Data protection and cyber security

Special category and criminal offence data in law firms

How law firms can lawfully handle health, criminal and other sensitive data: Article 9 and 10 conditions, Schedule 1 and a practical checklist.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Sensitive data is the normal state of a law firm
  2. Two tests, not one
  3. The legal claims conditions do most of the work
  4. Where firms actually trip up
  5. A front-desk script for sensitive disclosures
  6. Security and breaches
  7. A checklist for your data protection lead
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References

Key takeaways

  • Special category data needs an Article 6 lawful basis and a separate Article 9 condition; criminal offence data needs an Article 6 basis plus a Schedule 1 condition[1][2].
  • For client work, the legal claims conditions usually apply, covering prospective proceedings and obtaining legal advice[3].
  • Those conditions do not cover your marketing, staff records or wellbeing schemes, which need their own conditions and often a policy document.
  • Most real exposure sits at the front desk: free-text intake notes, shared calendars and emails to the wrong recipient.
  • Treat a breach involving this data as likely high risk and be ready to decide on ICO notification within 72 hours[4].

Sensitive data is the normal state of a law firm

A personal injury file holds medical records. A family file holds allegations of abuse, children's health and sometimes sexual history. An employment file holds sickness absence, disability and union membership. A crime file is built entirely around alleged offences. Most firms process sensitive data every day without ever having designed for it.

UK GDPR names the special categories in Article 9(1): racial or ethnic origin, political opinions, religious or philosophical beliefs, trade union membership, genetic data, biometric data used to identify someone, health data, and data about sex life or sexual orientation[1]. Criminal convictions, offences and related security measures sit outside that list and are governed separately by Article 10[2]. The Data Protection Act 2018 widens criminal offence data to include allegations and proceedings, which is why a crime team's intake notes count even before anyone is charged.

The scale is not small. In June 2026, 1,044 legal aid providers held criminal contracts and 1,281 held civil contracts in England and Wales[5]. Police station advice alone made up 69% of Crime Lower legal aid workload in April to June 2026[6], and that work is almost entirely criminal offence data gathered at speed, often by phone.

Legal aid providers by contract typeEngland and Wales, June 2026. Some providers hold both.
Legal aid providers by contract typeComparison. Providers with criminal contracts: 1,044; Providers with civil contracts: 1,281.1,044Providers with criminal contractsProviders with criminal contracts: 1,0441,281Providers with civil contractsProviders with civil contracts: 1,281Legal aid providers by contract typeComparison. Providers with criminal contracts: 1,044; Providers with civil contracts: 1,281.1,044Providers with criminal contractsProviders with criminal contracts: 1,0441,281Providers with civil contractsProviders with civil contracts: 1,281

Source: Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK), 2026[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
Providers with criminal contracts1,044
Providers with civil contracts1,281

Two tests, not one

Every use of personal data needs a lawful basis under Article 6. Special category data then needs one of the Article 9(2) conditions on top. Criminal offence data needs an Article 6 basis plus authorisation in domestic law, which in practice means a condition in Schedule 1 to the 2018 Act[2]. Record both layers, not just the first.

Example mapping for a mixed-practice firm. Check each entry against your own processing before relying on it.
DataWhere it turns upUsual Article 6 basisUsual extra condition
Health of a clientPersonal injury, clinical negligence, family, Court of ProtectionContract or legitimate interestsArticle 9(2)(f) legal claims
Health of an opponent or witnessLitigation bundles, expert reportsLegitimate interestsArticle 9(2)(f) legal claims
Alleged offences of a clientCrime, regulatory, some family and employmentContract or legitimate interestsSchedule 1, Part 3, paragraph 33 legal claims
Staff sickness and disabilityYour own HR recordsLegal obligationEmployment condition, with an appropriate policy document
Staff criminal record checksRecruitment for regulated rolesLegal obligation or legitimate interestsA specific Schedule 1 condition, documented
Equality monitoringSRA diversity data collectionLegal obligation or consentEquality of opportunity condition or explicit consent

When a new type of processing appears, run it through four questions before anyone starts collecting data:

  1. What does the data reveal? A note that a client attends a mosque reveals religion; a sick note reveals health. Inference counts.
  2. Whose data is it? Clients, opponents, witnesses, children and your own staff often need different conditions.
  3. Is the processing necessary for the claim or the advice, or merely convenient? If it is convenient, stop and find another condition or collect less.
  4. Does the condition need an appropriate policy document or explicit consent? If yes, who owns that document and when was it last reviewed?

Write the answers into your record of processing. When the ICO, a client's insurer or an SRA investigator asks how you justify holding sensitive data, a dated record made at the time is far more persuasive than a reconstruction after the event.

Article 9(2)(f) allows processing that is necessary for the establishment, exercise or defence of legal claims, or whenever courts or tribunals act in their judicial capacity; the reference to tribunals was added by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025[1]. For criminal offence data, paragraph 33 of Schedule 1 is met where processing is necessary for legal proceedings, including prospective proceedings, for obtaining legal advice, or for establishing, exercising or defending legal rights[3].

Two words matter. Prospective means the condition can apply at the enquiry stage, before any retainer, when a caller explains a problem so you can decide whether to act. Necessary means you collect what the claim or advice actually needs, not everything the caller volunteers.

The legal claims conditions cover client work. They do not cover a newsletter list built from family clients, a staff wellbeing survey or a case study for your website. Each of those needs its own condition, and many need explicit consent.

Where firms actually trip up

  • Free-text intake fields. A web form box labelled Tell us what happened collects health and offence details from people you may never act for. Ask for a summary, not the full story, and set a short deletion period for enquiries that do not become matters.
  • Calendar and room booking titles. Shared diaries that show Smith: injunction, DV or Jones: police interview leak sensitive data to everyone in the building. Use matter numbers.
  • Email auto-complete. A misdirected email containing a medical report is one of the most common incidents a firm will face. Turn off auto-complete for external addresses or add a send delay.
  • Voicemail and call notes. Messages left overnight often contain more detail than the caller would put in writing. Restrict who can play them and file them to the matter.
  • Marketing segmentation. Tagging contacts by matter type, such as divorce, creates special category inferences in your CRM. Keep marketing tags generic.
  • Retention. Crime and family enquiries that never became instructions are often kept indefinitely because nobody owns them.

A front-desk script for sensitive disclosures

Receptionists and intake staff are the first people to hear sensitive facts, often before a fee earner is involved. Give them a short, consistent approach rather than leaving it to instinct.

  1. Acknowledge and slow down

    Thank you for telling me. So I can get you to the right person, I only need a short outline today; the solicitor will go through the detail with you.

  2. Capture the minimum

    Record matter type, urgency, dates of any hearing or police interview, and contact details. Do not record diagnoses, allegations or names of third parties unless the fee earner has asked for them.

  3. Check how to contact them safely

    Is it safe to call you on this number and leave a message? Is there an email address only you can read? This matters most in domestic abuse and crime matters.

  4. Route by urgency

    Police station attendance, injunction and hearing-tomorrow matters go to the named duty fee earner at once. Everything else goes into the normal enquiry queue with a call-back time.

  5. File and close

    Save the note to the enquiry record, not to a personal inbox or notebook, and mark it so it is deleted on schedule if no matter is opened.

If an AI Employee such as Ava answers calls out of hours, give it the same approved intake: minimum facts, a safe-contact question and immediate routing for police station and injunction calls. The rule should not change depending on who or what picks up the phone.

Example: a caller to a fictional four-partner firm says her husband has threatened her and she needs to stop him returning home. The receptionist records family, urgent, non-molestation enquiry, safe mobile number and no voicemail, and transfers to the duty family solicitor. She does not type the details of the threats. The solicitor takes those directly, under the legal claims condition, onto the matter file.

Security and breaches

A breach involving health or offence data is far more likely to create a high risk for the people affected, through discrimination, distress, loss of a job or physical danger. That affects two decisions: whether to notify the ICO, which must happen without undue delay and where feasible within 72 hours of becoming aware[4], and whether to tell the individuals. Our guide to reporting data breaches to the ICO sets out the assessment.

Practical controls follow from the risk. Restrict crime and family folders to the teams that need them. Encrypt laptops and removable media. Send medical and police disclosure through a secure portal rather than ordinary email. Review access lists at least twice a year, and immediately when someone moves team.

A checklist for your data protection lead

  1. List each team's sensitive data types and record the Article 6 basis and the Article 9 or Schedule 1 condition for each.
  2. Confirm which non-client activities, such as HR, recruitment and equality monitoring, need an appropriate policy document, and write or update it.
  3. Rewrite enquiry forms and intake scripts to collect the minimum at first contact.
  4. Set a deletion period for enquiries that do not become matters, and assign an owner.
  5. Replace descriptive calendar titles with matter references.
  6. Move medical, police and social services disclosure to a secure channel.
  7. Brief reception and out-of-hours cover on the script above and test it with a mock call.
  8. Add special category and criminal data as a high-risk factor in your breach assessment template.

Frequently asked questions

Is a client's own health information special category data even if they told us voluntarily?

Yes. The category depends on what the data reveals, not how you received it. You still need an Article 9 condition, which for client work is usually the legal claims condition, and you should only keep what the matter needs.

Do we need consent to hold criminal offence data for a crime client?

No. Consent is rarely the right basis for client work. Paragraph 33 of Schedule 1 covers processing necessary for legal proceedings, including prospective proceedings, and for obtaining legal advice.

Do we need an appropriate policy document?

Not for the legal claims conditions on their own, but you will usually need one for your HR processing under the employment condition and for most substantial public interest conditions. Keep it short, specific and reviewed.

Are allegations criminal offence data, or only convictions?

The 2018 Act treats data about alleged offences and proceedings as criminal offence data, so a note that someone has been arrested or accused is covered.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 9: Processing of special categories of personal data (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 10: Processing of personal data relating to criminal convictions and offences (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2018). Data Protection Act 2018, Schedule 1, Part 3: Additional conditions relating to criminal convictions etc (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). UK GDPR Article 33: Notification of a personal data breach to the supervisory authority (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Legal aid statistics England and Wales bulletin Apr to Jun 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Legal aid statistics England and Wales bulletin Apr to Jun 2026 (Crime Lower workload) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo