Key takeaways
- Keep the menu to three or four options, one level deep, with a way to reach a person at any point.
- Name options by the caller's situation, not the firm's department names.
- Put urgent routes first, such as someone at a police station, and send new enquiries somewhere that is always answered.
- Measure what callers press and where they hang up, and cut any option that few people use.
Why menus go wrong at law firms
A phone menu, or IVR, is meant to get callers to the right person faster. At many firms it does the opposite: a long welcome, six options named after departments, a second menu inside the first and no obvious way to speak to anyone. Callers who are anxious about a legal problem are the least patient audience there is for that experience.
Department names are a particular problem because many callers do not know how legal work is divided. 38% of adults in England and Wales have a low level of legal confidence, and 47% are unsure how accessible lawyers are[1]. Asking someone in that position to choose between 'litigation' and 'private client' is asking them to guess. The cost of a bad menu is mostly silent: among dissatisfied legal services consumers, the most common response was to do nothing at all, at 40%[2]. Callers who give up on a menu rarely complain; they ring another firm.
- Did nothing about it 40%
Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Did nothing about it | 40% |
Design rules
- Three or four options at most. If you need more, the firm probably needs fewer routes, not a longer menu.
- One level only. No menus inside menus.
- A route to a person from the first moment: 'or stay on the line to speak to reception'.
- Plain words that describe the caller's situation, not the firm's structure.
- The most urgent route first, then new enquiries, then existing clients.
- A welcome of one sentence. No marketing, no 'please listen carefully as our options have changed', no reading out the website address.
- Every option ends with a person or a monitored queue that overflows to reception, never at an unmonitored voicemail box.
- A different, shorter message out of hours that tells callers what happens next and how to get urgent help.
Plain-English option names
| Department name | Plain-English option | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Conveyancing or residential property | Buying, selling or remortgaging a home | Most callers will recognise themselves in this |
| Private client | Wills, estates after a death, or powers of attorney | 'Private client' means nothing to most callers |
| Family | Separation, divorce or arrangements for children | Keep it gentle; some callers are distressed |
| Employment | A problem at work, or a business with an employee issue | Covers employees and employers in one option |
| Litigation or dispute resolution | A dispute with a person or business | Avoid 'litigation'; many callers are not yet in court |
| Crime | Someone arrested or at a police station | Put this first if the firm does criminal work |
| Accounts | Paying a bill | Usually better as a secondary option or handled by reception |
Combine where you can. A small firm rarely needs a separate option for every team. 'New enquiry' and 'existing matter' can be enough, with reception asking the rest. Calls about an existing matter are often better routed by matter number or the fee earner's name than by department.
Sample menus
Example for a general practice without criminal work: 'Thank you for calling [firm name]. If you're calling about something new, press 1. If we're already helping you, press 2. For anything else, or to speak to reception, please stay on the line.'
Example for a firm with a criminal team: 'Thank you for calling [firm name]. If someone has been arrested or is at a police station, press 1 now. If you're calling about something new, press 2. If we're already helping you, press 3. Otherwise, stay on the line for reception.'
Example out of hours: 'Thank you for calling [firm name]. Our office is closed and reopens at 9am on [day]. If someone is at a police station, press 1 for our on-call solicitor. If anyone is in danger, please hang up and call 999. To leave a message for a callback when we reopen, press 2. You can also contact us through our website.'
The police station route deserves its place at the top where it applies. Police station duty solicitors in England and Wales are available 24 hours a day[3], so a firm that does criminal work and buries its on-call number behind three menu levels is sending callers to the duty scheme by default. If the firm does not do criminal work, leave the option out rather than offering a dead end.
Where each option should end
A good menu is only as good as what happens after the caller presses a number. Design the destinations at the same time as the words.
- New enquiries: a queue answered by the enquiry owner or reception, overflowing to a second person, and only then to a voicemail that is checked hourly. This is the call the firm most needs to answer.
- Existing matters: the fee earner's team, with the assistant as backup. If neither answers within a set time, the call returns to reception, who takes a full message.
- Urgent routes: a person, always, including out of hours where the firm offers it.
- Reception: the default for anyone who presses nothing or presses the wrong key.
Difficulty getting through is a real frustration for some clients: 16% of conveyancing clients cited difficulty contacting their provider as a barrier to complaining[4]. A menu that ends in an unanswered extension or a full mailbox makes that worse and creates the complaint the firm was trying to avoid.
Queue messages and hold time
Once a caller has chosen an option, the wait in the queue is part of the menu experience. Most firms play hold music with an occasional 'your call is important to us', which callers hear as a sign that it is not. A few small changes make the wait more tolerable and reduce hang-ups.
- Tell callers early, and once only, that they can stay on the line or press a key to leave their name and number for a callback.
- If your system can announce position in the queue or an estimated wait, use it. Uncertainty is harder to bear than a known wait.
- Keep any recorded messages in the queue useful, such as where to find price information or what to have ready for the call, and no more than one or two.
- Set a maximum time in any queue, after which the call goes to reception or a callback option rather than waiting indefinitely.
- Choose music that is quiet and neutral, and check it plays cleanly over a mobile connection.
Review queue times for each option with the other phone measures every month. A menu that routes well but leaves callers waiting several minutes in one queue has simply moved the problem to a different place.
Designing and testing your menu
Count what people call about
For two weeks, ask reception to tally the reason for every external call. The top three or four reasons become the menu options; everything else goes to reception.
Write the words aloud
Draft the menu and read it aloud at normal speed. If it takes longer than about fifteen seconds before the first option, cut the welcome.
Test with outsiders
Ask a few people who do not work at the firm to call with a made-up problem and say which option they would choose. If they hesitate, change the words.
Record in a real voice
Use a clear, calm recording, ideally from a member of the team, at a steady pace. Re-record when anything changes rather than adding notes on the end.
Measure and adjust
After a month, check how often each option is chosen, where callers hang up and how quickly each queue answers. Cut options that few people use and fix any queue where callers wait too long.
Some firms decide after testing that they do not need a menu at all. A small firm whose receptionist answers quickly may serve callers better with a human greeting and no options. The trade-offs are covered in automated phone menus vs a human greeting. Whichever you choose, check answer times with how quickly a law firm should answer its phones, and plan for the gaps in lunchtime and holiday phone cover.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Reading out every department because each partner wants their team named.
- Hiding the option to speak to a person at the end, or offering none.
- Asking callers to enter a matter number they do not have to hand, with no alternative.
- Playing a recorded message about the firm's awards or website while callers wait in a queue.
- Leaving the holiday message running after the office has reopened.
- Changing the menu without telling reception, so staff cannot explain to callers what they will hear.
Frequently asked questions
How many options should a law firm phone menu have?
Three or four at most, in a single level, with a way to reach a person at any point by staying on the line.
What should the first option be?
The most urgent route the firm offers, such as someone arrested or at a police station for firms with a criminal team. Otherwise, new enquiries usually go first.
Should law firms name departments in their phone menu?
Use plain descriptions of the caller's situation instead, such as 'buying, selling or remortgaging a home' rather than 'conveyancing'.
How do we know if our phone menu is working?
Check how often each option is chosen, where callers hang up and how quickly each queue answers. Cut little-used options and fix slow queues.
References
Legal Services Board (2024). Legal Needs Survey 2023: Summary report (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Being arrested: your rights: Legal advice at the police station (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑