Enquiry handling

Conflict checks at enquiry stage without slowing down

A two-stage conflict check for solicitors: a quick name search at first contact and a full check before engagement, protecting confidentiality throughout.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What the check has to answer
  2. Two stages: quick screen, then full check
  3. What to collect at first contact
  4. Reading the results
  5. Mergers, joiners and other blind spots
  6. Keeping it fast
  7. Joint enquiries need extra care
  8. What not to do
  9. Protecting confidentiality during the check
  10. Example: a hold resolved in an hour
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Run a quick name search before the enquirer tells their story, then a full check before engagement.
  • The SRA Code bars acting where there is a conflict or significant risk of one, and protects former clients' confidential information[1].
  • Collect the minimum: client, other side and closely connected people, plus a one-line matter description.
  • Mergers import other firms' client lists; 18.5% of firm closures in the year to June 2026 were mergers or amalgamations[2].
  • Agree who can clear a possible match, and how fast, so checks never become the bottleneck.

What the check has to answer

A conflict check at enquiry stage has one job: to stop the firm hearing confidential information, or giving advice, in a matter where it cannot act. The SRA Code sets out three tests that matter here[1].

  • Own interest conflict (paragraph 6.1): the firm or an individual has a personal interest that conflicts with the prospective client's.
  • Client conflict (paragraph 6.2): the firm would be acting for two or more clients whose interests in the same or a related matter conflict, or where there is a significant risk of that. Narrow exceptions exist for a substantially common interest or competing for the same objective, with informed consent and safeguards.
  • Confidentiality conflict (paragraph 6.5): the firm holds confidential information about a current or former client that is material to the new matter and the interests are adverse, unless effective measures are in place or the former client consents.

The duty of confidentiality in paragraph 6.3 applies throughout[1]. Even the fact that someone is or was a client can be confidential, so the check itself has to be discreet.

Two stages: quick screen, then full check

Example two-stage process for a firm with a searchable client database.
AspectStage 1: quick screenStage 2: full check
WhenDuring the first contact, before detailed factsAfter the consultation is booked, before engagement
WhoReception or new business teamFee earner, risk team or COLP for difficult cases
What is searchedClient name and other side's nameAll parties, connected people, companies, addresses, previous names
Typical outcomeClear, possible match or definite matchCleared, cleared with notes, or declined
Time taken (Example)Under a minuteSame working day

The quick screen exists so that the person answering the phone can stop a call politely before the enquirer explains, for example, how their business partner has been taking money, when the business partner is an existing client. The full check catches what the quick screen cannot: the other side's new company, the spouse with a different surname, the director who was a client of a firm you merged with.

What to collect at first contact

  1. The prospective client's full name, and any previous names they are known by.
  2. If the client is a company, its registered name and company number.
  3. The name of the other side: the employer, the former partner, the seller, the landlord, the insurer.
  4. Closely connected people where they matter: a spouse in a family matter, directors and shareholders in a company dispute, beneficiaries in a contested estate.
  5. A one-line description of the matter in neutral terms, such as 'dispute with former employer about dismissal'.

Reception should ask for the other side's name early, with a short explanation: 'Before you tell me more, can I take the name of the other person involved? We always check that first, so we know we are free to help.' Most enquirers accept that immediately; it sounds careful rather than bureaucratic.

Reading the results

Use the same categories in your enquiry log so outcomes can be counted.
ResultMeaningWhat to do
No matchNobody connected appears in the databaseProceed to booking; record the search
Match to the client onlyThe enquirer is a current or former clientProceed; note the existing relationship for the fee earner
Match to the other side, former client, unrelated matterPossible confidentiality issueHold; ask a named solicitor to review before the consultation
Match to the other side, current clientLikely client conflictStop; use the neutral decline line and escalate
Fuzzy or partial matchCould be the same person or businessHold; check further identifiers such as address or company number

Neutral line for any stop or hold that cannot be resolved quickly: 'I am sorry, we need to check something before we can go further. A colleague will call you back today.' Never explain what the search found.

Mergers, joiners and other blind spots

Conflict databases are only as good as their contents. Consolidation is steady in England and Wales: in the 12 months to the end of June 2026, 514 firms closed, and of those closures 18.5% were mergers or amalgamations while 62.1% ceased practising[2].

Why law firms closed, July 2025 to June 2026England and Wales; 'other reasons' is the remainder of the reported shares
Why law firms closed, July 2025 to June 2026Donut chart. Ceased practising: 62.1%; Merged or amalgamated: 18.5%; Other reasons: 19.4%.Ceased practising: 62.1%Merged or amalgamated: 18.5%Other reasons: 19.4%514 closures
  • Ceased practising 62.1%
  • Merged or amalgamated 18.5%
  • Other reasons 19.4%

Source: Solicitors Regulation Authority, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Ceased practising62.1%
Merged or amalgamated18.5%
Other reasons19.4%

Each merger brings another firm's client and matter history, often in a different format, and acquiring firms sometimes import it late or partly. At the same time, 386 new firms opened in the 12 months to the end of August 2026[3], many founded by solicitors who carry knowledge of former clients with them. Lateral hires create the same issue on a smaller scale.

  • Import merged firms' client and party data into the conflict database before taking new work from their areas.
  • Ask new joiners to declare matters they worked on that might conflict, and record them in a restricted list.
  • Search parties as well as clients. Many systems only search client names, which misses the most common conflict: acting against someone the firm has acted for.
  • Use fuzzy matching or search on several fields: surname plus postcode, company number, previous names.

Keeping it fast

  1. Give reception search access

    A read-only search on names and parties lets the quick screen happen during the call, without waiting for a fee earner.

  2. Name the clearers

    Agree which solicitors can clear a possible match in each department, with a deputy, and a target of the same working day.

  3. Use fixed outcome codes

    Clear, clear with note, hold or stop. Fixed codes make the log readable and the decision auditable.

  4. Flag time-sensitive holds

    If an enquiry with a deadline is on hold, the clearer is told immediately, not at the end of the day.

  5. Review a sample monthly

    Check a handful of cleared enquiries to make sure the search covered the other side and connected people, not just the client.

Joint enquiries need extra care

Some of the trickiest conflicts arrive as a single enquiry from two people. The quick screen will show no match, because neither person is in the database, yet the conflict sits inside the enquiry itself.

  • Separating couples who want 'one solicitor to sort it out amicably'. A firm cannot act for both parties in a divorce or financial settlement; explain early that the firm can act for one of them only, and that the other should take independent advice.
  • Business partners or shareholders who want help with a fall-out. If their interests on the dispute differ, the firm may be able to act for one, or for the company, but rarely for all.
  • Family members in an estate. Executors and beneficiaries may share an interest at first and then diverge; record who the client is from the start.
  • Buyer and lender in a conveyancing transaction. Acting for both is common, but the firm should still be clear who instructs it and watch for any divergence in their interests.
  • A relative calling for an older person. The client is the older person, and the firm must be satisfied that instructions genuinely come from them.

Train reception to spot the word 'we' in an enquiry and ask, gently, who the firm would be acting for. Paragraph 8.1 of the SRA Code requires the firm to identify who it is acting for in each matter[1], and settling that at the first call prevents the more awkward conversation later.

What not to do

  1. Do not take the full story first and search afterwards. By then the information has been heard.
  2. Do not rely on memory. 'I don't think we've acted for them' is not a search.
  3. Do not search only the client. The most common conflicts involve the other side.
  4. Do not let a hold drift. An enquiry on hold for three days has usually been lost, whatever the search shows.

Protecting confidentiality during the check

Share only what the clearer needs: names and the one-line matter description. Do not circulate an email to all partners asking 'does anyone know Mr X, who wants to sue his brother?'. That turns a conflict check into a confidentiality breach. If personal data is sent to the wrong person in the process, it may be a personal data breach; under UK GDPR, a notifiable breach must be reported to the ICO without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours of becoming aware of it[4].

Example: a hold resolved in an hour

Example (fictional). A caller wants advice on a boundary dispute with his neighbour. The quick screen shows a fuzzy match: the neighbour's surname and street match a former conveyancing client from six years ago. Reception uses the neutral hold line and passes the names to the property partner. The partner checks the old file: the former client sold that house four years ago, so the current neighbour is a different person. Cleared with note, and the caller is booked the same afternoon. Total delay: about an hour, with nothing confidential heard before the check.

Frequently asked questions

When should a law firm run a conflict check on a new enquiry?

Run a quick name search during the first contact, before the enquirer gives detailed facts, then a full check covering all parties and connected people before the firm is engaged.

Can reception run conflict checks?

Reception can run the quick screen if they have read-only search access and clear outcome rules. Possible matches should go to a named solicitor to clear.

What if the search shows a match with the other side?

Pause, use a neutral line with the enquirer and escalate. Do not explain what the search found, because the existence of a client relationship can itself be confidential.

Do we need to search former clients?

Yes. The SRA Code protects former clients' confidential information, so the database must include past clients and the parties to their matters.

References

  1. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Breakdown of firm closures by reason (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Firms opened and closed (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 33: Notification of a personal data breach to the supervisory authority (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo