Finance and metrics

Fixed fees vs hourly rates for solicitors

Fixed fees or hourly rates? A comparison for solicitors: client certainty, firm risk, incentives, transparency duties and criteria for choosing each.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The choice most firms have already half made
  2. How the two models work
  3. Side by side
  4. When a fixed fee works best
  5. When an hourly rate works best
  6. Choosing for each practice area
  7. Hybrids are often the answer
  8. Transparency duties apply either way
  9. Explaining the fee on the first call
  10. Business clients see it differently
  11. Review the line every year
  12. Disputes and how to avoid them
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

Key takeaways

  • Fixed fees are now the most common way consumers are billed; hourly rates are the exception[1].
  • Fixed fees suit work with a predictable scope and good data on time; hourly rates suit work whose scope cannot be known.
  • Many matters work best as a hybrid: fixed fees for defined stages, with hourly or separately quoted work outside them.
  • For several common services the SRA requires published price information, whichever model you use[2].
  • Write down the assumptions behind every fixed fee and explain them on the first call.

The choice most firms have already half made

For consumer work, the market has moved. In the Legal Services Consumer Panel's 2026 tracker, 57% of legal services consumers had their bill calculated as a fixed fee, while 9% were charged an hourly rate[1]. Conveyancing, wills, lasting powers of attorney and uncontested probate are now overwhelmingly sold at fixed prices. Hourly rates remain common in litigation, complex family finance, commercial advice and anything where the other side controls the pace.

So the real question for most firms is not which model to adopt but where the line should sit for each practice area, and how to make each model work well. The comparison below sets out the trade-offs.

How the two models work

A fixed fee is an agreed price for a defined piece of work, set out with the assumptions it depends on. If the work takes longer than expected, the firm absorbs the extra time unless an assumption turns out to be wrong. If it takes less, the firm keeps the margin. The client knows the price before agreeing to proceed.

An hourly rate charges for the time actually spent, at rates set by grade of fee earner, usually with an estimate of the total that must be updated as the matter develops. The client carries the risk that the matter takes longer; the firm is paid for the work it does. Between the two sit capped fees, stage fees and other alternatives, covered in capped fees and value pricing.

Side by side

Fixed fees and hourly rates compared
FactorFixed feeHourly rate
Client certaintyHigh: the price is known at the startLower: depends on time and on updates to the estimate
Risk of overrunCarried by the firmCarried by the client
IncentiveWork efficientlyRecord time thoroughly
AdminLess billing detail; more pricing disciplineDetailed time records and narratives on bills
Fits bestPredictable, repeatable workUncertain, contested or bespoke work
MarketingEasy to compare and publishHarder for clients to compare
Dispute riskArguments about what was includedArguments about time spent

When a fixed fee works best

  • The scope can be described in a few clear sentences, with known stages.
  • The firm has data on how long similar matters actually take, including the slow ones.
  • The main variables can be written as assumptions, such as a freehold title, no more than one mortgage lender or an estate without business assets.
  • Clients compare prices before choosing, so a clear number helps them decide.
  • The work can be delegated to the right grade, keeping delivery cost predictable.

Price matters most where consumers compare. In the Consumer Panel's tracker, price was compared by 67% of those shopping around for will writing and 62% for conveyancing, against 57% for legal services overall[3].

Consumers who compared price when shopping around for legal services, 2026Legal Services Consumer Panel tracker, 2026
Consumers who compared price when shopping around for legal services, 2026Column chart. Will writing: 67%; Conveyancing: 62%; All legal services: 57%.0%20%40%60%80%Will writing: 67%67%Will writingConveyancing: 62%62%ConveyancingAll legal services: 57%57%All legal servicesConsumers who compared price when shopping around for legal services, 2026Column chart. Will writing: 67%; Conveyancing: 62%; All legal services: 57%.0%20%40%60%80%Will writing: 67%67%WillwritingConveyancing: 62%62%Conveyanci-ngAll legal services: 57%57%All legalservices

Source: Legal Services Consumer Panel, 2026[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
Will writing67%
Conveyancing62%
All legal services57%

When an hourly rate works best

  • The other side, the court or a third party controls how long the matter takes.
  • The scope is genuinely unknown at the start, such as an investigation or a dispute that may settle early or go to trial.
  • The client wants advice as needed rather than a defined outcome.
  • The work is bespoke and the firm has no reliable data on time.
  • The matter may change shape, for example a family case that moves from negotiation to contested proceedings.

Hourly billing still needs certainty for the client. The SRA Code of Conduct requires solicitors to give clients the best possible information about pricing at the time of engagement and as the matter progresses[4]. In practice that means an estimate for each stage, updated in writing when it changes.

Choosing for each practice area

  1. Can the work be broken into stages with predictable content? If yes, fix the price for those stages.
  2. Do you have time data for at least the last twenty matters of this type? If not, collect it before fixing a price.
  3. How much do clients in this area compare prices? The more they compare, the stronger the case for a fixed fee.
  4. What are the two or three things that make a matter take much longer? Turn them into assumptions or separately priced extras.
  5. Does the service fall under the SRA Transparency Rules? If so, you will need to publish price information either way.

Hybrids are often the answer

Many matters suit a mix. An employment claim can have a fixed fee for initial advice and the early conciliation stage, then hourly rates with stage estimates if the claim proceeds. A probate matter can have a fixed fee for obtaining the grant and an hourly rate or a separate quote for administration. A family matter can have fixed fees for a first meeting and for preparing a financial disclosure pack, with hourly billing for negotiations.

The key is to tell the client clearly where each stage begins and ends, what triggers a move from one basis to another and how they will be told before it happens.

Transparency duties apply either way

For several services offered to individuals, including residential conveyancing, uncontested probate, most immigration applications, summary road traffic offences and employment tribunal claims for unfair or wrongful dismissal, the SRA Transparency Rules require firms to publish price and service information[2]. Firms can publish a fixed fee, a range or an hourly rate with an average total, but the information must be real and usable. Publishing a clear fixed fee is often the simplest way to comply.

Explaining the fee on the first call

Example script: 'For a straightforward freehold purchase with one mortgage, our fixed fee is set out on our website and in the quote I'll send you today. That covers everything from receiving the contract to registering you as owner. If the property turns out to be leasehold, or there's a second lender, I'll tell you before we do any extra work and confirm the change in writing.'

Write the assumptions and exclusions down and send them with the quote:

  • What the fee covers, stage by stage.
  • The assumptions it depends on.
  • What is excluded, and how excluded work is charged.
  • Disbursements and VAT, shown separately.
  • What happens if the client ends the matter early.

Business clients see it differently

Commercial clients often have their own view. Larger businesses may ask for fixed fees or budgets for whole projects, then measure the firm against them. Smaller businesses usually want the same certainty as consumers, and are less able to absorb an unexpected bill. Some business clients prefer hourly billing for advisory work because they want to call when needed without negotiating a fee each time.

For regular business clients, a monthly retainer for defined advice, with fixed fees for routine transactions such as contracts and debt recovery letters, can give both sides predictability. Debt recovery for business clients up to £100,000 is another service where published price information is required[2].

Review the line every year

The right split between fixed and hourly work changes as the firm collects data and the market moves. Once a year, look at each practice area: which hourly matters followed a predictable pattern and could have been fixed, which fixed fees overran so often that the price or assumptions need changing, and where competitors have moved. Small, regular adjustments are easier for clients and staff than an occasional overhaul.

Disputes and how to avoid them

Each model creates its own disputes. Fixed fees produce arguments about what was included; hourly rates produce arguments about how much time was justified. Both are cheaper to prevent than to resolve. Where the Legal Ombudsman recommended fee refunds, reductions or waivers in 2025/26, refunds averaged £3,520[5].

Example: a fictional firm offered hourly rates for all employment work and found prospective clients often went elsewhere after asking for a price. It introduced a fixed fee for settlement agreement advice, a fixed fee for an initial claim assessment and hourly rates with stage estimates beyond that. Enquiries converted more often, and complaints about cost fell. To set the fixed fees themselves, see how to price fixed-fee legal services; to keep hourly work under control, see WIP management for solicitors.

Frequently asked questions

Are fixed fees better than hourly rates for solicitors?

Neither is better in general. Fixed fees suit predictable work where the firm has good time data; hourly rates suit work whose scope cannot be known. Many matters work best as a mix of the two.

Do solicitors have to publish their prices?

For certain services to individuals and businesses, the SRA Transparency Rules require published price and service information, such as residential conveyancing, uncontested probate and employment tribunal claims for unfair or wrongful dismissal.

What should a fixed-fee quote include?

What the fee covers by stage, the assumptions it depends on, exclusions and how they are charged, disbursements and VAT shown separately, and what happens if the matter ends early.

Can we change a fixed fee during a matter?

Only on the basis agreed at the start, usually when an assumption proves wrong. Tell the client before doing the extra work and confirm the change in writing.

References

  1. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are using legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Transparency Rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2025). SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs, RFLs and RSLs (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Legal Ombudsman (2026). Legal Ombudsman 2025/26 annual complaints data and insight (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo