Enquiry handling

Callback requests: making 'we'll call you back' reliable

Why law firm callbacks get missed and how to fix it: a five-field callback record, time windows, ownership, escalation, scripts and one honest measure.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why 'we'll call you back' so often fails
  2. The five-field callback record
  3. Windows, not vague promises
  4. Make callbacks visible to everyone who could cover
  5. Escalation: what happens when the window will be missed
  6. Scripts for promising and making a callback
  7. Callback requests that arrive out of hours
  8. Measure one honest number
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • A callback is a promise with five parts: who calls, whom, on which number, by when, and about what.
  • Promise a window, not 'later today', and make the window visible to everyone who can cover it.
  • Escalate automatically: if the window is about to pass, someone else calls or the caller gets an update.
  • Measure one thing: the share of callbacks made inside the promised window.

Why 'we'll call you back' so often fails

Almost every firm promises callbacks, and almost every firm misses some. The failure is rarely laziness. It is a note on a pad that goes home with a part-time receptionist, a message in a fee earner's inbox under forty others, a callback promised by the person who then goes to court. The caller does not see any of that. They see a firm that said it would ring and did not.

Clients notice. In Legal Services Consumer Panel research, clients described follow-up emails that went unanswered for weeks and not knowing who to contact, and said communication was typically reactive, with many having to chase for updates[1]. At the Legal Ombudsman, poor communication (24%) and delay or failure to progress (22%) were the two most common complaint types in 2025/26[2]. For a prospective client, the stakes are even more immediate: 69% of consumers chose their provider within a week[3], so a missed callback is often a lost instruction.

Complaints brought to the Legal Ombudsman by type, 2025/26
Complaints brought to the Legal Ombudsman by type, 2025/26Donut chart. Poor communication: 24%; Delay or failure to progress: 22%; All other complaint types: 54%.Poor communication: 24%Delay or failure to progress: 22%All other complaint types: 54%46% about communication or delay
  • Poor communication 24%
  • Delay or failure to progress 22%
  • All other complaint types 54%

Source: Legal Ombudsman, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Poor communication24%
Delay or failure to progress22%
All other complaint types54%

The five-field callback record

A callback that exists only in someone's head is a hope. A callback recorded with five fields, in a place the whole team can see, is a commitment the firm can manage. Use whatever tool you already have, whether a shared calendar, the case management system's task list or a phone system's callback queue, but always capture the same five things.

The minimum record for every callback promised
FieldWhat to recordWhy it matters
OwnerThe named person who will make the callWithout an owner, everyone assumes someone else will do it
Caller and numberFull name and the number read back to themA wrong digit makes a perfect process useless
WindowA start and end time, for example 2pm to 3pm todayGives the caller something to plan around and the team a deadline
PurposeOne line on what the call is for and any deadline mentionedLets anyone pick it up without asking the caller to start again
FallbackWhether voicemail is acceptable and whether email is a backupProtects callers who cannot have messages left, such as in abuse cases

Read the number back digit by digit, every time. It takes five seconds, and wrong numbers are the most common reason a properly scheduled callback still fails.

Windows, not vague promises

'Someone will call you back later' gives the caller nothing to hold on to and the team no deadline. 'Ruth will call you between 2 and 3 this afternoon' does both. Windows also let the firm manage capacity: if the afternoon is already full of court calls, offer tomorrow morning rather than squeezing in a promise that will break.

  • Offer a choice of two windows when you can: 'I can have Ruth call you between 2 and 3 today, or first thing tomorrow between 9 and 10. Which suits?'
  • Keep windows to an hour for same-day callbacks and a morning or afternoon for next-day ones.
  • Ask whether there is a time that does not work, especially for callers at work or caring for children.
  • If the caller mentions a date, such as a hearing or completion, put it in the purpose field and treat the callback as urgent.

Make callbacks visible to everyone who could cover

Callbacks fail most often when the owner becomes unavailable. The fix is visibility: a single list, board or queue that anyone covering the phones can see, sorted by window. When a fee earner goes into a meeting that overruns, the list shows that their 3pm callback is about to be missed, and someone else can act.

  1. Choose one place

    Pick a single shared location for callbacks, such as a shared calendar named 'Callbacks' or a task list in the case management system. Ban personal notes and private inboxes for this purpose.

  2. Log at the moment of promise

    The person who makes the promise logs it before ending the call or the chat, not afterwards.

  3. Review at fixed times

    The duty enquiry handler checks the list at 10am, 12pm, 2pm and 4pm and flags any window due in the next hour whose owner is not free.

  4. Close each callback with an outcome

    Spoke and booked, spoke and signposted, voicemail left, no answer and retry set. Never just delete it.

  5. Hand over at the end of the day

    Anything not closed moves to a named person for the next morning, with a note to the caller if the window was missed.

Escalation: what happens when the window will be missed

Some callbacks will slip. The difference between a firm that keeps clients and one that loses them is what happens next. Set a rule that a callback cannot simply pass its window without action. With fifteen minutes to go, if the owner cannot make it, one of two things must happen: someone else makes the call, or the caller is contacted with a new time.

  1. Fifteen minutes before the window closes, the duty handler checks with the owner.
  2. If the owner cannot call, another person who can handle the purpose makes the call, introducing themselves and the reason: 'Ruth's been held up in a meeting and didn't want to keep you waiting, so I said I'd ring.'
  3. If nobody suitable is free, the duty handler calls or emails the caller before the window closes with a new window, and an apology.
  4. If a callback is missed twice for the same person, the practice manager calls them personally.

Telling someone their call will be late is uncomfortable. It is far less damaging than silence. Most people are reasonable about a delay they were told about, and resentful about one they discovered.

Scripts for promising and making a callback

  • Promising: 'I'll ask Daniel, our employment solicitor, to call you. He's free between 11 and 12 today, or between 4 and 5. Which is better? Let me read your number back to you.'
  • Opening the callback: 'Hello, it's Daniel from the firm, calling back as promised about your dismissal. Is now still a good time to talk for ten minutes?'
  • No answer, voicemail allowed: 'This is Daniel calling back as arranged. I'll try again at 4.30, or you can reach me directly on this number until 5.'
  • No answer, voicemail not allowed: hang up, try once more within the window, then send the agreed fallback email if one was agreed.

Callback requests that arrive out of hours

Web forms, voicemails and answering-service messages that arrive in the evening or at the weekend are callback requests too, even if nobody promised anything. Treat them as the first callbacks of the next working day. Before the phones open, the duty handler clears the overnight list, gives each request an owner and a window, and sends a short message to each person saying when they will hear from the firm.

  • Sort the overnight list by urgency first, then by the time each request arrived.
  • Call back anyone who mentioned a hearing, completion or other date before 10am.
  • For the rest, offer windows across the day so that one person is not trying to return twenty calls by lunchtime.
  • If a voicemail gives no number, check the caller ID and the web form log before giving up on it.

Monday mornings are where this matters most. A weekend's worth of requests, plus Monday's normal demand, can swamp a small team. Schedule extra cover for the first two hours of the week, or move one fee earner's diary to start an hour later on Mondays so they can take the overflow.

Measure one honest number

Track the share of callbacks made inside the promised window, every week. Count a callback as made when someone spoke to the caller or left the agreed message, not when the task was ticked. Example (fictional figures): a firm logs 60 callbacks in a week and makes 45 inside the window, 75%. Of the 15 misses, 11 belong to fee earners who were in meetings, which points to a cover problem rather than a training problem.

Most people can reach their lawyer when they need to: 86% of people with a contentious issue found it easy to contact their main adviser using their chosen methods[4]. But difficulty getting through is still a live frustration, especially in conveyancing, where 16% of clients cited difficulty contacting their provider as a barrier to complaining[5]. A reliable callback system is how you stay in the first group.

Callbacks are one part of a wider promise about response. Write the same standards into your auto-replies and first-response email templates so every channel tells the client the same thing about when they will hear from you.

Frequently asked questions

How quickly should a law firm return a call?

Set a standard you can keep, such as the same working day for new enquiries, and promise each caller a specific window. Meeting a stated window matters more than a fast but vague promise.

Who should own a callback?

One named person, recorded at the moment the promise is made, with a visible list so someone else can cover if the owner is unavailable.

What if we cannot call back in the promised window?

Have someone else make the call, or contact the caller before the window closes with a new time and an apology. Never let a window pass silently.

Should we leave voicemails for prospective clients?

Only if the caller agreed to it. Some callers, for example in domestic abuse cases, need a different fallback, so ask and record the answer.

References

  1. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2025). Service Delivery Research Report (M·E·L Research for the LSCP) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo