Marketing and reputation

In-house marketer vs agency for law firms

Cost, control and skills compared: when a UK solicitors firm should hire an in-house marketer, use an agency or combine both, with a worked cost example.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The question behind the question
  2. What each model does well
  3. The true cost of an in-house hire
  4. When in-house is the better choice
  5. When an agency is the better choice
  6. If you hire: the skills that matter in a law firm
  7. The hybrid model most firms end up with
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References

Key takeaways

  • Most legal businesses are small: 78% of UK legal activities enterprises employed four people or fewer in 2026, which shapes what marketing model is affordable[1].
  • An employee costs more than salary: employer National Insurance is 15% on earnings above £5,000 a year in 2026/27, though the Employment Allowance can cut the bill by up to £10,500[2].
  • In-house staff win on firm knowledge, speed of sign-off and enquiry follow-through; agencies win on specialist skills and scale.
  • For many firms the best model is hybrid: one in-house coordinator who owns the plan and the data, with specialist agencies for search or paid advertising.
  • Decide on the work you need done, not on the job title, and compare total cost per year against what each model would deliver.

The question behind the question

Partners rarely ask 'in-house or agency?' in the abstract. They ask it when marketing has stalled: the website is tired, enquiries have dipped, or the one person who used to post on LinkedIn has left. The useful first step is to list the work that needs doing over the next year, then decide who is best placed to do each part. The job title comes last.

Firm size sets the boundaries. In 2026, 78% of UK legal activities enterprises employed between zero and four people, and a further 5,310 employed five to nineteen[1]. Many firms are also modest in turnover: 58% of legal activities enterprises had annual turnover below £250,000[1]. For most of them a full marketing department is out of reach, and the real choice is between a part-time or junior in-house role, an agency, or a mix.

UK legal activities enterprises employing 0 to 4 people, 2026ONS UK business: activity, size and location, 2026
UK legal activities enterprises employing 0 to 4 people, 2026Donut chart. Employing 0 to 4 people: 78%.Employing 0 to 4 people: 78%78%
  • Employing 0 to 4 people 78%

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Employing 0 to 4 people78%

What each model does well

In-house marketer and agency compared for a solicitors firm
FactorIn-house marketerAgency
Knowledge of the firmDeep: knows fee earners, clients and prioritiesLearns over months; depends on briefings
Speed of sign-offFast; can walk to a partner's deskSlower; changes go through account managers
Specialist skillsUsually a generalistAccess to search, paid media, design and analytics specialists
CapacityFixed hours; holidays and sickness create gapsCan scale up for a launch or campaign
Enquiry follow-throughCan check what happened to leads and fix intakeRarely sees beyond the form submission
Cost structureSalary plus on-costs, ongoingMonthly retainer or project fees, can be paused
Continuity riskKnowledge leaves when the person doesKnowledge sits with the agency, so ownership terms matter

The row firms most often underrate is enquiry follow-through. Marketing that produces enquiries which then wait two days for a callback is wasted spend, and an agency cannot see that happening. An in-house person can sit with reception, read the enquiry log and fix the handover between marketing and fee earners.

The true cost of an in-house hire

The salary is only the start. Employers pay Class 1 secondary National Insurance at 15% on earnings above the £5,000-a-year secondary threshold in 2026/27[2]. Eligible employers can reduce their National Insurance bill by up to £10,500 a year through the Employment Allowance[2], which for a small firm may absorb much of the extra cost of one new hire, depending on the existing payroll. Add pension contributions, software, training, recruitment and management time.

Labour is already a large share of a law firm's costs. UK legal activities businesses spent £18.2 billion on employment costs in 2024, about 36% of turnover[3]. A marketing hire adds to that fixed base, while an agency retainer can usually be reduced or paused if the firm's income dips.

Be realistic about recruitment, too. A marketing role in a small firm is often a single-person team with no senior colleague to learn from, so experienced candidates may expect more pay or flexibility than the firm first assumes. Budget for the time it takes to recruit and settle in a new hire, often several months before the work is fully productive. An agency can usually start within weeks, which matters if the firm has a launch or a gap in its pipeline to fill.

Example (fictional) annual cost comparison; figures are illustrative, not market rates
Cost lineIn-house coordinator (Example)Agency retainer (Example)
Salary or retainer£35,000£24,000
Employer NI at 15% above £5,000£4,500 before any Employment AllowanceNone
Pension (Example 3%)£1,050None
Software and tools£2,000Usually included
Advertising spendSeparateSeparate
Management timeTwo hours a week of partner timeOne hour a week plus monthly review
Total before ad spendAbout £42,550About £24,000

Example: on paper the agency is cheaper, but the comparison is incomplete. The in-house coordinator works roughly full time on the firm, also handles newsletters, events, directories and enquiry reporting, and can brief specialist freelancers. The agency's retainer buys a fixed scope, often search and content only. Compare what each would actually deliver, not just the cost line.

When in-house is the better choice

  • The firm has several practice areas and offices that need coordinating.
  • Much of the marketing is relationship-based: events, referrers, client newsletters, directories.
  • Fee earners need someone to chase for content, reviews and case studies.
  • Enquiry handling needs fixing as much as enquiry generation.
  • The firm wants to build marketing knowledge that stays in the business.
  • There is a partner willing to manage the role and give it time.

A common mistake is hiring a junior marketer and expecting them to deliver strategy, design, search and paid advertising alone. A junior hire works well with a clear plan and specialist support; on their own they often end up producing social posts nobody reads.

When an agency is the better choice

  • The firm needs specialist skills for a defined job, such as a new website or a search campaign.
  • The firm is too small to keep one person fully occupied.
  • Work comes in bursts, such as a launch, a merger rebrand or a new office.
  • The firm wants to test a channel before committing to a hire.
  • There is a partner or practice manager who can brief the agency and approve work quickly.

Agencies need managing too. Without someone in the firm who owns the plan, checks the reports against real enquiries and approves copy within days, an agency relationship drifts. Our guide to hiring a legal marketing agency lists the questions to ask before signing.

If you hire: the skills that matter in a law firm

The best in-house marketers in solicitors firms are rarely the most creative candidates. They are organised, comfortable with regulation and persistent with busy fee earners. Legal marketing involves a lot of chasing: for a case study approval, a directory submission, a review request or a quote for the local paper. Someone who finds that frustrating will not last.

  • Writing: clear, plain English that a fee earner can approve with light edits.
  • Regulatory awareness: understands that publicity must be accurate, that prices must be published for some services and that unsolicited approaches are banned.
  • Data: can set up enquiry tracking, read analytics and produce a monthly report partners trust.
  • Website management: can update pages, check forms and spot broken tracking without calling the agency.
  • Supplier management: can brief and challenge agencies and freelancers.
  • Discretion: handles client stories and enquiry data with the same care as fee earners.

Give the role a clear reporting line to one partner or the practice manager, and a written plan for the first six months. Without both, a new marketer in a firm of busy lawyers tends to become an internal design service, producing leaflets and social posts on request rather than building a pipeline of enquiries.

The hybrid model most firms end up with

Many firms settle on a mixed approach: one in-house coordinator, sometimes part time, who owns the marketing plan, the enquiry data and the relationships with fee earners, plus one or two specialist agencies or freelancers for search, paid advertising or design. The coordinator does not need to be an expert in every channel; they need to be good at briefing, chasing and measuring.

  1. List the year's work

    Write down every marketing task for the next twelve months, from directory submissions to website updates, and estimate the hours each needs.

  2. Sort by skill and by knowledge

    Tasks that need deep firm knowledge (fee earner content, events, referrers, enquiry reporting) stay in-house. Tasks that need specialist skills (technical search, paid media, design) go to specialists.

  3. Cost each option for a full year

    Include on-costs, management time and tools, not just salary or retainer.

  4. Agree ownership of assets

    Whatever the model, the firm owns the website, domain, analytics, ad accounts and content.

  5. Set one set of numbers

    Everyone, in-house and agency, reports against the same measures: enquiries, instructions and fee income by channel.

  6. Review after six months

    Check whether the mix is delivering and change it if not. Models that suited one stage of the firm's growth may not suit the next.

AI tools are changing what one person can do. 55% of UK employees report using AI for work or education[4], and a capable coordinator can now draft, edit and analyse more than before. That strengthens the case for a single in-house owner of marketing, but it does not remove the need for legal accuracy checks or for care with client information.

Frequently asked questions

Is an in-house marketer cheaper than an agency?

Not usually on a like-for-like cost line, once employer National Insurance, pension, tools and management time are added. But an in-house person often covers more ground, so compare what each option delivers over a year.

What size of firm needs a full-time marketer?

There is no fixed threshold. Firms with several practice areas or offices, or with lots of relationship-based marketing, tend to benefit first. Smaller firms often start with a part-time coordinator or an agency.

Can a fee earner run marketing part time?

They can own the plan and the relationships, but billable time is expensive and easily squeezed. Many firms pair a fee earner sponsor with a coordinator or agency who does the work.

What should we keep in-house whatever we choose?

Ownership of the website and accounts, sign-off of all copy, the enquiry data and relationships with referrers and fee earners.

References

  1. Office for National Statistics (2026). UK business: activity, size and location, 2026 (Tables 2, 4, 9 and 17) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (HMRC) (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (2024). Non-financial business economy, UK: Sections A to S (Annual Business Survey), Table 16 Section M (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Artificial intelligence in UK businesses: 2023 to 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo