SRA regulation and complaints

The Mazur ruling and conducting litigation

What the 2025 High Court ruling in Mazur said about non-authorised staff, how the Court of Appeal reversed it in March 2026, and what firms should do now.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the case mattered
  2. What the High Court said in 2025
  3. What the Court of Appeal decided in 2026
  4. The SRA's updated guidance
  5. What firms should do now
  6. Questions to ask about each role in the team
  7. Tools, technology and litigation tasks
  8. Example: a personal injury team after the appeal
  9. Keep watching
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • In September 2025 the High Court held that unauthorised staff could not conduct litigation even under supervision, causing alarm across litigation teams.
  • On 31 March 2026 the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal: unauthorised people can carry out tasks within the conduct of litigation for an authorised individual who directs, manages, supervises and controls the work.
  • The authorised individual, not the unauthorised person, is the one carrying on the conduct of litigation, and keeps responsibility for it.
  • The SRA updated its supervision guidance on 12 June 2026; firms should check that delegation, supervision and escalation are clear and evidenced on every litigation file.

Why the case mattered

The conduct of litigation is one of the reserved legal activities under the Legal Services Act 2007. It is an offence to carry on a reserved activity without being entitled to do so; on conviction on indictment the penalty can be up to 2 years' imprisonment, a fine or both, and acting in the purported exercise of a right to conduct litigation can also be a contempt of court[1]. Litigation teams in England and Wales rely heavily on trainees, paralegals and legal executives who are not themselves authorised to conduct litigation. The question in Mazur was whether that model was lawful.

Being a solicitor is not enough on its own: entitlement depends on authorisation. At the end of September 2026 there were 217,550 solicitors on the roll but 181,481 practising solicitors holding practising certificates[2].

Solicitors on the roll and practising solicitors, England and Wales, September 2026
Solicitors on the roll and practising solicitors, England and Wales, September 2026Comparison. Solicitors on the roll: 217,550; Practising solicitors (holding practising certificates): 181,481.217,550Solicitors on the rollSolicitors on the roll: 217,550181,481Practising solicitors (holding practisingcertificates)Practising solicitors (holding practising certificates): 181,481Solicitors on the roll and practising solicitors, England and Wales, September 2026Comparison. Solicitors on the roll: 217,550; Practising solicitors (holding practising certificates): 181,481.217,550Solicitors on the rollSolicitors on the roll: 217,550181,481Practising solicitors (holdingpractising certificates)Practising solicitors (holding practising certificates): 181,481

Source: Solicitors Regulation Authority, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Solicitors on the roll217,550
Practising solicitors (holding practising certificates)181,481

What the High Court said in 2025

In Mazur v Charles Russell Speechlys LLP [2025] EWHC 2341 (KB), Sheldon J held in September 2025 that unauthorised individuals were not permitted to conduct litigation under the 2007 Act, even under supervision[3]. The decision drew a line between supporting an authorised solicitor, which was lawful, and conducting litigation under that solicitor's supervision, which was not.

The practical effect was immediate. Firms reviewed which tasks their unauthorised staff carried out on litigation files, some reallocated work to authorised fee earners, and legal executives without litigation rights faced uncertainty about their roles. CILEX appealed, with the Law Society, the SRA and the Legal Services Board involved in the appeal.

What the Court of Appeal decided in 2026

The Court of Appeal handed down judgment on 31 March 2026 in Mazur and others v CILEX and others [2026] EWCA Civ 369, with Birss LJ giving the leading judgment, and allowed the appeal[3]. It held that an unauthorised person can lawfully perform any tasks within the scope of the conduct of litigation for an authorised individual, that the unauthorised person does not commit an offence, and that the authorised individual is the person carrying on the conduct of litigation[3].

The court said delegation requires proper direction, management, supervision and control, and that the degree required depends on the circumstances: some work needs approval beforehand, while routine work may need only regular meetings and sampling[3]. It held that the High Court was wrong to distinguish between supporting an authorised solicitor and conducting litigation under their supervision; both are lawful if the conditions are met[3]. The authorised individual keeps responsibility for the delegated tasks and must put in place and maintain appropriate arrangements for supervision and delegation[3].

The two Mazur decisions compared, as summarised in commentary on the judgments.
QuestionHigh Court, September 2025Court of Appeal, March 2026
Can unauthorised staff carry out tasks within the conduct of litigation?Not even under supervisionYes, for an authorised individual, under proper supervision
Who is carrying on the conduct of litigation?Whoever performs the tasksThe authorised individual
Supporting versus conducting under supervisionA meaningful distinctionWrong to distinguish; both lawful if conditions met
What must the authorised individual do?Do the reserved work personallyDirect, manage, supervise and control; keep responsibility

The SRA's updated guidance

The SRA updated its effective supervision guidance on 12 June 2026 to reflect the judgment[4]. The guidance says delegation must be clear and not based on assumptions by the solicitor or the unauthorised person, and can be done by allocating tasks directly or through a process with a clear scheme of delegation[4]. Authorised persons can show direction through prior instructions on each matter or through a work process that requires non-standard issues to be escalated, and they will need to be able to demonstrate that they directed the progress of a matter[4].

The guidance confirms that the authorised individual is the person carrying on the conduct of litigation, and an annex describes the courts' narrow interpretation of what conduct of litigation covers, with examples such as pre-litigation work and gathering evidence that are unlikely to fall within it[4]. Supervisors must also confirm that any authorisation unauthorised staff hold covers the activities they perform[4].

What firms should do now

  1. Name the authorised person on every litigation file

    Record, on the file and in the case management system, which authorised individual is carrying on the litigation. It should never be unclear.

  2. Write a scheme of delegation

    List the litigation tasks unauthorised staff may carry out, which need prior approval and which are routine. Base it on the risk and judgement involved.

  3. Build in escalation

    Define the non-standard issues that must go to the authorised person before action, such as a deadline at risk, a change in strategy or a without-prejudice offer.

  4. Evidence direction and control

    Keep instructions, approvals, supervision notes and file review records on the file so that you can show the authorised person directed the matter.

  5. Check spans and capacity

    An authorised person cannot direct and control work they never see. Check that each supervisor's span allows real oversight.

  6. Brief the team

    Explain the position to trainees, paralegals and legal executives so they know what they can do, what needs approval and who to go to.

The Court of Appeal's ruling restores the delegation model, but it does not remove the risk. If something goes wrong on a file where nobody can show who was directing the work, the question of who was carrying on the litigation will be asked again.

Questions to ask about each role in the team

The judgment changes the legal question, but the practical one is the same for every team: for each person who works on litigation files, who are they working for, what can they do on their own, and how does the authorised person know what they are doing? Work through each role in turn.

  • Trainee solicitors: which tasks need approval before they go out, and how is that approval recorded?
  • Paralegals and case handlers: does the scheme of delegation list their tasks, and is there a named authorised person on each of their files?
  • Legal executives without litigation rights: are they treated as unauthorised for litigation purposes, and supervised accordingly?
  • Legal executives and others with their own litigation rights: does the firm hold a record of what their authorisation covers?
  • Costs draftsmen, outsourced teams and agents: who in the firm directs and checks their litigation work?
  • Supervisors: do they have the time and visibility to direct and control the files they are responsible for?

Record the answers in your supervision protocol. They are the evidence that the firm's arrangements meet the standard the Court of Appeal described.

Tools, technology and litigation tasks

The same logic applies to technology. The SRA has said firms remain responsible and accountable for outputs from AI they use[5], and its supervision guidance expects human review and an authorised individual retaining ultimate responsibility for AI-assisted work[4]. If a tool drafts court documents, prepares disclosure or tracks deadlines, the authorised person carrying on the litigation must direct and check that work just as they would a junior's.

Example: a personal injury team after the appeal

Example (fictional). After the High Court ruling, a personal injury firm moved all issuing and filing to its solicitors, slowing the team. After the Court of Appeal decision and the SRA's June guidance, it restores the earlier model but with tighter controls: each file names a supervising solicitor, a scheme of delegation lists the tasks paralegals may carry out, and anything involving a court deadline, a Part 36 offer or a change of strategy needs the solicitor's approval recorded on the file.

Example (continued). Supervisors sample two files per paralegal each month and record the review. The COLP checks a sample each quarter to confirm the scheme is being followed. When a paralegal leaves, the firm can show for every file who carried on the litigation and how they directed it.

Keep watching

The law on reserved activities can change through further appeals, new regulator guidance or legislation. Check the current position, including any further appeal or legislative change, before relying on this summary for a specific decision. See reserved legal activities explained, effective supervision and reporting serious breaches for related duties.

Frequently asked questions

What did the Mazur High Court judgment decide?

In September 2025 the High Court held that unauthorised individuals were not permitted to conduct litigation under the Legal Services Act 2007, even under the supervision of an authorised solicitor.

Was the Mazur ruling overturned?

Yes. On 31 March 2026 the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in [2026] EWCA Civ 369, holding that unauthorised people can carry out tasks within the conduct of litigation for an authorised individual who properly directs, manages, supervises and controls the work.

Can paralegals issue proceedings after Mazur?

They can carry out litigation tasks for an authorised individual under proper supervision. The authorised individual carries on the litigation and must be able to show they directed and controlled the work.

What should firms change after the Court of Appeal ruling?

Name the authorised person on every litigation file, write a scheme of delegation with escalation points, evidence supervision on the file and follow the SRA's updated supervision guidance.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2007). Legal Services Act 2007, section 14 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Population of solicitors in England and Wales (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Kingsley Napley (2026). Mazur & others v CILEX & others (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Effective supervision (guidance) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2023). Risk Outlook report: The use of artificial intelligence in the legal market (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo