Key takeaways
- Every purpose for which a firm uses personal data needs one lawful basis under Article 6 of the UK GDPR, chosen before the processing starts.
- For client work the usual bases are contract and legal obligation; consent is rarely the right basis outside marketing.
- Since 5 February 2026, a new recognised legitimate interests basis covers specific purposes such as safeguarding and crime prevention, without a balancing test.
- Special category data needs an Article 9 condition as well; for most legal work the condition for legal claims applies.
One purpose, one basis
The UK GDPR does not ask whether processing is lawful in general. It asks whether each purpose has a lawful basis. A single enquiry call can involve several purposes: deciding whether you can help, checking for conflicts, recording the call, opening a matter, carrying out anti-money laundering checks and, later, sending a newsletter. Each needs its own basis, recorded before the processing begins.
Article 6 sets out the bases. Processing is lawful only if at least one applies: consent; necessity for a contract with the person or for steps at their request before entering one; compliance with a legal obligation; protecting someone's vital interests; a task in the public interest or official authority; a recognised legitimate interest; or the controller's or a third party's legitimate interests, unless overridden by the person's interests or rights[1].
The recognised legitimate interest basis is new. It was inserted by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 and has been fully in force since 5 February 2026. Neither it nor ordinary legitimate interests can be used by public authorities in performing their tasks[1].
Why consent is rarely the answer for client work
Many firms default to consent because it feels respectful. For most client work it is the wrong choice. Consent must be freely given and can be withdrawn at any time; if a client withdraws consent to processing that you need in order to act, or that the law requires, you are left with no basis. And where the client has little real choice, for example because the firm cannot act without the information, consent is unlikely to be freely given.
- Use contract for processing needed to act for the client, including steps they ask you to take before the retainer starts.
- Use legal obligation for processing the law requires, such as anti-money laundering checks and record-keeping.
- Use legitimate interests for processing about people who are not your client, such as opponents and witnesses, after a short balancing assessment.
- Keep consent for genuinely optional things: most electronic marketing, optional surveys and testimonials.
Matching purposes to bases
| Purpose | Likely lawful basis | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Handling an enquiry and giving an initial view | Contract (steps at the person's request before a contract) | Collect only what you need to decide whether you can help |
| Acting on the client's matter | Contract | Add an Article 9 condition for any special category data |
| Data about opponents, witnesses and other third parties on the file | Legitimate interests | Record a brief legitimate interests assessment for the matter type |
| Anti-money laundering and identity checks | Legal obligation | Keep records for the period the regulations require |
| Conflict checks | Legitimate interests or legal obligation | Limit the data in the conflict system to what is needed |
| Recording calls for quality and evidence | Legitimate interests | Tell callers at the start and in your privacy notice |
| Email or text newsletters | Consent, or the soft opt-in under PECR | PECR applies as well as the UK GDPR |
| Staff records and payroll | Contract and legal obligation | Separate staff privacy notice |
| Passing safeguarding concerns to the authorities | Recognised legitimate interest (safeguarding) | Only where an Annex 1 condition is met |
The table is a starting point, not a substitute for thinking about your own processing. The right answer can change with the facts, for example where a firm acts under a legal aid contract or for a public body.
Recognised legitimate interests
Processing is necessary for a recognised legitimate interest only if it meets a condition in Annex 1 to the UK GDPR[1]. Unlike ordinary legitimate interests, there is no separate balancing test, which is the point: the conditions describe purposes Parliament has decided are legitimate in themselves.
- Disclosure in response to a request from someone who says they need the data for a public task with a proper legal basis[2].
- Safeguarding national security, protecting public security or defence[2].
- Responding to an emergency, as defined in the Civil Contingencies Act 2004[2].
- Detecting, investigating or preventing crime, or apprehending or prosecuting offenders[2].
- Safeguarding a vulnerable individual, meaning someone under 18, or 18 or over and at risk, from neglect or harm, or protecting their well-being[2].
For law firms, the safeguarding and crime conditions are the most likely to matter, for example when a family or private client team needs to share a concern about a vulnerable adult. The basis does not override professional confidentiality or privilege, which still have to be considered separately.
Special category data and legal claims
Health, ethnic origin, religious belief, sexual orientation and other special category data need an Article 9 condition in addition to an Article 6 basis. Article 9 prohibits processing them unless a condition applies, and one condition is that processing is necessary for the establishment, exercise or defence of legal claims or whenever courts or tribunals are acting in their judicial capacity[3].
That condition covers much contentious work, such as health evidence in a personal injury or employment claim. It fits less neatly with non-contentious work such as wills and lasting powers of attorney, where firms should consider other conditions and record their reasoning. Criminal offence data has its own rules; see special category and criminal offence data in law firms.
Do not collect health details at the enquiry stage unless you need them to decide whether you can help. Ask for them once the matter is open and you have a clear basis and condition.
Transparency: what clients expect
Whatever basis you rely on, people must be told what you are doing with their data. Expectations are rising as firms adopt new tools. In the Legal Services Board's 2026 research with legal service users, AI acting without the user's knowledge or consent was the single most urgent AI concern (56%), and 81% agreed AI legal tools should never act automatically for a vulnerable person in high-stakes situations. 89% expected an AI legal tool to have a complaints process and 66% expected it to involve a real human[4].
The law points the same way. Under the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, significant solely automated decisions need safeguards, including the right to challenge the decision and obtain human intervention[5]. If any part of your intake or triage makes decisions about people without a human looking, check whether those safeguards apply and say so in your privacy information.
Marketing: two sets of rules
Marketing needs a lawful basis under the UK GDPR and compliance with PECR for electronic messages. The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 also makes clear that a PECR direct marketing breach can occur even if the call or message never reached the intended recipient[6]. Keep marketing lists separate from client files, record how and when each person agreed, and include an easy opt-out in every message.
Documenting your bases
List your purposes
Work through each stage of the client journey, plus staff, recruitment and marketing, and list every purpose.
Choose one basis per purpose
Pick the basis that fits best and record why. Avoid listing several 'just in case'.
Add Article 9 conditions
For each purpose involving special category data, record the condition you rely on.
Write legitimate interests assessments
For each purpose relying on legitimate interests, record the interest, why the processing is necessary and why it does not override the person's interests.
Update privacy notices
Make sure each notice states the purposes and bases in plain language.
Review annually
Revisit when you add a new service, tool or supplier, and at least once a year.
Example: from enquiry to newsletter
Example. A caller rings a fictional employment firm about a dismissal. The receptionist records her name, number, employer and a short summary so a solicitor can call back: contract, as steps at her request before a retainer. The call is recorded for quality, as the greeting explains: legitimate interests. The solicitor runs a conflict check against the employer: legitimate interests. She instructs the firm, which carries out identity checks: legal obligation. Her medical evidence for a disability discrimination claim is processed under contract with the Article 9 legal claims condition.
At the end of the matter she ticks a box to receive the firm's employment law newsletter: consent, with an unsubscribe link in every edition. Each step is in the firm's record of processing, and its privacy notice sets them out in the same order. For the wider framework, read UK GDPR for solicitors: the essentials, check whether you need a data protection officer, and make sure your ICO registration and data protection fee are in order.
Frequently asked questions
Should a law firm rely on consent to process client data?
Usually not for client work. Contract and legal obligation normally fit better, because consent can be withdrawn and may not be freely given where the firm needs the data to act.
What is a recognised legitimate interest?
A lawful basis added by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 and fully in force since 5 February 2026. It applies only where a condition in Annex 1 is met, such as crime prevention or safeguarding a vulnerable individual, and needs no balancing test.
Which Article 9 condition covers health data in a claim?
Processing necessary for the establishment, exercise or defence of legal claims, or whenever courts or tribunals are acting in their judicial capacity, is a condition under Article 9.
What lawful basis covers anti-money laundering checks?
Legal obligation, because the checks are required by the money laundering regulations.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2026). UK GDPR Article 6: Lawfulness of processing (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2025). UK GDPR Annex 1: Recognised legitimate interests (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 9: Processing of special categories of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Board (2026). AI in Legal Services: Research Report (LSB Public Panel) (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (DSIT) (2025). Data (Use and Access) Act 2025: data protection and privacy changes (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (DSIT) (2025). Data (Use and Access) Act factsheet: PEC Regulations (opens in a new tab) ↑