Key takeaways
- Measure each channel to the point of instruction and fee income, not to clicks or enquiries: cost per instruction is the number that decides budgets.
- Include the cost of handling enquiries: solicitors' median hourly pay was £31.50 in 2026, so an hour of fee earner time on unqualified enquiries is a real marketing cost[1].
- Most clients decide quickly (69% chose a provider within a week), so a short attribution window captures most of the effect[2].
- 63% of consumers first learned the price through a discussion with the provider: if you do not track phone calls, you are missing most of your conversions[2].
- Review the numbers monthly and act quarterly; small firms need enough data before cutting or doubling a channel.
Why most law firm marketing reports mislead
A typical monthly marketing report for a solicitors firm shows website visits, social media followers, maybe the number of form submissions. None of those numbers pays the rent. A channel can generate plenty of enquiries and still lose money if the enquiries are for work you do not do, if they arrive when nobody can answer, or if they come from people who will never pay your fees.
Return on investment for legal marketing has to follow an enquiry all the way through: from first contact, to initial consultation, to instruction, to the fees billed on the matter. That sounds like a large analytics project. In practice it needs three things most firms already have: a consistent source field on every enquiry, a link between the enquiry and the matter number, and a monthly half-hour with the figures.
Employment costs make up a large share of a law firm's spending: UK legal activities businesses spent £18.2 billion on employment costs in 2024, about 36% of turnover[3]. Much of the hidden cost of marketing sits there, in the time fee earners and support staff spend handling enquiries that never instruct.
The five numbers to track for every channel
- Spend: what you paid in the period, including agency fees, advertising, sponsorship, design and printing.
- Enquiries: genuine new-client contacts from that channel, counted once per person and matter, whether by phone, form, email or walk-in.
- Instructions: enquiries that became paying matters, counted when the client care letter is signed or funds are received.
- Fee income: fees billed on those matters, recorded when billed, so long matters still count.
- Handling cost: the staff time spent dealing with enquiries from that channel, at a realistic hourly cost.
From those five you can work out the ratios that drive decisions. Cost per enquiry is spend divided by enquiries. Conversion rate is instructions divided by enquiries. Cost per instruction is spend plus handling cost, divided by instructions. Return on marketing is fee income from the channel, minus spend and handling cost, divided by spend and handling cost. Keep the formulas in a shared spreadsheet so everyone calculates them the same way.
Count enquiries once. A person who rings, then fills in the web form, then emails a document is one enquiry. Duplicate counting makes every channel look better than it is.
Putting a price on enquiry handling time
Handling cost is the number firms leave out, and it is often what separates a profitable channel from a loss-making one. ONS figures give a fair starting point for an hourly rate. In 2026, median gross hourly pay was £31.50 for solicitors and lawyers, £14.95 for legal secretaries, £14.86 for call and contact centre staff and £13.51 for receptionists[1]. Add employer National Insurance, pension and overheads to reach a loaded cost, and use your own payroll figures where you have them.
A channel that produces many low-quality enquiries can tie up a fee earner for hours each week in calls that end with 'we don't do that' or 'that's more than I expected to pay'. Logging the time spent per enquiry for a month, even roughly, is usually enough to show which channels carry the heaviest handling burden.
Worked example: three channels compared
| Measure | Paid search | Google Business Profile and reviews | Accountant referrals |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spend in quarter | £6,000 | £600 | £900 |
| Enquiries | 120 | 60 | 15 |
| Instructions | 18 | 15 | 9 |
| Conversion rate | 15% | 25% | 60% |
| Handling time (hours) | 60 | 25 | 8 |
| Cost per instruction incl. handling | £433 | £90 | £127 |
| Fee income billed | £27,000 | £19,500 | £22,500 |
Example: on enquiry volume alone, paid search looks like the star channel. On cost per instruction it is the most expensive, because its enquiries are less qualified and take longer to handle. The accountant referrals produce few enquiries but convert at a high rate. The firm's sensible response is not to switch off paid search, which still produces worthwhile income, but to tighten its targeting and invest more time in the referral relationships.
Example: note what the table does not show. The accountant referrals may bring repeat work over several years, and the reviews support every other channel. Lifetime value matters, so add a column for repeat instructions within two years once you have the data.
Setting up tracking that survives a busy week
Fix the source list
Agree eight to twelve sources (for example paid search, organic search, Business Profile, past client, recommendation, named referrer, directory, event, press) and make the field mandatory on every new enquiry record.
Ask the question the same way
Reception asks 'How did you hear about us?' and picks from the list, adding a note for named referrers. Web forms carry a hidden field for the landing page and campaign.
Track phone calls
Use a separate tracked number for each major channel, or at least for paid advertising, so calls can be attributed without relying on memory.
Link enquiry to matter
When an enquiry instructs, copy the source onto the matter record, so fee income can be reported by source from the practice management system.
Record why enquiries are lost
Use a short list: price, timing, not our work, no response, chose another firm, no further contact. Lost reasons often tell you more than the conversion rate.
Review monthly, decide quarterly
Look at the figures every month to catch problems early, but change budgets only once a quarter, when there is enough data to separate a trend from noise.
Phone tracking matters more in legal services than in most sectors. 63% of consumers first found out the price of their legal service through a discussion with the provider[2]. If the call that turns an enquiry into an instruction is invisible to your reporting, your best channels will look worse than they are.
Choosing an attribution window
Attribution is the question of which channel gets the credit. For most legal work it is simpler than in retail. 69% of consumers took a week or less to choose a legal services provider[2], so most of the effect of a channel shows within a few weeks. Shopping around is common, though: 42% of consumers shopped around before choosing in 2026[2], so a client may see your advert, read your reviews and then ring after a friend's recommendation.
Research habits vary by matter. When choosing a main adviser for a contentious issue, 25% of people searched around, 15% obtained details of the service, 14% searched for reviews and 13% searched for prices[4]. Reviews and published prices therefore influence decisions that are finally credited to a phone call or a recommendation. Treat them as supporting channels: measure their health (review volume and rating, price page visits) rather than expecting them to show instructions of their own in a last-touch report.
- Use first-touch reporting (how they first heard of you) for brand and community activity.
- Use last-touch reporting (what prompted the enquiry) for paid search and directories.
- Record both where you can: a single extra question at intake is enough.
- For long-cycle commercial work, keep the enquiry open and attribute fee income when it is billed, even months later.
Acting on the numbers
The purpose of measuring is to move money and time. Cut or fix channels whose cost per instruction exceeds the fee margin on the work they bring. Protect channels with high conversion and repeat value even when volumes are low. Look at handling time before you look at spend: often the quickest gain is a better first response, not a new campaign.
Response speed is part of ROI. A channel that delivers enquiries at evenings and weekends performs worse if nobody answers until Monday. Some firms use an AI Employee such as Ava to answer and qualify those enquiries and book consultations into the diary, which changes the conversion rate of every channel at once. Whatever you use, measure the effect by comparing conversion before and after.
Finally, share the numbers with fee earners. People who can see which enquiries convert and why tend to handle the first call better. For tracking web enquiries properly, see our guide to Google Analytics 4 for law firm websites, and for conversion by person, measuring consultation conversion by fee earner.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good cost per instruction for a law firm?
It depends on the fee value and margin of the work. Compare cost per instruction with the average fee and profit margin for that type of matter; a channel is worth keeping when the margin comfortably covers the cost, including handling time.
How do we track phone enquiries from marketing?
Use tracked numbers for major paid channels, ask every caller how they heard about you and record the answer in a fixed list, then copy the source onto the matter when they instruct.
Should handling time really be included in marketing ROI?
Yes. Fee earner and support time spent on unqualified enquiries is a real cost. Leaving it out flatters high-volume, low-quality channels.
How often should a small firm review marketing results?
Look at the figures monthly to spot problems, and change budgets quarterly, when there is enough data to make a fair decision.
References
Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2024). Non-financial business economy, UK: Sections A to S (Annual Business Survey), Table 16 Section M (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑