Staffing and training

Mazur ruling: restructuring litigation teams

What the Court of Appeal decided in Mazur, what the SRA's updated supervision guidance expects, and how to structure litigation teams and records now.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What happened, in short
  2. What the Court of Appeal decided
  3. The regulator's response
  4. What many firms changed after the High Court decision
  5. Reviewing your interim changes
  6. Designing supervision for a litigation team
  7. Records that show supervision works
  8. Talking to your team and clients
  9. Roles and careers in the new picture
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • On 31 March 2026 the Court of Appeal held that unauthorised staff can lawfully perform tasks within the conduct of litigation for an authorised individual who keeps responsibility for them[1].
  • The delegation needs proper management supervision and control; the level depends on the task, from prior approval to regular meetings and sampling[1].
  • The SRA welcomed the judgment and updated its effective supervision guidance in June 2026[2][3].
  • Firms that moved all litigation steps to solicitors after the High Court decision can review those changes, but should keep the stronger supervision records.
  • Design roles around risk: what each person may do alone, what needs sign-off and how that is recorded.

What happened, in short

In September 2025, the High Court decision in Mazur v Charles Russell Speechlys LLP [2025] EWHC 2341 (KB) caused alarm across litigation teams. The judgment adopted a distinction, argued by the Law Society and the SRA, between unauthorised staff supporting or assisting an authorised person, which was lawful, and conducting litigation under supervision, which was not[1]. Many firms that relied on paralegals, litigation executives and trainees to run files under supervision reviewed their structures in a hurry.

The Chartered Institute of Legal Executives (CILEX) appealed. On 31 March 2026, the Court of Appeal, sitting as the Master of the Rolls, the Chancellor of the High Court and Lady Justice Andrews, handed down its judgment in CILEX and others v Mazur and others [2026] EWCA Civ 369[1]. It held that the distinction drawn below between supporting and conducting litigation under supervision was not correct[1].

What the Court of Appeal decided

The core of the decision is set out in the court's summary of its conclusions.

  • An unauthorised person can lawfully perform any tasks within the scope of the conduct of litigation for and on behalf of an authorised individual, such as a solicitor or an appropriately authorised CILEX member[1].
  • The authorised individual retains responsibility for the delegated tasks and is the person carrying on the conduct of litigation; the unauthorised person does not commit an offence[1].
  • As a regulatory matter, delegation requires proper management supervision and control, the details of which are for the regulators[1].
  • Sometimes the degree of control will be high, with approval required before things are done. In routine circumstances, regular meetings and sampling of work may be sufficient[1].
  • The degree of prior approval contended for by the Law Society and the SRA is not required by the Legal Services Act 2007[1].

The court also said the authorised individual keeps the professional responsibilities that go with the work, including independence and integrity, proper standards of work, acting in clients' best interests and the duty to the court[1].

The regulator's response

The SRA's statement on the day of the judgment welcomed the clear direction from the Court of Appeal that an unauthorised person can lawfully conduct litigation under appropriate supervision by an authorised individual, and said it would review its guidance[2]. Its effective supervision guidance was updated on 12 June 2026[3].

The updated guidance expects solicitors to be satisfied that they are exercising proper direction, management supervision and control over work, including delegated work, and says that putting arrangements in place is not enough: firms should take steps to check supervision works in practice[3]. It sets a risk-based approach, taking account of the risks to clients if services are defective and the experience, competence and workload of those doing the work[3]. One example of a higher-control arrangement it gives is that no court documents are filed without partner or senior solicitor sign-off[3].

What many firms changed after the High Court decision

Between September 2025 and March 2026, firms took different interim approaches. Some moved signing and filing of court documents, service and correspondence with the court to solicitors only. Some re-titled roles and narrowed what paralegals did. Some reallocated files so that a solicitor was formally on the record for every matter. Others paused growth in volume litigation teams.

Some of those changes were sensible regardless of the law: clearer sign-off for court documents, better records of who did what and closer supervision of inexperienced staff. Others, such as stripping experienced litigation executives of the work they are best at, added cost without reducing risk. Now is the time to decide which to keep.

Reviewing your interim changes

Example: reviewing post-September 2025 changes in a litigation team
Interim changeKeep, adjust or reverse?Reasoning
Only solicitors may sign and file court documentsAdjust by riskKeep prior sign-off for complex or high-value matters; routine filings can be delegated with sampling
All correspondence with the court sent by solicitorsUsually reverseRoutine correspondence is a classic task for supervised staff
A solicitor named on every fileKeepMatches the court's emphasis on a responsible authorised individual
Written delegation and sign-off rulesKeepThe SRA guidance expects firms to show supervision works in practice
Paralegal and litigation executive roles narrowedReview case by caseRestore responsibilities where competence is evidenced
Recruitment of extra solicitors to replace paralegalsReviewCostly; may not be needed if supervision is sound

The cost point matters. The 2026 provisional median gross annual pay for full-time solicitors and lawyers was £57,198, against £37,148 for legal associate professionals, the ONS group that includes paralegals and legal executives[4]. Replacing experienced supervised staff with solicitors, where it is not needed, is an expensive way to manage a risk that supervision can address.

Median gross annual pay, full-time, 2026Provisional, ONS ASHE; excludes employer on-costs
Median gross annual pay, full-time, 2026Comparison. Solicitors and lawyers: £57,198; Legal associate professionals: £37,148.£57,198Solicitors and lawyersSolicitors and lawyers: £57,198£37,148Legal associate professionalsLegal associate professionals: £37,148Median gross annual pay, full-time, 2026Comparison. Solicitors and lawyers: £57,198; Legal associate professionals: £37,148.£57,198Solicitors and lawyersSolicitors and lawyers: £57,198£37,148Legal associate professionalsLegal associate professionals: £37,148

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Solicitors and lawyers£57,198
Legal associate professionals£37,148

Designing supervision for a litigation team

  1. Name the responsible authorised individual

    For every matter, record which solicitor or authorised CILEX member is carrying on the litigation and supervising the staff working on it.

  2. Classify tasks by risk

    For example: routine (chasers, standard directions questionnaires, bundles), standard (most correspondence, routine applications), high (statements of case, witness statements, settlement, anything with a deadline consequence).

  3. Set the control for each class

    Routine: regular meetings and sampling. Standard: review before sending for less experienced staff. High: approval before the step is taken.

  4. Match control to the person

    Ease controls as competence is shown, and record when and why each change was made.

  5. Hold regular meetings

    Weekly file-list reviews and fortnightly one-to-ones, as the court recognised for routine work.

  6. Sample and record

    Review a meaningful sample of each person's files each month and keep a short note of findings.

  7. Review the system

    Quarterly, check that the controls are working and adjust them.

Our guide to supervising junior staff and trainees sets out a daily, weekly and monthly rhythm that fits this model.

Records that show supervision works

  • A delegation record for each person: which task types they may do alone, which need review and which need prior approval.
  • Sign-off notes on the file for high-risk steps, showing who approved and when.
  • File review notes, dated, with findings and actions.
  • Notes of supervision meetings, even brief ones.
  • Training records showing how each person's competence was built and assessed.

Keep these simple and consistent. A short template completed every time is worth more than a detailed one completed occasionally.

Talking to your team and clients

The months after the High Court decision were unsettling for many paralegals and litigation executives, some of whom were told their roles might change or disappear. Even with the appeal decided, it is worth explaining the position clearly to the team.

  1. Explain in plain terms what the Court of Appeal decided and what the firm's supervision arrangements now are.
  2. Tell each person what they may do alone, what needs review and what needs approval, and give it to them in writing.
  3. Explain how they can earn more autonomy, and what evidence of competence the firm will look for.
  4. Invite questions, and correct any rumours about job losses or pay changes.
  5. If any interim changes affected someone's role or pay, review those individually.

Clients rarely need a detailed explanation, but they are entitled to know who is handling their matter and who is responsible for it. Make sure client care letters name the supervising authorised individual as well as the day-to-day contact, and that clients know who to contact if they have concerns. For insurers, check whether your professional indemnity broker asked for information about supervision arrangements during the period of uncertainty, and update them on your current approach.

Roles and careers in the new picture

The judgment confirms that experienced paralegals and litigation executives can continue to do substantive work under supervision. It also highlights the value of authorisation. CILEX members with litigation rights can conduct litigation in their own right and supervise others, and supported qualification routes, including solicitor apprenticeships and the chartered legal executive route, give firms more authorised people over time. 9,575 new solicitors were admitted in 2024[5], but competition for experienced litigators remains strong, so growing your own is often the more reliable option.

Example: the debt recovery team at a fictional firm had moved all court filings to its two solicitors in October 2025, creating a backlog. After the Court of Appeal judgment, the team classified its tasks by risk, restored routine filings to three experienced litigation executives with weekly meetings and monthly sampling, and kept partner sign-off for defended claims above an agreed value. Filing delays cleared within a month and the firm kept the new delegation records.

For pay and progression as roles change, see salary bands and pay transparency. For hiring, see reference and DBS checks for law firm staff. The practice manager can usually own the delegation records.

Frequently asked questions

Can paralegals conduct litigation after Mazur?

The Court of Appeal held that unauthorised staff can perform tasks within the conduct of litigation for and on behalf of an authorised individual who keeps responsibility, with proper management supervision and control.

Does every step need a solicitor's prior approval?

No. The court said the degree of control depends on the circumstances. Higher-risk steps may need approval first, while routine work may be supervised through regular meetings and sampling.

What has the SRA said?

The SRA welcomed the judgment and updated its effective supervision guidance on 12 June 2026, setting out a risk-based approach to direction, management supervision and control.

Should we reverse the changes we made after the High Court decision?

Review them one by one. Keep changes that improved supervision and records, and reverse those that added cost without reducing risk.

References

  1. Court of Appeal (Judiciary of England and Wales) (2026). CILEX and others v Mazur and others [2026] EWCA Civ 369 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Conducting litigation: response to Mazur v CILEX judgment (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Solicitors Regulation Authority (2026). Effective supervision guidance (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Earnings and hours worked, occupation by four-digit SOC: ASHE Table 14 (2026 provisional) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. The Law Society (2024). Annual statistics report 2024 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo