Client experience

Recovering a client relationship after a mistake

Service recovery for solicitors: tell the client promptly, apologise without hedging, put things right, check insurer terms and rebuild trust step by step.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. What the rules expect
  2. Silence does not mean the client has moved on
  3. The recovery plan
  4. Matching the response to the mistake
  5. Words that help and words that hurt
  6. Telling your own team
  7. What not to do
  8. When the client complains anyway
  9. Rebuilding trust over the rest of the matter
  10. Learning from it
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • The SRA Code expects you to be honest and open with clients when things go wrong and to explain promptly what happened and its likely impact.
  • Many unhappy clients never complain, so a mistake the client has noticed but not raised is still live.
  • Check your professional indemnity policy before admitting liability, but never let that delay telling the client.
  • A recovery plan has five parts: tell, apologise, fix, compensate where appropriate, and follow up.
  • Record the root cause so the same mistake does not happen on another file.

What the rules expect

The SRA Code of Conduct says solicitors are honest and open with clients if things go wrong, and if a client suffers loss or harm as a result they put matters right where possible and explain fully and promptly what has happened and the likely impact[1]. Service recovery for a law firm starts there. The rest of this guide is about doing it in a way that keeps the client.

Mistakes in legal work range from the trivial, such as a misspelt name on a letter, to the serious, such as a missed limitation date. The approach below scales: the same five parts apply, with more formality and partner involvement as the impact grows.

Silence does not mean the client has moved on

Most unhappy clients do not complain. Among dissatisfied legal services consumers in 2026, the most common response was to do nothing, at 40%[2]. Only 51% said they would know how to complain about a legal service, while 27% were unsure and 22% said they would not[3]. A client who has noticed an error but said nothing may simply be deciding not to come back or recommend you.

Would legal services consumers know how to complain? 2026
Would legal services consumers know how to complain? 2026Stacked bar chart. Would know how: 51%; Unsure: 27%; Would not know: 22%.Would know how: 51% (51%)Unsure: 27% (27%)Would not know: 22% (22%)Would legal services consumers know how to complain? 2026Stacked bar chart. Would know how: 51%; Unsure: 27%; Would not know: 22%.Would know how: 51% (51%)Unsure: 27% (27%)Would not know: 22% (22%)
  • Would know how 51%
  • Unsure 27%
  • Would not know 22%

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Would know how51%
Unsure27%
Would not know22%

When things do reach the Legal Ombudsman, the finding is often against the firm. Evidence of poor service was found in 72% of the complaints it assessed in 2025/26[4]. Early, honest recovery is the cheapest point to intervene.

The recovery plan

  1. Find out exactly what happened

    Before contacting the client, establish the facts: what went wrong, when, who knew, and what the impact is or could be. Keep it brief for small errors, but do not guess.

  2. Check your insurance position

    If the error could give rise to a claim, read your professional indemnity policy's notification and admission terms, and speak to your COLP or risk partner. Do this the same day; it is not a reason to delay telling the client.

  3. Tell the client promptly

    Call them, then confirm in writing. Say what happened, what it means for their matter and what you are doing about it. If they may need independent advice, say so.

  4. Apologise plainly

    An apology for the service failure is not the same as admitting legal liability, and you can make one without hedging. "I am sorry we sent the wrong draft" works; "I regret any inconvenience" does not.

  5. Put it right

    Correct the error, reprioritise the file and give the client a date by which it will be fixed. Assign a named person if the original fee earner is the source of the problem.

  6. Consider a remedy

    For service failures, a fee reduction, waived charges for the corrective work or a goodwill gesture may be appropriate. Explain what it reflects.

  7. Follow up

    Contact the client once the fix is complete and again a few weeks later. Ask whether anything else is worrying them.

Timing matters more than polish. A short, honest call today is better than a perfect letter next week; the full written explanation can follow once the facts are settled.

Matching the response to the mistake

Example severity grid for service recovery; adapt the thresholds to your firm's risk policy
SeverityExampleWho leadsTypical response
MinorWrong date in a letter, quickly correctedFee earnerSame-day call or email, correction, apology
ModerateMissed internal deadline that delays the matter by a weekSupervisorCall, written explanation, revised timetable, no charge for catch-up work
SeriousError that may cause financial lossPartner and COLPInsurer notification check, call, letter, advice to seek independent advice where needed
CriticalMissed limitation or completion failureSenior partner, COLP, insurerAs serious, plus immediate mitigation steps and regular written updates

Words that help and words that hurt

  • Say "we" rather than naming a junior colleague. The client instructed the firm.
  • Name the mistake specifically. Vague apologies sound rehearsed.
  • Explain the impact honestly, including what you do not yet know.
  • Avoid "unfortunately" at the start of every sentence; it shifts blame to fate.
  • Do not over-promise. A date you can meet is better than a fast date you miss.
  • Offer a direct line or named contact for the rest of the matter.

Example call opening: "I am calling because we made a mistake on your file and I want you to hear it from me first. Yesterday we sent the other side an old draft of the settlement terms. We have withdrawn it and sent the right version this morning. I do not believe it affects your position, and I will explain why. I am sorry."

Telling your own team

Clients notice when different people at the firm tell different stories. Once the facts are clear, brief everyone who might speak to the client: the fee earner, assistant, reception and anyone covering leave. Agree one short summary of what happened and what is being done, and who the client should be put through to.

Keep the briefing factual and blame-free. People who expect blame hide near misses, and near misses are the cheapest warnings a firm ever gets.

What not to do

  • Wait for the client to hear about it from the other side, the court or HM Land Registry.
  • Bury the explanation in a routine update email.
  • Ask the client to agree not to complain in return for a fee reduction.
  • Charge for the time spent putting your own mistake right.
  • Change fee earner without explaining why and introducing the new person.
  • Discuss the error with the client's family or other advisers without the client's authority.

Example: a probate application is returned because the fee earner used an out-of-date form, delaying the estate by several weeks. A beneficiary rings to ask why. The supervisor calls the executor the same day, explains the error, confirms the corrected application went in that morning and gives the current expected timescale. The firm does not charge for the corrective work and sends a short written summary the same afternoon.

When the client complains anyway

Recovery does not take away the client's right to complain, and you should not imply that it does. If they want to complain, follow your published procedure and remind them of the Legal Ombudsman route. Early resolution is common: 51% of the complaints the Ombudsman resolved in 2025/26 were settled through early resolution[5], which suggests many disputes can be resolved with a sensible offer and a clear explanation.

For fee-related fallout, the process in bill queries and fee complaints applies.

Rebuilding trust over the rest of the matter

An apology repairs the moment; the next few weeks repair the relationship. Clients watch for proof that the firm now treats their file differently.

  • Increase contact for a while: a short weekly update even where the matter would normally get one a month.
  • Have the supervisor review the next few outgoing documents on the file, and tell the client this is happening.
  • Meet every promised date exactly. A second miss so soon after the first does far more damage.
  • Invite questions directly: "Is there anything on the file you would like me to check?"
  • At the end of the matter, acknowledge the problem briefly in the closing letter and thank the client for their patience.

Over a year, track what happened to clients after a recovery: did they complain, instruct again or recommend the firm? That record shows whether your approach is working better than any single conversation can.

Learning from it

After every moderate or worse mistake, hold a short review. Keep it blame-free so people report near misses as well as errors. Record what happened, the root cause, and one change that would prevent it. Typical changes are a checklist step, a second-pair-of-eyes rule for certain documents, or a diary alert.

Example: a private client team that twice sent a draft will to the wrong address adds a rule that any document containing a client's address is checked against the matter record before sending. The change takes seconds and closes the gap on every file, not just the two that went wrong.

When the matter ends, a careful closing letter helps reset the relationship; see file closure letters and ending the retainer.

Frequently asked questions

Do we have to tell a client about a mistake?

Yes. The SRA Code expects you to be honest and open when things go wrong and to explain promptly what happened and its likely impact[1].

Is an apology an admission of liability?

An apology for a service failure is not the same as admitting legal liability, but check your indemnity policy's admission terms where a claim is possible, and take advice from your COLP or insurer.

Should we reduce the fee after a mistake?

Often, where the client has paid for poor service or corrective work. Explain what the reduction reflects and do not make it conditional on the client not complaining.

Who should call the client?

For minor errors, the fee earner. For anything that affects the outcome, a partner should make or join the call.

References

  1. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (paragraphs 7.11, 8.6 and 8.7) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo