Key takeaways
- Start with evidence of demand in your area before costing anything; national trends are a prompt, not proof[1].
- Split costs into fixed and variable, and work out the contribution each matter makes after variable costs.
- Break-even volume is fixed costs divided by contribution per matter; break-even time adds ramp-up and lock-up.
- Cost the team fully, including employer National Insurance and rising pay for support roles[2].
- Agree in advance what result would justify continuing, and what would trigger a rethink.
The question partners need answered
A new practice area is an investment. The firm hires or redeploys people, spends on marketing and systems, and waits for matters to arrive, complete and be paid for. Break-even analysis answers two questions before the commitment is made: how many matters a month the new team needs to cover its costs, and how long it will take to reach that level and earn back the money spent getting there.
It will not predict the future, but it turns a discussion about whether a department 'feels right' into one about specific assumptions that can be tested, challenged and tracked once the team is running.
Start with demand
National figures can show where demand is growing. Single-claim Employment Tribunal receipts rose 28% year on year in April to June 2026, to 14,000, and the open single-claim caseload reached 70,000 at the end of June 2026, up 51% in a year[1]. In the family courts, new cases rose 1% in the same quarter, driven by private law cases, up 11%[3].
Those trends are a reason to look, not a reason to hire. Test local demand directly: count enquiries the firm already turns away for that type of work, ask referrers such as accountants and other firms what they see, check how many local competitors offer the service and how they price it, and look at search interest for the service in your area. Local firms have a strong base to build on: 59% of consumers who used a lawyer said they used a small local firm[4].
Fixed costs and variable costs
Split every cost into one of two groups. Fixed costs are incurred whether the department handles one matter or fifty: salaries of the core team, a share of premises, software licences, insurance uplift, marketing and supervision time. Variable costs rise with each matter: case-specific software charges, search fees and other disbursements not recharged, outsourced work and any per-matter referral or lead costs that are permitted.
Most of the cost of a new legal team is fixed, because it is people. That is why volume matters so much, and why ramp-up is the riskiest period.
Costing the team fully
Use realistic pay, not hopes. ONS provisional figures for 2026 put median gross annual pay for full-time solicitors and lawyers at £57,198, legal associate professionals such as paralegals at £37,148 and legal secretaries at £27,824[5]. Local rates and specialisms vary, so check recruiter data for your area and the seniority you need.
Add employer costs. Class 1 secondary National Insurance is 15% on earnings above the £5,000 secondary threshold in 2026/27, and eligible employers can reduce their total bill by up to £10,500 a year through the Employment Allowance[2]. Add pension contributions, recruitment fees, training and the supervising partner's time.
Support pay is rising too. The National Living Wage for workers aged 21 and over rose from £12.21 to £12.71 an hour in April 2026 and is due to reach £13.21 from April 2027[6], which pushes up pay scales for junior support roles above it.
Source: GOV.UK, 2026[6]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| April 2025 | £12.21 |
| April 2026 | £12.71 |
| April 2027 | £13.21 |
Contribution per matter
Contribution is what each matter leaves after its variable costs, available to pay fixed costs and then profit. For a fixed-fee service it is the fee less variable costs. For hourly work, use the average fee you expect to collect per matter, based on comparable work, less variable costs. Be conservative: new teams tend to price low to win early work, and early matters often take longer while processes settle.
The break-even calculation
- Monthly fixed costs: total the annual fixed costs of the department and divide by twelve.
- Contribution per matter: expected fee collected less variable costs.
- Break-even volume: monthly fixed costs divided by contribution per matter gives the completed, paid matters needed each month.
- Time to break even: add how long it takes to build volume to that level, plus the delay between opening a matter and being paid for it.
- Payback: add up the monthly losses before break-even to see how much the firm invests before the department starts repaying it.
A worked example
| Item | Example value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Team | One solicitor, one paralegal, half a secretary | Employment department |
| Annual fixed costs | £186,000 | Pay, employer costs, share of premises, software, marketing, supervision |
| Monthly fixed costs | £15,500 | Annual figure divided by twelve |
| Average fee collected per matter | £1,400 | Mix of settlement agreements and claims |
| Variable cost per matter | £150 | Unrecovered disbursements and per-matter software |
| Contribution per matter | £1,250 | Fee less variable cost |
| Break-even volume | 13 matters a month | £15,500 divided by £1,250, rounded up |
Example: if the fictional team starts at 4 completed matters a month and adds 1 a month, it reaches 13 in month ten. Allow two more months for payment, and cash break-even arrives around month twelve. The monthly shortfalls before then add up to the firm's investment, which the department must repay from its surplus once above break-even.
Ramp-up and cash
Ramp-up is where most new departments struggle. Marketing takes months to work, referrers need time to trust a new team, and matters opened in month one may not be billed and paid until month four or later. Model cash month by month, not just profit, and agree with the bank or partners how the investment will be funded.
Build a monthly model
Show matters opened, completed and paid each month, alongside costs, for at least two years.
Use realistic lock-up
Apply the firm's own average time from opening to payment for similar work.
Test the assumptions
Ask partners and the new hire to challenge fees, volumes and costs before approval.
Set milestones
Agree monthly targets for enquiries, instructions and completed matters for the first year.
Review monthly
Compare actuals with the model and update the forecast, not just the explanation.
Lower-risk ways to start
A full team on day one gives the highest fixed costs and the longest payback. Alternatives can test demand before the firm commits. An existing fee earner with relevant experience can take on the new work part time, with their other work reallocated. A paralegal can handle routine stages under an existing partner's supervision. A consultant solicitor paid on a share of fees can bring a client following with lower fixed costs, provided supervision and insurance are in place.
Each option changes the model: fewer fixed costs, often a lower contribution per matter, and a different risk of losing the key person. Run the numbers for each before choosing, and plan the point at which the firm would move from the trial set-up to a permanent team.
Marketing within the rules
Marketing spend is usually a large share of the launch budget, and it must stay within the SRA's rules. Solicitors must not make unsolicited approaches to members of the public, other than current or former clients, to advertise legal services[7], so cold calling and doorstep campaigns are out. Budget instead for referrer relationships, search visibility, content that answers what local clients ask, and telling existing clients that the new service exists.
Test the sensitivity
- What if the average fee is lower than planned, for example because early matters are smaller?
- What if volume grows more slowly, or conversion of enquiries is lower than in the firm's other departments?
- What if the key hire leaves in year one?
- What if lock-up is longer than assumed?
- What if a rival opens a similar service nearby?
Run each scenario through the model. If one plausible change pushes break-even beyond the firm's appetite, either reduce the fixed costs at launch, for example by starting with a paralegal supervised by an existing partner, or set a firmer review point.
Decide what success looks like
Before launch, agree three things in writing: the milestones that show the department is on track, the review dates at which partners will decide, and the result that would trigger a rethink. That keeps the conversation about evidence rather than loyalty to the idea. For pricing the new service, see how to price fixed-fee legal services; for checking its matters once running, see matter profitability analysis; and for the value of clients over time, see lifetime value of a law firm client.
Frequently asked questions
How do you calculate break-even for a new legal department?
Divide monthly fixed costs by the contribution each matter makes after variable costs. That gives the paid matters needed each month. Then add ramp-up time and the delay between opening matters and being paid.
How long does a new practice area take to break even?
It depends on fixed costs, fees, how quickly volume builds and how long matters take to be paid. Build a monthly cash model for at least two years rather than relying on a rule of thumb.
What costs should be included?
Salaries, employer National Insurance and pension, recruitment, training, supervision time, a share of premises, software, insurance and marketing, plus variable costs per matter such as unrecovered disbursements.
How can a firm reduce the risk of a new department?
Test local demand first, start with a smaller team supervised by an existing partner, set milestones and review dates, and run scenarios for lower fees, slower growth and the loss of a key hire.
References
Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Tribunal Statistics Quarterly: April to June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (HMRC) (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Ministry of Justice (GOV.UK) (2026). Family Court Statistics Quarterly: April to June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rates (opens in a new tab) ↑
Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑