Practice area operations

Data breach compensation claim enquiries: screening

How to screen data breach compensation enquiries after Farley v Equiniti: what UK GDPR allows, the evidence that matters, economics and conduct rules.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why these enquiries need careful screening
  2. What the case law now says
  3. First-call screening questions
  4. Strong and weak indicators
  5. Groups, employees and repeat callers
  6. Complain to the controller first
  7. The economics of a data claim
  8. Worked example: two callers, one breach
  9. Conduct rules and your own data
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • UK GDPR gives a right to compensation for material or non-material damage caused by an infringement[1].
  • The Court of Appeal in Farley v Equiniti rejected restrictive thresholds, but fears must be well-founded, not speculative[2].
  • In Farley, 14 of 432 claimants showed that unauthorised people had opened their statements: evidence of exposure matters[2].
  • Organisations must now run a process for data protection complaints, so a complaint to the controller is a sensible first step[3].
  • Screen for exposure, harm and causation on the first call, and be candid about value against cost.

Why these enquiries need careful screening

Data breach enquiries arrive in waves. A company sends notification letters to thousands of customers, a news story follows, and people start searching for compensation. Some have suffered real harm: fraud, harassment, or serious and lasting distress. Many have received a letter and are worried but have not been affected in any measurable way. A firm that takes every enquiry will spend heavily on low-value cases; a firm that dismisses them all will miss the strong ones.

The law gives a clear starting point. Under Article 82 of UK GDPR, any person who has suffered material or non-material damage as a result of an infringement has the right to receive compensation from the controller or processor[1]. The question for intake is whether the caller can show damage, caused by the infringement, worth pursuing.

What the case law now says

Two appellate decisions frame the screening. In Lloyd v Google, the Supreme Court in 2021 rejected the idea that everyone affected by a data protection breach could recover a uniform sum for 'loss of control' of their data without showing what had happened to them individually. That decision under the older Data Protection Act 1998 made large opt-out representative claims for identical damages very difficult.

The Court of Appeal returned to the question in Farley v Paymaster (1836) Ltd, trading as Equiniti, in August 2025. More than 750 annual pension benefit statements had been sent to out-of-date addresses, and 432 claimants sued[2]. The court allowed compensation for non-material damage, including distress, without what it saw as unjustly restrictive thresholds, but held that fears of misuse must be well-founded rather than hypothetical or speculative, judged on the objective facts at the time[2]. Parts of the case were sent back to the High Court[2].

Farley v Equiniti: claimants and evidence of exposure
Farley v Equiniti: claimants and evidence of exposureComparison. All claimants: 432 claimants; Showed a third party opened their statement: 14 claimants.432 claimantsAll claimantsAll claimants: 432 claimants14 claimantsShowed a third party opened their statementShowed a third party opened their statement: 14 claimantsFarley v Equiniti: claimants and evidence of exposureComparison. All claimants: 432 claimants; Showed a third party opened their statement: 14 claimants.432 claimantsAll claimantsAll claimants: 432 claimants14 claimantsShowed a third party opened theirstatementShowed a third party opened their statement: 14 claimants

Source: Solicitors Journal, 2025[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
All claimants432 claimants
Showed a third party opened their statement14 claimants

The practical lesson: the claim is no longer blocked just because the harm seems small, but each claimant still needs a credible account of exposure and its effect on them. In Farley only 14 claimants could show that unauthorised people had opened their statements[2]. Intake should find out which group a caller is in.

First-call screening questions

  1. Who told you about the breach, and when? Do you have the notification letter or email?
  2. What information was involved: name and address only, or financial, health, identity or account details?
  3. Do you know whether anyone actually saw or used your information?
  4. Has anything happened since: fraud attempts, unusual contact, account changes or financial loss?
  5. How has it affected you: worry, sleep, time spent protecting accounts, medical or counselling support?
  6. Have you complained to the organisation, and did they reply?
  7. Have you contacted any other firm or claims company about this breach?

Do not suggest symptoms. Ask open questions and record the caller's own words. Statements of distress that were prompted on the first call can undermine the claim later.

Strong and weak indicators

Indicators to record when screening a data breach compensation enquiry
FactorPoints to a stronger claimPoints to a weaker claim
Data involvedFinancial, health, identity documents, or sensitive personal detailsName and email address only
ExposureEvidence a third party saw or used the dataData sent to a secure system or retrieved quickly
ConsequencesFraud, harassment, financial loss, time and cost spent on protectionWorry with no change in behaviour
DistressSpecific, lasting effects, ideally with GP or counselling recordsGeneral annoyance described in passing
CausationHarm clearly follows from this breachSimilar data exposed elsewhere, or unrelated events
Controller's responseNo notification, delay or poor handling of complaintsPrompt notification and practical support offered

The controller's own conduct matters too. A controller must notify the ICO of a personal data breach without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours of becoming aware of it[4]. Ask the caller when they were told, and whether the organisation has said when it found out.

Groups, employees and repeat callers

Breach enquiries rarely come one at a time. When a large organisation writes to its customers, a firm may receive dozens of calls about the same incident in a week. Treat these as a project from the start: open a breach file that records what is known about the incident, the date of the notification, the categories of data involved and any public statements by the controller. Each individual enquiry then links to that file, and screeners can ask consistent questions.

Employees are a distinct group. A breach of HR records can expose salaries, health information, disciplinary history and bank details, and the caller may still work for the controller. Ask whether they are a current employee, whether they have raised it internally and whether there is any wider employment dispute, because that can change both the strategy and who in the firm should handle it.

Repeat callers who have been rejected by another firm or a claims company are common. Ask why, and record the answer. Sometimes the earlier decision was wrong; often it reflects a weak claim that the caller hopes someone else will take.

Complain to the controller first

The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 requires organisations to handle data protection complaints from individuals, for example by providing an electronic complaint form, and to tell them the outcome[3]. Encourage callers to use that process and keep a copy of what they send and receive. A complaint creates a dated record of the caller's concerns, may produce information about what happened to their data, and sometimes leads to an offer that resolves the matter without legal costs.

If the firm is going to act, it can draft the complaint for the client as the first step. The response often tells you more about exposure than the original notification letter did.

The economics of a data claim

Most individual data breach claims are modest in value. That does not make them worthless, but it does mean the cost of running them must be kept proportionate. Before taking a case, consider:

  • Likely value against the cost of each stage, and which court track a claim of that value would follow.
  • Whether other claimants from the same breach could be grouped efficiently, with consistent evidence gathering.
  • Whether the client has legal expenses insurance or wants to fund the work privately.
  • Whether the firm offers a conditional fee agreement for this kind of claim, and on what terms.
  • Whether the claim adds misuse of private information or breach of confidence, which can change the analysis.

Talk money early. Most consumers expect it: 63% first found out the price of their legal service through a discussion with the provider[5]. Explain how the firm would charge, what the client could realistically recover and what they might pay if the claim fails, and confirm it in writing.

Worked example: two callers, one breach

Example: a regional retailer writes to customers saying a misconfigured system exposed order details for three weeks. Two customers call the same week.

Example, continued: the first caller received the letter and is understandably annoyed, but no fraud has followed, her data was limited to her name, email and order history, and she has not changed anything about how she uses her accounts. The screener records her account, explains the complaint process[3] and sends a template complaint. The second caller's card was used fraudulently two days after the exposure window, he spent several days dealing with his bank and he has seen his GP about anxiety. The note records the dates, the bank correspondence and the GP visit, and books him with a data protection solicitor. Both callers were treated fairly; only one was taken on.

Conduct rules and your own data

Breach claims attract aggressive marketing. Solicitors must not make unsolicited approaches to members of the public, other than current or former clients, to advertise legal services[6]. Check how any referred enquiry was obtained, and keep a record on the file.

Practise what you advise. Intake notes for these claims contain the very data at issue, plus health information. Store them in the matter record, limit access and be ready to meet the same notification duty if your own systems are breached[4]. If calls arrive faster than the team can screen them, an AI Employee such as Ava can ask the screening questions above and book suitable callers in, with the decision to act left to the solicitor. For related work, see SEND and EHCP appeals, document certification and running a sustainable legal aid practice.

Frequently asked questions

Can you claim compensation for distress after a data breach?

Yes. UK GDPR gives a right to compensation for material or non-material damage caused by an infringement[1], and the Court of Appeal in Farley rejected unjustly restrictive thresholds[2].

Is worry about possible misuse enough?

Only if the fear is well-founded on the objective facts, not hypothetical or speculative[2].

Should someone complain to the organisation first?

Usually yes. Organisations must now handle data protection complaints and tell people the outcome[3].

How quickly must an organisation report a breach to the ICO?

Without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours of becoming aware of it[4].

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 82: Right to compensation and liability (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Journal (2025). Court of Appeal clarifies GDPR compensation thresholds in Farley v Equiniti (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (DSIT) (2025). Data (Use and Access) Act 2025: data protection and privacy changes (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 33: Notification of a personal data breach to the supervisory authority (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo