Enquiry handling

Enquiry handling audit: a 30-point checklist

A printable 30-point enquiry handling audit for solicitors firms: phones, web forms, email, follow-up, compliance, reviews and reporting, with scoring.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. How to run the audit
  2. Phones: points 1 to 6
  3. Website and forms: points 7 to 12
  4. Email and written replies: points 13 to 17
  5. Follow-up and handover: points 18 to 22
  6. Compliance and trust: points 23 to 27
  7. Reporting and improvement: points 28 to 30
  8. What first audits usually find
  9. Scoring and what to do with it
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Audit from the outside in: test what a prospective client experiences before reading policies.
  • Score each point as met, partly met or not met, with evidence, so the next audit can be compared.
  • The compliance points are not optional: SRA badge, complaints procedure and published prices are required for many firms.
  • Fix the three lowest-scoring points first, give each an owner and a date, and re-audit in six months.

How to run the audit

An enquiry handling audit checks the whole route a new client takes, from the first search to a booked consultation or a recorded decline. It is most useful done twice a year by someone who does not handle enquiries day to day, such as a partner or the compliance officer, with a colleague acting as a test enquirer. Allow half a day: a couple of hours for testing, an hour for reading the enquiry log and an hour to score and agree actions.

  1. Test first

    Before reading any policy, make test calls, submit test forms and send test emails, during and outside office hours. Note exactly what happened.

  2. Read the log

    Pull the last month's enquiry records and check a sample of twenty against the points below: source, response time, outcome and reason.

  3. Check the website

    Work through the compliance points on a phone, as a stranger would.

  4. Score with evidence

    Mark each point met, partly met or not met, with a one-line note of the evidence.

  5. Agree actions

    Pick the three weakest points, name an owner for each and set a date. Re-audit in six months.

Phones: points 1 to 6

  1. New-client calls are answered within the firm's own standard during opening hours, tested at least three times, including at lunchtime.
  2. The greeting gives the firm's name and the person's name clearly and at a calm pace.
  3. The person answering can say within a minute whether the firm handles the caller's type of matter.
  4. Missed calls from unknown numbers are returned the same working day, and someone owns the list.
  5. Voicemail and out-of-hours messages give opening hours, an urgent route and a realistic callback time.
  6. Transfers never go to an unanswered extension; if the fee earner is unavailable, the call comes back to reception with a message taken.

Website and forms: points 7 to 12

  1. The phone number is visible without scrolling on every page and starts a call when tapped on a phone.
  2. Each main service has its own page written around the client's situation, with a named person responsible.
  3. Enquiry forms ask only for what is needed to route the enquiry and run a conflict check, plus an optional free-text box.
  4. Forms ask about upcoming dates such as hearings, completions or deadlines.
  5. The page after submission, and the acknowledgement email, say who will reply and by when.
  6. Every form submission lands in the enquiry log automatically, not in a personal inbox.

Email and written replies: points 13 to 17

  1. The automatic acknowledgement says it is automatic, gives a reply time and an urgent route, and comes from a monitored address.
  2. Human first responses are sent within the published standard, measured from receipt, not from when someone opened the message.
  3. First responses are signed by a named person with a direct line and contain a specific next step.
  4. First responses link to published price and service information where it exists, and explain the fee basis otherwise.
  5. Decline emails are sent promptly, signpost somewhere useful and make clear the firm has not reviewed the merits or agreed to act.

Follow-up and handover: points 18 to 22

  1. Every promised callback has an owner, a time window and a recorded outcome, in one place the team can see.
  2. Unbooked enquiries receive a fixed number of follow-ups on a written schedule, and then a recorded close.
  3. Conflict searches are run before any consultation is confirmed, including on the other party.
  4. Fee earners receive a complete note before the first meeting: facts, dates, adjustments needed and how the client found the firm.
  5. Third-party callers and possible vulnerability are flagged on the record, with the adjustment or authority needed.

Compliance and trust: points 23 to 27

These points are partly regulatory. SRA-authorised firms must display their SRA number and the SRA digital badge prominently on their website, publish their complaints procedure including how and when a complaint can be made to the Legal Ombudsman and the SRA, and, for services covered by the Transparency Rules, publish price and service information[1]. Solicitors must also tell clients in writing at the time of engagement about their right to complain[2]. Many consumers still do not know how to complain: only 51% said they would know how, 27% were uncertain and 22% said they would not[3].

Would consumers know how to complain about a legal service? 2026
Would consumers know how to complain about a legal service? 2026Donut chart. Would know how: 51%; Uncertain: 27%; Would not know how: 22%.Would know how: 51%Uncertain: 27%Would not know how: 22%51% would know how
  • Would know how 51%
  • Uncertain 27%
  • Would not know how 22%

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Would know how51%
Uncertain27%
Would not know how22%
  1. The SRA number and digital badge appear on every page, including on phones.
  2. The complaints procedure is published, easy to find from the footer and up to date with Legal Ombudsman details.
  3. Price and service information is published for every service the Transparency Rules cover that the firm offers, and the enquiry team knows where it is.
  4. If the firm publishes client reviews, it has a published review policy and does not write, commission or selectively solicit reviews in a misleading way.
  5. The privacy notice linked from forms describes how enquiry data is actually used and how long it is kept.

Reviews carry their own rules. Since April 2025, UK businesses that publish consumer reviews must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews, and the CMA expects a published policy that clearly prohibits fake reviews[4]. Prospective clients read them: 14% of people choosing a main adviser searched for reviews[5].

Reporting and improvement: points 28 to 30

  1. A weekly report shows enquiry volume by source and matter type, response time, booking rate and the reasons for lost enquiries.
  2. Complaints that mention first contact, delay or communication are reviewed alongside the enquiry report each quarter.
  3. Actions from the last audit were completed, and their effect is visible in the numbers.

Point 29 matters because complaint handling is itself a weak spot across the profession. In 2025/26, 46% of Legal Ombudsman investigative outcomes found unreasonable complaint handling by the provider[6]. Problems that start at first contact, such as a promise not kept or a price misunderstood, often turn into complaints that are then handled badly.

What first audits usually find

Firms auditing for the first time tend to find the same handful of gaps. None of them is expensive to fix, but each is easy to miss from the inside because the people doing the work know how things are meant to happen.

  • Lunchtime is the weakest hour on the phones, because the people who cover reception take lunch at the same time.
  • Web forms work, but the acknowledgement promises a reply time nobody is rostered to meet.
  • Missed calls are returned only when someone happens to look, and there is no record of which were returned.
  • Price pages exist for the services the Transparency Rules cover, but the enquiry team does not know where they are and quotes figures from memory.
  • Reasons for lost enquiries are blank on most records, so the firm cannot tell whether it is losing on price, speed or fit.
  • Fee earners receive a name and a number before a first meeting, with no note of dates or what the client said they wanted.

Write these down as findings rather than criticisms. The audit is about the system, and the people closest to the work usually have the best ideas for fixing it once the gap is visible.

Scoring and what to do with it

Scoring the audit
Score per pointMeaningEvidence needed
2: metWorks every time it was tested and in the log sampleTest notes and log sample
1: partly metWorks sometimes, or exists on paper but not in practiceExamples of when it worked and when it did not
0: not metDoes not exist or failed in testingTest notes

Example (fictional): a firm scores 41 out of 60 at its first audit. Its lowest areas are follow-up (points 18 and 19 both scored 0) and email (point 14 scored 0, because replies were measured from when messages were opened). It sets three actions: one callback list, a written follow-up schedule and a change to how response time is measured. Six months later, it scores 49.

Do not chase a perfect score. Use the audit to find the few changes that matter most, and pair it with the regular enquiry handling KPIs and periodic mystery shopping. To see what a full rebuild looks like in practice, read the four-partner firm example.

Frequently asked questions

How often should a law firm audit its enquiry handling?

Twice a year is enough for most firms, with lighter monthly checks through KPIs and occasional mystery shopping in between.

Who should carry out the audit?

Someone who does not handle enquiries day to day, such as a partner or the compliance officer, with a colleague acting as a test enquirer.

Which points are regulatory requirements?

Displaying the SRA number and digital badge, publishing the complaints procedure, and publishing price and service information for services covered by the SRA Transparency Rules. Review rules come from consumer law.

What should we do after the audit?

Pick the three weakest points, give each an owner and a deadline, and re-audit in six months to check the changes worked.

References

  1. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Transparency Rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo