Marketing and reputation

Hiring a legal marketing agency: questions to ask

The questions UK solicitors should put to a marketing agency before signing: SRA and PECR compliance, reporting, ownership, contract terms and red flags.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Before you speak to any agency
  2. Questions about legal sector knowledge
  3. Questions about compliance and data
  4. Questions about reporting and results
  5. Questions about the website itself
  6. Contract terms to check before signing
  7. Scoring the shortlist
  8. Red flags in agency pitches
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • Your firm, not the agency, is responsible for every advert and page: SRA rules require publicity to be accurate and not misleading[1].
  • Ask how the agency handles PECR: a direct marketing breach can occur even if the message never reached the person, and fines now align with data protection law[2].
  • Insist that the firm owns the website, domain, analytics, ad accounts and content, with admin access from day one.
  • Only 56% of consumers found information on indemnity insurance and the right to complain easy to locate, so ask agencies how they will handle regulatory information, not just design[3].
  • Score agencies against written criteria and agree a short initial term with clear reporting before any long contract.

Before you speak to any agency

Most poor agency relationships start with an unclear brief. A firm says it wants 'more enquiries' and the agency delivers more enquiries, many of them for work the firm does not want, at prices it would not charge. Before the first meeting, write down three things: which practice areas you want to grow, roughly how many extra instructions a month would make the spend worthwhile, and how your team will handle the extra enquiries.

Then decide what you are buying. Some agencies do everything from websites to paid advertising; others specialise in search, content or paid social. A specialist is often better at one job; a generalist saves you managing several suppliers. Neither is wrong, but you should know which you want before proposals start arriving, because each will argue that its model is the right one.

  • Practice areas and locations to target, in order of priority.
  • Work you do not want, so the agency can exclude it.
  • Current numbers: enquiries per month, conversion rate, average fee by work type.
  • Who in the firm will approve copy and adverts, and how quickly.
  • Who owns the website, domain, analytics and advertising accounts today.
  1. Which solicitors firms do you work with now, and may we speak to two of them?
  2. How do you make sure adverts and pages comply with the SRA Code of Conduct and Transparency Rules?
  3. What do you know about the SRA ban on unsolicited approaches, and how does it affect outreach you might suggest?
  4. How do you handle published price and service information on practice area pages?
  5. Who writes legal content, and who checks it for legal accuracy before it goes live?
  6. How do you approach reviews, given CMA rules on fake and incentivised reviews?

The answers should be specific. Under the SRA Code, any publicity about a practice, including about charges, must be accurate and not misleading[1], and solicitors must not make unsolicited approaches to members of the public to advertise legal services[1]. An agency that suggests buying lists for cold calls, or writing ads that promise outcomes, has not understood the sector, however good its case studies look.

Reviews are a common weak point. Businesses that publish consumer reviews should have a published policy clearly prohibiting fake reviews and setting out their approach to incentivised reviews[4]. Ask the agency to show you the review policy it would put in place, and how it would ask clients for reviews without offering anything in return.

Questions about compliance and data

Agencies that run email, text or retargeting campaigns are processing personal data on your behalf, and the regulatory risk lands on the firm. The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 makes clear that a PECR direct marketing breach can occur even if the call or message never reached the intended recipient, and it aligns PECR fines with the Data Protection Act 2018[2].

  • Will you sign a data processing agreement, and where is our data stored?
  • What consent records will you keep for email and text marketing lists?
  • Which tracking tags and cookies will you add to our site, and how will consent be handled?
  • Do you use AI tools to produce content or analyse data, and does any client or enquiry information go into them?
  • Who at the agency can access our enquiry forms, call recordings or CRM?
  • What happens to our data when the contract ends?

The AI question matters more than it used to. The Legal Ombudsman warns that not all free AI tools are secure or keep what users type confidential[5]. If an agency drafts content with AI tools, ask what checks it applies, and make sure no enquiry details or client information are pasted into them.

Questions about reporting and results

Reporting tells you whether the money is working, and agencies differ widely in what they are willing to be measured on. Many prefer metrics they control, such as rankings, impressions and clicks. The firm needs metrics that connect to fee income: enquiries by practice area, consultations booked and instructions. A good agency will accept that it cannot control your conversion rate, but it should still want to see it, because it shows which of its campaigns attract the right clients.

  • Which numbers will you report monthly, and can we see a sample report from a current solicitor client?
  • How will you count enquiries, and how will you avoid double counting calls and forms from the same person?
  • Will you use our enquiry log or practice management data to report instructions by source?
  • What would make you recommend reducing our spend, and have you done that for another client?
  • Who attends the monthly review, and how quickly will you act on what we find?

Watch how the agency answers the question about recommending lower spend. An agency that has never advised a client to spend less is selling budget, not results.

Questions about the website itself

Agencies naturally talk about design and speed. Ask them as much about the regulatory information a solicitors site must carry. SRA-authorised firms must display their SRA number and the SRA digital badge prominently on their website[6]. Consumer research shows that regulatory information is often hard to find: 74% of consumers who shopped around found cost information easy to find, but only 56% found information on professional indemnity insurance and the right to complain to an ombudsman easy to locate[3].

Consumers who found information easy to find when shopping around, 2026Legal Services Consumer Panel tracker survey
Consumers who found information easy to find when shopping around, 2026Bar chart. Cost information: 74%; Service quality information: 73%; Indemnity insurance and right to complain: 56%.Cost informationCost information: 74%74%Service quality informationService quality information: 73%73%Indemnity insurance and right to complainIndemnity insurance and right to complain: 56%56%Consumers who found information easy to find when shopping around, 2026Bar chart. Cost information: 74%; Service quality information: 73%; Indemnity insurance and right to complain: 56%.Cost informationCost information: 74%74%Service quality informationService quality information: 73%73%Indemnity insurance and right tocomplainIndemnity insurance and right to complain: 56%56%

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Cost information74%
Service quality information73%
Indemnity insurance and right to complain56%

Ask to see an existing solicitors site the agency built and check it yourself: is the SRA badge visible, are prices and service information easy to reach from each relevant page, is the complaints procedure linked from the footer? A good agency will treat these as design requirements, not afterthoughts.

Contract terms to check before signing

Agency contract terms for a solicitors firm
ClauseWhat good looks likeRed flag
Term and noticeInitial term of three to six months, then rolling with one month's noticeTwelve to twenty-four months with no break clause
OwnershipFirm owns domain, website, content, analytics and ad accountsAgency owns the site or licenses it back to you
AccessFirm has admin access to every account from day oneAccess only through the agency's dashboard
ReportingMonthly report on enquiries and instructions by channelReports on impressions, rankings and traffic only
Ad spendPaid directly by the firm to the platform, agency fee separateSpend bundled into one fee with no visibility
ApprovalNo advert or page goes live without firm sign-offAgency can publish without approval
ExitHandover of all files, logins and data within a set periodExit fees or loss of the website on termination

If the agency builds the website on its own proprietary platform, ask in writing what you would receive if you left: the content, the design files and the domain, or only a PDF of the pages.

Scoring the shortlist

  1. Agree criteria before the pitches

    For example: legal sector understanding, compliance approach, reporting quality, ownership terms, team you will actually work with, and cost. Weight them before you meet anyone.

  2. Use the same questions for every agency

    Send the questions in advance and score the answers, not the presentation.

  3. Take references properly

    Speak to two current solicitor clients. Ask what changed in enquiries and instructions, not whether they liked the people.

  4. Ask for a ninety-day plan

    A good agency can describe specifically what it would do in the first quarter and what you should expect to see by the end of it.

  5. Start small

    Begin with one practice area or one channel. Expand only when the reports show instructions, not just activity.

Example (fictional): a three-partner firm interviews four agencies. The most polished pitch scores lowest on ownership, because the agency would own the website. The winning agency is smaller, works with several solicitors firms and offers a six-month initial term with monthly reporting of enquiries and instructions by source. The firm starts with its conveyancing pages only and reviews the results at month four.

Red flags in agency pitches

  • Guaranteed first-page rankings or a guaranteed number of leads.
  • Offers to write or 'manage' reviews.
  • Reports built around rankings and traffic rather than enquiries.
  • Reluctance to give the firm admin access to its own accounts.
  • Generic legal content that could appear on any firm's site.
  • Cold outreach or bought data proposed as a lead source.
  • No named person at the agency who will run your account.

If you are still deciding whether to hire an agency at all, our comparison of an in-house marketer versus an agency for law firms sets out the trade-offs, and our guide to measuring marketing ROI for solicitors shows what the agency's reports should eventually tell you.

Frequently asked questions

Is the firm responsible for what a marketing agency publishes?

Yes. The SRA holds the firm and its solicitors responsible for publicity about the practice. Keep sign-off rights over every advert and page in the contract.

How long should an agency contract be?

Start with a short initial term, often three to six months, followed by a rolling arrangement with reasonable notice. Avoid long fixed terms without a break clause.

Should the agency pay for our adverts?

It is usually better for the firm to pay the advertising platform directly and pay the agency a separate fee, so you can see exactly what is spent on media.

What should an agency report every month?

Enquiries and instructions by channel and practice area, cost per enquiry and per instruction, and what the agency will change next month. Rankings and traffic are supporting information.

References

  1. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (DSIT) (2025). Data (Use and Access) Act factsheet: PEC Regulations (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Ombudsman (2026). AI and Complaints: A Consumer Guide (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Transparency Rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo