Staffing and training

Reference and DBS checks for law firm staff

Pre-employment checks for solicitors firms: right to work, DBS levels and eligibility, SRA register checks, references and handling criminal records data.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why checks matter more in a law firm
  2. The checks at a glance
  3. Right to work: the check you cannot skip
  4. DBS checks: what is available
  5. SRA checks for legal roles
  6. Taking references that tell you something
  7. Handling criminal records information
  8. Checks for temporary, agency and contract staff
  9. A pre-employment workflow
  10. After the first day
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Employers can face a civil penalty of up to £60,000 for each illegal worker unless they made the correct right to work checks[1].
  • A basic DBS check can be used for any position; standard and enhanced checks are only available for roles where the law allows the employer to ask about full criminal history[2].
  • DBS checks have no official expiry date; the employer decides when a new check is needed[3].
  • For any role touching client money or data, combine identity, right to work, DBS, SRA register checks and properly verified references.
  • Criminal records information needs careful handling under data protection law: collect only what you need and limit who sees it.

Why checks matter more in a law firm

Law firm staff handle money and information that clients cannot afford to lose. A cashier can release completion funds. A secretary can see a client's medical records, finances and family history. A receptionist can change a client's contact details. Clients trust firms with all of this: 94% of consumers said they were confident their legal provider would keep their money safe[4].

Pre-employment checks are one of the simplest ways to protect that trust. They will not catch everything, but they deter dishonest applicants, catch false CVs and give the firm evidence that it took reasonable care.

The checks at a glance

Example: a pre-employment check matrix for a solicitors firm
CheckWhat it confirmsWho needs itWhen
IdentityThe person is who they say they areEveryoneBefore an offer becomes unconditional
Right to workThe person is allowed to work in the UKEveryoneBefore employment starts
Basic DBSUnspent convictions and conditional cautionsAny role; especially money and data rolesAfter a conditional offer
Standard or enhanced DBSSpent and unspent convictions, and moreOnly roles eligible in lawAfter a conditional offer, if eligible
SRA register and historyPractising status, conditions, disciplinary historySolicitors and anyone in a legal roleBefore an offer
ReferencesEmployment history, role, reliabilityEveryoneAfter a conditional offer
QualificationsDegrees, legal qualifications, accreditationsWhere relevant to the roleBefore an offer becomes unconditional

Right to work: the check you cannot skip

Employers can face a civil penalty of up to £60,000 for each illegal worker[1]. Knowingly employing someone without the right to work, or having reasonable cause to believe they have none, is a criminal offence carrying up to five years in prison and an unlimited fine[1]. You will not have to pay the civil penalty if you can show you made the correct right to work checks[1].

  • Check every new starter, whatever their nationality, before their first day.
  • Use the Home Office's prescribed methods: original documents checked in the person's presence, the online checking service, or a certified identity service for British and Irish passport holders.
  • Keep a dated copy of the evidence and a record of how and when you checked it.
  • Diary follow-up checks for anyone with time-limited permission.

Apply the checks consistently. Checking only people who seem foreign risks race discrimination claims.

DBS checks: what is available

There are four levels of criminal record check. A basic check shows unspent convictions and conditional cautions; a standard check shows spent and unspent convictions and cautions; an enhanced check adds any relevant information held by local police; and an enhanced check with barred lists adds whether the person is barred from certain work[3].

The basic check can be used for any position or purpose[2]. Standard and enhanced checks are available only for specific duties, positions and licences listed in the rehabilitation of offenders legislation, and only to employers entitled by law to ask an exempted question, meaning they may ask for a person's full criminal history[2]. Most support roles in a law firm are not eligible for more than a basic check, so take advice before requesting anything higher.

The fees, updated on 5 October 2026, are £20 for a basic check, £20 for a standard check and £41 for an enhanced check, with or without barred lists[2].

DBS check fees from October 2026Fee per check, GOV.UK, updated 5 October 2026
DBS check fees from October 2026Column chart. Basic: £20; Standard: £20; Enhanced: £41; Enhanced with barred lists: £41.£0£20£40£60Basic: £20£20BasicStandard: £20£20StandardEnhanced: £41£41EnhancedEnhanced with barred lists: £41£41Enhanced with barredlistsDBS check fees from October 2026Column chart. Basic: £20; Standard: £20; Enhanced: £41; Enhanced with barred lists: £41.£0£20£40£60Basic: £20£20BasicStandard: £20£20StandardEnhanced: £41£41EnhancedEnhanced with barred lists: £41£41Enhancedwithbarre…

Source: GOV.UK (Disclosure and Barring Service), 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Basic£20
Standard£20
Enhanced£41
Enhanced with barred lists£41

A DBS check has no official expiry date; the information is accurate when the check is carried out, and the employer decides when a new check is needed[3]. Many firms repeat a basic check every few years for cashiers and other roles with authority over client money.

  • Solicitors: check the SRA's register for practising status, any conditions on their practising certificate and any published disciplinary decisions.
  • Former solicitors and other legal staff: check whether the person is subject to an SRA order controlling their employment in a law firm. A firm needs the SRA's permission to employ someone who is struck off, suspended or subject to such an order.
  • Chartered legal executives and other regulated lawyers: check the relevant regulator's register.
  • Everyone in a legal role: ask directly, on the application form, about any regulatory findings or investigations.

These checks take minutes and are free. Missing one can leave the firm in breach of its own regulatory obligations.

Taking references that tell you something

Many employers now give only factual references: dates of employment and job title. That is still useful for confirming a CV, but you will learn more if you speak to a referee by phone, with the candidate's permission.

  1. Get contact details for the referee from the firm's switchboard or website, not only from the candidate, to avoid fake referees.
  2. Confirm dates, job title and main duties against the CV.
  3. Ask whether the person handled client money or confidential data, and whether there were any concerns.
  4. Ask whether the referee would re-employ the person, and listen for hesitation.
  5. Ask about any gaps in employment history, and follow them up with the candidate.
  6. Record who you spoke to, when and what was said.

When giving references for former staff, be accurate and fair. You do not have to give a reference, but if you do, it must not be misleading, in either direction.

Handling criminal records information

Criminal records data is treated with extra care under UK data protection law. Before asking for it, work out your lawful basis and the condition you rely on, which for employment checks may require an appropriate policy document. Then:

  • Only ask for checks that are justified for the role.
  • Tell candidates what you will check, why and who will see the result.
  • Limit access to the people making the hiring decision.
  • Do not keep copies of DBS certificates longer than necessary; record the date, the level and the outcome instead.
  • Consider each disclosure on its merits: the offence, its age and its relevance to the role, rather than rejecting everyone with a record.

Checks for temporary, agency and contract staff

Temporary staff often get the least scrutiny, even though they may be given full system access on their first morning to cover an absence. Locum cashiers, agency secretaries, contract paralegals and consultants should meet the same standard as permanent staff for the access they will have.

  • Ask the agency in writing which checks it has carried out, and see the evidence for right to work and identity.
  • Run your own SRA register check for anyone in a legal role, even if the agency says it has done so.
  • Give temporary staff access only to the files and systems they need, and remove it on their last day.
  • Do not give a temporary worker sole authority over client account payments.
  • Brief them on the firm's confidentiality, data protection and payment procedures before they start.

The same applies to outside providers whose staff can see client data, such as IT support or a typing service. Ask how they vet their own people, and make it part of the contract.

A pre-employment workflow

  1. State the checks in the advert and application

    Say which checks apply to the role, so candidates know before they apply.

  2. Make a conditional offer

    Make the offer conditional on satisfactory checks, listing them in the offer letter.

  3. Run identity and right to work checks

    Before the start date, using prescribed methods, and keep the evidence.

  4. Request the DBS check and references

    In parallel, so the start date is not delayed.

  5. Check the SRA register

    For solicitors and anyone in a legal role.

  6. Review and decide

    If anything concerning appears, discuss it with the candidate before deciding.

  7. Confirm in writing

    Make the offer unconditional and record that the checks are complete.

Example: a fictional six-person conveyancing firm hiring a cashier made its offer conditional on a basic DBS check, two phone references and verification of a legal accounts qualification. One referee, contacted through the previous firm's switchboard, confirmed the dates but said the candidate had never held payment authority, contrary to the CV. The firm discussed the gap with the candidate, who withdrew.

After the first day

Checks at hiring are a snapshot. For roles with authority over client money, ask staff to confirm annually that nothing has changed, such as a new conviction or a regulatory finding, and repeat the basic check at intervals you set in policy. Combine checks with controls such as dual authorisation of payments, as described in legal cashiers and accounts staff. For the role that usually runs these checks, see the practice manager role, and for what happens when people leave, exit interviews.

Frequently asked questions

Can a law firm require a DBS check for a receptionist?

A basic DBS check can be requested for any position. Standard and enhanced checks are only available for roles that are eligible in law, which most law firm support roles are not.

How long is a DBS check valid?

A DBS check has no official expiry date. It is accurate on the day it is issued, and the employer decides when a new check is needed.

Do we need to check the right to work of British staff?

Yes. Check every new starter before employment begins, using the prescribed methods, to have a statutory excuse against a civil penalty.

What should we do if a check reveals a conviction?

Consider it on its merits: the offence, how long ago it was and its relevance to the role. Discuss it with the candidate before making a decision.

References

  1. GOV.UK (2026). Penalties for employing illegal workers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (Disclosure and Barring Service) (2026). DBS check requests: guidance for employers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (2026). DBS checks: check someone's criminal record as an employer (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Legal Services Consumer Panel (2026). How consumers are choosing legal services (Tracker Survey 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo