Key takeaways
- An auto-reply confirms receipt and sets one honest expectation; it is not a response.
- Promise a time you will meet every time, and say what the person should do if the matter is urgent.
- Be plain that the message is automatic, and always give a route to a person.
- Test the auto-reply from outside the firm, on a phone, for every form and inbox that sends one.
The job of an auto-reply, and its limits
Someone has just pressed send on a web form about their divorce, or emailed the firm about a parent's estate at 10pm. The automatic acknowledgement that lands seconds later answers one question in their mind: did it work? A good auto-reply also answers a second: when will a person get back to me? Anything beyond that tends to irritate.
The risk is that firms let the auto-reply stand in for a response. People notice when contact feels impersonal. In 2026, 17% of legal services consumers would have preferred to speak to a legal professional more than they did, rising to 24% for those served by telephone and 25% for those served by email or online[1]. An auto-reply that promises 'someone will be in touch shortly' and is followed by two days of silence makes that worse, and with 69% of consumers choosing a provider within a week[2], two days is a large share of the decision window.
Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| All consumers | 17% |
| Served by telephone | 24% |
| Served by email or online | 25% |
What to say, what to promise, what to avoid
| Say | Promise | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Your message has reached us | A human reply by a stated time, such as within two working hours or by 10am on the next working day | 'Shortly', 'as soon as possible', 'in due course' |
| This is an automatic confirmation | Who will reply, by team or name where you can | Pretending the message is from a person |
| What to do if it is urgent | A phone number that is answered, with hours | Telling people to call a line that goes to voicemail |
| Where to find price and service information | Nothing about fees beyond the published page | Fee figures in the auto-reply itself |
| How the information they sent will be used, with a link to the privacy notice | Nothing about the merits | Marketing content, newsletters or offers |
| A short confidentiality line at the end | Nothing you cannot deliver | Long legal disclaimers above the useful content |
The most important column is the middle one. The time you promise in the auto-reply becomes the standard the client judges you against. Promise what you meet on your worst normal week, not your best. If the form says two working hours, the inbox needs an owner every working hour.
Be honest that it is automatic
Some firms write acknowledgements that look personal, signed by a named solicitor who has not read the message. People see through it, and it raises a question of trust at exactly the wrong moment. Concern about automation is real: lack of trust in AI technology (51%) and lack of human oversight (49%) were the main barriers people gave to using AI to access legal services[3], and AI acting without the user's knowledge or consent was the single most urgent AI concern for legal service users, at 56%[4]. A plain 'this is an automatic confirmation' line costs nothing and avoids the problem.
If any part of your response is automated, from the acknowledgement to an out-of-hours call assistant, say so clearly and tell people how to reach a person.
Three templates
Keep each under 120 words. The person reading it is anxious and probably on a phone.
During working hours. Subject: We've received your message. This is an automatic confirmation that your message has reached [firm name]. A member of our [team] team will reply personally by [time, for example 'within two working hours']. If your matter is urgent, for example there is a court hearing, completion or deadline in the next few days, please call us on [number], [hours]. You can see our prices and how we work here: [link]. We'll use the details you sent only to respond to your enquiry; our privacy notice is here: [link].
Evenings and weekends. Subject: Thanks, we'll reply on [next working day]. Thank you for your message. It has reached us safely. Our office is closed at the moment, and a member of the team will reply personally by [10am] on [next working day]. If you've been arrested or are at a police station, you can ask for the duty solicitor, which is free. If anyone is in danger, call 999. Our price and service information is here: [link].
Office closure. Subject: Our office is closed until [date]. Thank you for your message. Our office is closed from [date] to [date] and reopens at [time] on [date]. We'll reply personally to every message received during the closure by [time and date]. If you have a court date, completion or other deadline during this period, please call [emergency number or arrangement] and we'll do what we can. Our price and service information is here: [link].
Example: rewriting a typical acknowledgement
Example (fictional): a firm's existing form acknowledgement read, in full: 'Thank you for contacting us. Your enquiry is important to us and will be dealt with as soon as possible. This email and any attachments are confidential and intended solely for the addressee. If you are not the intended recipient please notify the sender.' It was sent from a no-reply address, at every hour, for every form on the site.
The rewrite took ten minutes. It says the message has arrived and that this is an automatic confirmation; names the team that will reply; gives a time, 'by 10am on the next working day' for evening messages; offers a phone number for anything with a date in the next few days; links to the price page and the privacy notice; and moves a one-line confidentiality note to the end. It is sent from the monitored enquiries address, so a reply reaches a person.
The more important change was behind the message. The firm named an inbox owner for the first hour of each working day, so the 10am promise was always kept. Without that, the new wording would simply have been a more specific broken promise.
Prospects and existing clients need different messages
Many firms run one auto-reply on the main inbox for everyone. Existing clients writing about a live matter and strangers writing for the first time need different things. A prospective client needs reassurance that the firm will respond and a route for urgent help. An existing client needs to know whether their fee earner has seen the message, and who to contact if that person is away.
- Use separate addresses or form routes for new enquiries and for existing matters where you can, each with its own acknowledgement.
- For fee earners' out-of-office messages, name a colleague who can deal with urgent matters and give a direct number, not just the switchboard.
- Never send a new-enquiry acknowledgement, with price links and a privacy notice for prospects, to a client halfway through a matter.
The common annoyances, and fixes
- The no-reply address. Fix: send from an address that is monitored, so a reply to the auto-reply reaches a person.
- The duplicate. Fix: if a form also copies the main inbox, make sure only one acknowledgement goes out, not one from each system.
- The every-message auto-reply. Fix: acknowledge the first message in a thread only; replying automatically to every follow-up email feels like talking to a machine.
- The wall of disclaimers. Fix: move confidentiality and disclaimer wording below the useful content, and keep it short.
- The promise nobody owns. Fix: before publishing a response time, name who monitors the inbox at each hour of the working day.
- The stale closure message. Fix: set an end date on holiday auto-replies so they switch off automatically, and diarise a check.
Clients remember the gap between what was promised and what happened. In Legal Services Consumer Panel research, some clients described follow-up emails that went unanswered for weeks and not knowing who to contact[5]. An auto-reply that names a team and a time, followed by a human reply inside that time, is the opposite of that experience.
Test before go-live, and every quarter
List every route
Every web form, every published email address, the contact page, the booking page and any directory listing that forwards messages. Each may send its own acknowledgement.
Send a test from outside
Use a personal email address and a phone. Submit each form and email each address, during office hours and in the evening.
Read it as a stranger
Is the message clear on a small screen? Does it say when a person will reply and how to get urgent help? Do the links work?
Time the human reply
Note whether the promised human reply arrived inside the window. If not, the promise or the rota needs to change.
Fix and record
Correct anything that failed, note the date of the test and repeat it each quarter or whenever a form or inbox changes.
Pair the acknowledgement with a strong human follow-up using the first-response email templates, and make sure your out-of-hours wording matches what people expect, covered in evening and weekend enquiries. If someone asks to be phoned, the callback rules take over.
Frequently asked questions
Should a law firm use an auto-reply for enquiries?
Yes, if it confirms receipt, states honestly when a person will reply, explains what to do if the matter is urgent and is followed by a human reply inside that time.
What response time should the auto-reply promise?
One you meet on a normal bad week, such as within two working hours during office hours or by 10am the next working day for evening messages.
Should the auto-reply say it is automatic?
Yes. Messages that pretend to be personal undermine trust. A short line saying it is an automatic confirmation, with a route to a person, is better.
Can we include prices in the auto-reply?
Link to your published price and service information instead. Prices in an automated email go out of date and cannot reflect the details of the enquiry.
References
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2026). AI in Legal Services: Research Report (LSB Public Panel) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2025). Service Delivery Research Report (M·E·L Research for the LSCP) (opens in a new tab) ↑