Client experience

Net Promoter Score for solicitors: useful or not?

Is Net Promoter Score useful for law firms? How NPS works, where it misleads solicitors, the alternatives that tell you more and how to use it well.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. What NPS is
  2. Why it appeals to law firms
  3. Where NPS misleads solicitors
  4. NPS compared with the alternatives
  5. A short scorecard instead of one number
  6. Ask at the right moment
  7. If you use NPS, use it well
  8. What to do with detractors
  9. Worked example
  10. The verdict
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • NPS is one question: how likely is the client to recommend you, scored 0 to 10.
  • It suits law firms because recommendation drives new work, but small samples and one-off clients make it noisy.
  • Satisfaction scores, effort questions and comment themes often tell a firm more about what to fix.
  • If you use NPS, always ask why, report the number of responses, and never treat a small change as a trend.

What NPS is

Net Promoter Score asks one question: how likely are you to recommend us to a friend or colleague? Answers are scored from zero to ten. The score is the percentage of promoters, who answer 9 or 10, minus the percentage of detractors, who answer 0 to 6[1]. People who answer 7 or 8 are passives and do not count either way.

The result runs from minus 100 to plus 100. It is popular because it is simple, comparable over time and easy to explain to partners.

Firms usually send the question by email or text shortly after a matter closes, sometimes with a short follow-up asking for the reason. Some add it to a longer survey. Either way, the score is only as good as the sample: who is asked, when, and how many reply.

Why it appeals to law firms

Recommendation is how many clients find a solicitor. Prior use by the client or their family (21%) and recommendations from family or friends (18%) were the most common ways consumers chose a legal provider in 2026[2]. A measure built around recommendation speaks directly to where much new work comes from.

NPS also gives a single number that can sit on a management dashboard alongside billing and new matters, which helps keep client experience on the agenda at partner meetings.

It is also easy for clients. One question takes seconds, so response rates tend to be better than for long surveys, and the same question can be asked across every department without rewriting it for each type of work.

Where NPS misleads solicitors

  • Small samples. A department with 25 responses a quarter can swing by 20 points because two or three clients answered differently. The number looks precise but is not.
  • One-off clients. Many clients buy a house or make a will once a decade. 'Would you recommend us' is a reasonable question; 'would you come back' often is not.
  • Outcome bias. A client who lost a dispute may score the firm low however good the service was. A client who won may score it high despite poor communication.
  • High baseline satisfaction. 90% of consumers were satisfied with their provider's service and 91% with the outcome[3]. When nearly everyone is satisfied, a single score struggles to show what to improve.
  • It hides the reason. A score of 6 tells you nothing about whether the problem was cost, delay or a rude phone call.
Satisfaction is high; the gaps are elsewhere, 2026Legal services consumers, England and Wales.
Satisfaction is high; the gaps are elsewhere, 2026Bar chart. Satisfied with the outcome: 91%; Satisfied with the service: 90%; Would have liked to speak to a legal professional more: 17%.Satisfied with the outcomeSatisfied with the outcome: 91%91%Satisfied with the serviceSatisfied with the service: 90%90%Would have liked to speak to a legal professional moreWould have liked to speak to a legal professional more: 17%17%Satisfaction is high; the gaps are elsewhere, 2026Bar chart. Satisfied with the outcome: 91%; Satisfied with the service: 90%; Would have liked to speak to a legal professional more: 17%.Satisfied with the outcomeSatisfied with the outcome: 91%91%Satisfied with the serviceSatisfied with the service: 90%90%Would have liked to speak to a legalprofessional moreWould have liked to speak to a legal professional more: 17%17%

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Satisfied with the outcome91%
Satisfied with the service90%
Would have liked to speak to a legal professional more17%

The more useful signal is often outside the satisfaction figures. 17% of consumers would have preferred to speak to a legal professional more than they did[3], and poor communication was the most common complaint type at the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26[4]. Neither shows up in a single recommendation score.

NPS compared with the alternatives

Six ways to measure client experience and what each is good for
MeasureWhat it tells youBest used forMain weakness
Net Promoter ScoreOverall loyalty and likelihood to recommendA headline trend across the whole firmNoisy with small samples; no reason given
Satisfaction score (1 to 5)How a specific stage or aspect feltChecking a particular change, such as a new update rhythmScores cluster at the top
Effort questionHow easy it was to get things done, such as reaching someoneFinding friction in contact and adminSays little about the legal work
Comment themesWhat clients actually mention, good and badDeciding what to fixTakes time to read and tag
Complaints and chasersWhere service failed badly enough to actSpotting serious problemsLagging; many unhappy clients never complain
Online review ratingPublic reputationMarketing and reassuranceSelf-selected; subject to rules on fake and incentivised reviews

Online reviews come with legal duties. Businesses that publish consumer reviews must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake and concealed incentivised reviews[5], so a review score should never be your only measure.

No single measure does everything. A firm with enough clients can use NPS for the headline trend, a satisfaction or effort question to test specific changes, and comment themes to decide what to fix. A small firm may get most of the value from the open comments alone.

A short scorecard instead of one number

Many firms get more from a small scorecard than from a single headline figure. Four measures, reported together each quarter, show both how clients feel and what to change.

  • Likelihood to recommend, as a rolling twelve-month NPS with the number of responses shown.
  • Ease of reaching the right person, scored 1 to 5.
  • Whether the final cost matched what the client expected, as the share answering yes.
  • The top three themes from comments, with the count for each.

The scorecard fits on one page and gives partners something to act on. If the recommendation score falls, the other three lines usually show why.

Ask at the right moment

Timing changes the answer. Ask on the day of a completion and the score reflects relief. Ask after the final bill and it reflects the bill. Ask three months later and fewer people reply. Choose one moment for each matter type and keep to it, so scores can be compared over time. Avoid asking in the middle of a contested matter, when the score will mostly reflect how the case is going.

If you use NPS, use it well

  1. Always ask why

    Follow the score with one open question: what is the main reason for your score? The comment is worth more than the number.

  2. Report the base

    Show the number of responses next to every score. A score from 12 responses should not be discussed like one from 300.

  3. Use rolling periods

    Report a rolling twelve-month score for small teams to smooth out noise.

  4. Segment carefully

    Split by department where numbers allow, never by individual fee earner on small samples.

  5. Pair it with an action measure

    Track one specific score, such as ease of reaching the right person, alongside NPS so you know what to change.

What to do with detractors

A low score is an invitation. Contact every client who scores 0 to 6 within a few days, ideally by phone and from someone who did not run the matter. Thank them, ask what went wrong and listen. Some will raise a complaint, which should then be handled under the firm's complaints procedure. Others simply want to be heard.

Keep a short log of what detractors say and what the firm did. Over a year, the log usually shows two or three recurring causes. Fixing those does more for future scores than any amount of work on the survey itself.

Worked example

Example: a fictional private client team receives 40 responses in a year. 22 clients score 9 or 10, 12 score 7 or 8, and 6 score between 0 and 6. Promoters are 55% of responses and detractors 15%, so the NPS is 40.

The comments matter more. Four of the six detractors mention slow replies while their fee earner was on holiday; the other two mention the final bill. Neither fact appears in the number. The team's next action is holiday cover, not a campaign to raise the score.

Notice also how fragile the number is. If three of the passives had scored 9 instead of 8, the NPS would rise to nearly 48 without any change in service. With 40 responses, a movement of a few points means very little.

The verdict

NPS is useful as a headline trend for a firm with enough clients to make the number stable, and as a prompt for the question that really matters: why did you give that score? It is not useful as a target for individuals, as a measure for small teams, or as a substitute for reading what clients write.

In short: use it if you have the volume, report it honestly with the number of responses, and spend more time on the comments than on the number. If you do not have the volume, a single open question about what the firm could do better will tell you more.

For the survey itself, see client feedback surveys for law firms. For the most common reasons behind low scores, see response times for client emails and fee-earner holiday cover.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good NPS for a law firm?

There is no reliable public benchmark for UK law firms. Compare your own score over time, on a large enough base, rather than against figures from other industries.

How is NPS calculated?

Subtract the percentage of detractors (scores 0 to 6) from the percentage of promoters (scores 9 or 10). Passives (7 or 8) are left out.

Should individual fee earners have NPS targets?

Usually not. Samples are too small, outcomes affect scores, and targets encourage people to ask only happy clients for feedback.

References

  1. Bain & Company (2026). Measuring your Net Promoter Score (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Competition and Markets Authority (GOV.UK) (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo