Key takeaways
- The SRA minimum terms require PII to cover losses to clients and third parties caused by a cyber attack, including client money stolen from client account that the firm does not replace[1].
- They do not require cover for the firm's own losses, such as forensic costs, downtime and restoration; that is what standalone cyber cover is for[1].
- In the SRA's thematic review, £3.6m of more than £4m of stolen client money was claimed against insurance, and about £400,000 came from firms' own funds[2].
- 47% of businesses have some form of cyber insurance, rising to 55% of small and 61% of medium businesses[3].
- Check social engineering cover, incident response support, security warranties and how the policy interacts with your PII.
Two kinds of loss, two kinds of cover
A cyber incident at a law firm produces two quite different sets of losses. Third-party losses fall on clients and others: money diverted from a completion, confidential information exposed, a deadline missed because systems were down. First-party losses fall on the firm itself: forensic investigators, IT rebuilding, lost fee-earning time, notification costs, legal advice on regulatory duties and, sometimes, the cost of dealing with an extortion demand.
Professional indemnity insurance was designed for the first kind. The SRA's minimum terms and conditions require cover for losses to a client or other aggrieved third party caused by a cyber attack, and the SRA gives the example of client money stolen from a firm's client account in a cyber attack where the firm does not replace it[1]. But the minimum terms do not require cover for business losses to the firm itself, apart from certain costs of investigating and defending a claim. The SRA notes that first-party losses can be covered by a separate standalone cyber policy, but it does not mandate one[1].
Who pays for what
| Loss | PII (SRA minimum terms) | Standalone cyber policy |
|---|---|---|
| Client money stolen from client account and not replaced | Covered as a third-party loss | May also respond; check the other-insurance clause |
| Client sends money to a fraudster after a fake email from your compromised mailbox | Covered if the client has a civil liability claim against you | Often relevant for investigation and response costs |
| Forensic investigation and IT restoration | Not required | Core cover |
| Lost fees while systems are down | Not required | Business interruption cover, usually with a waiting period |
| Notifying clients and the regulator | Not required | Usually covered, with legal advice |
| Firm's own money stolen from office account | Not required | Only with social engineering or funds transfer fraud cover, often sub-limited |
| Extortion and ransom negotiation | Not required | Often covered, subject to law and insurer consent |
| Regulatory investigation costs | Not required | Often covered; fines only where insurable |
What losses look like in practice
The SRA's cyber security thematic review gives a sense of scale. Of the 30 firms it visited that had been targeted, 23 cases saw a total of more than £4m of client money stolen. Of that, £3.6m was claimed against insurance and about £400,000 was repaid from firms' own money[2]. The review also described a firm that lost around £150,000 of billable time after a ransomware attack[2], a first-party loss that PII would not have covered.
For a small firm, that kind of loss can be existential. 58% of legal activities enterprises have annual turnover below £250,000[4], and 78% employ four people or fewer[5]. A single week of lost fee earning, a forensic bill and the cost of notifying clients can exceed a year's profit.
How many businesses buy it
Almost half of businesses, 47%, have some form of cyber insurance, rising to 55% of small businesses and 61% of medium businesses[3]. Having a policy is only half the story: among insured businesses, 51% included informing their cyber insurer among their incident response steps[3], which suggests many would not call the insurer early enough to use its response services.
Source: GOV.UK (DSIT and Home Office), 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| All businesses | 47% |
| Small businesses | 55% |
| Medium businesses | 61% |
What to look for in a policy
- A 24-hour incident response line with access to forensic, legal and communications specialists from the first hour, ideally without eating into the main limit.
- First-party cover for investigation, data and system restoration, notification and business interruption, with a waiting period you can live with.
- Social engineering and funds transfer fraud cover for the firm's own money, and a clear statement of the sub-limit. This is the area where policies differ most.
- Extortion cover, subject to legal and sanctions checks.
- Regulatory cover for investigations by the data protection regulator and the costs of responding to the SRA.
- A clear other-insurance clause explaining how the policy sits alongside PII, so the two insurers do not argue while the client waits.
- Security conditions you can meet, such as multi-factor authentication, backups and patching, and an honest record of how you meet them.
- Cover for incidents at your IT provider or cloud suppliers that affect you.
Proposal forms are increasingly detailed: do you enforce multi-factor authentication for all users and remote access, are backups offline, do you train staff? Answer accurately. A wrong answer can give the insurer grounds to refuse a claim when you need it most.
Sizing the cover
Map your peak exposure
Look at the highest client account balance on a busy completion day and the largest single payments you handle.
Estimate downtime cost
Work out lost fees per day if every system went down, and how many days a full rebuild would take.
Count the records
Estimate how many clients and third parties you would need to notify after a serious breach.
Check what PII already covers
Ask your broker to set out where your PII and any cyber policy overlap or leave gaps, in writing.
Use certification and controls
Cyber Essentials and documented controls can improve terms; see Cyber Essentials certification.
Review annually
Revisit the limits when you add a practice area, take on more conveyancing or change IT providers.
Questions to ask your broker
Brokers who specialise in law firms will have seen these questions before, and their answers tell you a lot about the policy and about the broker. Ask for the answers in writing:
- If a client pays a fraudster after a fake email that appears to come from us, which policy responds, and in what order?
- If our own office account money is diverted, what is the sub-limit, and does it apply if the fraud started with a phone call rather than an email?
- Does the policy cover incidents that start at our IT provider, case management supplier or cloud host?
- What security conditions or warranties apply, and what happens if one control was not in place on the day of the incident?
- Are incident response costs inside or outside the main limit, and is there an excess for using the insurer's panel?
- How long is the waiting period before business interruption cover starts, and how are lost fees calculated for a law firm?
- Is there cover for responding to a data protection regulator investigation and to the SRA?
- What is the retroactive date, and are we covered for an intrusion that began before inception but was discovered after?
Compare at least two quotes on these answers rather than on premium alone. The cheapest policy is often the one with the lowest social engineering sub-limit and the strictest warranties, which are exactly the areas where law firms most often need to claim.
Keeping the cover valid between renewals
A policy is only as good as the facts it was written on. If you told the insurer that multi-factor authentication is enforced everywhere, a new remote access tool set up without it can create a gap. Keep a short note of what you declared on the proposal form, give it to your IT provider, and ask them to tell the practice manager before making any change that would make an answer untrue. At renewal, update the answers from evidence, such as enrolment reports and backup test results, rather than from memory.
Tell the insurer about material changes during the year as the policy requires, such as a merger, a new office, a move into higher-risk work or a change of IT provider. A short email to the broker at the time is far easier than explaining the change after a claim.
Making a claim work
Most policies expect you to call their incident line as soon as you suspect an incident, and to use their approved responders. Calling your own IT provider first is natural, but agree in advance that they will join the insurer's process rather than work around it. Keep an incident log from the first minute, do not admit liability to clients before speaking to your insurers, and notify your PII insurer of circumstances that could give rise to a claim, following the policy's notice terms. Pair the policy with a written ransomware response plan so that the first hour is not spent hunting for numbers.
Example: a fictional 12-person firm's accounts mailbox is compromised and a payment of the firm's own money to a supplier is diverted. Its PII does not respond, because there is no third-party loss. Its cyber policy includes funds transfer fraud cover, but with a sub-limit well below the loss. At renewal the firm increases that sub-limit, adds a call-back rule for supplier bank changes and enforces multi-factor authentication on every mailbox, which also improves its proposal form answers.
Cyber cover is a backstop, not a strategy. The controls in cyber security basics and hybrid working security reduce the chance of needing it, and the procedures in secure email and file sharing reduce the size of any claim.
Frequently asked questions
Does our PII cover cyber incidents?
It must cover third-party losses caused by a cyber attack, including client money stolen from client account that you do not replace. It does not have to cover your own losses, such as forensic costs, restoration and lost fees.
Is standalone cyber insurance compulsory for solicitors?
No. The SRA does not mandate it, but many firms buy it to cover first-party losses and to get access to specialist incident response.
Will cyber insurance pay a ransom?
Some policies cover extortion costs, subject to the insurer's consent, sanctions checks and the law. Many firms with good backups never need to consider payment.
What happens if PII and cyber policies both respond?
The policies' other-insurance clauses decide which pays first. Ask your broker to explain the interaction before an incident, not during one.
References
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2021). Professional indemnity insurance: questions and answers (cyber cover) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2020). Cyber security: a thematic review (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (DSIT and Home Office) (2026). Cyber security breaches survey 2025/2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). UK business: activity, size and location, 2026 (legal activities by turnover) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). UK business: activity, size and location, 2026 (legal activities by employment size) (opens in a new tab) ↑