Key takeaways
- You must not act where there is an own interest conflict, or a significant risk of one. There is no exception[1].
- For client conflicts there are only two exceptions, substantially common interest and competing for the same objective, and the second needs written informed consent and safeguards[1].
- In an SRA thematic review, conflict checks had not been done on 28 of 50 client files[2].
- Run the conflict search at first contact, before the caller shares confidential details, and record the result.
Why conflicts still trip up good firms
Most solicitors can recite the basic rule: do not act for two clients whose interests conflict. Conflicts still cause regulatory trouble because the risk usually arises in ordinary, busy moments. A caller describes a dispute with a neighbour who turns out to be an existing client. A partner's spouse is a director of the company on the other side. A referral arrangement gives the firm a financial reason to prefer one outcome. In each case the problem is not ignorance of the rule, but the absence of a reliable check at the right time.
The evidence suggests the check is often missing. In the SRA's 2025 thematic review of high-volume consumer claims firms, conflict checks had not been carried out on 28 of the 50 client files reviewed[2]. Clients notice the consequences. In the 2026 Legal Services Consumer Panel tracker, 76% of consumers said they trust lawyers to tell the truth, compared with 86% for doctors[3]. Handling conflicts well is one of the most direct ways to protect that trust. When it goes wrong, clients complain: the Legal Ombudsman received 14,259 new complaints in 2025/26, up 37% on the year before[4], and a client who discovers that their firm also acted for the other side is unlikely to be forgiving.
The two kinds of conflict
The SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors deals with conflicts in paragraphs 6.1 and 6.2. They cover two different situations, and the rules differ sharply.
An own interest conflict arises where your duty to act in the client's best interests conflicts, or there is a significant risk that it may conflict, with your own interests. Paragraph 6.1 says you do not act if there is an own interest conflict or a significant risk of such a conflict[1]. There are no exceptions and client consent does not cure it. Typical examples include a financial interest in the outcome, a close personal relationship with someone on the other side, a referral or funding arrangement that rewards a particular result, or a dispute in which the firm itself may have been at fault.
A client conflict arises where you owe separate duties to act in the best interests of two or more clients in the same or a related matter, and those duties conflict, or there is a significant risk they may. Paragraph 6.2 says you do not act in relation to the matter, or the particular aspect of it, unless one of two exceptions applies[1].
The two exceptions for client conflicts
The first exception applies where the clients have a substantially common interest in relation to the matter or the relevant aspect of it[1]. Think of business partners setting up a company together on agreed terms, where their shared aim clearly outweighs any differences. The second applies where the clients are competing for the same objective, such as two bidders for the same asset[1]. That exception only applies if all of three conditions are met[1]:
- all the clients have given informed consent, given or evidenced in writing, to you acting;
- where appropriate, you have put in place effective safeguards to protect each client's confidential information;
- you are satisfied it is reasonable for you to act for all the clients.
Both exceptions are narrow and both require judgement. Record why you think an exception applies, who decided and what safeguards are in place. If circumstances change, for example the common interest breaks down during a business sale, revisit the decision straight away. Acting under an exception is a continuing judgement, not a one-off permission.
Scenarios and answers
| Scenario | Type | Usual answer |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer and seller of a house ask the same firm to act | Client conflict | Generally decline one side; neither exception fits a typical sale |
| Two founders want the firm to draft a shareholders' agreement on agreed terms | Client conflict risk | Possible under substantially common interest; record the basis and watch for divergence |
| Two clients bid for the same business | Client conflict | Possible only with written informed consent, safeguards and reasonableness |
| Caller's dispute is with a current client of the firm | Client conflict | Decline the new matter; do not take confidential details |
| Partner's spouse is a director of the opposing company | Own interest conflict risk | Assess the significance; if significant, do not act |
| Firm receives payments from a referrer whose interests differ from the client's | Own interest conflict risk | Assess independently; disclose; do not act if the risk is significant |
These are starting points, not answers. Each depends on the facts, and the guidance your firm writes for fee earners should include its own worked examples from the work you actually do.
Own interest conflicts in funding and referrals
The SRA's consumer claims review shows how own interest conflicts can hide inside a business model. It found arrangements in which a referrer could receive up to 50% of a client's damages, and files on which clients were not told about a referrer's financial interest[2]. It recommended that firms assess funding and referral arrangements independently, including any own interest conflict, and act in clients' best interests[2].
Any firm that pays for referrals, receives commissions or relies on a single funder should ask a simple question: does this arrangement give us a reason to advise the client differently from how we would otherwise advise them? If the honest answer is yes, or maybe, the arrangement needs to be restructured, disclosed and monitored, or the firm should not act.
A conflict check at first contact
Take names, not facts
At first contact, collect the caller's name, the other party's name, any related parties and the matter type. Ask the caller not to share the details of the problem yet.
Search the database
Search clients, former clients, opponents and related parties, including spelling variants and company names.
Ask about personal interests
Check whether anyone in the firm has a personal or financial connection with the parties.
Decide
A supervisor decides: clear, clear with an exception and safeguards, or decline. Record the reason.
Tell the caller
If declining, say only that the firm cannot act and suggest they seek advice elsewhere promptly, especially if a deadline may apply.
Repeat when parties change
Run the search again whenever a new party joins the matter.
Front-office staff and intake tools need clear instructions here. If an AI employee such as Ava answers first calls, it can collect the other side's name using the firm's approved questions so the team can run its own conflict search before anyone gives advice. The decision itself always stays with the firm.
Training the people who take first contact
Conflict checks fail most often at the very start, when a caller is keen to explain the problem and the person answering wants to be helpful. If the caller shares sensitive details before the search is run, and the firm then finds it acts for the other side, it holds confidential information it cannot use and must protect. That can make it harder to keep acting for the existing client, and it is avoidable.
Train everyone who takes enquiries, including receptionists, secretaries and trainees covering phones, to do three things. First, take names before facts: the caller, the other party and any related people or companies. Second, explain why, in plain words: before we go into detail, we need to check we are free to act for you. Third, never give a view on the merits until the search is clear. Practise the wording, because it can feel abrupt until people have said it a few times, and include conflicts in induction and in your annual training record.
Example: a boundary dispute
Example (fictional). A caller wants advice about a boundary dispute and starts describing a fence his neighbour moved. The intake coordinator politely stops him, takes his name and the neighbour's name and says a solicitor will call back within the day. The conflict search shows the neighbour is a current private client of the firm for an unrelated will.
The supervising partner concludes that acting against a current client in a dispute would create a client conflict, with no exception available. The coordinator calls the caller back, says the firm is unable to help on this occasion and suggests he contacts another firm soon. Because no confidential details were taken, there is no confidentiality problem for either person, and the decision is recorded with the reason.
Recording conflict decisions
- the names searched, the date and the result;
- any connections found and how they were assessed;
- the decision, the person who made it and the reason;
- for exceptions, the written consent and a description of the safeguards;
- the date of any re-check when parties changed.
Conflict checks sit at the start of every file. See opening a new matter: a file-opening checklist for the full list, and requesting money on account for what comes next. Screening runs alongside the conflict search, as covered in sanctions screening for new clients.
Frequently asked questions
Can a client consent to an own interest conflict?
No. Paragraph 6.1 of the SRA Code says you do not act where there is an own interest conflict or a significant risk of one, and it has no exceptions.
Can one firm act for both buyer and seller of a house?
Usually not. A typical sale involves a client conflict, and neither the substantially common interest nor the competing for the same objective exception fits most residential transactions.
When should we run a conflict check?
At first contact, before the caller shares confidential details, and again whenever a new party joins the matter.
What does informed consent need to look like?
For the competing for the same objective exception, consent must be informed and given or evidenced in writing, after the clients understand the issues and the risks of you acting for all of them.
References
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). High-volume consumer claims thematic review (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑