Finance and metrics

How to price fixed-fee legal services

A step-by-step method for pricing fixed-fee legal services: define the product, measure time, cost it fully, price for the slow matters and review.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why fixed fees lose money
  2. Step 1: define the product
  3. Step 2: measure how long it really takes
  4. Step 3: cost the time fully
  5. Step 4: add a fair share of overheads
  6. Step 5: price for the spread, not the average
  7. A worked example
  8. Step 6: write assumptions and publish properly
  9. Pricing the extras
  10. Common pricing mistakes
  11. When a product does not work
  12. Step 7: review regularly
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

Key takeaways

  • Price from your own costs and time data first, then test against the market, not the other way round.
  • Cost fee-earner time fully: salary, employer National Insurance, pension and a fair share of overheads[1].
  • Price for the spread of matters, including the slow ones, not for the average file.
  • Turn the main causes of overruns into written assumptions or separately priced extras.
  • Publish key stages and timescales where the SRA Transparency Rules apply, and review prices at least yearly[2].

Why fixed fees lose money

Most unprofitable fixed fees were set by looking at competitors' websites. The number felt right, the matters came in, and nobody checked what each file cost to run until the year-end figures disappointed. A competitor's price tells you what clients will tolerate; it tells you nothing about whether your team, systems and matter mix can deliver the work for that sum.

A sound fixed fee comes from four things in order: a clearly defined product, real data on the time it takes, a full cost for that time and a margin that covers the slow matters as well as the quick ones. Only then should the market decide whether the price needs to move, and if so whether the product or the process has to change to make it work.

Step 1: define the product

Write the service down as if it were a product on a shelf. Say what it includes, stage by stage, what it assumes and what it excludes. A residential purchase product might assume a freehold title, one buyer's mortgage lender and a property in England and Wales, and exclude leasehold work, help-to-buy schemes, gifted deposits and new-build issues, each quoted separately.

The clearer the definition, the less room for overruns and disputes. If the team cannot agree what the product includes, it cannot be priced.

Step 2: measure how long it really takes

Pull time records for the last 20 to 30 completed matters of the type, split by grade of fee earner. Look at three numbers, not one: the median time, the time at which three quarters of matters were finished and the slowest few. The median tells you what a normal file costs. The slow tail tells you what the fee must absorb.

If time is poorly recorded on fixed-fee matters, which is common, start recording it properly now and price provisionally until you have a few months of data. Without time data, every fixed fee is a guess.

Step 3: cost the time fully

An hour of a fee earner's time costs far more than their hourly pay. ONS provisional figures put median gross hourly pay for solicitors and lawyers at £31.50 in 2026, and £14.95 for legal secretaries[3]. On top of salary, employers pay Class 1 secondary National Insurance at 15% on earnings above the £5,000 secondary threshold in 2026/27[1], plus pension contributions and other benefits.

Then divide by chargeable hours, not paid hours. Example: a fictional associate costs the firm £58,000 a year in salary, National Insurance and pension, and records 1,150 chargeable hours. The direct cost of each chargeable hour is about £50 before any overheads. Add the time of support staff who work on the matter, costed the same way.

Step 4: add a fair share of overheads

Premises, insurance, technology, compliance and management time all have to be paid from fees. Staff are the largest single cost for legal businesses: employment costs were about 36% of UK legal activities turnover in 2024[4], and the rest of each pound of fees has to cover every other cost and leave a profit.

A simple method is to add an overhead charge per chargeable hour, calculated as total non-staff overheads divided by total chargeable hours across the firm. It is not perfect, but it is better than ignoring overheads, and it can be refined later by department.

Step 5: price for the spread, not the average

If the fee only covers a median matter, every slower-than-median file loses money, and there are always more slow files than people remember. Set the base cost at somewhere between the median and the three-quarter point, depending on how well the assumptions exclude the causes of slow matters, then add the margin the firm needs.

  1. Base time

    Choose a time per matter from your data, between the median and the three-quarter point.

  2. Cost it

    Multiply by the full cost per hour for each grade involved, including overheads.

  3. Add margin

    Add the profit margin the partners have agreed for the practice area.

  4. Round and test

    Round to a clear price, then compare with the market and with what clients value.

  5. Decide

    If the price is far above the market, change the process or the product before cutting the fee.

A worked example

Example costing for a fictional residential purchase product; figures are illustrative
ItemExample valueHow it was set
ProductFreehold purchase, one lenderWritten definition with assumptions
Median time9 hoursLast 25 matters
Three-quarter point12 hoursLast 25 matters
Base time used11 hoursAssumptions exclude leasehold and new-build
Fee earner mix8 hours conveyancer, 3 hours assistantDelegation plan
Full cost per hour£85 conveyancer, £45 assistantSalary, on-costs and overheads
Cost of the matter£815Hours times cost per hour
Price before VAT£1,050Cost plus agreed margin, rounded

Example: in this fictional costing, the price leaves a margin on a typical matter and still covers most slow ones. If the market price were far lower, the firm would look first at delegation and process, for example moving more of the work to the assistant, before cutting the fee.

Step 6: write assumptions and publish properly

Put the assumptions, exclusions and extra-work charges in the quote and the client care letter. Where the service falls within the SRA Transparency Rules, published price information must include the key stages of the matter and likely timescales for each stage[2]. A good product definition makes that easy.

Many clients still hear the price before they read it. In the Consumer Panel's tracker, 63% of consumers first found out the price of their legal service through a discussion with the provider, rising to 70% for conveyancing and 72% for will writing[5]. Give staff who take enquiry calls a short, accurate summary of each product and its assumptions.

Consumers who first learned the price through a discussion with the provider, 2026Legal Services Consumer Panel tracker, 2026
Consumers who first learned the price through a discussion with the provider, 2026Column chart. Will writing: 72%; Conveyancing: 70%; All legal services: 63%.0%20%40%60%80%Will writing: 72%72%Will writingConveyancing: 70%70%ConveyancingAll legal services: 63%63%All legal servicesConsumers who first learned the price through a discussion with the provider, 2026Column chart. Will writing: 72%; Conveyancing: 70%; All legal services: 63%.0%20%40%60%80%Will writing: 72%72%WillwritingConveyancing: 70%70%Conveyanci-ngAll legal services: 63%63%All legalservices

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
Will writing72%
Conveyancing70%
All legal services63%

Pricing the extras

Extras are where fixed-fee products make or lose their margin. Each common exclusion should have its own price or pricing rule, worked out the same way as the main fee: the time it adds, costed fully, plus margin. Typical extras include a leasehold supplement, an additional lender, a gifted deposit, a statutory declaration or an extra beneficiary to trace.

Tell clients about extras at the quote stage, not when they arise. A short list of likely extras, each with a price, makes the main fee more credible and removes the most common source of disputes. When an extra applies, confirm it in writing before doing the work.

Common pricing mistakes

  • Using the fastest fee earner's time as the base for a product the whole team delivers.
  • Ignoring support staff time, which can be a large part of transactional work.
  • Leaving out overheads because they are hard to allocate.
  • Pricing the best case and treating every slow file as bad luck.
  • Never repricing, so inflation erodes the margin a little each year.
  • Discounting to win work without checking the cost of the matter first.

When a product does not work

Sometimes the numbers show that a product cannot be delivered profitably at a price clients will pay. Before dropping it, check whether the process can change: more delegation, better templates, earlier collection of information from the client or fewer manual steps. If none of that closes the gap, it may be better to stop offering the service, refer it elsewhere or offer it only as part of a wider package, rather than subsidising it indefinitely.

Step 7: review regularly

Compare actual time against the base time every quarter, and reprice at least once a year. Costs move: the National Living Wage rose to £12.71 an hour from April 2026 and is due to reach £13.21 from April 2027[6], which flows through to support staff pay scales. Track which assumptions are breached most often and either price them in or make them clearer at the start.

For the comparison with hourly billing, see fixed fees vs hourly rates. For other alternatives, see capped fees and value pricing, and to check whether each fixed-fee product is really paying its way, use utilisation and realisation rates.

Frequently asked questions

How do you calculate a fixed fee for legal work?

Define the product and its assumptions, measure the time similar matters take, cost that time fully including on-costs and overheads, choose a base time that covers slower matters, add margin and then test the result against the market.

Should fixed fees be based on competitors' prices?

Competitors show what clients will accept, but the fee must be built from your own costs and time data. If your cost-based price is far above the market, change the process or product before cutting the fee.

How many matters do we need to set a fixed fee?

Twenty to thirty recent matters of the same type usually give a usable picture of the median and the slow tail. With less data, price provisionally and review after a few months.

How often should fixed fees be reviewed?

Compare actual time with the assumed time quarterly and reprice at least yearly, or sooner if pay, overheads or the type of matters you receive change.

References

  1. GOV.UK (HMRC) (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Transparency Rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2024). Non-financial business economy, UK: Sections A to S (Annual Business Survey), Table 16 Section M (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. GOV.UK (2026). National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rates (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo