Finance and metrics

Matter profitability analysis

How to measure profit by matter type and fee earner in a solicitors firm: cost per hour, overhead allocation, a worked example and what to do with results.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why measure profit by matter
  2. The basic calculation
  3. Step by step
  4. Building a cost per hour
  5. Allocating overheads
  6. A worked example
  7. Getting the data you need
  8. Open matters and early warnings
  9. Clients as well as matters
  10. Fixed fees make this essential
  11. Looking at fee earners fairly
  12. What usually drives losses
  13. Acting on the results
  14. Frequently asked questions
  15. References

Key takeaways

  • Firm-wide profit hides matter types that lose money; measure profit at matter level, then group by type and team.
  • Build a cost per hour for each grade from salary, employer costs and chargeable hours[1].
  • Choose one overhead allocation method, keep it stable and refine it only when the results are being used.
  • With most consumer work on fixed fees, matter profitability is the only reliable test of a price[2].
  • Use results to reprice, redesign, delegate or stop; never just to rank fee earners.

Why measure profit by matter

Most firms know whether they made a profit last year. Far fewer know which kinds of matter made it. A healthy overall figure can hide one practice area that subsidises another, a fixed-fee product that loses money on every third file, or a client whose work is always written down. Matter profitability analysis looks at the result of each matter, then adds them up by type, team and fee earner to find where profit is made and lost.

The cost base explains why it matters. UK legal activities businesses had turnover of £50.7 billion in 2024 and spent £18.2 billion on employment costs, about 36% of turnover[3]. Because people are the biggest cost, profit depends on how their time is spent on each matter and whether that time is paid for.

UK legal activities: turnover and employment costs, 2024 (£)ONS Annual Business Survey, SIC 69.1
UK legal activities: turnover and employment costs, 2024 (£)Comparison. Turnover: 50.7 billion; Employment costs: 18.2 billion.50.7 billionTurnoverTurnover: 50.7 billion18.2 billionEmployment costsEmployment costs: 18.2 billionUK legal activities: turnover and employment costs, 2024 (£)Comparison. Turnover: 50.7 billion; Employment costs: 18.2 billion.50.7 billionTurnoverTurnover: 50.7 billion18.2 billionEmployment costsEmployment costs: 18.2 billion

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2024[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Turnover50.7 billion
Employment costs18.2 billion

The basic calculation

For each completed matter, profit is the fees collected, less the cost of the time spent by everyone who worked on it, less any disbursements that were not recovered, less a share of overheads. The result can be shown as a sum and as a margin: profit divided by fees collected.

Use collected fees, not billed fees, so that bad debts and credit notes show up where they belong. Use completed matters for the main analysis, because open matters carry WIP whose final value is uncertain, and look at open matters separately to spot problems early.

Step by step

  1. Pick the matter types

    Start with three to five types that make up most of the firm's volume, such as residential purchases, wills, uncontested probate and employment settlement agreements.

  2. Gather the data

    For each completed matter in the last year: fees collected, hours by fee earner, unrecovered disbursements and the dates opened and closed.

  3. Cost each hour

    Work out a cost per chargeable hour for each grade or person, as below.

  4. Allocate overheads

    Choose one method for spreading non-staff costs and apply it to every matter.

  5. Calculate and group

    Work out profit and margin per matter, then the average and spread by type, team and fee earner.

  6. Investigate the outliers

    Look at the least profitable tenth of each type and find out what they have in common.

Building a cost per hour

For each fee earner or grade, add up salary, employer National Insurance, pension and other benefits, then divide by chargeable hours actually recorded. Employer National Insurance is charged at 15% on earnings above the £5,000 secondary threshold in 2026/27, and eligible employers can reduce their bill by up to £10,500 through the Employment Allowance[1]. For a sense of scale, median gross annual pay for full-time solicitors and lawyers was £57,198 in 2026 and for legal associate professionals £37,148[4].

Include support staff time. If secretaries and assistants work on matters but do not record time, allocate their cost to the teams they support, in proportion to fee earner hours, so their cost is not hidden in overheads.

Allocating overheads

Common ways to allocate overheads in matter profitability
MethodHow it worksAdvantagesDrawbacks
Per chargeable hourTotal overheads divided by total chargeable hours, added to each hourSimple; matches effortTreats every hour as using the same resources
Per matterOverheads divided by number of matters, added to eachReflects fixed admin per filePenalises low-value, high-volume work
By departmentOverheads assigned to departments by space, headcount or systems usedFairer between teamsMore work to set up and maintain
Contribution onlyNo overhead allocation; profit is fees less direct costsClear and uncontroversialHides whether the contribution covers overheads

Start with the per-hour method or contribution only. Both are easy to explain and give useful comparisons between matter types. Refine the method once partners are using the results to make decisions, and change it rarely so trends remain comparable.

A worked example

Example matter profitability for a fictional firm; figures are illustrative
Matter typeAverage fee collectedAverage cost of timeAverage overhead shareAverage margin
Residential purchase£1,100£620£19026%
Simple will£300£160£6027%
Uncontested probate£2,800£2,100£5206%
Settlement agreement£600£250£8045%

Example: in this fictional firm, probate looks healthy on fee income but earns a thin margin because matters take far longer than the fee assumes. Investigation shows the least profitable probate files share two features: estates with many small accounts, and long waits for information from beneficiaries. The firm adds an assumption and a supplement for estates above a set number of accounts, and introduces a checklist for beneficiaries at the first meeting.

Getting the data you need

The analysis is only as good as the time records behind it. If fee earners do not record time on fixed-fee matters, or record it in large blocks at the end of the week, the cost side will be understated and every product will look more profitable than it is. Before the first analysis, agree that time is recorded on every matter, fixed fee or not, and that support staff time is captured or allocated.

Most practice management systems can export fees, time and disbursements by matter into a spreadsheet. Start there rather than buying a new tool. A simple spreadsheet with one row per completed matter and columns for fees collected, hours by grade, cost of time, disbursements written off and overhead share is enough to answer the important questions.

Open matters and early warnings

Completed matters tell you what happened; open matters tell you what is happening. For each open fixed-fee matter, compare the cost of time so far with the fee, and flag any that have used most of the fee while still at an early stage. For hourly matters, compare time recorded with the latest estimate given to the client. These flags give supervisors a chance to act before the loss is locked in, by resetting the estimate with the client, moving work to a more junior grade or agreeing a priced extra.

Clients as well as matters

For business clients and repeat private clients, add matter results up by client as well. A client whose individual matters each look marginal may still be valuable because of the volume and referrals they bring, and a client with one large, profitable matter may consistently demand discounts on everything else. Look at both before deciding how to price or prioritise their work.

Fixed fees make this essential

With hourly billing, every extra hour is billed, so overruns show up as larger bills. With fixed fees, overruns are invisible unless someone compares time against the fee. In the Legal Services Consumer Panel's 2026 tracker, 57% of legal services consumers had their bill calculated as a fixed fee[2], so for many firms the majority of matters can only be judged this way.

Looking at fee earners fairly

Profitability by fee earner is useful and easy to misuse. A partner who supervises others, a fee earner given the hardest files and a junior still learning will all show lower margins for good reasons. Look at fee earner results alongside the mix of matters, supervision responsibilities and training, and discuss them privately. The aim is to understand why matters overrun, not to produce a league table.

What usually drives losses

  • Scope that was not defined, so extra work was done without being priced.
  • Work done at the wrong grade, for example a partner doing routine steps.
  • Write-offs before billing, often after estimates were not updated.
  • Slow billing and collection, which raise financing costs and bad debt.
  • Complaints and remedies: the Legal Ombudsman awarded £3,700,986 in remedies in 2025/26[5], and every complaint also costs management time.
  • Matters that should have been declined or referred at the enquiry stage.

Acting on the results

  1. Reprice: raise the fee or add priced extras where assumptions are regularly breached.
  2. Redesign: change the process, templates or delegation so the work takes less time.
  3. Refocus: market more actively for the matter types with the best margins.
  4. Refer or stop: for work that cannot be made profitable at a price clients accept, refer it to a firm that specialises in it, or stop offering it.

Run the analysis twice a year, and quarterly for any matter type you have just repriced. For setting the prices themselves, see how to price fixed-fee legal services; for contentious work and recovery, see guideline hourly rates and costs recovery; and before adding a new department, read break-even analysis for a new practice area.

Frequently asked questions

How do you calculate profit on a legal matter?

Take the fees collected, subtract the cost of the time everyone spent on it, any unrecovered disbursements and a share of overheads. Show the result as a sum and as a margin on fees collected.

How should overheads be allocated to matters?

Start with a simple, stable method, such as an overhead charge per chargeable hour or contribution before overheads, and refine it only when the results are being used for decisions.

Should we measure profitability by fee earner?

Yes, but carefully. Read results alongside matter mix, supervision and training, discuss them privately and use them to find causes of overruns rather than to rank people.

How often should matter profitability be reviewed?

Twice a year for the main matter types, and quarterly for any type that has just been repriced or redesigned.

References

  1. GOV.UK (HMRC) (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (2024). Non-financial business economy, UK: Sections A to S (Annual Business Survey), Table 16 Section M (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo