Staffing and training

Performance reviews for fee earners and support staff

A fair review framework for solicitors firms: separate measures for fee earners and support staff, a template, a conversation plan and sample objectives.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why reviews often fail in law firms
  2. The regulatory angle
  3. One framework, two sets of measures
  4. Client communication in every review
  5. Gathering evidence through the year
  6. A simple review template
  7. Running the conversation
  8. Writing useful objectives
  9. Making reviews fair for part-time and hybrid staff
  10. When performance is a concern
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Solicitors who manage others must make sure the people they manage are competent and keep their knowledge up to date, so reviews are part of regulatory compliance[1].
  • Use one framework for everyone but different measures: fee earners on fees, quality and client care; support staff on accuracy, responsiveness and teamwork.
  • Client communication belongs in every review: poor communication was the largest upheld complaint type at the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26[2].
  • Gather evidence through the year so the annual review holds no surprises.
  • Every review should end with two or three specific objectives and a training plan.

Why reviews often fail in law firms

In many small and mid-sized firms the annual review is a rushed half-hour in December, driven by the hours report and remembered mainly for the pay conversation that follows. Fee earners hear about their numbers. Support staff hear very little. Nobody leaves with a clear idea of what good looks like next year.

A better review does three things. It looks back fairly at the whole job, not just the parts that are easy to count. It looks forward with a small number of specific objectives. And it connects to the firm's regulatory duties on competence, so that training is planned rather than accidental.

The regulatory angle

The SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors requires every solicitor to maintain their competence and keep their professional knowledge and skills up to date[1]. Where solicitors manage others, they must make sure those people are competent to carry out their role and keep their knowledge, skills and understanding of their legal, ethical and regulatory obligations up to date[1]. The Code for Firms puts the same duty on the firm for its managers and employees[3].

Solicitors also make an annual declaration about their continuing competence when they renew their practising certificate[4]. The SRA sets no minimum number of training hours; it expects solicitors to reflect on their practice and address their learning needs[4]. A good review is the natural place for that reflection to happen and be recorded. Our guide to continuing competence and training budgets covers the planning side.

One framework, two sets of measures

Fee earners and support staff do different jobs, but they should feel they are judged by the same principles: quality, client service, contribution to the team and growth. What changes is how each principle is measured.

Example: review principles and how they are measured for each group
PrincipleFee earnersSupport staff
QualityFile review results, rework needed, risk incidentsAccuracy of documents, diary entries and data input
Client serviceClient feedback, complaint themes, response timesCall handling, message quality, courtesy with clients
DeliveryRealised fees, matters progressed, lock-upTurnaround times, workload handled, deadlines met
TeamworkSupervision delivered, help to colleagues, know-how sharedCover for colleagues, flexibility at busy times
GrowthTraining completed, new matter types run, readiness for next gradeNew skills, systems learned, readiness for a wider role

Weight the measures by role. A volume conveyancer might be judged mostly on matters completed and quality. A litigation associate on realised fees, quality and supervision. A legal secretary on accuracy, turnaround and teamwork. Agree the weighting at the start of the year, not at the review.

Client communication in every review

Communication problems drive complaints more than technical mistakes. Poor communication was the largest upheld complaint type at the Legal Ombudsman in 2025/26 at 25%, followed by delay and failure to progress at 19%[2].

Largest upheld complaint types at the Legal Ombudsman, 2025/26Share of upheld complaints
Largest upheld complaint types at the Legal Ombudsman, 2025/26Comparison. Poor communication: 25%; Delay or failure to progress: 19%.25%Poor communicationPoor communication: 25%19%Delay or failure to progressDelay or failure to progress: 19%Largest upheld complaint types at the Legal Ombudsman, 2025/26Comparison. Poor communication: 25%; Delay or failure to progress: 19%.25%Poor communicationPoor communication: 25%19%Delay or failure to progressDelay or failure to progress: 19%

Source: Legal Ombudsman, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Poor communication25%
Delay or failure to progress19%

Clients also want simpler language: 41% of adults who used a legal adviser said communication could be improved by using plain language[5]. Ask reviewers to look at a sample of each person's client letters and emails, and to note whether updates were proactive or only sent when clients chased. For support staff, include how calls and messages were handled, because the first conversation shapes how a client feels about the whole firm.

Gathering evidence through the year

  • File reviews: keep a short note of findings for each person, positive and negative, with the date.
  • Client feedback: pass on compliments and concerns as they arrive and keep a copy for the review.
  • Complaints: record any complaint linked to the person's work, what caused it and what was learned.
  • Numbers: monthly fees, matters opened and closed, lock-up, turnaround times for support work.
  • Peer input: two or three short comments from colleagues who work closely with the person.
  • Self-assessment: ask the person to complete a one-page reflection a week before the meeting.

Quarterly check-ins of 20 to 30 minutes stop the annual review from becoming a memory test. They also mean problems are raised when they can still be fixed.

A simple review template

  1. Part 1: the year in summary

    Three to five sentences from the reviewer on the main achievements and the main area to improve, written before the meeting.

  2. Part 2: measures

    Each agreed measure with the evidence and a rating on a four-point scale: exceeds, meets, partly meets, does not meet.

  3. Part 3: self-assessment

    The person's own reflection on what went well, what was hard and what support would help.

  4. Part 4: objectives for next year

    Two or three specific objectives, each with a measure and a date.

  5. Part 5: learning and development plan

    The training, experience or supervision needed to meet the objectives and stay competent.

  6. Part 6: sign-off

    Both parties sign, and the person can add comments. Pay is discussed separately.

Keep pay out of the review meeting where you can. When the two are combined, people stop listening after the pay figure and the development conversation is lost.

Running the conversation

  1. Start by asking the person how they think the year went.
  2. Agree on the strengths first, with specific examples.
  3. Discuss one or two areas to improve, with evidence, and ask for their view.
  4. Check for anything getting in the way: workload, systems, supervision, health.
  5. Agree objectives together and write them down in the meeting.
  6. Agree the training plan and who will arrange it.
  7. Close by summarising what was agreed and when you will next check in.

Reviewers need some training too. A short session on giving specific feedback, avoiding recency bias and using the rating scale consistently makes a large difference. After reviews are drafted, have partners compare ratings across teams to make sure the same performance gets the same rating.

Writing useful objectives

Objectives should be specific, measurable and within the person's control. Some examples:

  • Fee earner: run five residential leasehold sales without supervision sign-off on the contract pack by June, with no significant file review findings.
  • Fee earner: send a written progress update on every live matter at least monthly, checked through quarterly file reviews.
  • Supervisor: hold a fortnightly one-to-one with each supervisee and complete two file reviews each month.
  • Legal secretary: reduce average turnaround for dictated letters to one working day by March.
  • Receptionist: complete the firm's call-handling training and achieve consistently accurate message notes, checked monthly by the practice manager.

Making reviews fair for part-time and hybrid staff

Reviews can quietly disadvantage people who work part-time or mostly from home. Their work is less visible, they miss informal conversations and their numbers are sometimes compared with full-time colleagues without adjustment. A few rules keep the process fair.

  • Set targets and measures pro rata to contracted hours, and say so in writing.
  • Base ratings on evidence such as file reviews and client feedback, not on how often the reviewer sees the person.
  • Ask reviewers to note examples from the whole year, not just the last few weeks they remember.
  • Check ratings by working pattern each year: if part-time or remote staff are consistently rated lower, find out why.

The same applies to people returning from family leave or long-term sickness. Review them on the period they actually worked, and agree what a fair objective looks like for the months ahead.

When performance is a concern

If someone is not meeting the standard, do not wait for the annual review. Raise it promptly, explain what good looks like, agree support and set a reasonable period to improve. Distinguish capability, where the person cannot yet do the job to the standard, from conduct, where they choose not to. Capability issues usually call for training, supervision and time; conduct issues follow your disciplinary policy and the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures.

Example: a fictional paralegal at a personal injury firm received two client complaints about unreturned calls in a quarter. Her supervisor found she was carrying 40% more files than colleagues after a leaver was not replaced. The review focused on workload first: files were redistributed, a call-back routine was agreed and no further complaints followed. The firm also brought forward its recruitment plans.

Reviews depend on supervision that works day to day. See supervising junior staff and trainees and capacity planning and workload management. For the debate on hours as a measure, see billable hours targets.

Frequently asked questions

How often should law firms hold performance reviews?

An annual review with short quarterly check-ins works well for most firms. The check-ins keep evidence fresh and allow problems to be raised early.

Should support staff have the same review process as fee earners?

Use the same framework and principles, so everyone feels judged fairly, but use measures that fit the role, such as accuracy and turnaround for support staff.

Should pay be discussed in the review meeting?

It is usually better to discuss pay separately, so the review can focus on performance and development.

How do reviews link to SRA continuing competence?

Reviews are a natural place to reflect on learning needs and plan training, which supports the competence declaration solicitors make each year.

References

  1. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Code of Conduct for Firms (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Continuing competence FAQs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo