Staffing and training

Billable hours targets: fair or counterproductive?

When chargeable hours targets help a solicitors firm and when they backfire, the alternatives, and how to set a fairer target with a worked example.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What hours targets are meant to do
  2. The case for hours targets
  3. The case against
  4. Hours compared with other measures
  5. Client service is part of performance
  6. Worked example: setting a fairer target
  7. Fixed-fee teams need different numbers
  8. Linking targets to bonuses without distorting behaviour
  9. Protecting the integrity of time records
  10. Making the change
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Only 31% of legal professionals who manage others say their targets or billable hours were adjusted for management or training time[1].
  • Almost 79% regularly work beyond contracted hours, so an hours target that ignores non-chargeable work pushes the load into evenings[1].
  • Hours targets suit hourly-rate work and capacity planning; they say little about value on fixed-fee matters.
  • A fairer system measures realised fees, file quality and client outcomes alongside hours, and adjusts targets for supervision.
  • Never let a target create pressure to record time that was not worked; that is an integrity issue, not a performance one.

What hours targets are meant to do

A chargeable hours target does three jobs at once. It is a capacity tool, telling the firm how much work a fee earner can carry. It is a pricing input, because hourly rates are set on the assumption that a certain number of hours will be billed. And it is a performance measure, often linked to bonuses and promotion. The trouble starts when one number is asked to do all three.

Staff costs are the largest cost in most firms. UK legal activities businesses spent about 36% of turnover on employment costs in 2024[2], and the 2026 provisional median hourly pay for solicitors and lawyers was £31.50[3]. A firm needs to know that the hours it pays for are turning into fees. Targets are one way of seeing that, but not the only one.

The case for hours targets

  • They are simple, objective and easy to compare across people and months.
  • They link directly to revenue on hourly-rate work, such as commercial litigation, employment and private client advisory work.
  • They show capacity: someone consistently recording far fewer hours than colleagues may need more work, or may be struggling.
  • They support pricing: you cannot set rates sensibly without some idea of recoverable hours.
  • They give junior fee earners a clear, early benchmark while other measures, such as client relationships, are still developing.

Used as one input among several, a target is a reasonable management tool. Firms that drop targets entirely often find they have lost the clearest early warning of capacity problems.

The case against

  • They reward time, not results. A quicker, better solution earns the fee earner less credit than a slower one.
  • They are close to meaningless on fixed-fee work such as conveyancing, wills and many probate matters, where the price is set in advance.
  • They discourage delegation and supervision, because time spent teaching a trainee does not count.
  • They push work into evenings and weekends when non-chargeable tasks are not allowed for.
  • They can create pressure to pad time records, which is a serious integrity and conduct risk.

The supervision point is backed by the evidence. In LawCare's 2025 research, only 31% of people who managed others said their targets or billable hours were adjusted to take account of management or training time[1]. Almost 79% of respondents said they regularly work beyond their contracted hours[1].

Hours and targets in legal work, 2025LawCare, Life in the Law 2025
Hours and targets in legal work, 2025Comparison. Regularly work beyond contracted hours: 79%; Managers whose targets were adjusted for management or training time: 31%.79%Regularly work beyond contracted hoursRegularly work beyond contracted hours: 79%31%Managers whose targets were adjusted formanagement or training timeManagers whose targets were adjusted for management or training time: 31%Hours and targets in legal work, 2025Comparison. Regularly work beyond contracted hours: 79%; Managers whose targets were adjusted for management or training time: 31%.79%Regularly work beyond contractedhoursRegularly work beyond contracted hours: 79%31%Managers whose targets were adjustedfor management or training timeManagers whose targets were adjusted for management or training time: 31%

Source: LawCare, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Regularly work beyond contracted hours79%
Managers whose targets were adjusted for management or training time31%

Workload is also the main cause people give for work-related stress, depression or anxiety, especially tight deadlines and too much pressure or responsibility[4]. A target that ignores the non-chargeable side of the job turns directly into that kind of workload.

Hours compared with other measures

Example: performance measures for fee earners compared
MeasureWhat it tells youWeaknessBest used for
Recorded chargeable hoursEffort and capacityRewards slowness; meaningless on fixed feesHourly-rate teams, capacity planning
Billed and realised feesMoney actually earnedPartly outside the fee earner's controlMost fee earners, quarterly
Lock-up (unbilled work and unpaid bills)Cash disciplineCan push premature billingSenior fee earners and partners
Matters opened and closedThroughput on volume workIgnores complexityConveyancing, wills, debt recovery
File review resultsQuality and complianceSmall samplesEveryone, especially juniors
Client feedback and complaintsService experienceLow response ratesEveryone
Supervision and training deliveredContribution to the teamHard to quantifySupervisors and senior staff

No single measure is fair on its own. The most useful approach combines two or three money and volume measures with one or two quality measures, weighted by the type of work.

Client service is part of performance

An hours target says nothing about whether clients are being kept informed. Yet poor communication was the largest upheld complaint type at the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26, at 25%, followed by delay and failure to progress at 19%[5]. Both are signs of fee earners who are overloaded or chasing the wrong measure. Include a service element, such as complaint themes, client feedback and file review findings on communication, in every fee earner's review.

Worked example: setting a fairer target

Example: Mira is a fictional five-year qualified employment solicitor at a regional firm. The firm's standard target for her grade is 1,200 chargeable hours a year. She also supervises a trainee and a paralegal, runs the firm's monthly employment law updates for clients and covers the duty phone line one day a week.

  1. Start with available hours: contracted hours minus holidays, bank holidays and a sickness allowance.
  2. Deduct agreed non-chargeable work: in Mira's case, about 150 hours a year for supervision, 40 for business development and 30 for the duty line.
  3. Set the chargeable target on what remains, adjusted for realistic recovery: say 980 hours.
  4. Set a realised fees figure that matches, based on her actual rates and the team's historic realisation.
  5. Add two quality measures: file review results and client feedback on her matters.
  6. Review quarterly and adjust if her supervision load changes.

The result is a lower hours number, but a more honest one. Mira's supervisees get the time they need, the firm can still see her capacity and she is not quietly doing supervision on Sunday evenings.

Fixed-fee teams need different numbers

For conveyancing, wills, lasting powers of attorney and most uncontested probate, the fee is set when the matter is opened. Recording time still has value, because it shows which matter types lose money and where a process is slow, but a personal hours target makes little sense. Better measures are matters completed per month at an agreed quality standard, average time from instruction to completion, complaint rates and how many files need rework at review.

If you keep time recording on fixed-fee work, say clearly that it is for pricing and process improvement, not for judging individuals. Otherwise people will either stop recording accurately or start rushing files to keep numbers down.

Linking targets to bonuses without distorting behaviour

The strongest behavioural effect of an hours target comes from what it is tied to. A target that feeds only a quarterly capacity discussion changes little. A target that decides most of a bonus changes a great deal, and not always for the better. Fee earners on hours-driven bonuses are slower to delegate, less keen to train juniors and more likely to hold on to matters that should move to someone cheaper.

If you pay bonuses, build them from more than one measure and cap the share that depends on hours. A common structure gives roughly equal weight to realised fees, quality and contribution, with an hours threshold acting as a gateway rather than the main driver. Contribution can include supervision delivered, know-how shared and help given to other teams during busy periods.

  • Publish the bonus formula so people can see how each measure counts.
  • Use realised fees rather than recorded hours where you can.
  • Include a quality gate: no bonus where file reviews show serious problems.
  • Reward team results as well as individual numbers, so people help each other.
  • Review the formula each year against what actually happened.

Protecting the integrity of time records

Whatever system you use, make one rule absolute: time records must reflect work actually done. Inflated records lead to inaccurate bills, which can mislead clients and breach the duty to act with honesty and integrity. A target that can only be met by padding is a target that needs changing, and partners should say so out loud.

  • Review write-offs and write-ups together, not just recorded hours.
  • Look for patterns, such as identical daily totals or large end-of-month entries.
  • Make it easy to record non-chargeable time, so it is visible and valued.
  • Discuss shortfalls as a capacity question first: is there enough work, or the right work?

Making the change

  1. Map the work

    For each role, list chargeable work, required non-chargeable work and optional contributions.

  2. Choose two to four measures

    Mix money, volume and quality, weighted by work type.

  3. Set targets per person

    Adjust for supervision, part-time hours and roles such as department lead.

  4. Explain the system

    Show staff how each measure is calculated and how it links to pay and promotion.

  5. Review after a year

    Check whether the measures changed behaviour in the way you wanted, and whether complaints, delays or out-of-hours working moved.

Targets feed into reviews, so read this alongside performance reviews for fee earners and support staff and supervising junior staff and trainees. For part-time fee earners, our guide to flexible working requests explains why pro-rata targets matter.

Frequently asked questions

What is a typical chargeable hours target in a UK firm?

It varies widely by firm size, location and work type. Rather than copying another firm's figure, work out available hours, deduct agreed non-chargeable work and set a target the person can meet within contracted hours.

Should supervisors have lower targets?

Yes. Supervision is required work. Reducing a supervisor's personal target to reflect the time it takes makes supervision more likely to happen properly.

Are hours targets useful for fixed-fee work?

Not as a personal measure. Time recording on fixed-fee work is still useful for pricing and process improvement, but measure people on throughput, quality and client outcomes.

How do we stop time padding?

Make it clear that records must reflect work done, review write-offs and patterns, and change any target that can only be met by inflating time.

References

  1. LawCare (2025). Life in the Law 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Office for National Statistics (2024). Non-financial business economy, UK: Annual Business Survey, Table 16 Section M (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Health and Safety Executive (2025). Work-related stress, depression or anxiety statistics in Great Britain, 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo