Key takeaways
- Bad news delivered early, by phone, with a plan, rarely becomes a complaint; bad news discovered by the client often does.
- Prepare the facts, the options and the next step before you call; never deliver bad news and improvise the plan.
- Use a simple structure: warn, tell, pause, explain, plan and confirm in writing.
- Costs news is bad news too, and the SRA expects clients to get the best possible information as the matter progresses.
Why the way you deliver bad news matters
Every matter has bad news in it somewhere: an offer lower than hoped, a hearing that went the wrong way, a completion that has slipped, a survey that has found a problem, costs that will exceed the estimate. The news itself is rarely the firm's fault. How it is delivered almost always is.
Clients judge lawyers on how clearly they explain things. Explaining things clearly ranks alongside being regulated as a factor that increases trust, each named by 91% of consumers[1]. Bad news is where that clarity is tested hardest.
When it goes wrong, it shows up in complaints. Poor communication was the largest upheld complaint type at the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26, at 25%, followed by delay and failure to progress at 19%[2]. Many of those cases involve news the client learned late, learned from someone else, or did not understand.
Before you pick up the phone
Get the facts straight
Know exactly what has happened, when and why. A call that has to be followed by "I will need to check that" loses the client's confidence.
Work out the options
Bad news without options feels like a dead end. Have at least two realistic next steps ready, with their likely cost and timescale.
Decide your recommendation
Clients usually want to know what you would do. Be ready to say it, while making clear the decision is theirs.
Choose the time
Call as soon as you have the facts and options, ideally the same day. Avoid late on Friday unless the news cannot wait, because the client then spends a weekend unable to reach you.
Check the client's circumstances
Look at the file for vulnerability, communication needs or anything else that affects how the news should be delivered.
If the news is serious and the client is vulnerable, consider whether a meeting is better than a call, and whether the client would like someone with them.
A structure for the call
- Warn: signal that the news is not good, so the client is not caught mid-sentence. 'I am afraid I have some disappointing news about the hearing.'
- Tell: say what has happened in one or two plain sentences. Do not bury it in background.
- Pause: stop talking. Let the client react, ask questions or be silent. Resist filling the silence with detail.
- Explain: once the client is ready, explain why it happened and what it means for them, without jargon.
- Plan: set out the options and your recommendation, and agree the next step and when you will speak again.
- Confirm: tell the client you will put the main points in writing today.
Example opening: 'I am calling with news about the offer, and I am afraid it is not what we hoped for. The other side has offered less than half of what we asked. I know that is disappointing. Take a moment, and then I will explain what I think it means and what we can do next.'
Words that help and words that hurt
| Instead of | Try |
|---|---|
| Unfortunately, the court was not with us on this occasion. | The judge decided against us on the main point. |
| It is what it is. | This is a setback. Here is what we can still do. |
| As I said in my letter of the 4th... | I want to make sure this is clear, so let me go through it again. |
| There is nothing more we can do. | There are two options left, and I will explain both. |
| You should have told us sooner. | Now that we know, here is how we deal with it. |
| Do not worry. | I understand this is worrying. Here is what happens next. |
Plain language matters most here. 41% of adults who used a legal adviser said communication could be improved by using plain language[3], and a client absorbing bad news has even less capacity for jargon than usual.
When bad news should be in writing first
Most bad news is best delivered by phone or in person, then confirmed in writing. There are exceptions. Some clients prefer to receive difficult information in writing so they can read it in their own time; this should be on the file from the first meeting. Some news is technical enough that the client needs to see figures or a document before discussing it. And where there is a risk of conflict, a written record may need to come first.
When writing, keep the same structure: say the news in the first paragraph, explain it, set out the options, and offer a call at a set time. Do not send a letter late on a Friday or immediately before a holiday.
Bad news about costs
Costs news is the bad news firms most often delay, and the delay makes it worse. The SRA Code of Conduct requires clients to receive the best possible information about how their matter will be priced, both at engagement and as the matter progresses[4]. A client who learns of a large increase from the final bill will feel misled however reasonable the extra work was.
- Raise it as soon as you know the estimate will be exceeded, before the extra work is done where possible.
- Explain what has changed and why, in plain terms.
- Give a revised estimate and what it depends on.
- Offer choices where they exist, such as a narrower scope or a staged approach.
- Confirm in writing and get the client's agreement to proceed.
Following up
Send the written summary the same day: what happened, what it means, the options discussed, what the client decided or is considering, and the next step with a date. Then call again when you said you would. Clients who have had bad news often think of their most important questions a day or two later.
Research for the Legal Services Consumer Panel found communication with many clients was reactive, with clients having to chase for updates[5]. After bad news, being proactive matters more than ever. A short check-in call a week later is often remembered long after the details of the case are forgotten.
Bad news at court or in a meeting
Some bad news arrives with the client sitting next to you: a judgment at the end of a hearing, a refusal at a mediation, a revelation in the other side's evidence. There is no time to prepare, so use the same structure in a shortened form. Find a private space if you can, tell the client plainly what has happened, give them a moment, and then explain the immediate next step, even if that is only 'we will talk through the options tomorrow morning'.
Do not try to give full advice in a corridor. Agree a time to speak properly, usually within a day, and send a short note of what happened that evening so the client has something to read when the shock wears off.
Looking after yourself and the team
Delivering bad news is hard on the person delivering it, especially in family, personal injury and private client work. Junior fee earners should not deliver serious bad news alone for the first time. Let them listen to a supervisor's call first, then make the call with the supervisor present, then on their own with a debrief afterwards. Building that into training costs little and protects both the client and the lawyer.
Example: a completion that will not happen on Friday
Example: on a Wednesday afternoon, a fictional conveyancer learns that the buyer at the bottom of her client's chain has lost their mortgage offer. Completion on Friday will not happen. She checks the facts with the other solicitors, works out two options, and calls her client within the hour.
She warns, tells, pauses, then explains the options: wait for the buyer to secure a new offer, likely to take two to four weeks, or consider remarketing. She recommends waiting a week before deciding, explains the costs position, and agrees to call again on Monday. She sends a summary email that evening. The client is upset about the removals booking but later describes the firm as honest and on top of things.
For sensitive matters, see supporting bereaved clients and supporting clients through divorce and separation. For the rhythm that keeps bad news from being a surprise, see client service charters.
Frequently asked questions
Should bad news be given by phone or email?
Usually by phone or in person first, then confirmed in writing the same day. Use writing first only where the client prefers it or needs to see figures before discussing them.
How quickly should a solicitor tell a client bad news?
As soon as you have the facts and the options, ideally the same day. Delay almost always makes the conversation harder.
What if the client blames the firm?
Listen, acknowledge their frustration and stick to the facts. If they raise a complaint, handle it under the complaints procedure.
References
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2025). Service Delivery Research Report (M·E·L Research for the LSCP) (opens in a new tab) ↑