Enquiry handling

Qualifying legal enquiries: questions that predict instruction

The triage questions and signals that separate likely clients from information seekers, by practice area, with a simple scoring sheet you can test.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Likely clients and information seekers
  2. Five signals that predict instruction
  3. How matter type changes behaviour
  4. Signals by practice area
  5. Funding questions without awkwardness
  6. Business enquiries
  7. Do not mistake uncertainty for low intent
  8. A simple scoring sheet to test
  9. Example: three calls scored
  10. What to offer each group
  11. Mistakes that make qualifying backfire
  12. Testing whether your signals work
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

Key takeaways

  • Qualifying is about prioritising time and choosing the right next step, not about turning people away.
  • Five signals predict instruction in most areas: stage, timeline, decision-maker, funding and source.
  • Matter type changes behaviour: only 23% of people facing criminal charges shopped around, against 42% overall[1].
  • Most clients pay for themselves: 74% self-funded or had help from family, while legal aid funded 5%[2].
  • Test any scoring sheet against real outcomes for three months before relying on it.

Likely clients and information seekers

Every firm takes calls from people who want to understand their position but are not ready, or able, to instruct a solicitor. Some want a quick view to take back to an employer, a landlord or an ex-partner. Some are comparing four firms on price. Some will instruct next week if the first conversation goes well. Treating all three groups the same wastes fee-earner time on some and under-serves others.

Qualifying means asking a few questions that show which group an enquirer is in, so the firm can choose the right next step: an urgent consultation, a standard booking, a fixed-fee information pack, or a polite signpost elsewhere. It is not a test the enquirer must pass, and it should never feel like one.

Five signals that predict instruction

  1. Stage: has something already happened that requires action, such as a letter, a dismissal, a death, an accepted offer on a house or court papers? A concrete trigger is a strong signal.
  2. Timeline: is there a date driving the matter? Enquirers with a deadline decide quickly.
  3. Decision-maker: is the caller the person who will instruct and pay, or researching for someone else?
  4. Funding: does the person know how they will pay, whether privately, through legal expenses insurance, a trade union, an employer or legal aid?
  5. Source: did they come through a recommendation or previous use of the firm? Prior use by the client or family (21%) and recommendations from family or friends (18%) were the most common ways consumers chose a legal provider[1].

None of these questions is intrusive if asked naturally. 'Is there a date we need to work to?' and 'How did you hear about us?' are ordinary parts of a good triage call.

How matter type changes behaviour

Shopping around varies a great deal by matter. In the Legal Services Consumer Panel's 2026 tracker, 42% of all consumers shopped around before choosing, but only 23% of those with criminal charges, 31% with probate and 32% with power of attorney matters did so[1].

Consumers who shopped around, by type of matterEngland and Wales, 2026
Consumers who shopped around, by type of matterBar chart. All legal services: 42%; Power of attorney: 32%; Probate: 31%; Criminal charges: 23%.All legal servicesAll legal services: 42%42%Power of attorneyPower of attorney: 32%32%ProbateProbate: 31%31%Criminal chargesCriminal charges: 23%23%Consumers who shopped around, by type of matterBar chart. All legal services: 42%; Power of attorney: 32%; Probate: 31%; Criminal charges: 23%.All legal servicesAll legal services: 42%42%Power of attorneyPower of attorney: 32%32%ProbateProbate: 31%31%Criminal chargesCriminal charges: 23%23%

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
All legal services42%
Power of attorney32%
Probate31%
Criminal charges23%

In areas where people compare less, a well-handled enquiry is very likely to instruct and the main risk is slowness. In areas where comparison is common, price is compared more often: 67% of consumers who shopped around compared prices for will writing and 62% for conveyancing[1]. Enquirers in those areas may be gathering quotes; qualify on timeline and whether they have already received other quotes, and make sure yours arrives quickly and clearly.

Signals by practice area

Use as a starting point; refine with your own outcome data.
Practice areaStrong signalsWeaker signalsQuestion to ask
Residential conveyancingOffer accepted, mortgage in principle, completion targetJust starting to look, no property identifiedHave you had an offer accepted yet?
FamilySeparation has happened, papers received, children's arrangements disputedConsidering separation, wants general informationHas anything been sent to you, or have you sent anything?
EmploymentDismissed or resigned recently, settlement agreement offeredUnhappy at work, no specific eventWhat has happened, and when?
Wills and probateRecent death, executor named, property to sell; or a will needed before an eventGeneral planning with no triggerIs there anything that makes this more pressing now?
Personal injuryAccident with injury and treatment, other party identifiedMinor incident, no treatmentDid you need medical treatment?
CommercialContract to sign, dispute with a named customer, a deal timetableGeneral compliance questionsIs there a document or deadline in front of you?

Funding questions without awkwardness

Funding is the signal firms most often avoid asking about, and the one that most often explains why an enquiry did not convert. Most legal services are paid for privately: 74% of consumers paid themselves or with help from family or friends, and legal aid funded only 5%[2]. Most bills were fixed fees (57%), with 9% charged by the hour[2].

That gives a natural way in: 'For this kind of matter we usually work on a fixed fee, which the solicitor will confirm. Were you planning to fund it yourself, or do you have legal expenses insurance or union cover that might help?' The answer tells you whether the person has thought about paying, and whether a third-party funder is involved that changes the next step.

Business enquiries

Small businesses are a large, under-served market. The Legal Services Board's small business research found that 32% of small businesses had at least one legal issue in a year, yet only a quarter of those with a legal issue used professional help[3]. Qualifying signals for business enquiries are slightly different: who in the business decides, whether there is a document or deadline, whether the business has used solicitors before and whether it expects ongoing work.

Do not mistake uncertainty for low intent

Many enquirers are hesitant because they are unsure about the law and about solicitors, not because they will not instruct. The Legal Needs Survey found that 38% of adults in England and Wales have a low level of legal confidence[4]. A caller who says 'I don't really know if this is something a solicitor does' may have a strong case and a pressing deadline. Score on facts, not on how confident the caller sounds.

A simple scoring sheet to test

Example (fictional scoring sheet). Score each signal 0, 1 or 2 during triage.

Example: scores of 7 or more get a consultation offer within two working days; under 4 get an information pack and an open invitation.
Signal012
StageNo event yetEvent expected soonEvent has happened
TimelineNo dateDate in monthsDate in weeks or days
Decision-makerResearching for someone elseJoint decisionCaller decides
FundingNo ideaThinking about itClear route
SourceUnknown or cold advertSearch or directoryRecommendation or previous client

Use the score to decide priority and next step, never to refuse someone outright. A low score with a safety concern, a vulnerable person or a hard deadline still goes straight to a solicitor.

Example: three calls scored

Example (fictional). Caller one was dismissed last Friday, is the decision-maker, has legal expenses cover on her home insurance and was recommended by a colleague. She scores 2 on every signal: 10. Reception books her with the employment associate for the next morning and flags the date of dismissal for review.

Example, continued. Caller two is researching for his mother, who may want to change her will at some point; there is no date and no decision yet, and he found the firm through a search. He scores 0, 0, 0, 1, 1: 2. He receives the fixed-fee wills information, a note that the firm will need to speak to his mother directly, and an open invitation to book. Caller three has had an offer accepted on a flat, has a mortgage in principle and wants completion within ten weeks, but is getting three quotes. She scores 2, 2, 2, 2, 1: 9. The quote goes out the same day, with a follow-up call booked two days later.

None of the three was turned away. Each got a next step matched to where they were, and fee-earner time went first to the matters most likely to start.

What to offer each group

  • High score: a consultation within two working days, or a quote the same day for fixed-fee work, plus a named contact.
  • Middle score: a standard booking, published price information and a follow-up call if they do not book.
  • Low score: a short information pack, links to useful guidance, and a clear invitation to come back when something happens. Record them so you know if they return.
  • Any score with urgency, vulnerability or risk to safety: straight to a solicitor the same day.

Review the offers with each department. A family team may want to offer low-scoring callers a short paid initial meeting rather than an information pack, because people considering separation often need a first conversation before they can make any decision at all.

Mistakes that make qualifying backfire

  1. Asking about money before explaining how the firm charges. Lead with the firm's approach, then ask about funding.
  2. Treating every price-shopper as a poor prospect. Comparison is normal, and a fast, clear quote often wins.
  3. Letting the score override judgement. A sheet is a prompt, not a rule.
  4. Never checking the sheet against outcomes, so it keeps rewarding the wrong signals.

Testing whether your signals work

  1. Record the scores

    Add each signal as a field in the enquiry log, scored at triage before the outcome is known.

  2. Wait for outcomes

    Run for three months so most enquiries have an outcome: instructed, lost or declined.

  3. Compare

    For each signal, compare the instruction rate of enquiries scoring 0, 1 and 2. A signal that makes no difference should be dropped.

  4. Adjust the thresholds

    Move the cut-off for a fast consultation offer up or down depending on fee-earner capacity.

  5. Repeat yearly

    Markets change. Re-test the sheet each year and after any change to the firm's services or marketing.

Frequently asked questions

How do you qualify a legal enquiry?

Ask a few natural triage questions about what has happened, any dates, who will decide, how the matter will be funded and how the person found the firm. Use the answers to choose the next step, not to turn people away.

Is it appropriate to ask about funding on the first call?

Yes, if asked neutrally. Explaining how the firm usually charges and asking whether the person has insurance, union cover or plans to self-fund is helpful to both sides.

What are the strongest signs an enquirer will instruct?

A concrete event that has already happened, a near deadline, the caller being the decision-maker, a clear funding route and a referral or previous relationship with the firm.

Should low-scoring enquiries be declined?

No. Low scores should get a lighter next step, such as an information pack or a later appointment. Any safety issue, vulnerability or hard deadline should go to a solicitor regardless of score.

References

  1. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Board (2021). Small business legal needs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo