Key takeaways
- The DMCC Act explicitly bans posting and commissioning fake reviews, and the CMA can now fine businesses up to 10% of global turnover.
- Businesses that publish reviews must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake and concealed incentivised reviews.
- For law firms the risks sit in everyday habits: staff reviews, agency packages, review swaps and filtered website widgets.
- SRA rules on accurate publicity apply on top of consumer law, so a misleading review display is a regulatory issue too.
- A short written policy, a clean request process and an annual audit are enough for most firms.
What changed in April 2025
The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCC Act) brought in a new consumer protection regime that the CMA announced as in force in April 2025. Two changes matter most to law firms. The Act includes an explicit ban on the posting and commissioning of fake reviews, and the CMA can now decide for itself whether consumer law has been broken and fine businesses up to 10% of their global turnover[1].
The CMA's guidance for businesses sets out the practical duty. Since April 2025, UK businesses that publish consumer reviews must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews[2]. Under UK consumer law, businesses must not write or commission others to write fake reviews[3]. A law firm that shows reviews on its website, quotes them in brochures or embeds a review widget is a business publishing reviews.
Who is caught: the rules apply to traders generally, not only to review platforms. A sole practitioner who asks a friend to post a review on Google is commissioning a fake review in exactly the same way as a large retailer buying reviews in bulk.
The practices that are banned
The CMA's short guide groups the problems into three kinds. Each has a law firm version that can arise without anyone intending to mislead.
- Fake reviews: reviews that do not reflect a genuine experience of the firm. Examples include staff, partners' relatives or friends posting reviews, an agency posting reviews on the firm's behalf, and reviews written with an AI tool and posted under clients' names.
- Concealed incentivised reviews: reviews given in exchange for something, where the incentive is not disclosed. Examples include a discount on the next will, a prize draw entry or a fee reduction offered for a review.
- False or misleading review information: presenting reviews in a way that gives a false impression. Examples include showing only five-star reviews while implying they are representative, suppressing negative reviews, or copying reviews from another firm or another office.
Commissioning is wider than paying. Asking a professional contact to review your firm in return for you reviewing theirs, when neither of you has been a client of the other, is a review swap and produces fake reviews on both profiles.
Why trust is the real risk
Consumers already trust lawyers less than some other professionals: 76% trust lawyers to tell the truth, compared with 86% for doctors[4]. A firm found to have faked its reputation does lasting damage not only to itself but to the profession's standing.
Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[4]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Doctors | 86% |
| Lawyers | 76% |
Regulation is what consumers value most. Being regulated was rated important by 91% of consumers when choosing a provider, the most important factor in 2026[5]. That is why the SRA overlay matters: the Code requires all publicity about your practice to be accurate and not misleading[6], so a manipulated review profile can become a conduct issue as well as a consumer law one.
Reasonable and proportionate steps for a law firm
The duty is proportionate, so a small firm is not expected to run a fraud team. It is expected to have sensible controls and to act when something looks wrong.
| Step | What to do | Evidence to keep |
|---|---|---|
| Written policy | Prohibit fake reviews and incentives; explain how you invite reviews | Policy published on the website and included in staff induction |
| Request process | Invite every client at the same stage, with no suggested wording | File note or system flag showing each request |
| Staff rules | No reviews of the firm by staff, relatives or friends | Signed acknowledgement in induction records |
| Supplier checks | Confirm marketing agencies do not post or buy reviews | Clause in the agency contract and a written confirmation |
| Display rules | Show overall rating and count with any widget or quote | Screenshot of the website display each quarter |
| Monitoring | Check new reviews for signs of fakes, including reviews about you posted by competitors | Log of reported reviews and platform responses |
The CMA says businesses that publish reviews should have a published policy that clearly prohibits fake reviews and sets out their approach to incentivised reviews[7]. For most firms the policy fits on a single page and can sit beside your complaints procedure and privacy notice.
Grey areas firms ask about
Most questions come from situations that feel harmless. A few common ones:
- A partner's sister used the firm for her will. She is a genuine client, so a review reflecting her real experience is not fake, but disclose nothing that suggests independence she does not have and do not ask relatives in preference to other clients.
- A former employee who was also a client. A review of the client experience is genuine; a review written as an employee is not a client review and should not be on your client profile.
- An agency's reputation package. If the agency posts, buys or writes reviews, you are commissioning fake reviews. If it only sends genuine invitations on your behalf, check how it selects recipients.
- Thank-you gifts after completion. A gift sent to every client regardless of reviews is not an incentive; a gift tied to leaving a review is.
- AI-drafted reviews. Offering to draft a review for a client to post, by hand or with software, turns a genuine experience into words the client did not write.
An annual review audit
List every place reviews appear
Google profiles for each office, Trustpilot, legal review sites, Facebook, your website, brochures and proposals.
Check who asked for them
Confirm that requests were sent to clients generally and that no one was selected because they were expected to be positive.
Check for staff and connected reviews
Search reviews for names of staff, relatives and known contacts, and remove any you can, or ask the author to.
Check incentives
Review any promotions, gifts or discounts in the year for links to reviews.
Check displays
Make sure widgets and quotes are accurate, dated where relevant, and show the overall rating.
Check suppliers
Get written confirmation from marketing agencies about how they handle reviews.
Record and report
Write a short note of findings for the COLP and partners, with any actions and dates.
If you find a problem
Audits sometimes uncover something uncomfortable: a handful of reviews posted by a former marketing assistant, a prize draw that was linked to reviews, or a widget that has been quietly filtering out anything below five stars. The right response is quick and documented, not defensive.
- Stop the practice immediately and tell the people involved, in writing, that it must not continue.
- Remove or ask for removal of any reviews you know to be fake or tied to an undisclosed incentive, using each platform's tools, and keep screenshots of what was removed and when.
- Correct any misleading display on your website, brochures or proposals, and check archived pages and printed material still in circulation.
- Tell your COLP, who should record the issue and consider whether it needs reporting under the firm's regulatory obligations.
- Change the process that allowed it: update the policy, the supplier contract or the staff induction, and set a date to check the change has worked.
- Brief the team on what happened and why it matters, without blaming individuals in public.
A firm that finds and fixes its own problem, with a record of what it did, is in a far stronger position than one that waits for a competitor, a journalist or a regulator to notice. Keep the audit notes with the firm's other compliance records so the history is easy to show if anyone ever asks.
Example: the agency that offered a review boost
Example (fictional): a marketing agency offers a five-partner firm in Kent a package to raise its Google rating within three months. The proposal mentions 'review seeding' and 'positive sentiment campaigns'. The practice manager asks the agency to explain in writing how reviews will be generated.
The answer reveals that the agency uses a network of accounts to post reviews for its clients. The firm declines, adds a clause to its standard supplier terms prohibiting any posting, purchase or drafting of reviews, and instead adds a review request to its file-closing checklist. Its rating rises more slowly, but every review on the profile is from a real client and the firm has nothing to worry about if the CMA or the SRA ever asks.
Frequently asked questions
What is the maximum fine for fake reviews under the DMCC Act?
Under the regime the CMA announced in April 2025, it can fine businesses up to 10% of their global turnover for breaching consumer protection law, which includes the ban on fake reviews.
Can staff leave reviews of their own law firm?
No. Reviews by staff do not reflect a genuine client experience and risk being treated as fake reviews commissioned by the firm.
Is it illegal to only show positive reviews on our website?
Presenting reviews in a way that gives a false impression of your overall rating can be false or misleading review information. Show the overall rating and the number of reviews, or link to the full profile.
Do we need a fake reviews policy?
If you publish reviews, including through a website widget, the CMA expects a published policy that prohibits fake reviews and explains your approach to incentivised reviews.
References
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). CMA to boost consumer and business confidence as new consumer protection regime comes into force (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑