Client experience

Digital and personal: designing a hybrid legal service

Where digital tools speed up legal services and where clients want a person: research on channel preferences, a journey map and criteria for each step.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. What clients say they want
  2. What clients mean by personal
  3. Hybrid is not digital-first
  4. A journey map: digital or personal at each step
  5. Criteria for choosing a channel
  6. Where automation fits
  7. Designing the handoffs
  8. Choice and accessibility
  9. Common hybrid mistakes
  10. Example: a hybrid wills service
  11. Measuring a hybrid service
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • Clients want a person for the first meeting and for bad news, and digital speed for updates, documents and booking.
  • Most consumers think digital services improve access, but many would trust a digital-only provider less.
  • Decide channel by stakes, emotion, complexity and the client's own preference, not by what the software can do.
  • Every digital step needs an obvious route to a human.
  • Firms remain accountable for any automated tool they use with clients.

What clients say they want

The Legal Services Consumer Panel's 2026 tracker gives a clear picture of channel preferences. Face-to-face is the preferred channel for the first meeting with a lawyer, at 54%, while email is preferred for progress updates, at 45%[1]. Asked which channels they would be happy to use for an initial meeting, 79% said face-to-face, 66% telephone and 64% email[1].

Channels consumers would be happy to use for an initial meeting with a lawyer, 2026
Channels consumers would be happy to use for an initial meeting with a lawyer, 2026Bar chart. Face-to-face: 79%; Telephone: 66%; Email: 64%.Face-to-faceFace-to-face: 79%79%TelephoneTelephone: 66%66%EmailEmail: 64%64%Channels consumers would be happy to use for an initial meeting with a lawyer, 2026Bar chart. Face-to-face: 79%; Telephone: 66%; Email: 64%.Face-to-faceFace-to-face: 79%79%TelephoneTelephone: 66%66%EmailEmail: 64%64%

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Face-to-face79%
Telephone66%
Email64%

Two other findings from the same survey frame the design problem. When accessing legal services digitally, 73% of consumers said being able to meet the person handling their case in person was among the most important factors, and the same share said services fitting around their schedule mattered[1]. And while 69% agreed digital legal services would make legal services more accessible, 57% said digital-only access would make them trust providers less[1]. Clients want both, at different moments.

What clients mean by personal

Personal service is not the same as face-to-face service. Clients describe it in simpler terms: someone who knows their name and their matter, who explains things without making them feel foolish, and who calls when something important happens. A well-handled phone call can be more personal than a rushed office meeting. That is good news for firms, because it means "personal" can be designed into every channel through continuity of contact, plain language and timing, rather than requiring every client to visit.

Hybrid is not digital-first

A hybrid service uses digital tools where they reduce effort and waiting, and people where judgement, reassurance or trust is needed. The aim is not to move as much as possible online. It is to put each step in the channel that serves the client best, and to make switching between channels easy.

Clients in Consumer Panel research recommended that firms provide flexible appointment times, including evenings and weekends[2]. Digital tools are often the cheapest way to give that flexibility: online booking, document upload at midnight, a video call from the client's car park at lunchtime.

A journey map: digital or personal at each step

Example hybrid journey for a consumer matter
StepDigital defaultPersonal defaultWhy
First enquiryWeb form, call answering, online bookingA person available on the phoneSpeed matters; some callers need to talk
Identity and AML checksElectronic verification and secure uploadIn-person check where electronic failsDigital is faster for most clients
First meetingVideo for those who prefer itFace-to-face by default for sensitive mattersClients prefer to meet first in person
Engagement letterE-signatureShort call to explain fees and scopeWritten for record, spoken for understanding
Progress updatesScheduled email or portal updateCall when a date changes or a decision is neededEmail is preferred for updates
Bad news or a decisionNoneCall or meeting first, then writingEmotion and judgement
Signing documentsE-signature where legally allowedIn person where formalities require itWills, for example, have witnessing rules
ClosingClosing letter and feedback linkA thank-you call for long mattersEnds the relationship well

The map will differ by practice area. A commercial client buying a business may be happy to do nearly everything by email and video. A family client may want every significant conversation in person. Draw the map for each main service, and test it with a few recent clients before changing anything.

Criteria for choosing a channel

When designing or reviewing a step, score it against five questions. The more "high" answers, the stronger the case for a person.

  • Stakes: what is the cost to the client if they misunderstand? Losing a home or a child arrangement is high; a document checklist is low.
  • Emotion: is the client likely to be anxious, grieving or angry at this point?
  • Complexity: does the step need judgement, or just information?
  • Preference: has the client told you how they want to be contacted? Record it and use it.
  • Formality: do legal rules require a particular form, such as witnessed signatures or original documents?

Low stakes, low emotion, low complexity and no formal requirement: make it digital and fast. Anything else: offer a person, even if the digital route is also available.

Where automation fits

The SRA has noted that legal chatbots can respond quickly to enquiries from potential clients and potentially offer a 24/7 service, gathering information and triaging cases for urgency[3]. That is the natural home for automation in most firms: the first contact, out of hours, when the alternative is voicemail. An AI Employee such as Ava answers new enquiry calls, follows the firm's intake questions and books the initial consultation, while the consultation itself stays with a solicitor.

Trust is the constraint. The main barriers people report to using AI to access legal services are lack of trust in the technology (51%) and lack of human oversight (49%)[4]. Legal service users also expect AI legal tools to come with a complaints process, 89% of them, and 66% expect it to involve a real human[5]. Design automated steps so they are clearly labelled, hand over to a person whenever the client asks or the matter is urgent, and remain under the firm's supervision.

Keep a record of what automated steps say and do, review a sample regularly, and make sure staff know how to correct anything that goes wrong. The firm, not the software supplier, answers to the client and the regulator.

Designing the handoffs

Hybrid services fail at the joins. A client who completes an online form and then waits three days for a call has had a worse experience than one who simply phoned. Each handoff needs an owner and a time.

  1. Confirm every digital action

    When a client books, uploads or submits, confirm on screen and by email what happens next and when.

  2. Pass the context

    Whoever takes over from a digital step should see what the client already provided, so they are not asked again.

  3. Set a handoff time

    For example, a person reviews every new online enquiry within two working hours and calls urgent ones straight away.

  4. Show the human route

    Every page, form and automated message should show how to reach a person.

  5. Review the joins monthly

    Check a sample of matters where clients moved between channels and look for repeated questions or delays.

Choice and accessibility

A hybrid service should widen choice, not remove it. Some clients cannot or will not use digital tools: older clients, people with some disabilities, people without reliable internet, people in crisis. Others would much rather never visit an office. The design principle is that every step has a digital and a personal route, and the client chooses, with the firm's default based on the criteria above.

Record the choice. A client who says at the first meeting that they prefer phone calls should not receive portal notifications and nothing else for the rest of the matter.

Common hybrid mistakes

  • Launching a client portal and then sending all updates through it, even to clients who never log in.
  • Online booking that offers slots nobody is available to staff.
  • Automated messages with no reply route, so a client's question disappears.
  • Video meetings for bad news because they are convenient for the fee earner.
  • Asking clients to upload documents they have already emailed.
  • Digital tools introduced in one team only, so clients moving between departments meet two different firms.

Example: a hybrid wills service

Example: a private client team redesigns its wills service. Clients book a first meeting online or by phone, choosing in person or video. Before the meeting they complete a short online questionnaire about family and assets, with a phone number for anyone who prefers to go through it by phone. The meeting itself is always with a solicitor. Drafts go by email with a short call to walk through them. Signing happens in person at the office or at the client's home, because witnessing rules apply, and the closing letter confirms storage.

The team tracks two things: how many clients switch from the online questionnaire to a phone call, and how many drafts need more than one round of amendments. Both tell them where the digital step is not working.

Measuring a hybrid service

  • Share of clients using each channel at each step, and how many switch.
  • Time from digital action to human follow-up.
  • Repeated information requests: how often clients are asked for something they already gave.
  • Client feedback by channel, including those who chose not to use the digital route.

For a structured way to report these, see client experience metrics to report monthly. To compare your mix with local competitors without crossing ethical lines, see benchmarking competitors' client service ethically.

Frequently asked questions

Do clients prefer online or face-to-face legal services?

Both, at different points. Face-to-face is preferred for the first meeting and email for updates[1]. Most clients want digital convenience with a person available when it matters.

Will a digital-only service put clients off?

Many consumers say digital-only access would make them trust a provider less[1]. Keep a clear human route at every step.

Where should a law firm start with digital tools?

With low-stakes, high-volume steps: booking, document upload, identity checks and scheduled updates. These free time for the conversations clients value.

Who is responsible if an automated tool gets something wrong?

The firm. Supervise any tool used with clients, label it clearly and make it easy to reach a person.

References

  1. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2025). Service Delivery Research Report (M·E·L Research for the LSCP) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2023). Risk Outlook report: The use of artificial intelligence in the legal market (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Board (2026). AI in Legal Services: Research Report (LSB Public Panel) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo