggest a firm that is hard to deal with. Respond quickly and completely.
Review the terms before you sign
Check the excess, any conditions on specific work types and how the policy treats circumstances notified to the previous insurer.
Accreditations and other signals
Accreditations can help when they are backed by real practice. The Law Society says its Lexcel practice management standard can help firms access lower insurance premiums and receive favourable treatment from insurers[5]. Whether it does so for your firm depends on the insurer, but the discipline behind it, documented risk management, file review and complaints handling, is what underwriters are looking for anyway. Our guide to Lexcel for small firms weighs the cost against that benefit.
Other signals matter too: a stable team, a succession plan for key fee earners, a policy on taking new work types, and evidence that partners act on file review findings. If the firm is facing financial pressure or considering a merger, raise it early with your broker; surprises late in the process cost more than candour.
A one-page risk summary for underwriters
Underwriters read many proposals in a short season. A single page at the front of your pack, in plain language, makes yours easier to price and harder to misread. Keep it to facts you can evidence if asked.
- Who we are: structure, offices, number of partners, fee earners and support staff.
- What we do: fee income by work type this year and last, and any area we have entered or left.
- What went wrong: claims and circumstances in the last six years, each with one line on cause and one on the fix.
- How we supervise: supervisors by team, file review frequency and the last review date.
- How we protect money: who approves payments, how bank details are verified, and breaches found in reconciliations.
- How we manage cyber risk: login security, training dates and the incident plan.
- What is changing: new partners, departures, mergers, office moves or systems.
Update the page every year rather than starting again. Over several renewals it becomes a record of a firm that knows its risks and deals with them, which is exactly the impression a proposal should leave.
Example: a four-partner firm reworks its proposal
Example. A fictional four-partner firm earns about half its fees from residential conveyancing and the rest from private client and family work. Last year it notified one circumstance: a client was nearly caught by an email asking them to send their deposit to a new account, which a conveyancing assistant spotted.
Rather than list the circumstance with a one-line explanation, the firm's covering note explains what happened, the call-back rule it introduced the next day, the client warning now in every client care letter and the training session it ran, with dates. It attaches a summary of quarterly file reviews in the property team, a complaints log showing two complaints both resolved within eight weeks, and its undertakings register. The broker presents it to three insurers. The firm still pays a premium that reflects its conveyancing exposure, but it is offered a choice of terms rather than a single take-it-or-leave-it quote.
What to avoid
- Understating fee income or a work type to lower the quote; non-disclosure can undermine cover when you need it.
- Leaving a known circumstance off the proposal in the hope it goes away.
- Switching insurer every year purely on price, which can make the firm look unstable.
- Submitting at the last minute, which limits the insurers willing to quote.
- Describing controls you do not actually operate.
PII sits alongside the SRA's wider focus on consumer protection; see the consumer protection review. If you are closing or merging, cover changes again, as explained in run-off cover when closing or merging a firm, and if your firm is reconsidering client money altogether, compare third-party managed accounts with client account. Renewal of practising certificates runs on its own timetable, covered in SRA annual renewal.
Frequently asked questions
What is the minimum PII cover for a solicitors firm?
Under the SRA minimum terms, at least £3m for any one claim for relevant recognised bodies and licensed bodies, and at least £2m in other cases, with no aggregate limit beyond those terms.
Does Lexcel reduce PII premiums?
The Law Society says Lexcel can help firms access lower premiums and favourable treatment from insurers. The effect varies by insurer, but the documented risk management it requires is what underwriters look for.
Should we disclose a near miss on the proposal form?
If it is a circumstance that could give rise to a claim, it should be notified and disclosed. Explaining what happened and what you changed usually reads better than leaving it out.
What happens if a firm cannot renew its PII?
The SRA Indemnity Insurance Rules require a firm that cannot obtain qualifying insurance to cease practice promptly, after any extended policy period.
References
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Indemnity Insurance Rules (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (GOV.UK) (2025). Cyber security breaches survey 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 33: Notification of a personal data breach to the supervisory authority (opens in a new tab) ↑
The Law Society (2026). Lexcel (opens in a new tab) ↑