Phones and call handling

Automated phone menus vs a human greeting

When a press-1 menu helps a solicitors firm and when a human greeting wins more instructions, with a call-type decision table and a hybrid design to test.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The question behind the choice
  2. Where a press-1 menu genuinely helps
  3. Where a human greeting wins
  4. Decision table by call type
  5. Designing a hybrid that callers tolerate
  6. Where conversational automation fits
  7. Five mistakes that make either option fail
  8. How to measure the change
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • The telephone is still the most common way people talk to their main legal adviser, so the first ten seconds of a call carry real weight[1].
  • Menus work for existing clients, suppliers and known routes; new enquiries and distressed callers do better with a person or a conversational greeting.
  • Trust and human oversight are the main barriers people cite to automated legal help, so any automated route needs an obvious way to a human[2].
  • Keep any menu to one layer and three or four options, and put 'new enquiry' first.
  • Decide by call type, then measure abandonment and instructions before and after the change.

The question behind the choice

Most firms frame this as menu or no menu. The better question is which callers need to be sorted and which callers need to be welcomed. A conveyancing client chasing a completion date wants the right team quickly. A parent who has just been served with a C100 application wants to know that someone competent is listening. One phone line carries both, and the greeting has to work for each of them.

The channel still matters. In the Legal Services Board's Legal Needs Survey, the telephone was the most common way people communicated with their main adviser on a contentious issue, at 28%, just ahead of face to face and email[1]. When people choose a lawyer, many also move fast: 69% of consumers took a week or less to choose a provider[3]. A caller who meets a confusing menu in that window has plenty of other firms to try.

28%

of people with a contentious issue talked to their main adviser mainly by telephone, the most common method[1]

Where a press-1 menu genuinely helps

Menus are a routing tool. They earn their place when the firm has distinct teams with their own phones, when a large share of calls come from people who already know where they are going, and when reception would otherwise spend the day transferring calls.

  • Existing clients and their agents who want a named team, such as residential conveyancing or the private client department.
  • Accounts and supplier calls that should never reach a fee earner's line.
  • A dedicated urgent route, such as a crime line, that must bypass everything else.
  • Multi-office firms where callers want a particular branch.
  • Out-of-hours periods, when the menu can offer the urgent route and a message option instead of ringing an empty office.

Even then, the menu should be short. Callers remember three or four options at most, and every extra layer is another place to give up. If the team structure needs more than four choices, the structure is probably too detailed for a phone menu and belongs on the website or in a direct-dial list.

Where a human greeting wins

New enquiries are where menus cost the most. A first-time caller often does not know which department handles their problem. 'Press 3 for dispute resolution' means little to someone whose builder has walked off the job. They guess, land in the wrong queue, or hang up. A person, or a conversational greeting that asks what the call is about in plain words, can sort the matter without asking the caller to understand your org chart.

Distressed callers are the second group. Family, crime, employment and bereavement matters often start with a call made under pressure. A recorded list of options at that moment can feel cold, and plain language is something clients notice: 41% of adults who used a legal adviser said communication could be improved by using plain language[1].

Automation is not ruled out for these callers, but it has to earn trust. When the Legal Services Board asked about barriers to using AI to access legal services, the top answers were lack of trust in the technology and lack of human oversight[1]. In its separate AI panel research, 66% of legal service users expected a complaints process for an AI legal tool to involve a real human[2].

Main barriers to using AI to access legal servicesAdults in England and Wales, Legal Needs Survey 2023
Main barriers to using AI to access legal servicesBar chart. Lack of trust in AI technology: 51%; Lack of human oversight: 49%.Lack of trust in AI technologyLack of trust in AI technology: 51%51%Lack of human oversightLack of human oversight: 49%49%Main barriers to using AI to access legal servicesBar chart. Lack of trust in AI technology: 51%; Lack of human oversight: 49%.Lack of trust in AI technologyLack of trust in AI technology: 51%51%Lack of human oversightLack of human oversight: 49%49%

Source: Legal Services Board, 2024[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Lack of trust in AI technology51%
Lack of human oversight49%

The practical reading is simple. Whatever answers first, the caller must hear early that a person at the firm will deal with the matter, and must be able to reach one when they need to.

Decision table by call type

Matching the greeting to the call: a starting point for a small or mid-sized firm
Call typeBest first touchWhyWatch out for
New enquiry, any practice areaPerson or conversational greetingCaller cannot name the department; first impression drives instructionLong hold before anyone speaks
Existing client chasing progressShort menu to the team, then a personThey know the team and want it quicklyMenu that sends them back to reception
Estate agent or brokerMenu option or direct dialHigh volume, routine updatesAgents taking fee-earner time with no fixed update point
Urgent crime or familyDedicated number or first menu optionTime-critical, often out of hoursUrgent route buried under general options
Supplier, accounts, salesMenu option or emailShould never reach fee earnersSales callers choosing 'new enquiry' to get through
Vulnerable or distressed callerPerson, with a fallbackNeeds reassurance and plain languageMenus with no zero-out option

Most firms end up with a hybrid: a person or conversational greeting for the main number, a short menu for existing clients, and separate numbers for the urgent work that cannot wait.

Designing a hybrid that callers tolerate

  1. Open with the firm name and a promise

    'Thank you for calling Example Solicitors. If this is a new enquiry, stay on the line and we will take your details now.' New callers hear their route first and do nothing.

  2. Offer one layer, three or four options

    For example: 1 for an existing matter, 2 for the crime line, 3 for accounts. Put the most time-critical route where people expect it and say it clearly.

  3. Always allow a way out

    Pressing 0, or saying nothing, should reach a person or a message taker. Never loop a caller back to the start.

  4. Keep the recording short

    Aim for a greeting that is finished in well under half a minute. Cut marketing lines, awards and website plugs.

  5. Use the same words as your website

    If the website says 'Wills, trusts and probate', the menu should too. Mismatched labels create wrong-queue calls.

  6. Test from a mobile, at lunchtime and after hours

    Ring the number yourself in the conditions callers face, and listen to the whole journey, including what happens when nobody answers.

Example: a six-solicitor firm in Leeds replaced a five-option menu with a single prompt for existing clients and a live greeting for everyone else. Reception took slightly more calls, but wrong-department transfers fell and new callers no longer had to choose between 'property' and 'dispute resolution' for a boundary problem.

Where conversational automation fits

There is a middle option between a keypad menu and a receptionist: a greeting that asks callers to say what the call is about and routes or takes details accordingly. The SRA has noted that legal chatbots can respond quickly to enquiries from potential clients and gather information and triage cases, potentially around the clock[4]. The same regulator is clear that firms remain responsible for what any AI tool they use tells clients[4].

An AI Employee such as Ava sits in this space: it answers in a natural voice, asks the firm's approved intake questions, routes urgent matters through an escalation tree the firm sets, and hands over a structured note. Whether that suits your firm depends on the same test as any menu: does the caller feel heard, can they reach a person, and does the firm see a clean record of what was said?

  • Approve every phrase the automated greeting uses, including how it says it cannot give legal advice.
  • Set escalation rules for urgent and vulnerable callers before go-live, not after the first complaint.
  • Tell callers early that they are speaking to an automated assistant.
  • Review a sample of call records every week for the first month.

Five mistakes that make either option fail

  1. A live greeting with nobody free to give it. If reception is also the cashier, the post room and the conflict checker, a human-first design becomes a ringing phone. Plan cover before you remove the menu.
  2. Menu options named after internal teams. 'Private client' and 'commercial property' mean something to staff, not to callers. Use the words a client would use, such as 'wills and probate' or 'renting out a shop'.
  3. No route for the opponent or the court. Calls from the other side's solicitors and court staff need to reach the right fee earner quickly; give them a direct-dial list rather than a menu guess.
  4. Different greetings on different lines. A firm with three numbers on its website, each with its own recording, sounds disorganised. Use one script, with small changes for each number.
  5. Nobody owning the recording. Greetings mention a closed office, a departed partner or an old opening time for months. Put a named person in charge and review it every quarter.

How to measure the change

Before changing the greeting, pull four weeks of call data from your phone system: total inbound calls, calls abandoned before answer, calls abandoned in the menu, and transfers per call. Pair that with your enquiry log so you can see new enquiries and instructions by source.

Run the new design for at least four weeks and compare like with like, avoiding bank holiday weeks and the first days after a marketing push. Listen to a handful of recordings each week, if you record calls, and ask new clients at engagement how easy it was to get through. A greeting that lifts instructions while cutting transfers is worth keeping; one that only shortens the receptionist's day is not.

Related reading: the pros and cons of designing IVR menus callers tolerate and overflow call handling options.

Frequently asked questions

Should a small law firm have a phone menu at all?

Only if it routes calls that reception would otherwise transfer all day. Many firms with one reception desk do better with a live greeting and a short menu for existing clients only.

How many options should a solicitors phone menu have?

One layer with three or four options. Put new enquiries first or let new callers stay on the line, and always allow a way to reach a person.

Do callers mind automated greetings?

They mind being stuck. Research for the Legal Services Board found trust and human oversight are the main concerns about AI in legal services, so automation needs a clear route to a human[1].

Can an automated greeting give legal advice?

It should not. Use approved wording that makes clear the call is an enquiry, not advice, and that a solicitor will review the matter. The firm stays responsible for what the tool says[4].

References

  1. Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Services Board (2026). AI in Legal Services: Research Report (LSB Public Panel) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2023). Risk Outlook report: The use of artificial intelligence in the legal market (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo