Technology and AI

When an AI assistant should hand a call to a person

Escalation rules for automated call handling in law firms: trigger categories, an escalation ladder, handover scripts, cover rotas and monitoring.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The handover is the safety system
  2. What people expect
  3. Trigger categories
  4. Liberty calls need a guaranteed route
  5. The escalation ladder
  6. What the caller hears
  7. What the person receives
  8. Cover rotas and out of hours
  9. Preparing the people who take handovers
  10. Err towards handing over
  11. Example: two calls on a Tuesday evening
  12. Monitoring the handover
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

Key takeaways

  • The handover to a person is the most important safety feature of any automated call line.
  • Write triggers in callers' own words across categories: safety, liberty, deadlines, distress, complexity, complaints and a simple request for a person.
  • Use an escalation ladder so an urgent caller always reaches someone, with emergency signposting when nobody can be reached in time.
  • Err towards handing over, and review every escalated call and every call where the caller gave up.

The handover is the safety system

An automated assistant can answer every call, take details and book consultations. What it cannot do is exercise judgement, comfort someone in crisis or take responsibility for a decision. The point at which it hands a call to a person is therefore where most of the risk sits. Get it right and automation improves service; get it wrong and a caller in real difficulty is left talking to a machine.

Good escalation design answers four questions: what should trigger a handover, who receives it, what happens if they are not available, and what the caller hears while it happens. This guide works through each.

What people expect

The public is clear about where automation should stop. In the Legal Services Board's 2026 public panel research, 81% of legal service users agreed that AI legal tools should never act automatically for a vulnerable person in high-stakes situations, with only 14% disagreeing[1]. Some 66% expected an AI legal tool's complaints process to involve a real human[1].

AI legal tools should never act automatically for a vulnerable person in high-stakes situationsLegal Services Board public panel, 2026
AI legal tools should never act automatically for a vulnerable person in high-stakes situationsComparison. Agree: 81%; Disagree: 14%.81%AgreeAgree: 81%14%DisagreeDisagree: 14%AI legal tools should never act automatically for a vulnerable person in high-stakes situationsComparison. Agree: 81%; Disagree: 14%.81%AgreeAgree: 81%14%DisagreeDisagree: 14%

Source: Legal Services Board, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Agree81%
Disagree14%

Earlier research for the Board found lack of human oversight was one of the two main barriers to people using AI to access legal services, cited by 49%[2]. The law points the same way: under the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, significant solely automated decisions require safeguards, including the ability to obtain human intervention[3]. A reliable handover is how a firm shows that people remain in charge.

Trigger categories

Adapt the wording and targets to your practice areas; test every trigger with varied phrasing.
TriggerWhat callers might sayActionTarget
Immediate dangerSomeone is threatening me now; I am scared to go home tonightEmergency signposting, then transfer to a personAt once
LibertyMy son has been arrested; I am at the police stationTransfer to the criminal duty contactAt once
Imminent court or deadlineThe hearing is tomorrow; completion is today and the money has not arrivedTransfer to the team or duty fee earnerWithin minutes
Distress or vulnerabilityCrying, confusion, mentions of self-harm, difficulty understandingStop the script, transfer or urgent call backWithin minutes
Complexity or confusionRepeated misunderstanding; multiple linked mattersOffer a person or a booked callSame day
Complaint or angerI want to complain; this is unacceptableLog, then route to the complaints leadSame day
Existing client, urgentI am a client and something has changed on my matterTransfer to the fee earner or teamWithin the hour
Money and bank detailsCan I check your bank details; I have been sent new detailsRoute to accounts with call-back checksAt once if a payment is pending
Request for a personCan I speak to someone; human pleaseTransfer, or book a call if nobody is freeAt once

Write triggers as examples of what people actually say, not as legal categories. Callers do not say they need emergency protection; they say they are frightened. Include indirect and partial phrasings, and test with callers who are upset, speaking quickly or using a second language.

Liberty calls need a guaranteed route

Police station duty solicitors in England and Wales are available 24 hours a day[4]. If your firm does criminal work, a call about someone at a police station must reach a person or your duty arrangements immediately, at any hour. If your firm does not do criminal work, the assistant should say so straight away and explain that the person at the police station can ask for the duty solicitor, rather than taking details for a call back the next morning.

The escalation ladder

  1. Warm transfer

    The assistant tells the caller it is putting them through, transfers to the named person for that trigger and passes a one-line summary so the caller does not have to start again.

  2. Second contact

    If the first person does not answer within a set time, the call goes to a second named person or the duty fee earner.

  3. Urgent message and call-back promise

    If nobody answers, the assistant takes essential details, tells the caller honestly when they will be called back, and sends an urgent alert by more than one channel.

  4. Emergency signposting

    Where there is a risk to safety, the assistant tells the caller to call 999 if they are in immediate danger, before or alongside any other step.

  5. Follow-up check

    The next morning, a supervisor checks that every urgent alert was picked up and acted on.

What the caller hears

Transferring: “Thank you, that sounds urgent. I’m putting you through to a member of our team now and I’ll pass on what you’ve told me, so you won’t need to repeat it.”

Nobody available: “I haven’t been able to reach anyone straight away. I’ve sent an urgent message to our duty solicitor, who will call you back on this number. If you don’t hear from us within 30 minutes, please call again.” Only promise a time you can keep.

Safety risk: “If you or anyone else is in immediate danger, please hang up and call 999 now. I’m also asking someone from our team to call you back as quickly as possible.”

Request for a person: “Of course. Let me put you through.” Do not ask the caller to justify the request or try to persuade them to continue with the assistant.

What the person receives

  • Why the call was escalated: the trigger and the caller's own words.
  • The caller's name and number, and whether they are an existing client.
  • Any dates, places or names mentioned, such as the police station, court or other party.
  • What the assistant has already said or promised, including any call-back time.
  • Whether the caller was given emergency signposting.

Keep this summary short. The person picking up an urgent call needs to know in five seconds what is happening and what has been said.

Cover rotas and out of hours

A handover is only as good as the person at the end of it. Draw up a rota showing who receives each trigger during office hours, at lunchtime, in the evening and at weekends, with a second contact for each. Keep it in the assistant's configuration and update it when people are on leave. If your firm cannot cover certain triggers out of hours, decide in advance what the assistant says instead, and make sure that wording directs the caller to an appropriate service.

Preparing the people who take handovers

An escalated call arrives with no warning, often outside normal hours and sometimes with a caller who is frightened or angry. Brief everyone on the rota on what an escalated call looks like, how to read the summary quickly, and what to say first. A short opening such as confirming the caller's name and saying that you have the details they gave helps the caller feel heard. Give on-call staff a one-page sheet with emergency numbers, local support services and the firm's own urgent procedures, and make sure they know how to record the outcome so the supervisor's morning check is simple.

Err towards handing over

Every trigger set produces some false alarms and some misses. A false alarm costs a few minutes of someone's time; a miss can leave a frightened caller without help. Set triggers broadly at first and narrow them only when reviews show they fire too often for genuinely routine calls. Callers also generally want more contact, not less: 17% of consumers would have preferred to speak to a legal professional more than they did[5].

Example: two calls on a Tuesday evening

Example (fictional): at 8.10pm a caller tells a family firm's assistant that her ex-partner is outside the house. The assistant tells her to call 999 if she is in immediate danger, then transfers to the on-call solicitor, passing a summary. The solicitor answers within two minutes.

At 8.40pm another caller asks about a divorce and becomes upset. The assistant notices repeated pauses and the words 'I can't cope', offers to arrange a call with a person, and when the caller agrees, sends an urgent call-back request. The duty solicitor calls back within the hour. Both calls are reviewed the next morning: the first worked exactly as designed, and the second leads the firm to add two more distress phrases to its triggers.

Monitoring the handover

  • Number of escalations by trigger, and how many were genuinely urgent.
  • Time from trigger to a person speaking to the caller.
  • Escalations where nobody answered, and how long the call back took.
  • Calls where the caller hung up during the script, reviewed for missed triggers.
  • Complaints or concerns about the automated line.

For the design of the rest of the script, read designing an AI intake assistant. The data protection side is covered in automated call handling and UK GDPR, the website equivalent in AI chat on law firm websites: guardrails, and the line between information and advice in information vs advice: limits for automated tools.

Frequently asked questions

When should an AI phone assistant transfer a call to a person?

When there is a risk to safety, someone's liberty, an imminent hearing or deadline, signs of distress or vulnerability, a complaint, an urgent issue on an existing matter, a payment or bank detail query, or whenever the caller asks for a person.

What if nobody is available to take an urgent call?

The assistant should take essential details, send an urgent alert by more than one channel, tell the caller honestly when they will be called back, and give emergency signposting where there is a safety risk.

Should callers be able to ask for a person at any time?

Yes. A simple request should lead straight to a transfer or a booked call, without the caller having to justify it.

How do we know our escalation rules work?

Review every escalated call and every call where the caller hung up mid-script, measure time to a person, and adjust triggers based on what you find.

References

  1. Legal Services Board (2026). AI in Legal Services: Research Report (LSB Public Panel) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (DSIT) (2025). Data (Use and Access) Act 2025: data protection and privacy changes (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (2026). Being arrested: your rights: legal advice at the police station (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo