Staffing and training

Recruiting fee earners in a tight market

How smaller UK firms can recruit solicitors and other fee earners: role scorecards, sourcing channels, a fast process, offers that land and retention.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why recruiting fee earners feels harder
  2. Start with a role scorecard
  3. Sourcing channels
  4. Running a process candidates respect
  5. What experienced candidates ask
  6. Making an offer that lands
  7. Budgeting the full cost
  8. Worked example: a fast, structured hire
  9. Keeping the people you hire
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Private practice competes with in-house: in-house solicitors rose 4% to 37,035 in 2024, while partner equivalents fell 2%[1][2].
  • Median full-time pay for solicitors and lawyers was £57,198 in 2026; benchmark offers against it and the local market[3].
  • Write a role scorecard before advertising: the work, the caseload, the targets and what success looks like at twelve months.
  • Speed wins: aim to move from first interview to offer within days, not weeks.
  • Budget the full cost, including employer National Insurance at 15% above £5,000 a year[4].

Why recruiting fee earners feels harder

Many firm owners say they could take on more work if they could find the people to do it. The data explains part of the problem. There were 181,481 practising solicitors in England and Wales at the end of September 2026[5], but they are spread across many kinds of employer. 72% of practising solicitors worked in private practice and 28% in-house in 2024[6], and in-house numbers rose 4% in a year to 37,035[1].

Where practising solicitors worked, England and Wales, 2024
Where practising solicitors worked, England and Wales, 2024Donut chart. Private practice: 72%; In-house: 28%.Private practice: 72%In-house: 28%Solicitors
  • Private practice 72%
  • In-house 28%

Source: The Law Society, 2024[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Private practice72%
In-house28%

Senior capacity is shrinking too. Partner-equivalent solicitors fell 2% to 28,256 in 2024[2]. For a small firm hoping to hire an experienced solicitor who can run a caseload and bring in work, the pool is limited and contested.

Start with a role scorecard

Before writing an advert, write a one-page scorecard. It forces the partners to agree what they need and gives every interviewer the same yardstick.

  1. Purpose: the role in one sentence, such as 'run a caseload of residential conveyancing and supervise two paralegals'.
  2. Work mix: the types of matter and their share of the role.
  3. Caseload and targets: the number of live files expected, chargeable hours or fee targets, and how they will be phased in.
  4. Support: secretarial, paralegal and reception support the person will have.
  5. Supervision: who they report to, and whether they will supervise others.
  6. Outcomes at twelve months: what a successful first year looks like, in two or three concrete statements.
  7. Must-haves and nice-to-haves: limit the must-haves to three or four.

Be honest about targets. Candidates talk to each other, and a target that only the previous post-holder's predecessor ever met will be known.

Sourcing channels

Sourcing channels for fee earner recruitment in smaller firms
ChannelStrengthsWeaknessesBest for
Your own network and referralsTrusted, fast, low costLimited reachAll roles; offer a referral reward to staff
Specialist legal recruitersAccess to passive candidates; screening done for youFees, and candidates may be shown to competitorsSenior or hard-to-fill roles
Job boards and the firm's websiteWide reach, lower costHigh volume of unsuitable applicantsJunior and mid-level roles with clear requirements
Returners and flexible workersExperienced people seeking part-time or flexible rolesNeeds a genuinely flexible offerRoles that can be part-time or remote
Growing your ownLoyalty and knowledge of the firmTakes yearsLong-term pipeline through paralegals and apprentices

Use more than one channel for important roles. A referral and a recruiter often find different people, and the comparison helps you judge the market.

Running a process candidates respect

In a tight market, the firm is being interviewed as much as the candidate. A slow, disorganised process tells an experienced solicitor what working at the firm might be like. Keep it short and predictable: a screening call, one substantive interview with the people they would work with most, a short practical exercise and, if needed, a brief second conversation about the offer. Tell candidates the timetable at the start and stick to it.

Make the practical exercise relevant and brief. A thirty-minute file review, a draft letter of advice or a short discussion of a scenario from your own practice shows more than a list of competency questions, and it gives the candidate a feel for the work. Do not ask for unpaid work that looks like real client work; candidates notice, and it damages the firm's reputation.

Give feedback quickly to everyone, including the people you do not hire. The legal market is small and people move between firms. A candidate who was treated well may apply again, refer a colleague or become a referrer of work.

What experienced candidates ask

  • How realistic is the target, and how many people in the team hit it last year?
  • What support will I have, and who covers when my secretary or paralegal is away?
  • How does the firm win work, and will I be expected to bring my own clients?
  • How flexible is the working pattern in practice, not just in the policy?
  • What does progression to partner look like, and when did someone last make it?
  • What systems does the firm use, and how up to date are they?

Prepare honest answers before the first interview. A firm that answers these clearly, with examples, stands out from one that promises everything and explains nothing.

Making an offer that lands

Pay matters, and so does everything around it. ONS provisional data for 2026 gives a median gross annual pay for full-time solicitors and lawyers of £57,198, and a median hourly rate of £31.50[3][7]. Local markets vary widely, so use those figures as a reference point and check current adverts in your area and practice.

£57,198

median gross annual pay for full-time UK solicitors and lawyers, 2026 (provisional)[3]

  1. Lead with the role

    Open the offer conversation with the work, the team and the scorecard outcomes, then the package.

  2. Be clear on pay and targets

    State base pay, any bonus and how it is calculated, and the target, with any phasing for the first months.

  3. Show the flexibility

    Hybrid working, hours and part-time options are often decisive. State them in writing.

  4. Show the support

    Name the secretary, paralegal or team who will support the hire, and the systems they will use.

  5. Show the future

    Explain the route to senior associate, salaried or equity partner, and what it depends on.

  6. Move fast

    Make the offer within days of the final interview and follow up the same week. Candidates in a tight market rarely wait.

Budgeting the full cost

A hire is a significant commitment. UK legal activities businesses spent £18.2 billion on employment costs in 2024, about 36% of turnover[8]. Employers pay Class 1 secondary National Insurance at 15% on earnings above the £5,000-a-year secondary threshold in 2026/27[4], plus employer pension contributions, practising certificate fees, professional indemnity implications, training and equipment.

Example: a solicitor hired at £60,000 would carry employer National Insurance of 15% on the £55,000 above the threshold, which is £8,250, before pension and other costs. If the role is expected to bill well above its total cost within the first year, the hire makes sense; if billing will take two years to build, the partners need to plan cash flow for that period.

Worked example: a fast, structured hire

Example: a four-partner firm needs an employment solicitor with around five years' experience after the departure of its only specialist. It writes a scorecard: run a caseload of tribunal claims and advisory work for business clients, supervise one paralegal, reach a phased fee target by month nine.

Example, continued: the firm asks staff and contacts for referrals, briefs one specialist recruiter and posts on its own site. Two strong candidates emerge within three weeks. Each has a first interview with two partners and a short practical exercise: reviewing a settlement agreement and explaining it as if to a client. The preferred candidate has a second conversation focused on flexibility and support, and receives a written offer two days later including hybrid working, a named paralegal and the phased target. She accepts within the week. The firm credits the speed and the clarity of the scorecard; a competitor's offer arrived a fortnight later.

Keeping the people you hire

  • Plan the first ninety days: introductions to key clients, referrers and colleagues, and a clear handover of files.
  • Review the scorecard at three months and six months, and adjust targets if the work mix has changed.
  • Give new hires support staff from day one; a fee earner without support will spend the first months on administration.
  • Protect their time from constant interruptions so they can build a caseload.
  • Ask what would make them leave, early and directly, and act on what you hear.

The pipeline matters too. 9,575 new solicitors were admitted in 2024[9], and many firms find that the best long-term answer to a tight market is to develop their own through paralegal and apprenticeship routes.

Protecting fee earners' time includes the phones. Some firms use an AI Employee such as Ava to answer new enquiries and book consultations, so a new hire's diary fills with qualified appointments rather than unscreened calls. For related reading, see the SQE and qualifying work experience, solicitor and paralegal apprenticeships and low-cost ways to retain staff.

Frequently asked questions

How much do solicitors earn in the UK?

The median gross annual pay for full-time solicitors and lawyers was £57,198 in 2026 (provisional)[3]; local markets and practice areas vary widely.

Why is it hard to recruit solicitors into private practice?

In-house roles are growing (up 4% to 37,035 in 2024)[1] and partner-equivalent numbers are falling[2], so experienced people have more choice.

How quickly should a firm make an offer?

Within days of the final interview. In a tight market, slow processes lose candidates.

What does a fee earner cost on top of salary?

Employer National Insurance at 15% above £5,000 a year[4], pension contributions, practising certificate fees, training and equipment.

References

  1. The Law Society (2024). Annual statistics report 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. The Law Society (2024). Annual statistics report 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (HMRC) (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Population of solicitors in England and Wales (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. The Law Society (2024). Annual statistics report 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Office for National Statistics (2024). Non-financial business economy, UK: Sections A to S (Annual Business Survey), Table 16 Section M (opens in a new tab) ↑

  9. The Law Society (2024). Annual statistics report 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo