Staffing and training

Flexible working requests: the current rules

The day-one right to request flexible working, the two-month deadline, the eight business reasons for refusal and what the Employment Rights Act changes.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The right in brief
  2. Who can ask, and how often
  3. Your process as an employer
  4. The eight business reasons, applied to a law firm
  5. Assessing the requests you are most likely to get
  6. Handling a request, step by step
  7. Discrimination risk
  8. What the Employment Rights Act changes
  9. Making flexibility work in practice
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Employees can request flexible working from their first day in a job[1].
  • They can make two statutory requests in any 12-month period, and each must be decided, including any appeal, within two months[2].
  • You must consult the employee before rejecting a request, and a refusal must rest on one or more of eight business reasons[2].
  • The government's timetable lists the Employment Rights Act's flexible working changes for October 2027[3].
  • Tribunal time limits rose from three to six months from 1 October 2026, so a badly handled request can come back much later[3].

The right in brief

All employees have the legal right to request flexible working, and they can make a request from their first day in a job[1]. The right is to ask and to have the request handled properly, not a right to have it granted. An employer can refuse if it has a good business reason[1], but it must deal with the request in a reasonable manner[1] and follow the statutory process.

Flexible working covers more than working from home. A request can be about the number of hours, the times someone works or where they work. In a solicitors firm that typically means part-time hours, compressed weeks, school-hours patterns, staggered start times, term-time working, job shares and hybrid or remote working.

Who can ask, and how often

The statutory right belongs to employees. Workers who are not employees, such as some consultants or agency staff, do not have the statutory right, though nothing stops a firm agreeing flexibility with them. Under the Acas Code of Practice, an employee may make two statutory requests for flexible working within any 12-month period[2].

A statutory request should be in writing and dated, say that it is a statutory request, set out the change asked for and when it should start, and say whether the employee has made a previous request and when. Employees no longer have to explain what effect the change would have on the business, but many still do, and it helps. If a request is badly drafted, ask for the missing detail rather than rejecting it on a technicality.

Your process as an employer

The Acas Code sets the standard tribunals look at. Its core points are short and firm-friendly if you follow them from the start.

  • You must not reject a request without first consulting the employee[2]. A meeting, in person or by video, is the usual way.
  • All requests, including any appeal, must be decided and communicated within two months of when you first receive the request, unless you agree a longer period with the employee[2].
  • If you refuse, the decision must be for one or more of the business reasons set out in law[2], explained in writing.
  • Offer an appeal, even though it is not strictly required, and let someone other than the original decision-maker hear it where possible.
  • Consider alternatives, such as a different pattern or a trial period, before refusing outright.

The eight business reasons, applied to a law firm

The eight statutory business reasons for refusal, with law firm examples
Business reasonHow it might apply in a solicitors firm
The burden of additional costsA request that would need a second paralegal to cover hours the team cannot fund
An inability to reorganise work among existing staffA sole conveyancing assistant whose completion-day tasks cannot be shared
An inability to recruit additional staffNo realistic prospect of recruiting a part-time job share partner locally
A detrimental impact on qualityCourt-facing work that needs same-day continuity on a fast-moving case
A detrimental impact on performanceMissed limitation or completion deadlines if a key person is unavailable on set days
A detrimental effect on ability to meet customer demandReception or call cover that cannot be provided on the requested pattern
Insufficient work during the periods proposedRequested hours that fall when there is little work in that department
Planned structural changesA planned merger or department restructure that will change the role

The reasons are listed in the Acas Code[2]. A tribunal will look at whether the reason you gave was genuine and based on correct facts, so record the facts you relied on at the time. Saying that the role has always been full-time is not a business reason.

Assessing the requests you are most likely to get

Most requests in a solicitors firm fall into a handful of patterns. Each raises different practical questions, and thinking them through in advance makes the consultation meeting more productive.

  • Part-time hours for a fee earner: the main questions are client continuity and supervision. Who picks up an urgent call on the non-working day, and how will the fee earner's target and pay be adjusted pro rata?
  • Compressed hours, such as four longer days: workable for many roles, but watch for fatigue and for a gap in cover on the fifth day, especially around court hearings and completions.
  • School-hours or term-time working: often suits support roles with predictable work. Consider how holiday cover and busy periods such as the end of the tax year or quarter days will be handled.
  • Remote or mostly remote working: check supervision arrangements, confidentiality at home and whether the person's role involves face-to-face client meetings or office-based tasks such as post and scanning.
  • Staggered start and finish times: usually low-risk and can improve phone cover across a longer day, which clients welcome.
  • Job shares: work well when the two people hand over clearly. Agree a shared file note discipline and one point of contact for each client.

For each request, ask the same three questions: what would the client notice, what would colleagues notice and what would it cost. If the honest answers are nothing much, little and not a great deal, the request is very likely to be workable, and refusing it is hard to justify.

Handling a request, step by step

  1. Log the request

    Record the date you received it. The two-month clock starts then.

  2. Arrange a meeting promptly

    Within two to three weeks. Invite the employee to bring a colleague if they wish, even though the Code does not require it.

  3. Explore the request

    Ask how the pattern would work in practice: who covers calls, deadlines and client meetings on the days off.

  4. Look for a workable version

    If the exact request will not work, test alternatives, such as a different day off or a trial period of three months.

  5. Decide and write to the employee

    Confirm the decision, the start date and any trial terms, or the business reason for refusal with the facts behind it.

  6. Hear any appeal

    Use a different decision-maker if you can, and keep within the two-month overall limit unless an extension is agreed.

  7. Update the contract

    An accepted request is usually a permanent change to terms. Issue a written variation.

Example: a fictional conveyancing paralegal asks to work Monday to Thursday. The firm worries about Friday completions. In the meeting, they agree a three-month trial in which the paralegal prepares completion packs by Thursday afternoon and a colleague handles Friday calls. The trial works and the change is confirmed in writing.

Discrimination risk

Many disputes about flexible working are not brought under the flexible working rules themselves, where compensation is limited, but as discrimination claims. Refusing requests from parents, especially mothers, can be indirect sex discrimination if a full-time or office-only requirement cannot be justified. Requests linked to disability may also be requests for reasonable adjustments, which brings a separate and stronger duty under the Equality Act 2010.

  • Treat similar requests consistently across teams and grades.
  • Do not assume senior roles cannot be done part-time; look at the facts.
  • If a request mentions a health condition, consider reasonable adjustments separately.
  • Keep notes of meetings and the facts behind any refusal.

What the Employment Rights Act changes

The Employment Rights Act 2025 reforms the flexible working regime. The government's implementation timeline lists the flexible working measures for October 2027[3]. Under the Act, an employer will only be able to refuse a request where it is reasonable to do so on one of the business grounds, and it will have to explain why it considers the refusal reasonable. Detail will come in regulations and an updated Acas Code.

The tribunal landscape is already changing. The time limit for bringing an Employment Tribunal claim increased from three to six months from 1 October 2026[3]. Tribunals are also busier: single-claim receipts rose 28% year on year in April to June 2026 to 14,000[4].

Employment Tribunal single claims, 2026Ministry of Justice, Tribunal Statistics Quarterly
Employment Tribunal single claims, 2026Comparison. Single claims received, April to June 2026: 14,000; Open single-claim caseload, end of June 2026: 70,000.14,000Single claims received, April to June 2026Single claims received, April to June 2026: 14,00070,000Open single-claim caseload, end of June 2026Open single-claim caseload, end of June 2026: 70,000Employment Tribunal single claims, 2026Comparison. Single claims received, April to June 2026: 14,000; Open single-claim caseload, end of June 2026: 70,000.14,000Single claims received, April toJune 2026Single claims received, April to June 2026: 14,00070,000Open single-claim caseload, end ofJune 2026Open single-claim caseload, end of June 2026: 70,000

Source: Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK), 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Single claims received, April to June 202614,000
Open single-claim caseload, end of June 202670,000

For the rest of the Act's timetable, see our guide to the Employment Rights Act 2025.

Making flexibility work in practice

The firms that handle flexible working best decide in advance what they can offer. A written hybrid or flexible working framework, with patterns people can choose from, means most requests are agreed quickly and only unusual ones need a full process. It also makes decisions more consistent, which lowers discrimination risk.

Flexibility only works if client service holds up. Agree how calls, deadlines and urgent matters are covered on non-working days, and check after three months. Our guides to hybrid working policies and wellbeing and stress in law firms cover the wider picture, and billable hours targets explains how to adjust targets for part-time fee earners fairly.

Frequently asked questions

Is flexible working a day-one right?

Yes. Employees can make a statutory request for flexible working from their first day of employment.

How long do we have to respond to a flexible working request?

Two months from receiving the request, including any appeal, unless you and the employee agree to extend it.

Can we refuse a flexible working request?

Yes, but only for one or more of the eight business reasons, after consulting the employee, and with the facts recorded. Refusals can also raise discrimination risk.

Do we have to offer a trial period?

No, but a trial is often a sensible middle ground when you are unsure whether a pattern will work.

References

  1. GOV.UK (2026). Flexible working (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Acas (2024). Code of Practice on handling flexible working requests (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (Department for Business and Trade) (2026). Plan to Make Work Pay and Employment Rights Act: timeline update (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Tribunal Statistics Quarterly: April to June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo