Key takeaways
- Your reply is written for future clients as much as for the reviewer; calm and brief beats detailed and defensive.
- Confidentiality covers former clients too, so do not confirm someone was a client or discuss their matter in public.
- Treat every negative review from a client as a possible complaint and route it to your complaints procedure.
- Use a small set of approved templates and adapt them, rather than drafting from scratch when you are annoyed.
- Ask platforms to remove reviews only when they breach the platform's policies, not because they are unwelcome.
Who your reply is really for
When a prospective client reads a one-star review of your firm, they also read your reply. They are not judging who was right; they cannot know. They are judging how you behave under pressure, whether you take concerns seriously and whether you would treat them with respect if something went wrong. A short, courteous reply that offers to talk privately often reassures readers more than a page of five-star reviews.
A defensive reply does the opposite. Point-by-point rebuttals, sarcasm, or hints that the reviewer was difficult tell readers that the firm argues with its clients. They also risk the most serious mistake a solicitor can make in a reply: revealing something about the client's affairs.
What confidentiality means for review replies
The SRA Code of Conduct requires you to keep the affairs of current and former clients confidential unless disclosure is required or permitted by law or the client consents[1]. A public review does not amount to consent to discuss the matter. The reviewer may have described their case in detail; you still cannot.
Rule of thumb: do not confirm or deny that the reviewer was a client, and do not mention anything about their matter, its outcome, its cost, their behaviour or the advice they received. If your reply only makes sense to someone who knows the file, rewrite it.
This applies even when the review is unfair or inaccurate. Correcting the record by explaining what really happened is exactly the disclosure the Code prohibits. You can say that you do not recognise a description, that you take concerns seriously, and how the person can raise them with you. That is all.
Sorting the review before you reply
| What the review looks like | First step | Public reply |
|---|---|---|
| A client unhappy with service, cost or delay | Treat as a possible complaint; pass to the complaints partner | Acknowledge, apologise for the experience, invite them to contact the complaints partner |
| Someone you cannot identify | Check records discreetly; do not contact anyone on a guess | Say you cannot find a record matching the description and invite them to get in touch |
| The other side in a dispute | Note it; consider reporting it under the platform's conflict of interest rules | Brief, neutral reply that you act for your clients and cannot comment on any matter |
| An abusive or discriminatory post | Screenshot it and report it to the platform | Usually none until the platform decides; if you reply, keep it to one neutral line |
| A complaint about a staff member by name | Tell the staff member and their supervisor; review the file | Same as a service complaint; do not name or defend the individual publicly |
Agree a target time for replies, such as two working days. Replying within hours, while emotions are high, invites mistakes; leaving a review unanswered for weeks looks indifferent.
Reply templates you can adapt
Keep a short set of approved replies and adapt the wording each time so they do not read like a script. Each one acknowledges the reviewer, says nothing about any matter, and offers a private route.
- Service concern: 'Thank you for taking the time to share this. We are sorry to hear that your experience fell short of what you expected. We take feedback seriously and would welcome the chance to look into it. Please contact our complaints partner, [name], on [direct line or email].'
- Delay or communication: 'We are sorry you felt you were not kept informed. Clear communication matters to us, and we would like to understand what happened. Please get in touch with [name] directly so we can review this with you.'
- Cannot identify the reviewer: 'Thank you for your review. We have not been able to match your description to our records, but we would like to understand your concerns. Please contact [name] on [contact details].'
- Other side in a dispute: 'We act in the interests of our clients and are unable to comment on any matter. If you have concerns about our conduct, you can contact [name] or the Solicitors Regulation Authority.'
- After a complaint has been resolved: if the reviewer updates their review, a short 'Thank you for taking the time to update your review' is enough.
Do not include anything that confirms a retainer, such as 'we are sorry your divorce took longer than expected'. Do not mention fees, outcomes or dates. Do not invite the reviewer to remove the review in exchange for anything.
Words to avoid in a reply
Most confidentiality slips in review replies come from a single phrase written in good faith. Before posting, read the reply aloud and check it against this list.
- Anything confirming a retainer: 'your case', 'your purchase', 'when we acted for you', 'your file'.
- Anything about timing: 'as we explained in March', 'after completion', 'once the grant was issued'.
- Anything about money: fees charged, invoices, refunds offered or settlement figures.
- Anything about the other people involved: family members, the other side, the court, HMRC or a lender.
- Anything about the reviewer's conduct: missed appointments, late documents, unpaid bills or tone on the phone.
- Anything that defends a named colleague, which implicitly confirms they handled the matter.
A reply that avoids all six is almost always safe. It will feel unsatisfying to the person who handled the matter, which is a good reason why someone other than that fee earner should approve it.
Connecting reviews to your complaints procedure
Many negative reviews are complaints that have not been made through the proper channel. Only 51% of consumers said they would know how to complain about a legal service, with 27% uncertain and 22% saying they would not[2]. A public review is often what people do when they do not know what else to do.
- Would know how 51%
- Uncertain 27%
- Would not know 22%
Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Would know how | 51% |
| Uncertain | 27% |
| Would not know | 22% |
Your obligations do not change because the complaint arrived by review. The SRA Code requires complaints to be dealt with promptly, fairly and free of charge[3], and requires you to tell clients in writing at engagement about their right to complain and to inform them in writing if a complaint is not resolved within 8 weeks[4]. If the reviewer is a client and contacts you, log it as a complaint and follow your procedure, including the information about the Legal Ombudsman.
Look for patterns. Poor communication (24%) and delay or failure to progress (22%) were the most common complaint types brought to the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26[5]. If your negative reviews cluster around the same themes, the fix is in your service, not in your replies.
When to ask for a review to be removed
Platforms remove reviews that breach their own policies, not reviews that are negative or that you believe are unfair. Common grounds include reviews from people who were never customers, spam, offensive or discriminatory content, conflicts of interest such as a review from an opponent, and personal information about staff. Use the platform's reporting tool, explain the policy breach briefly without disclosing client information, and keep a record of what you reported and when.
If a review appears seriously defamatory, take advice before acting. Threatening a reviewer, especially a former client, can turn a single review into a much more visible dispute.
A simple process for the firm
Alert
Review alerts go to the marketing lead and the complaints partner, not to the fee earner involved.
Assess
Within one working day, decide which category the review falls into and whether it is a possible complaint.
Draft
Adapt an approved template; a second person checks it for any confidential detail before posting.
Reply
Post the reply within the agreed target time.
Follow up
If the reviewer contacts you, handle it under the complaints procedure and record the outcome.
Learn
Each quarter, review themes from negative reviews and complaints together and agree one service change.
Example: a review after a probate matter
Example (fictional): a one-star review says the firm took far too long to deal with an estate and never returned calls, and names the solicitor. The fee earner wants to reply explaining that the delay was caused by HMRC and a missing beneficiary.
The complaints partner explains that any such explanation would disclose the client's affairs. Instead the firm posts: 'Thank you for your feedback. We are sorry to read about your experience and would like to understand your concerns properly. Please contact our complaints partner directly on the number on our website.' The reviewer calls, the matter is handled as a complaint, the firm apologises for poor updates and agrees a fortnightly call. The reviewer later edits the review to three stars and mentions that the firm listened.
Frequently asked questions
Should a solicitor reply to every negative review?
Yes, in most cases, with a short, courteous reply that offers a private route. Abusive or spam reviews may be better reported to the platform first.
Can we explain our side of the story in a reply?
No. Explaining what happened on the file would disclose confidential information about a current or former client, even if the reviewer has described it publicly.
Is a negative review a formal complaint?
Not automatically, but treat it as a possible complaint. If the reviewer is a client and gets in touch, handle it under your complaints procedure.
Can we ask a client to remove a review after resolving their complaint?
You can let them know the issue has been resolved, but do not make any resolution conditional on removing or changing a review.
References
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (paragraph 6.3, confidentiality) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑