Staffing and training

Exit interviews and learning from leavers

How a solicitors firm can run exit interviews that get honest answers, record why people leave, cost turnover and turn leaver feedback into change.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why leavers are worth listening to
  2. Who should run it, and when
  3. Exit interviews in a very small firm
  4. A question set that works
  5. Getting honest answers
  6. Recording reasons as themes
  7. Turning feedback into change
  8. Mistakes to avoid
  9. What a departure really costs
  10. What leavers often tell firms
  11. Leaving well
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • 56% of legal professionals could see themselves leaving their current workplace within five years, and 32% could leave the sector entirely[1].
  • Workload and a lack of managerial support are the main causes people give for work-related stress, so expect them to come up in exit interviews[2].
  • Have someone other than the line manager run the interview, with a consistent question set and notes recorded as themes.
  • Review leaver themes every quarter at partner level and act on the top one; feedback that changes nothing stops being given.
  • Cost each departure: recruitment, lost fees, cover and training add up quickly, even for support roles.

Why leavers are worth listening to

People who are leaving have less reason to hold back than people who are staying. They can tell you what finally tipped the balance, what the firm does badly and what a competitor offered. In a small firm, where nobody wants to be the one who complains, an exit interview may be the only time you hear it.

The risk of losing people is real across the profession. In LawCare's Life in the Law 2025 research, 56% of respondents said they could see themselves leaving their current workplace within the next five years, and 32% said they could leave the legal sector entirely[1].

Legal professionals considering leaving, 2025LawCare, Life in the Law 2025
Legal professionals considering leaving, 2025Comparison. Could leave current workplace within five years: 56%; Could leave the legal sector entirely: 32%.56%Could leave current workplace within fiveyearsCould leave current workplace within five years: 56%32%Could leave the legal sector entirelyCould leave the legal sector entirely: 32%Legal professionals considering leaving, 2025Comparison. Could leave current workplace within five years: 56%; Could leave the legal sector entirely: 32%.56%Could leave current workplace withinfive yearsCould leave current workplace within five years: 56%32%Could leave the legal sectorentirelyCould leave the legal sector entirely: 32%

Source: LawCare, 2025[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Could leave current workplace within five years56%
Could leave the legal sector entirely32%

Exit interviews do not stop the person in front of you from leaving. Their value is in spotting patterns before the next resignation.

Who should run it, and when

  • Who: someone other than the line manager, such as the practice manager, a partner from another team or an external HR adviser. People rarely criticise their manager to their manager.
  • When: after notice is given and the departure is settled, but before the last week, when handover pressure is at its height. Some firms add a short follow-up a few months after the person has left, when they may speak more freely.
  • How: a 30 to 45 minute conversation, in person or by video, with an optional short written form beforehand for people who prefer to write.
  • Confidentiality: explain how notes will be used, who will see them and that themes, not names, will be reported to partners.

Exit interviews in a very small firm

In a firm of five or six people, there may be no one other than a partner to run the conversation, and every leaver is identifiable. The process still works if you adapt it.

  • Use a written form first, so the leaver can set out their views without having to say them to a partner's face.
  • Ask a trusted outside contact, such as an HR adviser or a partner at a friendly firm, to hold the conversation if the leaver prefers.
  • Accept that themes will take longer to emerge, and look at two or three years of leavers together.
  • Combine exit feedback with anonymous annual staff surveys, so you are not relying on one voice.
  • Be especially careful about confidentiality: in a small team, sharing even a theme can identify who said it.

Very small firms also feel each departure more acutely, which makes the effort worthwhile. Losing one secretary in a team of six is the equivalent of a large firm losing a whole department.

A question set that works

  1. What made you start looking for a new role?
  2. What was the main reason you accepted the new one?
  3. What did you enjoy most about working here?
  4. What would you change about the firm if you could?
  5. How manageable was your workload, most of the time?
  6. How well supported did you feel by your supervisor or manager?
  7. Did you feel you had a clear next step here? Why or why not?
  8. How did our pay and benefits compare with your new role?
  9. Was there anything that would have made you stay?
  10. Would you consider coming back in future, or recommend us to a friend?

Use the same core questions every time so answers can be compared. Follow up on anything specific, and resist the urge to argue or explain. The aim is to listen.

Getting honest answers

Many leavers give a polite answer, such as a better opportunity or a shorter commute, because they want a good reference and do not want to burn bridges. Make honesty easier:

  • Say clearly that the reference will not be affected by anything they say.
  • Start with open questions about what they enjoyed, before moving to what they would change.
  • Ask for specific examples: when did workload feel unmanageable, and what was going on?
  • Thank them for difficult feedback, and never share it in a way that identifies them while colleagues they named are still working together.
  • Offer a written option for people who find face-to-face criticism hard.

Recording reasons as themes

Example: themes for recording reasons for leaving
ThemeWhat it can includeTypical fix
PaySalary below market, unclear pay review, unfair differencesSalary bands, published review timetable
WorkloadToo many files, long hours, no coverCaseload caps, capacity planning, better cover
ManagementPoor supervision, little feedback, conflictManager training, fixed one-to-ones
ProgressionNo next step, slow route to qualificationWritten career paths, training support
FlexibilityRequests refused, rigid office attendanceAgreed flexible patterns, hybrid policy
CultureNot feeling valued, exclusion, poor behaviourRecognition, clear standards, harassment policy
Life reasonsRelocation, family, health, studyOften not fixable; keep in touch

Record a primary and a secondary theme for each leaver, alongside role, team and length of service. After a year, even a small firm has enough to see patterns, such as most leavers from one team citing workload, or most early leavers citing supervision.

Turning feedback into change

  1. Collect consistently

    Same questions, same recording template, for every leaver.

  2. Review quarterly

    The practice manager summarises themes for the partners' meeting, with no names attached.

  3. Pick the top issue

    Choose the single theme most often cited, or the one most within the firm's control.

  4. Agree an action and an owner

    For example, a caseload review in the family team, or fortnightly one-to-ones for all juniors.

  5. Tell current staff

    Explain what you heard and what you are doing about it. It encourages honest feedback from those still there.

  6. Check after six months

    Has the theme reduced in later exit interviews, stay interviews or staff surveys?

Exit interviews work best alongside stay interviews with people you want to keep. See low-cost ways to retain staff at small firms.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Treating the interview as a last chance to persuade the person to stay. If you want to make a counter-offer, do it separately.
  • Arguing with the leaver's account, even when you disagree. Note it and move on.
  • Filing the notes and never reading them again.
  • Acting on a single dramatic comment without checking whether others share the view.
  • Letting the person who caused the problem see unfiltered feedback about themselves.

Above all, close the loop. Staff notice when the same complaints keep coming up in leavers' feedback and nothing changes.

What a departure really costs

Turnover costs are easy to underestimate because they are spread across budgets. A rough costing for each leaver makes the case for acting on feedback.

Example: a fictional firm loses a full-time legal secretary on a salary close to the 2026 provisional median of £27,824[3]. Employer National Insurance is 15% on earnings above £5,000 a year[4]. The vacancy takes two months to fill, during which overtime and a temp cover part of the work. The firm pays a recruitment fee, and the new starter takes three months to reach full speed while a fee earner spends time training them. Added together, recruitment, cover, lost productivity and management time come to a significant fraction of the annual salary.

For fee earners the cost is higher, because lost fees and client relationships are added to the recruitment and cover costs. The 2026 provisional median for full-time legal associate professionals was £37,148 a year[3], and replacing an experienced paralegal who runs their own caseload rarely happens quickly.

What leavers often tell firms

National data gives a sense of what to expect. The main causes people give for work-related stress, depression or anxiety are workload, especially tight deadlines, too much work or too much pressure, and a lack of managerial support[2]. LawCare found almost 79% of legal professionals regularly work beyond their contracted hours, and only 31% of those who manage others had their targets adjusted for management or training time[1]. If your exit interviews mention long hours and stretched supervisors, you are not alone, but the fix is still yours to make. See billable hours targets and wellbeing and stress in law firms.

Leaving well

  • Plan the handover early: a written list of live matters, key dates, client preferences and anything unusual.
  • Tell clients who their new contact will be, before the person leaves.
  • Remove system access, building access and remote access on the last day, and recover devices.
  • Agree what reference the firm will give and stick to it.
  • Keep in touch with good leavers. Some return, and many refer work or candidates later.

For the checks that come with hiring a replacement, see reference and DBS checks for law firm staff, and for setting pay for the new hire, salary bands and pay transparency.

Frequently asked questions

Who should conduct an exit interview at a law firm?

Someone other than the leaver's line manager, such as the practice manager, a partner from another team or an external HR adviser.

Are exit interviews compulsory?

No. They are voluntary for the leaver, but most people agree if the purpose is explained and the conversation is kept confidential.

What should we do with exit interview feedback?

Record reasons as themes, review them quarterly at partner level, act on the most common issue and tell current staff what you changed.

How soon before someone leaves should we hold the interview?

After notice is settled but before the final week, when handover pressure is highest. A short follow-up after they have left can add more candid feedback.

References

  1. LawCare (2025). Life in the Law 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Health and Safety Executive (2025). Work-related stress, depression or anxiety statistics in Great Britain, 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (HMRC) (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo