Key takeaways
- Consumers compare firms on price, reputation and location, so you should know how you compare too.
- Most useful competitor information is public: published prices, timescales, reviews and websites.
- Do not invent a legal matter to test a competitor, write fake reviews or make misleading comparisons.
- New clients who spoke to other firms are an honest, willing source of comparison.
- Benchmarking is only worth doing if it changes something in your own service.
Why benchmark at all
Your prospective clients are benchmarking you. In the Legal Services Consumer Panel's 2026 tracker, 42% of legal services consumers shopped around before choosing a provider, and those who did most often compared price (57%), reputation (52%) and office location (36%)[1]. If you do not know how your published prices, reviews and response times compare with the firms down the road, you are guessing about why enquiries do or do not convert.
Benchmarking also protects against complacency. A firm that has served a town for decades can drift behind newer firms on response times or price clarity without noticing, because its loyal clients keep coming. The first sign is often fewer first-time clients, long before existing clients complain.
Benchmarking is not copying. The point is to understand what clients see when they compare, and to decide where your firm should be different or better.
The ethical lines
Solicitors are held to standards of integrity that apply to how they research competitors as much as to how they treat clients. A few lines are clear.
- Do not pose as a prospective client with an invented legal matter. It wastes another firm's time, puts their staff in a false position and is hard to square with acting with integrity.
- Do not write, commission or incentivise fake reviews of your firm or anyone else's. Under UK consumer law, businesses must not write or commission others to write fake reviews[2].
- Do not use what you learn in misleading comparisons. Any publicity about your practice, including about charges, must be accurate and not misleading[3].
- Do not ask staff who joined from a competitor to share that firm's confidential information, pricing models or client lists.
- Do not scrape or copy competitors' content. Learn from it; write your own.
A simple test: would you be comfortable if the competitor, the SRA and your own clients knew exactly how you gathered the information? If not, do not do it.
What you can learn from public information
| Area | Where to look | What to record |
|---|---|---|
| Prices and timescales | Price and service pages under the SRA Transparency Rules | Fee ranges, what is included, stated timescales by stage |
| Reviews | Google, review platforms, directories | Volume, recent rating, recurring praise and complaints, how the firm replies |
| Accessibility of contact | Website, Google Business Profile | Opening hours, out-of-hours options, online booking, stated response times |
| Website clarity | Practice area pages | Whether a client can find the price, process and next step quickly |
| Specialism signals | Accreditations, team pages, directories | Accreditation schemes, named specialists, years in the area |
| Local presence | Office addresses, community activity | Office locations, parking, home visits |
The Transparency Rules make price comparison much easier than it once was. Firms that offer residential conveyancing, uncontested probate, most immigration applications, summary road traffic offences or employment tribunal claims for unfair or wrongful dismissal to individuals must publish price and service information[4]. Read three or four local competitors' pages for the services you offer and note how clearly they explain what is included.
Ask the people who compared
New clients who shopped around are the most honest source of comparison you have, and asking them is entirely ethical. Ask at the end of the first meeting or in the onboarding form:
- Did you speak to any other firms before choosing us?
- What made you choose us in the end?
- Was there anything another firm did better, such as answering faster or explaining the price more clearly?
Record the answers as themes, not names. Do not press for details of what another firm quoted, and never use what a client tells you to criticise a named competitor. Over a few months, patterns appear: "the other firm called me back within the hour", "your website was the only one with a clear price".
Reviews also show what people look for. In the Legal Services Board's Legal Needs Survey, 14% of people choosing a main adviser searched for reviews and 13% searched for prices[5]. Reading competitors' reviews tells you what clients in your area praise and complain about.
Reading competitors' reviews well
Reviews are the closest public view of how other firms actually serve clients. Read them for patterns rather than star ratings.
- Which named people are praised repeatedly? It often reveals who handles first contact.
- Which complaints recur: slow replies, unexpected costs, not knowing who is dealing with the file?
- How does the firm respond to criticism: promptly, defensively, or without breaching confidentiality?
- How recent are the reviews? A strong rating from three years ago says little about service now.
- Do reviews mention the phone, the website or online booking? Those details show where clients felt the service was easy or hard.
Look beyond law firms
Your clients do not only compare you with other solicitors. Clients in Legal Services Consumer Panel research compared law firms with retail and banking, where they expect real-time updates, named points of contact and accessible help channels[6]. Benchmark a few non-legal services your clients use: how a bank confirms a payment, how a delivery company gives a time slot, how a surgery handles appointment booking. The ideas transfer more easily than you might expect.
A quarterly benchmarking routine
Choose four to six competitors
The firms your clients mention, plus any new entrant or national brand with a local office.
Review published prices and timescales
For your main services, record ranges and what is included. Note any changes since last quarter.
Read recent reviews
Read the last 20 reviews of each firm. Note themes, not individual comments.
Check contact options
Opening hours, online booking, out-of-hours arrangements and stated response times, from public pages only.
Collate client comments
Add the themes from new clients who shopped around.
Compare and decide
Pick one or two changes to your own service, price presentation or website for the next quarter.
Recording what you find
Keep the findings in one simple sheet so they can be compared quarter to quarter. One row per competitor, one column per area: price range for each main service, what is included, stated timescales, review volume and recent themes, contact options and response promises. Add a final column for "what we should learn from this". Date every entry and note the source page, so anyone can check it later and so you never repeat an out-of-date comparison in marketing.
Test yourself instead
The things you cannot ethically test at a competitor, such as how fast the phone is answered or how an enquiry is followed up, you can test at your own firm. Ask a friend or an agency to make realistic enquiries using a scenario you have written, and tell the team in advance that it will happen during the quarter. Compare your own response times with what competitors promise publicly. That gives you a fair benchmark without deceiving anyone.
For a full method, see mystery shopping your own law firm.
Turning findings into action
Example: a firm reviews five local competitors and finds that three publish conveyancing price pages with a clear breakdown, while its own page gives a single "from" figure. New clients mention that a competitor explained the costs more clearly on the phone. The firm rewrites its price page with a stage-by-stage breakdown and trains reception to walk callers through it. Six months later, fewer new clients mention another firm's pricing clarity as a reason they nearly went elsewhere.
- Fix presentation before price. Many firms lose on clarity, not on the figure.
- Match or beat the response promises competitors make publicly, and measure whether you keep them.
- Respond to reviews, especially critical ones, if competitors do and you do not.
- Keep any comparison claims in your own marketing factual and checkable.
Share the results with the whole firm, not just partners. Reception staff and assistants often have the most practical ideas for closing a gap, and seeing what competitors promise publicly helps them understand why response times matter.
Benchmarking findings belong in the same place as your other client measures; see client experience metrics to report monthly. Complaints often show where you fall short of competitors; see using complaints as improvement data.
Frequently asked questions
Is mystery shopping a competitor law firm ethical?
Posing as a client with an invented matter is hard to square with acting with integrity and wastes the other firm's time. Use public information and your own new clients' experiences instead, and mystery shop your own firm.
Can we compare our prices with competitors in our marketing?
Only if the comparison is accurate, current and not misleading[3]. Comparisons go out of date quickly, so many firms avoid naming competitors.
Where can we find competitors' prices?
For services covered by the SRA Transparency Rules, firms must publish price and service information on their websites[4].
How often should we benchmark?
Quarterly is enough for most firms, with a lighter check when a new competitor opens locally.
References
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Transparency Rules (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2025). Service Delivery Research Report (M·E·L Research for the LSCP) (opens in a new tab) ↑