Consultations and booking

Mental capacity concerns at a first meeting

Spotting capacity issues at a first client meeting: the Mental Capacity Act test, questions to ask, when to get medical evidence and what to record.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Start from the legal test, not a hunch
  2. Signs that should prompt a closer look
  3. Questions that test understanding without leading
  4. When to ask for medical evidence
  5. Why the stakes are high in wills and probate
  6. Talking to the client and family about your concerns
  7. Recording your assessment
  8. Example: an LPA request after a hospital stay
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • Capacity is decision-specific and time-specific: the question is whether the client can make this decision now, not whether they are generally capable.
  • The Mental Capacity Act test asks whether the person can understand, retain, use or weigh the relevant information and communicate a decision[1].
  • An unwise decision is not evidence of incapacity on its own[2].
  • For older or seriously ill will-makers, follow the golden rule and seek a medical opinion before the will is executed.
  • Your attendance note is the evidence. Record the questions asked and the client's own answers, not just your conclusion.

Solicitors are not expected to diagnose dementia, but they are expected to notice when a client may not have the capacity to give instructions, and to act on it. The Mental Capacity Act 2005 sets five principles. Two matter most at a first meeting: a person must be assumed to have capacity unless it is established that they lack it, and they are not to be treated as unable to decide unless all practicable steps to help them have been taken without success[2]. A third is easy to forget under pressure from relatives: a person is not to be treated as unable to make a decision merely because the decision is unwise[2].

Section 3 then sets out the functional test. A person is unable to make a decision if they cannot understand the information relevant to it, retain that information, use or weigh it as part of the process of deciding, or communicate the decision by any means[1]. Retaining information for only a short period does not by itself prevent someone being able to decide[1].

For wills, the courts still apply the common law test from Banks v Goodfellow: the testator must understand the nature of making a will and its effects, the extent of the property, and the claims of those they might be expected to benefit, with no disorder of the mind poisoning their judgement. Many practitioners use the Act's principles as good practice alongside it.

Signs that should prompt a closer look

None of these signs proves anything by itself. Each is a reason to slow down, ask more questions and write more down.

  • The client repeats the same question or story several times within a few minutes.
  • They cannot say roughly what they own, or name their main bank or their home's approximate value.
  • Their instructions differ sharply from a previous will without a reason they can explain.
  • They look to a relative before answering, or the relative answers for them.
  • They are confused about the date, the purpose of the meeting or who you are.
  • A recent hospital stay, fall, infection or change in medication.
  • The request comes from someone who benefits, and the client seems unaware of the details.

Context matters. The SRA Code of Conduct requires you to consider and take account of a client's attributes, needs and circumstances[3]. A hearing problem, low literacy or a second language can look like confusion. Rule those out first; our article on booking interpreters for client meetings covers language support.

Questions that test understanding without leading

Closed questions such as 'You want to leave everything to your daughter, don't you?' produce agreement, not evidence. Use open questions that map onto the legal test and let the client do the talking.

  1. Purpose: 'Can you tell me what you would like to do today, and why now?'
  2. Assets: 'What do you own? Think about your home, savings, pensions and anything valuable.'
  3. People: 'Who are the people closest to you? Is there anyone who might expect to receive something?'
  4. Reasons: 'You have mentioned leaving less to your son. Can you tell me a little about that?'
  5. Effect: 'What will happen to your house when you die if we write the will this way?'
  6. Retention: later in the meeting, return to an earlier point and ask the client to remind you what they decided.
  7. Communication: 'Is there anything about this you would like me to explain again, or in a different way?'

If the client struggles, try practicable steps before reaching a view: a shorter meeting, a different time of day, a diagram of who gets what, or a second meeting with a written summary sent in advance.

When to ask for medical evidence

The so-called golden rule, drawn from cases such as Kenward v Adams and Re Simpson, says that where a will-maker is aged or seriously ill, the will should be witnessed or approved by a medical practitioner who has assessed capacity and recorded the examination. It is guidance on good practice rather than a rule of law, but departing from it makes a later challenge harder to defend.

Decision guide for capacity concerns in wills and LPA matters
SituationSuggested action
Client is elderly, alert, instructions consistent and explainedProceed, keep a detailed note, consider medical evidence if the estate is large or the will departs from earlier ones
Diagnosis of dementia, or memory clinic involvementSeek a capacity assessment from the client's GP or a specialist before executing
Recent delirium, infection or hospital admissionWait for recovery where the timetable allows, then reassess
Client cannot explain assets or beneficiaries after supportDo not take instructions; explain kindly and consider whether a statutory will application may be needed
Relative pressing for urgencyTreat urgency as a risk factor, not a reason to skip checks

When you write to the doctor, set out the relevant legal test, the decision in question and the key facts the client needs to understand, such as the size of the estate and the people who might have a claim. A letter that simply asks whether the patient has capacity tends to produce an answer that does not help.

Why the stakes are high in wills and probate

Complaints data shows where problems surface. The Legal Ombudsman found evidence of poor service in 79% of wills and probate complaints it assessed in 2025/26, the highest rate of any area, against 72% for complaints overall[4].

Evidence of poor service in Legal Ombudsman complaints, 2025/26Share of complaints assessed where evidence of poor service was found
Evidence of poor service in Legal Ombudsman complaints, 2025/26Comparison. Wills and probate: 79%; Residential conveyancing: 78%; All assessed complaints: 72%.79%Wills and probateWills and probate: 79%78%Residential conveyancingResidential conveyancing: 78%72%All assessed complaintsAll assessed complaints: 72%Evidence of poor service in Legal Ombudsman complaints, 2025/26Comparison. Wills and probate: 79%; Residential conveyancing: 78%; All assessed complaints: 72%.79%Wills and probateWills and probate: 79%78%Residential conveyancingResidential conveyancing: 78%72%All assessed complaintsAll assessed complaints: 72%

Source: Legal Ombudsman, 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Wills and probate79%
Residential conveyancing78%
All assessed complaints72%

Clients and families are also less equipped than solicitors often assume. In the Legal Services Board's Legal Needs Survey, 38% of adults in England and Wales had a low level of legal confidence[5]. Families who did not understand how a will was prepared are more likely to suspect something went wrong. A careful process at the first meeting is the best defence for everyone.

Talking to the client and family about your concerns

Pausing a matter on capacity grounds can feel awkward, and it is tempting to keep the reason vague. Clients and relatives usually respond better to honesty delivered gently. Explain that the law asks you to be sure every client can make the decision for themselves, that this protects the client's wishes from challenge later, and that a short delay now is better than a dispute after death.

  • Speak to the client first, privately, and in plain words. Avoid clinical labels.
  • Offer concrete next steps: a second meeting, a written summary, a letter to the GP.
  • Do not share your concerns with relatives without the client's consent, even if they ask directly.
  • If a relative becomes insistent, note it. Pressure to skip checks is itself relevant evidence.
  • Give a realistic timetable so nobody feels the matter has been dropped.

Recording your assessment

  1. Set the scene

    Date, time, place, who was present at each stage and for how long the client was seen alone.

  2. Record the questions

    Write the questions you asked as asked, so a reader can see they were open and not leading.

  3. Record the answers in the client's words

    Short verbatim phrases carry more weight than a summary such as 'client understood'.

  4. Note practicable steps taken

    Hearing aids in, glasses on, quiet room, time of day chosen, information repeated or simplified.

  5. State your view and its basis

    Whether you are satisfied, unsure or concerned, and what you have decided to do next.

  6. File the medical evidence

    Keep the letter you sent to the doctor and their reply with the will file.

Example: an LPA request after a hospital stay

Example (fictional). A 79-year-old man attends with his niece two weeks after a hospital stay for a chest infection. He wants a property and financial affairs LPA appointing her. Seen alone, he can name his bank and explain that his niece already helps with shopping, but he cannot recall the earlier part of the conversation about replacement attorneys. The solicitor offers a second meeting in a fortnight, sends a one-page summary with a diagram of how an attorney acts, and asks the GP whether recovery from the infection may still be affecting him. At the second meeting he explains the role of an attorney in his own words and chooses a replacement. Both meetings are fully noted.

Frequently asked questions

Do solicitors have to assess mental capacity?

Solicitors are not medical assessors, but they must be satisfied a client can give instructions for the decision in question. Where there is doubt, they should take practicable steps to help, record their view and seek a medical opinion where appropriate.

What is the golden rule for wills?

Where a will-maker is elderly or seriously ill, the will should be witnessed or approved by a doctor who has assessed capacity and recorded the examination. It is good practice guidance from case law rather than a strict legal requirement.

Is a strange or unfair will a sign of incapacity?

Not on its own. The Mental Capacity Act says a person is not to be treated as unable to decide merely because the decision is unwise. Ask the client to explain their reasons and record them.

Can capacity change from one meeting to the next?

Yes. Capacity is assessed for a particular decision at a particular time. Illness, medication and fatigue can all affect it, so a second meeting at a better time is often the right step.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2005). Mental Capacity Act 2005, section 3: Inability to make decisions (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2005). Mental Capacity Act 2005, section 1: The principles (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo